Pular para o conteúdo principal

ETHNOS_APP

Início • Busca • Periódicos • Lista 0

Mind matters

A meta-analysis on parental mentalization and sensitivity as predictors of infant-parent attachment

Dados Bibliográficos

ID4862691
AutoresMoniek A J Zeegers (0000-0003-2853-1084), Cristina Colonnesi (0000-0002-5740-7827), Geert‐jan J M Stams, Geert-Jan J M Stams, Elizabeth Meins (0000-0002-5375-6448)
Ano2017
Volume143
Fascículo12
Páginas1245-1272
Data de publicação2017-12-01
Peer ReviewedSim
Open AccessNão
TipoARTICLE
PeriódicoPsychological Bulletin (JOURNAL)
Identificadores do periódicoISSN: 0033-2909 • E-ISSN: 1939-1455
EditoraAmerican Psychological Association (APA) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1037/bul0000114
PMID28805399
OpenAlexW2620967654
IdiomaEN
Citações recebidas104
Referências citadas4

Major developments in attachment research over the past 2 decades have introduced parental mentalization as a predictor of infant-parent attachment security. Parental mentalization is the degree to which parents show frequent, coherent, or appropriate appreciation of their infants' internal states. The present study examined the triangular relations between parental mentalization, parental sensitivity, and attachment security. A total of 20 effect sizes (N = 974) on the relation between parental mentalization and attachment, 82 effect sizes (N = 6,664) on the relation between sensitivity and attachment, and 24 effect sizes (N = 2,029) on the relation between mentalization and sensitivity were subjected to multilevel meta-analyses. The results showed a pooled correlation of r = .30 between parental mentalization and infant attachment security, and rs of .25 for the correlations between sensitivity and attachment security, and between parental mentalization and sensitivity. A meta-analytic structural equation model was performed to examine the combined effects of mentalization and sensitivity as predictors of infant attachment. Together, the predictors explained 12% of the variance in attachment security. After controlling for the effect of sensitivity, the relation between parental mentalization and attachment remained, r = .24; the relation between sensitivity and attachment remained after controlling for parental mentalization, r = .19. Sensitivity also mediated the relation between parental mentalization and attachment security, r = .07, suggesting that mentalization exerts both direct and indirect influences on attachment security. The results imply that parental mentalization should be incorporated into existing models that map the predictors of infant-parent attachment. (PsycINFO Database Record

Attachment theory · Developmental psychology · Maternal sensitivity · Mentalization · Meta-analysis · Attachment and Relationship Dynamics · Child and Adolescent Psychosocial and Emotional Development · Family Dynamics and Relationships · Psychology

  • Proposing a Role for Maternal Positive Empathy in the Caregiving Relationship

    Open Access•Matthew J Marvin•Journal of Family Theory & Review•2026

  • The Mentalizing Approach to Psychopathology

    Patrick Luyten, Chloe Campbell et al.•Annual Review of Clinical…•2020

  • Parenting and Child Development

    Open Access•Cynthia A Frosch, Sarah J Schoppe‐sullivan et al.•American Journal of Lifestyle…•2021

  • Individual and Structural Factors Associated with Interactive Skills of Child-Care Professionals in Early Childhood Education and Care

    Open Access•Laura Lærkegård Støve, Nina Thorup Dalgaard et al.•Educational Psychology Review•2026

  • Three Decades of Research on Individual Teacher-Child Relationships

    Open Access•Jantine L Spilt, Helma M Y Koomen•Frontiers in Education•2022

  • Patterns of student socio-emotional development and teacher-student-relationship-quality for high-school students with and without special educational needs

    Open Access•Giuliana Pastore, Wassilis Kassis et al.•Frontiers in Education•2025

  • Saga-Supporting Social-Emotional Development in Early Childhood Education

    Open Access•Mirjam Kalland, Tanja Linnavalli et al.•Education Sciences•2022

  • Mother Behavior Q-Set (MBQS)Dimensionalidad del Q-set del comportamiento materno en muestras de México, Colombia y Uruguay

    Open Access•F Salinas-Quiroz, Antonio Martínez Pineda et al.•Revista Iberoamericana de…•2021

  • Childcare context and socio-emotional development in toddlers – a quantitative report from the FinnBrain Birth Cohort Study, Finland

    Open Access•Katja Tervahartiala, Saara Nolvi et al.•European Early Childhood…•2024

  • Enhancing early childhood education student teachers’ mentalization, interaction, and relationships

    Open Access•Jenny Marttila, Ruben G Fukkink et al.•European Early Childhood…•2024

  • Early Childhood Temperament Factors and Callous-Unemotional Traits in Preschool and School Aged- Children

    Open Access•Vivian Chau, Valsamma Eapen et al.•Child & Youth Care Forum•2025

  • Prevention of Instability in Foster Care

    Open Access•Carolien Konijn, Cristina Colonnesi et al.•Child & Youth Care Forum•2021

  • Crianza Positiva

    Open Access•Ana I Balsa, Esteban Gómez Muzzio et al.•Child & Youth Care Forum•2024

  • The Relative Importance of Structural and Individual Factors for Child-care Professional's Interactive Skills in Early Childhood Education and Care

    Open Access•Laura Lærkegård Støve, Anne Christine Stuart et al.•Child & Youth Care Forum•2026

  • Variation in differential reactions to comfort by parents versus strangers in children with severe or profound intellectual disabilities

    Open Access•Sien Vandesande, Guy Bosmans et al.•Current Psychology•2023

  • Mind-mindedness in out-of-home Care for Children

    Open Access•Cristina Colonnesi, Carolien Konijn et al.•Current Psychology•2022

  • Factors associated with children’s attachment hierarchy in lesbian, gay, and heterosexual parent families through assisted reproduction

    Open Access•Maria Quintigliano, Nicola Carone et al.•Current Psychology•2025

  • Development and preliminary evaluation of the Caregiver Sensitivity Scale among Chinese preschool children

    Open Access•X Lin, Yuxin Tan et al.•Current Psychology•2025

  • Covid-19, child’s behavior problems, and mother’s anxiety and mentalization

    Open Access•Daphna G Dollberg, Keren Hanetz‐Gamliel et al.•Current Psychology•2023

  • A Meta-Analysis of the Effectiveness of EMDR and TF-CBT in Reducing Trauma Symptoms and Externalizing Behavior Problems in Adolescents

    Open Access•Larissa M Hoogsteder, Lotte ten Thije et al.•International Journal of Offender…•2022

  • Reflective functioning and emotion socialization behaviors in caregivers of preschoolers

    Open Access•Kristen Yule, John H Grych et al.•Family Relations•2024

  • Parenting during the Covid ‐19 pandemic

    Open Access•Franziska Köhler‐Dauner, Ute Ziegenhain et al.•Family Relations•2023

  • Interparental conflict predicts developmental trajectories of maternal sensitivity across early childhood

    Open Access•Jill M Trumbell, German Posada et al.•Family Relations•2023

  • Inter-relations between mind-mindedness, maternal communicative style in the context of attachment distress, and infant–mother attachment security

    Open Access•Elisabetta Lombardi, Cinzia Di Dio et al.•International Journal of…•2025

  • Parental reflective functioning in mothers and fathers of preschoolers

    Open Access•Ida Egmose, Tine Steenhoff et al.•Scandinavian Journal of Psychology•2024

  • Early relational origins of Theory of Mind

    Open Access•Grazyna Kochanska, Lilly C Bendel‐Stenzel et al.•Journal of Child Psychology and…•2025

  • Taking theory of mind research into much needed new terrain – a commentary on Kochanska et al. (2025)

    Open Access•Ross A Thompson•Journal of Child Psychology and…•2025

  • Annual Research Review

    Open Access•Marissa D Nivison, R M Pasco Fearon et al.•Journal of Child Psychology and…•2026

  • Disorganized attachment in emerging adulthood

    Open Access•Drew Whittington•Family Process•2024

  • Parental sensitivity and child behavioral problems

    Open Access•Jessica E Cooke, Audrey-Ann Deneault et al.•Child Development•2022

  • A smartphone app effectively facilitates mothers' mind-mindedness

    Open Access•Frances Larkin, Fionnuala Larkin et al.•Child Development•2024

  • Paternal Sensitivity and Children’s Cognitive and Socioemotional Outcomes

    Open Access•Michelle Rodrigues, Nina Sokolovic et al.•Child Development•2021

  • Narrative coherence across the transition to parenthood

    Open Access•Marjolein C E Branger, Rosanneke A G Emmen et al.•Acta Psychologica•2022

  • Working with refugee families, trauma and exile in family relationships

    Shirley Hodgson

  • Maternal mind-mindedness and communicative functions in free-play and mealtime contexts

    Open Access•Emiddia Longobardi, Pietro Spataro et al.•Journal of Child Language•2022

  • Parental History of Childhood Maltreatment and Offspring Attachment Insecurity and Disorganization

    Open Access•Aino Sirparanta, Camille Danner Touati et al.•Trauma Violence & Abuse•2025

  • Evaluating associations between parental mind-mindedness and children’s developmental capacities through meta-analysis

    Open Access•Naomi J Aldrich, Jing Chen et al.•Developmental Review•2021

  • Maternal mentalizing and quality of interactive behavior with their infant in the first year postpartum

    Open Access•Katrine Isabella Wendelboe, Sophie Reijman et al.•Developmental Review•2024

  • The relation of different constructs of parental mentalization

    Open Access•Konstantin Steinmassl, Jule Eilts et al.•Developmental Review•2026

  • Does attachment security predict children’s thinking-about-thinking and thinking-about-feeling? A meta-analytic review

    Open Access•Moniek A J Zeegers, Elizabeth Meins et al.•Developmental Review•2019

  • A new look at the relations between attachment and intelligence

    Open Access•Marco Del Giudice, John D Haltigan•Developmental Review•2023

  • Twenty years of research on parental mind-mindedness

    Open Access•Christopher Mcmahon, Catherine A McMahon et al.•Developmental Review•2017

  • L’expérience des participantes au programme STEP

    Nicolas Berthelot, Érica Goupil et al.•Revue de psychoéducation•2022

  • Representational mind-mindedness in Danish early childcare professionals

    Open Access•Katrine Isabella Wendelboe, Sophie Woergaard Gram et al.•European Early Childhood…•2026

  • Expectant mothers' not fathers' mind‐mindedness predicts infant, mother, and father conversational turns at 7 months

    Open Access•Foley, Claire Hughes et al.•Infancy•2022

  • Face‐Looking as a Real‐Time Process in Mind‐Mindedness

    Open Access•Hiroshi Yamamoto, Hiroki Yamamoto et al.•Infancy•2025

  • Exploring the relation between maternal mind‐mindedness and children’s symbolic play

    Open Access•Chiara Giovanelli, Cinzia Di Dio et al.•Infancy•2020

  • Maternal Mentalization and Behavior Under Stressful Contexts

    Open Access•Tal Yatziv, Noa Gueron-Sela et al.•Infancy•2018

  • Evidence of Cross‐Cultural Differences in Maternal Mind‐Mindedness

    Open Access•Fabiola Silletti, Gabrielle Coppola et al.•Infancy•2025

  • Parental Embodied Mentalizing and its Relation to Mind‐Mindedness, Sensitivity, and Attachment Security

    Open Access•Donna Shai, Dana Shai et al.•Infancy•2018

  • The effectiveness of maternal regulatory attempts in the development of infant emotion regulation

    Open Access•Shira C Segal, Margaret C Moulson•Infancy•2024

  • Non‐Attuned Mind‐Mindedness, Infant Negative Affect, and Emotional Availability

    Open Access•Christopher Mcmahon, Brooklyn Newey•Infancy•2018

  • Tempering Temperament

    Open Access•Allira Doyle, Emma E Walter et al.•Infancy•2025

  • Adverse Childhood Experiences Predict Common Neurodevelopmental and Behavioral Health Conditions among U.S. Children

    Open Access•Kasra Zarei, Guifeng Xu et al.•Children•2021

  • Promoting interactive skills and mind-mindedness among early childcare professionals

    Open Access•Johanne Smith‐nielsen, Katrine Isabella Wendelboe et al.•BMC Psychology•2022

  • Association between bullying victimization and mental health problems among Chinese left-behind children

    Open Access•Yuan Feng, Simai Zhang et al.•Frontiers in Psychiatry•2024

  • Parental Reflective Functioning as a Moderator of the Link Between Prematurity and Parental Stress

    Open Access•Daphna G Dollberg, Yael Harlev et al.•Frontiers in Psychiatry•2022

  • Improvements in the quality of the parent-child relationship following treatment with an integrated family approach

    Open Access•Hanna Stolper, Lieke Imandt et al.•Frontiers in Psychiatry•2024

  • Mediation-Moderation Links Between Mothers' ACEs, Mothers' and Children's Psychopathology Symptoms, and Maternal Mentalization During Covid-19

    Open Access•Daphna G Dollberg, Keren Hanetz‐Gamliel et al.•Frontiers in Psychiatry•2022

  • A Cohort Study on the Effect of Parental Mind-Mindedness in Parent−Child Interaction Therapy

    Open Access•Merlijn Meynen, Cristina Colonnesi et al.•International Journal of…•2022

  • The role of prenatal depression and infant negative emotionality on maternal mind-mindedness

    Feyza Corapci, Duygu Yıldız-Akay et al.•Applied Developmental Science•2024

  • Parent Emotion Regulation, Mindful Parenting, and Youth Attachment

    Open Access•Julia R G Vernon, Marlene M Moretti•Child Psychiatry & Human…•2022

  • Precursors and Effects of Self-reported Parental Reflective Functioning

    Open Access•Melanie Kungl, Melanie T Kungl et al.•Child Psychiatry & Human…•2024

  • Parental secure base support and child secure base use in mexican same-sex families

    Open Access•F Salinas-Quiroz, Fabiola Rodríguez-Sánchez et al.•Interpersona An International…•2022

  • Prenatal Psychological Adjustment, Relationship Satisfaction, and Parental Reflective Functioning

    Kristin J Perry, Stephanie A Godleski et al.•Parenting•2025

  • Socioemotional Mechanisms of Children’s Differential Response to the Effects of Maternal Sensitivity on Child Adjustment

    Jennifer A Somers, Linda J Luecken•Parenting•2020

  • The Unexpected for the Expecting Parent

    Keri Ka‐yee Wong, Gianluca Esposito•Parenting•2019

  • What watching others watching can tell us

    Nicola Dawson, Katherine Bain•Qualitative Research in Psychology•2021

  • Maternal cognition talk in the mother–toddler dyad mediates the influence of early maternal emotional availability on preschoolers' belief reasoning

    Open Access•Susanne Kristen, Maria Licata‐Dandel et al.•Social Development•2018

  • Do adolescent girls' relationships with their parents influence their perceptions of the therapeutic alliance and group climate in residential care

    Open Access•Mégan Rollin, Katherine Pascuzzo et al.•Child & Family Social Work•2023

  • Remediating Child Attachment Insecurity

    Open Access•Moniek A J Zeegers, Cristina Colonnesi et al.•Research on Social Work Practice•2019

  • Parents’ views on facilitating and inhibiting factors in the development of attachment relationships with their children with severe disabilities

    Open Access•Sien Vandesande, Dorien Steegmans et al.•Journal of Social and Personal…•2023

  • Can infant carrying prevent disorganized attachment? An intervention trial of adolescent mothers

    Open Access•Lela A Rankin, Lela Rankin et al.•Journal of Applied Developmental…•2026

  • Longitudinal links among parent-child attachment, emotion parenting, and problem behaviors of preadolescents

    Open Access•Juan Wang, Ying Yang et al.•Children and Youth Services Review•2021

  • The parental reflective functioning questionnaire

    Open Access•Katrine Isabella Wendelboe, Johanne Smith‐nielsen et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2022

  • Offline and online parental mentalizing in mothers with symptoms of postpartum depression

    Open Access•Katrine Isabella Wendelboe, Anne Christine Stuart et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2024

  • Relationship focused mother–infant groups

    Open Access•Sharon Cooke, Dawson Campbell Cooke et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2023

  • Development and validation of the Attachment Relationship Inventory—Caregiver Perception 2–5 years (ARI‐CP 2–5)

    Open Access•Anouk Spruit, Cristina Colonnesi et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2021

  • Triadic interactions, parental reflective functioning, and early social‐emotional difficulties

    Open Access•María José León, Marcia Olhaberry•Infant Mental Health Journal•2020

  • An explanatory model of parental sensitivity in the mother–father–infant triad

    Open Access•Marcia Olhaberry, María José León et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2022

  • Family risk and early attachment development

    Open Access•Jennifer Gerlach, Judith M Fößel et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2022

  • Testing reliability and validity of practitioner‐rated parental sensitivity

    Open Access•Mirte L Forrer, F Schneiders et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2024

  • Does Natural Mentoring Matter? A Multilevel Meta‐analysis on the Association Between Natural Mentoring and Youth Outcomes

    Open Access•Levi Van Dam, Dafne Smit et al.•American Journal of Community…•2018

  • The Role of Parental Reflective Functioning in Associations between Daily Autonomy-Relevant Parenting, Parenting Stress, and Early and Middle Adolescents’ Day-to-Day Difficulties

    Open Access•Simon Fiore, Elien Mabbe et al.•Journal of Youth and Adolescence•2025

  • Prospective Bidirectional Associations between Attachment and Depressive Symptoms from Middle Childhood to Adolescence

    Open Access•Laura Cortés-García, Lars Wichstrøm et al.•Journal of Youth and Adolescence•2019

  • Maternal nighttime sleep and infant–mother attachment security

    Open Access•L Bai, Christine Youngwon Kim et al.•Developmental Psychology•2022

  • Mind-mindedness in new mothers and fathers

    Foley, Rory T Devine et al.•Developmental Psychology•2022

  • When do mothers’ executive functions contribute to their representations of their child’s mind? A contextual view on parental reflective functioning and mind-mindedness

    Tal Yatziv, Yoav Kessler et al.•Developmental Psychology•2020

  • Mothers’ and fathers’ mind-mindedness in infancy and toddlerhood predict their children’s self-regulation at preschool age

    Milica Nikolić, Moniek A J Zeegers et al.•Developmental Psychology•2022

  • Long-term sequelae of mothers’ and fathers’ mind-mindedness in infancy

    Open Access•Jane Miller, Jane E Miller et al.•Developmental Psychology•2019

  • Maternal mind-mindedness during the first year of life

    Fabiola Silletti, Eliala A Salvadori et al.•Developmental Psychology•2022

  • Does expectant fathers' attachment style or depressive mood relate to their embodied mentalizing capacity of their 12-month-old infant

    Open Access•Hedvig Svendsrud, Mona Bekkhus et al.•Acta Psychologica•2026

  • Mentalizing Care

    Open Access•Katrine Isabella Wendelboe, Anne Christine Stuart et al.•Scandinavian Journal of Psychology•2025

  • How Does Representational Mind‐Mindedness Translate Into Observable Parenting Behaviors Among Parents of Six‐Year‐Olds

    Open Access•Riikka Pauliina Svane, Mette Skovgaard Væver et al.•Scandinavian Journal of Psychology•2025

  • Examining associations between Adult Attachment Interview responses and multiple indicators of parental mentalizing

    Open Access•Nikita Parkin, Amy Bird et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2026

  • Profiles of parental reflective functioning and mind‐mindedness in first‐time parents of 4‐month‐old infants

    Open Access•Eva Back Madsen, Ida Egmose et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2025

  • Holding dysregulation in mind

    Open Access•Anna Katharina Georg, Lea Alexandra Schlömp et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2025

  • Validation of the Parental Reflective Functioning Questionnaire in Finnish mothers and fathers of toddlers

    Open Access•Marjo Flykt, Hannu Haarala et al.•Infant Mental Health Journal•2025

  • Theory of mind and emotion regulation in school‐aged children

    Open Access•Plousia Misailidi, Peter Zimmermann et al.•Social Development•2024

  • What’s on your mind? The effects of an attachment-based intervention on residential youth workers’ reflexive functioning

    Open Access•Helena Carvalho, Tiago Ferreira et al.•Journal of Public Child Welfare•2024

  • Disorganized attachment in early childhood

    Open Access•Marinus H Van Ijzendoorn, Carlo Schuengel et al.•Development and Psychopathology•1999

  • Attachment, Exploration, and Separation

    Mary D Salter Ainsworth, Silvia M Bell•Child Development•1970

  • The Mother-Infant Relationship and Infant Attachment in a South African Peri-Urban Settlement

    Open Access•Mark Tomlinson, Peter Cooper et al.•Child Development•2005

Obras citantes distintas104
Citações por ano11,56
Intervalo de citações2017 - 2026 (10)
Velocidade de citaçãocurrent
Altamente citadoSim
Tipos de citaçãoNeutras: 103
Ethnos_APP • Projeto Open Source • Licença MIT • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacidade e Cookies • Documentação da API: api.ethnos.app/docs • Código da API: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Código do Frontend: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae