Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Captive and Captor Representations at Canadian Penal History Museums

Bibliographic Data

ID12875263
AuthorsA M Chen (0000-0003-3309-873X, University of Ottawa, corresponding author), Sarah Fiander (Carleton University), Justin Piché (0009-0006-9673-400X, University of Ottawa), Kevin Walby (0000-0002-5107-2309, University of Winnipeg)
Year2016
Volume12
Issue4
Pages22-42
Publication date2016-10-31
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueQualitative Sociology Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1733-8077 • E-ISSN: 1733-8077
PublisherUniwersytet Lodzki (University of Lodz) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.18778/1733-8077.12.4.02
OpenAlexW4205965904
LanguageEN
Citations received8
References cited47

This article examines representations of prisoners and prison staff from 45 penal tourism sites across Canada. Drawing from literature on representations of criminal justice, we demonstrate that the objects, signs, and symbolism in these heritage sites are curated in ways that can create separation between penal spectators and prisoners. Positive representations of prison staff stand in contrast to depictions of prisoners who are often demonized in museum displays through emphasis placed on narratives, relics, and images of danger and violence. Arguing that these depictions generate conditions for the support and justification of punitive practices including incarceration, we conclude by reflecting on what our findings add to social science literature on representations of captives and captors

Art · Criminal justice · Criminology · Literature · Narrative · Political science · Prison · Punitive damages · Sociology · Tourism · Criminal Justice and Corrections Analysis · Law · Law in Society and Culture · Memory, Trauma, and Commemoration

  • “Everybody criticizes police, but nobody criticizes museums”

    Kevin Walby, Justin Piché et al.•TOPIA Canadian Journal of…•2021

  • ‘A prison is no place for a party’

    Open Access•Linda Mussell, Justin Piché et al.•Contemporary Justice Review•2022

  • Representations of detention and other pains of law enforcement in police museums in Ontario, Canada

    Matthew Ferguson, Justin Piché et al.•Policing & Society•2017

  • Fantastical Authenticity in Correctional Officer Recruitment Videos

    Bilguundari Enkhtugs, Kevin Walby•Corrections•2023

  • They Didn't Just Do It Because It Was a Job”

    Open Access•Kevin Walby, Justin Piché et al.•International journal of law,…•2018

  • Regimes of representation in Canadian police museums

    Open Access•Haley Pauls, Kevin Walby et al.•Crime Media Culture An…•2022

  • Sweat a little water, sweat a little blood”

    Open Access•Patricia Morris, Tammi Arford•Crime Media Culture An…•2018

  • Les musées de prison au Canada

    Justin Piché, Kevin Walby•Déviance et Société•2018

  • A social representation is not a quiet thing

    Open Access•Caroline Howarth•British Journal of Social…•2006

  • The polysemy of punishment memorialization

    Open Access•Kevin Walby, Justin Piché•Punishment & Society•2011

  • The Prison Officer

    Alison Liebling, David Price et al.•The Prison Officer•2010

  • The Museological Side of the Conflict

    Open Access•Yonatan Mendel, Alexa Rose Steinberg•Museum and Society•2011

  • The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

    Open Access•Jamie Bennett•The Howard Journal of Criminal…•2006

  • Racist and Political Extremist Graffiti in Australian Prisons, 1970s to 1990s

    Open Access•Jacqueline Z Wilson•The Howard Journal of Criminal…•2008

  • The Iconography of Punishment

    Open Access•Eamonn Carrabine•The Howard Journal of Criminal…•2011

  • Representations of Prison in Nineties Hollywood Cinema

    Open Access•Sean O’sullivan, Sean O'Sullivan•The Howard Journal of Criminal…•2001

  • UK Policing and its Television Portrayal

    Open Access•Sean O’sullivan, Sean O'Sullivan•The Howard Journal of Criminal…•2005

  • Unlocking the Gates

    Open Access•Dawn K Cecil, J Leitner et al.•The Howard Journal of Criminal…•2009

  • The ‘dangerous other’ in maximum-security prisons

    Open Access•Deborah H Drake•Criminology & Criminal Justice•2011

  • Smart on crime

    Open Access•David L Altheide, Michael Coyle•Crime Media Culture An…•2006

  • Show me the prison! The development of prison tourism in the UK

    Open Access•Alana Barton, Alyson Brown•Crime Media Culture An…•2015

  • Naming, shaming and criminal justice

    Open Access•Steven Kohm•Crime Media Culture An…•2009

  • Bridging or fostering social distance? An analysis of penal spectator comments on Canadian penal history museums

    Open Access•Matthew Ferguson, Justin Piché et al.•Crime Media Culture An…•2015

  • Lies, distortion and what doesn’t work

    Open Access•Paul Mason•Crime Media Culture An…•2006

  • Dionysian and Apollonian in Advertising The Representations of Pleasure and Discipline in Finnish Television Advertisements

    Open Access•Harri Sarpavaara•Qualitative Sociology Review•2007

  • The Jury Is Out

    Sean Kelley•Museums & Social Issues•2011

  • Looking Beyond Caged Heat

    Open Access•Dawn K Cecil•Feminist Criminology•2007

  • Girls' Juvenile Justice Uniforms

    Open Access•Connie Ulasewicz•Feminist Criminology•2007

  • Television, Public Space and Prison Population

    Open Access•Thomas Mathiesen, Thomas J Mathiesen•Punishment & Society•2001

  • Depth, weight, tightness

    Open Access•Ben Crewe•Punishment & Society•2011

  • Beyond populist punitiveness

    Open Access•Neil Hutton•Punishment & Society•2005

  • US punitiveness ‘Canadian style’? Cultural values and Canadian punishment policy

    Open Access•Cheryl Marie Webster, Anthony N Doob•Punishment & Society•2015

  • Dark tourism and the celebrity prisoner

    Jacqueline Z Wilson•Journal of Australian Studies•2004

  • Re-theorizing the penal reform functions of the prison film

    Open Access•David Wilson, Sean O’sullivan•Theoretical Criminology•2005

  • Crime behind the glass

    Open Access•Laura Huey•Theoretical Criminology•2011

  • If you drop the soap in the shower you are on your own

    Open Access•Helen Eigenberg, Agnes L Baro et al.•Sexuality & Culture•2003

  • Courtroom proverbial murals in Lebanon

    Victor Khachan•Social Semiotics•2012

  • Prison Decayed

    Paul Mason•Social Semiotics•2006

  • Collecting the Gaze

    Joan Faber Mcalister•Women s Studies in Communication•2013

  • A Museum of Hope

    Open Access•Clifford Shearing, Michael Kempa•The Annals of the American…•2004

  • Public/Private Service

    Open Access•Martin Eide, Martin D Eide et al.•European Journal of Communication•1999

  • Bristol, slavery and the politics of representation

    Olivette Otele•Social Semiotics•2012

  • Critical Punishment Memorialization in Canada

    Open Access•Sarah Fiander, Ashley Chen et al.•Critical Criminology•2016

  • Tourists' expectations and perceptions of the Robben Island Museum-a world heritage site

    Nancy Phaswana-Mafuya, Nancy Phaswana‐Mafuya et al.•Museum Management and Curatorship•2005

  • Consuming dark tourism

    Open Access•Philip R Stone, Philip Stone et al.•Annals of Tourism Research•2008

  • The selected representation of contested prison history

    Hui-Wen Lin•International Journal of Heritage…•2015

  • Countering Punitiveness

    Open Access•Anthony N Doob, Cheryl Marie Webster•Law & Society Review•2006

  • Reforming the Carceral Past

    Seth C Bruggeman•Radical History Review•2012

Unique citing works8
Citations per year0,89
Citation span2017 - 2023 (7)
Citation velocityhistorical
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 8

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae