Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Abandoning Care? A Critical Perspective on Personalisation from an Ethic of Care

Bibliographic Data

ID12902157
AuthorsMarian Barnes (Barnes Hospital, corresponding author)
Year2011
Volume5
Issue2
Pages153-167
Publication date2011-05-28
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueEthics and Social Welfare (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1749-6535 • E-ISSN: 1749-6543
PublisherTaylor & Francis (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/17496535.2010.484265
OpenAlexW2045385541
LanguageEN
Citations received67
References cited18

The adoption of personalisation as the principle on which policy and practices for social care in England should be developed has been hailed as marking a fundamental transformation in the nature of social care and the experiences of service users. This article examines both the discourse of personalisation and the practices that are being adopted to implement this from an ethic of care perspective. It adopts an approach based on Sevenhuijsen's ‘Trace’ analysis to trace the normative frameworks in key policy documents (in particular Putting People First), noting that critics of care have largely succeeded in relegating care to a marginal position within policy discourse and that a relational sensibility is largely absent within this. The article considers the practices associated with personalisation in relation to the moral principles of an ethic of care and conceptions of the ‘individual’ within these. It addresses the implications of this approach for broader political and policy issues: the universality of provision, collective responsibility for welfare and well-being, and broader issues of social justice in conditions of vulnerability

Business · Environmental ethics · Ethics of care · Law and economics · Normative · Personalization · Political science · Politics · Public relations · Sociology · Geriatric Care and Nursing Homes · Healthcare innovation and challenges · Law · Social Policy and Reform Studies

  • Against Critical Thinking in Health, Social Care and Social Work

    Tom Grimwood•Against Critical Thinking in…•2023

  • Families, policy and place in times of austerity

    Open Access•Eleanor Jupp•Area•2017

  • Building knowledge for policy and practice based on service user and carer experiences

    Open Access•Fiona Sherwood‐johnson, Kathryn Mackay•Journal of Social Work•2021

  • Choice, control and person-centredness in day centres for older people

    Open Access•KATHARINE ORELLANA, Jill Manthorpe et al.•Journal of Social Work•2021

  • Relational pedagogy in social care education

    Niall Hanlon•Social Work Education•2024

  • Marketisation, Ethics and Healthcare

    Open Access•Angeliki Kerasidou, Ruth Horn et al.•Marketisation, Ethics and…•2018

  • Exploring the Ethical Underpinnings of Self-advocacy Support for Intellectually Disabled Adults

    Rohhss Chapman, Elizabeth Tilley•Ethics and Social Welfare•2013

  • Inform with Care

    Marian Barnes, Flis Henwood•Ethics and Social Welfare•2015

  • Person-centred acute hospital care for older people transitioning to residential aged care- whose needs are being met

    Sacha Kendall, Edward Reid•Ethics and Social Welfare•2016

  • What Justice, What Autonomy? The Ethical Constraints upon Personalisation

    John Owens, Teodor Mladenov et al.•Ethics and Social Welfare•2016

  • Older Women’s Expectations of Care, Reciprocity, and Government Support in Australia. ‘Am I Not Worthy?’

    Cassie Curryer, Mel Gray et al.•Ethics and Social Welfare•2018

  • Metaphors in a Patient's Narrative

    Christina Sinding•Ethics and Social Welfare•2014

  • You Were a Lifesaver’

    Jane Midgley•Ethics and Social Welfare•2017

  • Community Care

    Marian Barnes•Ethics and Social Welfare•2019

  • Ethics and Social Welfare the Journal

    Derek Clifford•Ethics and Social Welfare•2025

  • Relational Care Ethics from a Comparative Perspective

    YOSHIMI WADA•Ethics and Social Welfare•2014

  • Disenchanted Subjects? On the Experience of Subjectivity in Care Relations

    Catrin Dingler•Ethics and Social Welfare•2015

  • The Spaces of Personalisation

    Open Access•Claudia Needham•Social Policy and Society•2014

  • Conceptualisations of care

    Rosie Harrison•Medical Humanities•2021

  • Safeguarding and personal budgets

    Open Access•Fiona Aspinal, M Stevens et al.•The Journal of Adult Protection•2019

  • Dangerous care

    Open Access•Fiona Sherwood‐johnson, Fiona Sherwood-Johnson et al.•The Journal of Adult Protection•2023

  • The employment conditions of social care personal assistants in England

    Open Access•John Woolham, Caroline Norrie et al.•The Journal of Adult Protection•2019

  • Human rights and social justice in social work education

    María Inés Martínez Herrero, Helen Charnley•European Journal of Social Work•2018

  • Professional caring in affective services

    Open Access•Niall Hanlon•European Journal of Social Work•2021

  • Social workers’ negotiation of the liminal space between personalisation policy and practice

    Carol Southall, Sarah Lonbay et al.•European Journal of Social Work•2019

  • Counting inclusion with Chantal Mouffe

    Stacy Clifford Simplican, Geraldine Leader•Disability & Society•2015

  • Constructions of ‘vulnerability’ in comparative perspective

    Fiona Sherwood‐johnson, Fiona Sherwood-Johnson•Disability & Society•2012

  • Fresh news as meaningful? A multi‐site ethnographic analysis of meaningful activities at four day centres in Denmark and Norway

    Open Access•Christine Øye•Health & Social Care in the…•2022

  • Thinking ahead? Exploring adult social care provision with older people in Northern Ireland

    Open Access•Alexandra Chapman•Health & Social Care in the…•2018

  • Community treatment orders

    Open Access•Laura Banks, Laura Catherine Banks et al.•Health & Social Care in the…•2015

  • High-conflict divorce involving children

    Rachel Treloar•The Journal of Social Welfare Law•2018

  • Staff members' negotiation of power in client engagement

    Open Access•Andrea Petriwskyj, Alexandra Gibson et al.•Journal of Aging Studies•2015

  • Care, Disability, and Violence

    Open Access•Stacy Clifford Simplican•Hypatia•2014

  • Constituting link working through choice and care

    Open Access•Beatrice Griffith, Tessa Pollard et al.•Sociology of Health & Illness•2023

  • Towards a Caring Sociology

    Open Access•Bernhard Weicht•KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für…•2025

  • Ageing and Care Poverty

    Open Access•Kirstein Rummery, Teppo Kröger et al.•KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für…•2025

  • Care

    Open Access•Kirstein Rummery, Michael Fine•Social Policy and Administration•2012

  • Day centres for older people

    Open Access•KATHARINE ORELLANA, Jill Manthorpe et al.•Ageing and Society•2018

  • Manoeuvring challenging demands

    ANNA DUNÉR, G T Gustafsson•International Journal of Care and…•2020

  • Facilitators of, and barriers to, personalisation in care homes in England

    Jacqueline Damant, Stefanie Ettelt et al.•International Journal of Care and…•2022

  • Surveillance, intervention and the politics of care

    Chris Kubiak, Leah Tomkins et al.•International Journal of Care and…•2019

  • No one was clapping for us’

    Maria Cheshire‐Allen, Gideon Calder•International Journal of Care and…•2022

  • Between ‘Choice’ and ‘Active Citizenship’

    Ellen Grootegoed•Ethics and Social Welfare•2013

  • Gender Differences in Making Moral Decisions

    Sania Bilwani, Gulnaz Anjum•Ethics and Social Welfare•2021

  • Doing, Being and Becoming a Valued Care Worker

    Jill Manthorpe, J J Harris et al.•Ethics and Social Welfare•2016

  • Choosing to Live with Harm? A Presentation of two Case Studies to Explore the Perspective of those who Experienced Adult Safeguarding Interventions

    Kathryn Mackay•Ethics and Social Welfare•2017

  • Everyday ethics in professional life

    Bank•Ethics and Social Welfare•2016

  • A Relationship Between the Ethics of Care and Māori Worldview—The Place of Relationality and Care in Maori Mental Health Service Provision

    Tula Brannelly, Amohia Boulton et al.•Ethics and Social Welfare•2013

  • When morals and markets collide’

    Martin Woods, Suzanne Phibb et al.•Ethics and Social Welfare•2017

  • The changing shape of provision for rough sleepers

    Sadie Parr•Housing Studies•2022

  • Personalization

    Open Access•Claudia Needham, Catherine Needham•Critical Social Policy•2014

  • Irreconcilability of heritage missions

    Open Access•Jane Johnstone, Jane Hamilton Johnstone et al.•Annals of Tourism Research•2023

  • Do direct payments improve outcomes for older people who receive social care? Differences in outcome between people aged 75+ who have a managed personal budget or a direct payment

    Open Access•John Woolham, Guy Daly et al.•Ageing and Society•2017

  • Older People, Personalisation and Self

    Open Access•Gareth O'Rourke•Ageing and Society•2016

  • Older people's exercising of choice in long-term care

    Open Access•YOSHIMI WADA•Ageing and Society•2016

  • Caring relationships and their role in users’ choices

    Open Access•Ricardo Rodrigues•Ageing and Society•2020

  • Ethical dilemmas

    Open Access•Emma Miller, Karen Barrie•Ageing and Society•2022

  • Will Direct Payments Make Adult Residential Care more Personalized? Views and Experiences of Social Care Staff in the Direct Payments in Residential Care Trailblazers

    Open Access•Lorraine Williams, Stefanie Ettelt et al.•Social Policy and Administration•2017

  • The right to care? Social citizenship and care poverty in developed welfare states

    Open Access•Kirstein Rummery•International Journal of…•2023

  • The Costs and Benefits of Personal Budgets for Older People

    John Woolham, C Benton•The British Journal of Social Work•2013

  • Acquired Brain Injury, Social Work and the Challenges of Personalisation

    Mark Holloway, Rachel Fyson•The British Journal of Social Work•2016

  • Transforming Practice with Older People through an Ethic of Care

    Lizzie Ward, Marian Barnes•The British Journal of Social Work•2016

  • Accounting for care within human geography

    Open Access•Jennie Middleton, Farhan Samanani•Transactions of the Institute of…•2020

  • Tracing State Accountability for Covid-19

    Open Access•Felicity Daly, Claire Edwards•Social Policy and Society•2025

  • Do Personal Budgets Increase the Risk of Abuse? Evidence from English National Data

    Open Access•Mohamed Yusoff Ismail, Mohamed Ismail et al.•Journal of Social Policy•2017

  • Informing health? Negotiating the logics of choice and care in everyday practices of 'healthy living

    Open Access•Flis Henwood, Roma Harris et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2011

  • Negotiating the practical ethics of 'self-tracking' in intimate relationships

    Open Access•Catherine M Will, Catherine Will et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2020

  • Oppositional Consciousness

    Joanna Mansbridge, Aldon D Morris et al.•Oppositional Consciousness•2001

  • Participation, Responsibility and Choice

    Evelina Hendrika Tonkens, Anneli Anttonen et al.•Participation, Responsibility and…•2011

  • Love’s Labor

    Eva Feder Kittay•Love's Labor•2019

  • Disability and social policy

    Alan Roulstone, Hugh Bochel•Social Policy•2020

  • Participation, Citizenship and a feminist ethic of care

    Open Access•Marian Barnes•Care, Community and Citizenship•2018

  • International perspectives on health and social care. Partnership working in action

    Open Access•Trudi Nederland•International Journal of…•2009

  • Impairment and Disability

    Open Access•Jenny Morris•Hypatia•2001

  • South African Social Welfare Policy

    Open Access•Selma Sevenhuijsen, Vivienne Bozalek et al.•Critical Social Policy•2003

  • A new vision for adult social care? Continuities and change in the care of older people

    Open Access•Mark Lymbery•Critical Social Policy•2010

  • Caring in the third way

    Open Access•Selma Sevenhuijsen•Critical Social Policy•2000

  • Users as Citizens

    Open Access•Marian Barnes•Social Policy and Administration•1999

  • New Directions in the Sociology of Health

    Lynne E Lonnquist, Pamela Abbott et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1991

  • Increasing User Choice or Privatizing Risk? The Antinomies of Personalization

    Iain Ferguson•The British Journal of Social Work•2007

  • In a different voice

    Carol Gilligan, Carol Gilliagan•In a Different Voice•1993

Unique citing works67
Citations per year4,47
Citation span2011 - 2025 (15)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 66

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae