Comparative Responsiveness of Generic Versus Disease-Specific and Weighted Versus Unweighted Health Status Measures in Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

OBJECTIVES: The authors evaluated the relative responsiveness to change of generic versus disease-specific and unweighted versus weighted health status measures in carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). METHODS: Data were obtained from 196 subjects followed in a prospective community-based cohort study in Maine who underwent carpal tunnel release (The Maine Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Study). Patients were evaluated before and 6 months after surgery. The disease-specific, unweighted severity score was derived from the validated Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Assessment Questionnaire. Patients were asked to rate the importance of each symptom included in the severity score. Each severity question was weighted by its importance, creating a disease-specific weighted score. Generic instruments were the SF-36, SF-12, and a Quality of Life Rating Scale. Sensitivity to change was calculated with the standardized response mean (SRM, mean change/standard deviation of change) as well as the effect size (ES, mean change/standard deviation of baseline values). The ability of the instruments to distinguish clinically important differences was assessed by correlating the changes in scores with global ratings on satisfaction and perceived improvement as external criteria. RESULTS: The disease-specific weighted score (SRM: 1.56, ES: 1.99) was more responsive than the unweighted score (SRM: 1.36, ES: 1.57). The Quality of Life Rating Scale, SF-36, and SF-12 subscales were less sensitive to change, with standardized response means and effect sizes that ranged from -0.23 to 0.88. The ability to distinguish clinically important differences was higher for the two disease-specific scales. The coefficients of correlation with the external criteria ranged from 0.50 to 0.56 for the unweighted score and 0.56 to 0.62 for the weighted score and were significantly stronger than the correlations between external measures and the most responsive subscale of the SF-36 (Bodily Pain subscale, r = 0.36). The SF-12 health survey performed as well as the SF-36 in term of responsiveness and ability to distinguish clinically important change. CONCLUSIONS: Disease-specific measures were superior to generic measures in capturing clinical change after carpal tunnel release, and a weighted score was slightly more responsive than the unweighted score. The SF-12 showed comparable psychometric properties compared with the longer 36-item Short-Form Survey

Carpal tunnel · Carpal tunnel syndrome · Cohort · Physical therapy · Prospective cohort study · Quality of life (healthcare) · Rating scale · Severity of illness · Standard deviation · Statistics · Foot and Ankle Surgery · Internal Medicine · Mathematics · Medicine · Orthopedic Surgery and Rehabilitation · Peripheral Nerve Disorders · Surgery

• Statistical significant change versus relevant or important change in (quasi) experimental design

  Open Access•Berrie Middel, Eric Van Sonderen•International Journal of…•2002

  Incluir item

• Is a Generic Quality of Life Instrument Helpful for Evaluating Women with Urinary Incontinence

  Open Access•Seung‐June Oh, Seung-June Oh et al.•Quality of Life Research•2006

  Incluir item

• Defining clinically meaningful change in health-related quality of life

  Open Access•Ross D Crosby, Ronette L Kolotkin et al.•Journal of Clinical Epidemiology•2003

  Incluir item

• Is a single-item visual analogue scale as valid, reliable and responsive as multi-item scales in measuring quality of life

  Open Access•Angela G E M De Boer, J Jan B van Lanschot et al.•Quality of Life Research•2004

  Incluir item

• On assessing responsiveness of health-related quality of life instruments

  Open Access•Caroline B Terwee, F W Dekker et al.•Quality of Life Research•2003

  Incluir item

• How sharp is the short QuickDash? A refined content and validity analysis of the short form of the disabilities of the shoulder, arm and hand questionnaire in the strata of symptoms and function and specific joint conditions

  Open Access•Felix Angst, Jörg Goldhahn et al.•Quality of Life Research•2009

  Incluir item

• Measurement properties of the Boston Carpal Tunnel Questionnaire in subjects with neurophysiological confirmation of carpal tunnel syndrome

  Open Access•Camilo Mendoza‐Pulido, Fernando Ortiz‐Corredor et al.•Quality of Life Research•2021

  Incluir item

• Responsiveness of generic health-related quality of life measures in stroke

  Open Access•A Simon Pickard, Jeffrey Johnson et al.•Quality of Life Research•2005

  Incluir item

• Reliability and validity of functional health status and health-related quality of life questionnaires in children with recurrent acute otitis media

  Open Access•Carole N M Brouwer, Anne GM Schilder et al.•Quality of Life Research•2007

  Incluir item

• Effects of financial empowerment and self-confidence in financial empowerment on financial well-being

  Open Access•Su‐jung Nam•Current Psychology•2023

  Incluir item

• Interpretation of Changes in Health-related Quality of Life

  Geoffrey R Norman, Jeff A Sloan et al.•Medical Care•2003

  Incluir item

• Use of SF-36 and SF-12 Health Status Measures

  Daniel L Riddle, Kang T Lee et al.•Medical Care•2001

  Incluir item

• Methodological Inquiries in Health Status Assessment

  Colleen A Mchorney•Medical Care•1998

  Incluir item

• Psychometric Properties of the SF-12 (Hebrew Version) in a Primary Care Population in Israel

  Marianne Amir, N Lewin-Epstein et al.•Medical Care•2002

  Incluir item

• Reproducibility and responsiveness of health status measures statistics and strategies for evaluation

  Open Access•Richard A Deyo, Paula Diehr et al.•Controlled Clinical Trials•1991

  Incluir item

• Measuring change over time

  Open Access•Gordon Guyatt, Gordon Guaytt et al.•Journal of Chronic Diseases•1987

  Incluir item

• Bootstrap Methods

  B Efron•The Annals of Statistics•1979

  Incluir item

• Measurement of health status

  Open Access•Roman Jaeschke, Joel Singer et al.•Controlled Clinical Trials•1989

  Incluir item

• Measuring Health-Related Quality of Life

  Open Access•Gordon H Guyatt, Gordon Guaytt et al.•Annals of Internal Medicine•1993

  Incluir item

• A 12-Item Short-Form Health Survey

  John E Ware, Mark Kosinski et al.•Medical Care•1996

  Incluir item

• The MOS 36-ltem Short-Form Health Survey (SF-36)

  John E Ware, Cathy Donald Sherbourne•Medical Care•1992

  Incluir item

• Physician use in Ontario and the United States

  Steven J Katz, Timothy P Hofer et al.•American Journal of Public Health•1996

  Incluir item

• Workers' compensation recipients with carpal tunnel syndrome

  Jeffrey N Katz, Laura Punnett et al.•American Journal of Public Health•1996

  Incluir item

• Comparisons of Five Health Status Instruments for Orthopedic Evaluation

  Matthew H Liang, Anne H Fossel et al.•Medical Care•1990

  Incluir item

• Generic and Disease-Specific Measures in Assessing Health Status and Quality of Life

  Donald L Patrick, Richard A Deyo•Medical Care•1989

  Incluir item

• Comparative Measurement Sensitivity of Short and Longer Health Status Instruments

  Jeffrey N Katz, Martin G Larson et al.•Medical Care•1992

  Incluir item

• Effect Sizes for Interpreting Changes in Health Status

  Lewis E Kazis, Jennifer J Anderson et al.•Medical Care•1989

  Incluir item