Item Desirability Effects in Compliance-Gaining Research Seven Studies Documenting Artifacts in the Strategy Selection Procedure

A popular method for assessing compliance-gaming behavior involves having people rate lists of preformulated message strategies for likelihood of use. This "selection procedure" has been employed much more frequently than the alternative "construction procedure," a method that requires people to generate their own message strategies. The present article argues that the selection procedure is much less sensitive than the construction procedure to the effects of situational and individual-difference variables on compliance-gaining behavior. The article further suggests that the insensitivity of the selection procedure is due to a type of social desirability bias known as the item desirability effect. Seven studies were carried out testing the Marwell and Schmitt (1967) and Wiseman and Schenk-Hamlin (1 981) strategy checklists for the item desirability effect. These studies found that (a) the likelihood of use ratings prouided for the strategies on both checklists could be accurately predicted by the rated social appropriateness of the strategies, (b) likelihood of use ratingsfor preforrnulated strategies haue relatively poor reliability, and (c) the construction procedure is much less susceptible to social desirability biases than the selection procedure. On the basis of these and related findings, it is recommended that researchers eschew the use of strategy checklists in future research

Compliance (psychology · Personnel selection · Selection (genetic algorithm · Situational ethics · Social desirability · Social desirability bias · Statistics · Applied Psychology · Behavioral Health and Interventions · Computer Science · Customer Service Quality and Loyalty · Psychology · Psychology of Social Influence · Social Psychology · Artificial Intelligence

• Communication Aspects of Dyadic Social Influence in Organizations

  Bruce Barry, Mary R Watson•Annals of the International…•1996

  Incluir item

• Strategies for Resisting Persuasion

  Julia Zuwerink Jacks, Kimberly A Cameron•Basic and Applied Social Psychology•2003

  Incluir item

• A Certain Je Ne Sais Quoi

  Open Access•Matthew S Mcglone, Diane Kobrynowicz et al.•Human Communication Research•2005

  Incluir item

• A Certain Je Ne Sais Quoi

  Open Access•Matthew S Mcglone•Human Communication Research•2005

  Incluir item

• A Message-Centered Approach to Leadership

  Beverly Davenport Sypher•Annals of the International…•1991

  Incluir item

• Interaction Goals in Negotiation

  Steven R Wilson, Linda L Putnam•Annals of the International…•1990

  Incluir item

• Cellphone relevance in face-to-face interactions

  Open Access•Ryan Cummings, Torsten Reimer•Mobile Media & Communication•2020

  Incluir item

• Communication and Problematic Integration

  Open Access•Austin S Babrow•Communication Theory•1992

  Incluir item

• An Action Assembly Perspective on Social Skill

  Open Access•John O Greene, Deanna Geddes•Communication Theory•1993

  Incluir item

• Interpersonal Communication Research as Ideological Practice

  Open Access•John W Lannamann•Communication Theory•1991

  Incluir item

• Classifying Compliance Gaining Messages

  Open Access•Kathy Kellermann, Tim Cole•Communication Theory•1994

  Incluir item

• Paths II

  Open Access•Michael Burgoon•Communication Theory•1994

  Incluir item

• Gender Differences in Persuasive Message Practices

  Susan L Kline•Women s Studies in Communication•1994

  Incluir item

• A cross‐cultural comparison of implicit theories of requesting

  Min‐sun Kim, Steven R Wilson•Communication Monographs•1994

  Incluir item

• Effects of request legitimacy on the compliance‐gaining tactics of male and female managers

  Randy Y Hirokawa, Jeffrey Mickey et al.•Communication Monographs•1991

  Incluir item

• Path

  Michael Burgoon, Gerald R Miller•Communication Monographs•1990

  Incluir item

• An attributional analysis of compliance‐gaining interactions

  Steven R Wilson, Michael G Cruz et al.•Communication Monographs•1993

  Incluir item

• A cross‐cultural study of directive sequences and some implications for compliance‐gaining research

  Kristine L Fitch•Communication Monographs•1994

  Incluir item

• Guys Can't Say That to Guys”

  Brant R Burleson, A J Holmstrom et al.•Communication Monographs•2005

  Incluir item

• Cultural influences on the preferred forms of requesting and re‐requesting

  Min‐sun Kim, Hochang Shin et al.•Communication Monographs•1998

  Incluir item

• The effects of power and message variables on compliance

  Timothy R Levine, Timothy Levine et al.•Communication Monographs•2001

  Incluir item

• On the Continued Undesirability of Item Desirability A Reply to Boster, Hunter, and Seibold

  Open Access•Brant R Burleson, Steven R Wilson•Human Communication Research•1988

  Incluir item

• The Myth of Gender Cultures

  Open Access•Erina L Macgeorge, Angela Graves et al.•Sex Roles•2004

  Incluir item

• A process model of request tactic evaluation

  Min‐sun Kim, Minsun Kim et al.•Discourse Processes•1994

  Incluir item

• Perceptions of Influence in Managerial Dyads

  Open Access•Bruce Barry, Thomas S Bateman•Human Relations•1992

  Incluir item

• Failure of the Social Desirability Response Set Hypothesis

  Open Access•J E Hunter•Human Communication Research•1988

  Incluir item

• The haunting of communication research by dead metaphors

  Open Access•Christian K Nelson•Language & Communication•2001

  Incluir item

• Directiness and deference in pharmacy students' messages to physicians

  Open Access•Bruce L Lambert•Social Science & Medicine•1995

  Incluir item

• Weight-related social control and relationship quality

  Open Access•Tricia J Burke, C Segrin•Journal of Social and Personal…•2016

  Incluir item

• Individual Differences in Irony Use Depend on Context

  Open Access•Yoritaka Akimoto, Shiho Miyazawa•Journal of Language and Social…•2017

  Incluir item

• Implicit Theories of Persuasion

  Open Access•David R Roskos-Ewoldsen, David R Roskos‐ewoldsen•Human Communication Research•1997

  Incluir item

• Cognition and Social Information-Gathering Strategies Reinterpretation Assessment in Second-Guessing

  Open Access•Dean E Hewes, Maudie L Graham et al.•Human Communication Research•1989

  Incluir item

• Behavioral Antecedents of Peer Social Status

  Kenneth A Dodge•Child Development•1983

  Incluir item

• The Development of Functional Persuasive Skills in Childhood and Early Adolescence

  Ruth Anne Clark, Jesse G Delia•Child Development•1976

  Incluir item

• A Behavioral Analysis of Emerging Social Status in Boys' Groups

  John D Coie, Janis B Kupersmidt•Child Development•1983

  Incluir item

• Judgment under Uncertainty

  Amos Tversky, Daniel Kahneman•Utility, Probability, and Human…•1975

  Incluir item

• Handbook of Social Cognition

  Robert S Wyer, Robert S Wyer Jr et al.•Handbook of Social Cognition :…•2014

  Incluir item

• Popular, Rejected, and Supportive Preadolescents

  Brant R Burleson, Patricia Amason Waltman•Annals of the International…•1987

  Incluir item

• The Impact of Communication Context and Persuader Gender on Persuasive Message Selection

  Michael Burgoon, James Price Dillard et al.•Women s Studies in Communication•1984

  Incluir item

• Cognitive complexity‐simplicity as a determinant of communication effectiveness

  Claudia L Hale•Communication Monographs•1980

  Incluir item

• Utilization of compliance‐gaining strategies

  Thomas Baglan, James Lalumia et al.•Communication Monographs•1986

  Incluir item

• Compliance‐gaining message strategies

  Gerald R Miller, Gerald Miller et al.•Communication Monographs•1977

  Incluir item

• A typology of disengagement strategies and an examination of the role intimacy, reactions to inequity and relational problems play in strategy selection

  Michael J Cody•Communication Monographs•1982

  Incluir item

• Age, social‐cognitive development, and the use of comforting strategies

  Brant R Burleson•Communication Monographs•1984

  Incluir item

• A model of compliance‐gaining message selection

  J E Hunter, Franklin J Boster•Communication Monographs•1987

  Incluir item

• The impact of self interest and desire for liking on the selection of communicative strategies

  Ruth Anne Clark•Communication Monographs•1979

  Incluir item

• Attributions and communication in roommate conflicts

  Alan L Sillars, Alan Sillars•Communication Monographs•1980

  Incluir item

• A multidimensional scaling validation of an inductively‐derived set of compliance‐gaining strategies

  Richard L Wiseman, William J Schenck‐hamlin et al.•Communication Monographs•1981

  Incluir item

• The affinity‐seeking function of communication

  Robert A Bell, John A Daly•Communication Monographs•1984

  Incluir item

• The impact of construct system development on communication and impression formation in persuasive contexts 1

  James L Applegate•Communication Monographs•1982

  Incluir item

• The development of persuasive communication strategies in kindergarteners through twelfth‐graders

  Jesse G Delia, Susan L Kline et al.•Communication Monographs•1979

  Incluir item

• Situational influences on the selection of compliance‐gaining messages

  James Price Dillard, Michael Burgoon•Communication Monographs•1985

  Incluir item

• Communication Yearbook 3

  Graham B Kerr, Dan Nimmo•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1981

  Incluir item

• Dimensions of Compliance-Gaining Behavior

  Gerald Marwell, David R Schmitt•Sociometry•1967

  Incluir item

• A multimethod comparison of popular and unpopular children

  Barbara Vosk, Barbara N Vosk et al.•Developmental Psychology•1982

  Incluir item

• A naturalistic study of children's social understanding

  Robert L Selman, Mira Z Schorin et al.•Developmental Psychology•1983

  Incluir item

• Strategy and structure in conversational influence attempts

  Scott Jacob, Scott Jacobs et al.•Communication Monographs•1983

  Incluir item

• Parental Belief Systems

  F D Fincham, Irving E Sigel et al.•Journal of Marriage and the Family•1992

  Incluir item

• Appropriateness and Effectiveness Perceptions of Conflict Strategies

  Open Access•Daniel J Canary, Brian H Spitzberg•Human Communication Research•1987

  Incluir item

• Cognitive and Motivational Influences on Spontaneous Comforting Behavior

  Open Access•Wendy Samter, Brant R Burleson•Human Communication Research•1984

  Incluir item

• Compliance-Gaining Message Selection Behavior

  Open Access•Franklin J Boster, James B Stiff•Human Communication Research•1984

  Incluir item

• Generalizing About Messages

  Open Access•Sally Jackson, Scott Jacob et al.•Human Communication Research•1983

  Incluir item

• Social Cognition, Empathic Motivation, and Adults' Comforting Strategies

  Open Access•Brant R Burleson•Human Communication Research•1983

  Incluir item

• The Effect of Communication Apprehension and Situation on Communication Strategy Choices

  Open Access•Myron W Lustig, Stephen W King•Human Communication Research•1980

  Incluir item

• Situational Influences on the Selection of Strategies to Resist Compliance-Gaining Attempts

  Open Access•Margaret L Mclaughlin, Margaret Mclaughlin et al.•Human Communication Research•1980

  Incluir item

• The Stranger and the Spouse as Target Persons for Compliance-Gaining Strategies

  Open Access•Alan L Sillars, Alan Sillars•Human Communication Research•1980

  Incluir item

• Cognitive Complexity, Social Perspective-Taking, and Functional Persuasive Skills in Second- To Ninth-Grade Children

  Open Access•Ruth Anne Clark, Jesse G Delia•Human Communication Research•1977

  Incluir item