Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

A definition of journalistic objectivity as a performance

Bibliographic Data

ID11268635
AuthorsSandrine Boudana (0000-0002-8968-2292, New York University, corresponding author)
Year2011
Volume33
Issue3
Pages385-398
Publication date2011-04-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueMedia Culture & Society (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0163-4437 • E-ISSN: 1460-3675
PublisherSAGE Publications (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/0163443710394899
OpenAlexW2106616519
LanguageEN
Citations received48
References cited19

Historically, journalism as a profession emerged alongside the notion of objectivity. However, in the past decades, objectivity has been dismissed not only as an unattainable standard but also as an undesirable norm. Yet an analysis of the criticisms reveals that most scholars actually fail to define journalistic objectivity. This article tries to remedy this flaw and to suggest that journalistic objectivity is an evolving notion which can no longer be considered a synonym for neutrality or detachment. Objectivity is a standard that promotes truth, defined as a ‘correspondence, grounded in correctness, between thought and reality’ (Heidegger, 1943:1). Unlike alternative standards which are centered on personal moral values, objectivity conceives of journalism as a performance, with this term referring to three interrelated dimensions: the essential notion of practice, the existence of concrete and universal criteria of evaluation, and the openness to criticisms

Correctness · Credibility · Epistemology · Journalism · Media studies · Neutrality · Objectivity (philosophy · Openness to experience · Sociology · Computer Science · Narrative Theory and Analysis · Philosophy · Psychology · Public Relations and Crisis Communication · Rhetoric and Communication Studies · Social Psychology

  • Modos narrativos de fazer mundos

    Open Access•Antonio Claudio Engelke Menezes Teixeira•Revista FAMECOS•2016

  • Shifting Journalistic Capital

    Lea Hellmueller, Tim P Vos et al.•Journalism Studies•2012

  • Networks of Reference

    Open Access•Thomas Martine, Juliette De Maeyer•Communication Theory•2018

  • News Algorithms, Photojournalism and the Assumption of Mechanical Objectivity in Journalism

    Matt Carlson•Digital Journalism•2019

  • Impartiality is not fair

    Open Access•Sandrine Boudana•Journalism•2015

  • Wie normativ ist die Kommunikationswissenschaft

    Open Access•Stephanie Geise, Ulrike Klinger et al.•Publizistik•2021

  • Differences Based on Individual- and Organizational-level Factors in Experiences of External Interference among Finnish Journalists

    Open Access•Ilmari Hiltunen, Aleksi Suuronen•Journalism Practice•2020

  • Chinese-style pragmatic objectivity in war reporting

    Shixin Ivy Zhang•Asian Journal of Communication•2014

  • Look at what the real facts and experts say! The use of expert references and objectivity claims in disinformation

    Open Access•Michael Hameleers, Emma Van Der Goot•Journalism•2024

  • The Inapplicability of Objectivity

    Jingrong Tong, Landong Zuo•Journalism Practice•2019

  • Situated, Embodied and Political

    Bolette B Blaagaard, Bolette Blaagaard•Journalism Studies•2012

  • Why the h**l is There a White House Correspondents’ Dinner?” Boundary Work in Political Journalism

    Gregory Perreault, Kellie Stanfield et al.•Journalism Practice•2019

  • Shifting boundaries

    Open Access•Bolette B Blaagaard, Bolette Blaagaard•Journalism•2013

  • Mediatized war and the moralizing function of news about disruptive events

    Open Access•Tal Morse•Journalism•2017

  • ‘It’s What I Do’

    Open Access•Sini Kaipainen•Persona Studies•2022

  • Signaling persuasion in crowdfunding entrepreneurial narratives

    Open Access•Wei Wang, Ling He et al.•Computers in Human Behavior•2021

  • Objectivity and Moral Judgment in U.S. News Narratives

    Mengyao Xu, Zhujin Guo•Journal of Media Ethics•2023

  • Epistemic Contests in Journalism

    Matt Carlson•Digital Journalism•2025

  • Data “Objectivity” in a Time of Coronavirus

    Shangyuan Wu•Digital Journalism•2021

  • Solidarity‐based collective action among third parties

    Open Access•Dorainne J Green, Ajua Duker et al.•Analyses of Social Issues and…•2023

  • ‘Nobody feels safe’

    Open Access•Kathryn Claire Higgins•Journalism•2022

  • Transformative journalisms and the seductive power of imagery in digital climate niche journalism

    Open Access•Sylvia Hayes, Saffron O''Neill et al.•Journalism•2025

  • Practices of objectivity formation in journalism education

    Open Access•Anders Kruse Ljungdalh•Journalism•2025

  • “Virus Jihad”

    Open Access•Anilesh Kumar•Howard Journal of Communications•2023

  • Entering an Information Era of Parallel Truths? A Qualitative Analysis of Legitimizing and De-legitimizing Truth Claims in Established Versus Alternative Media Outlets

    Open Access•Michael Hameleers, Nilou Yekta•Communication Research•2025

  • Moving Society to a Sustainable Future

    Dimitrinka Atanasova•Environmental Communication•2019

  • Layers and limits of power and resistance in multinational subsidiaries

    Open Access•Zehra Sayed, Michal Frenkel•Organization•2024

  • Gathering emotion

    K Megan Hopper, John Huxford et al.•Journal of Media Practice•2015

  • From impartial commentator to emotional choirmaster – using the concept of liminality to theorize the departure from journalistic ‘norms’ during moments of national sporting euphoria

    Open Access•Ulrik Wagner, Michael Skey•Journalism•2026

  • Extending emphasis framing in an age of factual relativism and epistemic polarization

    Open Access•Michael Hameleers•Journalism•2026

  • A study on the presentation of China’s Covid-19 news in American mainstream media

    Open Access•Cunling Gao, Jiashuo Fan•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2026

  • Fact Checking the Campaign

    Open Access•Mark Coddington, Logan Molyneux et al.•The International Journal of…•2014

  • Autonomy, Objectivity, and Transparency

    Open Access•Phoebe Maares, Kim Löhmann et al.•The International Journal of…•2025

  • The New York Times distorts the Palestinian struggle

    Open Access•Holly Jackson, Holly M Jackson•Media War & Conflict•2023

  • Picturing a journey of protest or a journey of harmony? Comparing the visual framing of the 2008 Olympic torch relay in the US versus the Chinese press

    Open Access•Ying Huang, Shahira S Fahmy•Media War & Conflict•2013

  • Debates da história

    Open Access•Marco Gomes•Media & Jornalismo•2018

  • The Normativity of Communication Research

    Stephanie Geise, Ulrike Klinger et al.•Mass Communication & Society•2021

  • Seeing a crisis through colored glasses

    Open Access•Myoung-Gi Chon, Elisabeth Fondren•Journal of Public Affairs•2019

  • Friending” Journalists on Social Media

    Jayeon Lee•Journalism Studies•2020

  • Truth, Nothing but the Performative Truth

    Ayo Adeduntan•Journalism Studies•2017

  • Indigenous media producers’ perspectives on objectivity, balancing community responsibilities and journalistic obligations

    Open Access•Elizabeth Burrows•Media Culture & Society•2018

  • What’s the harm in moonlighting? A qualitative survey on the role conflicts of freelance journalists with secondary employment in the field of PR

    Open Access•Romy Fröhlich, Thomas Koch et al.•Media Culture & Society•2013

  • Perfect as the Enemy of Good

    Willow Beck, Amélie Daoust-Boisvert•Environmental Communication•2025

  • Cosmopolitan relations in the colonies

    Open Access•Bolette B Blaagaard, Bolette Blaagaard•European Journal of Cultural…•2016

  • Exploring Language Styles Associated With Scientificness in Health News

    Open Access•Chingching Chang, Ying‐Ju Chiu et al.•Science Communication•2025

  • Automated Detection of Media Bias Using Artificial Intelligence and Natural Language Processing

    Open Access•Mar Castillo-Campos, David Becerra-Alonso et al.•Social Science Computer Review•2025

  • Notes on the wire

    Open Access•Christopher Joseph Westgate•Media Culture & Society•2013

  • Being Objective With a Personal Perspective

    Open Access•Jingrong Tong•Science Communication•2015

  • The media monopoly

    Ben H Bagdikian•The media monopoly•1992

  • That Noble Dream

    Open Access•Peter Novick•That Noble Dream•1988

  • Verbal art as performance

    Richard Bauman•Verbal art as performance•1977

  • The Epistemic Charity of the Social Constructivist Critics of Science and Why the Third World Should Refuse the Offer Meera Nanda

    Meera Nanda•A house built on sand•1998

  • Knowledge and class

    Open Access•Donna L Doane•Journal of Economic Behavior &…•1988

  • Decline of a paradigm? Bias and objectivity in news media studies

    Robert A Hackett•Critical Studies in Mass…•1984

  • Balance and the Writer's Attitude in News Stories and Editorials

    Open Access•Jean S Kerrick, Thomas E Anderson et al.•Journalism Quarterly•1964

  • Existential Objectivity

    Kevin Stoker•Journal of Mass Media Ethics•1995

  • Media Performance

    Denis Mcquail, David Pritchard•Canadian Journal of Communication•1993

  • Reading the Newseum

    Celeste Michelle Condit, Ted Friedman•Critical Studies in Mass…•1998

  • The objectivity norm in American journalism

    Open Access•M Schudson•Journalism•2001

  • Media Hegemony

    David L Altheide•Public Opinion Quarterly•1984

  • Poetics and Performances as Critical Perspectives on Language and Social Life

    Richard Bauman, Charles L Briggs•Annual Review of Anthropology•1990

  • Social Dramas and Stories about Them

    Victor Turner•Critical Inquiry•1980

  • Objectivity as Strategic Ritual

    Gaye Tuchman•American Journal of Sociology•1972

Unique citing works48
Citations per year3,43
Citation span2012 - 2026 (15)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 47

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae