Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Entrepreneurial ecosystems and public policy in action

A critique of the latest industrial policy blockbuster

Bibliographic Data

ID12913629
AuthorsRoss Brown (0000-0002-6164-7639, University of St Andrews, corresponding author), Suzanne Mawson (0000-0003-1983-514X, University of Stirling)
Year2019
Volume12
Issue3
Pages347-368
Publication date2019-06-29
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueCambridge Journal of Regions Economy and Society (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1752-1386 • E-ISSN: 1752-1378
PublisherOxford University Press (OUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1093/cjres/rsz011
OpenAlexW2955259652
LanguageEN
Citations received28
References cited70

Efforts to develop entrepreneurial ecosystems (EEs) have proliferated in recent years, marking it out as the latest industrial policy ‘blockbuster’. This article reports the findings from the first comprehensive empirical analysis of EE policy approaches. It posits a basic typology of different policy frameworks deployed under the ecosystem rubric. The findings suggest the concept is fraught with conceptual ambiguity and is predominantly (and rather crudely) used to promote ‘more’ entrepreneurship. The research suggests the concept is a ‘messy metaphor’, open to wide-ranging misinterpretation and misuse by policymakers. In terms of recommendations, eradicating network failures, avoiding crude policy isomorphism and tailoring bespoke interventions to the specific nature of EEs are viewed as key policy lessons

Action (physics · Advertising · Ambiguity · Bespoke · Business · Economic growth · Economics · Entrepreneurship · Metaphor · Political science · Public policy · Public relations · Rubric · Sociology · Typology · Computer Science · Entrepreneurship Studies and Influences · Innovation Policy and RD · Private Equity and Venture Capital · Marketing

  • Start-up competitions as anchor events in Entrepreneurial Ecosystems

    Open Access•Lennard Stolz•Geografiska Annaler Series B…•2023

  • Toward an Entrepreneurial Ecosystem Research Program

    Open Access•Bernd Wurth, Emlyn Stam et al.•Entrepreneurship Theory and…•2022

  • Reprint of

    Open Access•Augusto Rocha, Ross Brown et al.•Research Policy•2022

  • A new tool for policymakers

    Open Access•Timothy R Hannigan, Anthony R Briggs et al.•Research Policy•2022

  • Mission-oriented or mission adrift? A critical examination of mission-oriented innovation policies

    Ross Brown•European Planning Studies•2021

  • Science and technology parks as evolving policy instruments

    Open Access•Jesús M Valdaliso, Cristina Andrés•European Planning Studies•2025

  • Sharing and exchange dynamics in entrepreneurial spaces

    Open Access•Lukas Schnell, Elisabeth S C Berger•Technological Forecasting and…•2025

  • Exploring Entrepreneurial Ecosystems in Developed Countries

    Open Access•Stephen Mago, Stephan van der Merwe•SAGE Open•2023

  • Innovation Ecosystem framework directed to Sustainable Development Goal #17 partnerships implementation

    Open Access•Larissa Oliveira Duarte, Diane Aparecida Reis et al.•Sustainable Development•2021

  • Which regional conditions facilitate university spinouts retention and attraction

    Federica Rossi, Ning Baines et al.•Regional Studies•2021

  • Places are not like people

    Open Access•Ross Brown, Suzanne Mawson et al.•Regional Studies•2022

  • Network governance and coordination of a regional entrepreneurial ecosystem

    Open Access•Stephen Knox, Norin Arshed•Regional Studies•2021

  • Towards a problem-oriented regional industrial policy

    Kieron Flanagan, Elvira Uyarra et al.•Regional Studies•2022

  • Regional incidence and persistence of high-growth firms

    Open Access•Alex Coad, Clemens Domnick et al.•Regional Studies•2025

  • Stranded nations? Transition risks and opportunities towards a clean economy

    Open Access•Pia Andres, Penny Mealy et al.•Environmental Research Letters•2023

  • A meta-analysis of entrepreneurial ecosystem elements and entrepreneurial activity

    Open Access•Martin Queissner, Lennard Stolz et al.•Small Business Economics•2025

  • Entrepreneurial finance and regional ecosystem emergence

    Open Access•P A Clayton, Paige Clayton et al.•Small Business Economics•2024

  • Examining the cohesiveness and nestedness entrepreneurial ecosystems

    Open Access•Ben Spigel•Small Business Economics•2022

  • Sowing the seeds of rural prosperity? The limited impact of Usda investments on county-level business dynamics

    Open Access•Pankaj C Patel•Small Business Economics•2026

  • Agencing entrepreneurial ecosystems for sustainability

    Open Access•Patrick Gregori, Erich J Schwarz et al.•Small Business Economics•2025

  • Effective policy mixes in entrepreneurial ecosystems

    Open Access•Hongqi Wang, Tianyi Zhao et al.•Small Business Economics•2023

  • Colonialism versus independence—the role of entrepreneurial ecosystems in Azerbaijan over time

    Open Access•Ganira Ibrahimova, Petra Moog•Small Business Economics•2023

  • Industrial policy back on the agenda

    Open Access•David Bailey, Amy Glasmeier et al.•Cambridge Journal of Regions…•2019

  • Rural entrepreneurial ecosystems

    Open Access•Gillian Bond, Paul Ryan et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2026

  • Spatialities of entrepreneurial ecosystems

    Open Access•Saskia Schäfer, Susann Schäfer•Geography Compass•2021

  • Spatial implications of digitization

    Open Access•Lonnie Haefner, Robert Sternberg•Geography Compass•2020

  • How Does the Local State Mediate the Relationship Between Technological Change and Work? Evidence from Warehousing in England

    Open Access•Abbie Winton, Charles Umney et al.•Work and Occupations•2025

  • Multiple entrepreneurial ecosystems? Worker cooperative development in Toronto and Montréal

    Open Access•Jason Spicer, Michelle Zhong•Environment and Planning A…•2022

  • Startup communities

    Open Access•Brad Feld•Startup Communities•2012

  • The resilience of entrepreneurial ecosystems

    Open Access•Philip T Roundy, Beverly K Brockman et al.•Journal of Business Venturing…•2017

  • The Relational Organization of Entrepreneurial Ecosystems

    Open Access•Ben Spigel•Entrepreneurship Theory and…•2017

  • The financing of business start-ups

    Open Access•Gavin Cassar•Journal of Business Venturing•2004

  • Ecosystem as Structure

    Open Access•Ron Adner•Journal of Management•2017

  • A critical review of entrepreneurial ecosystems research

    Janna Alvedalen, Ron Boschma•European Planning Studies•2017

  • Innovation ecosystems

    Open Access•Deog-Seong Oh, F Y Phillips et al.•Technovation•2016

  • Entrepreneurial Ecosystems and Regional Policy

    Emlyn Stam•European Planning Studies•2015

  • Localised learning and industrial competitiveness

    Peter Maskell•Cambridge Journal of Economics•1999

  • Some Causal Effects of an Industrial Policy

    Chiara Criscuolo, Ralf Martin et al.•American Economic Review•2019

  • A place-based developmental regional industrial strategy for sustainable capture of co-created value

    Open Access•David Bailey, Christos Pitelis et al.•Cambridge Journal of Economics•2018

  • Systemic instruments for systemic innovation problems

    Anna Wieczorek, A J Wieczorek et al.•Science and Public Policy•2012

  • National Systems of Entrepreneurship

    Open Access•Zoltan J Acs, Eero Autio et al.•Research Policy•2014

  • Entrepreneurial ecosystems

    Open Access•David B Audretsch, James A Cunningham et al.•The Journal of Technology Transfer•2019

  • Is There a Case for Industrial Policy? A Critical Survey

    Howard Pack•The World Bank Research Observer•2006

  • Toward a process theory of entrepreneurial ecosystems

    Open Access•Ben Spigel, Richard Harrison•Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal•2018

  • The lineages of the entrepreneurial ecosystem approach

    Open Access•Zoltan J Acs, Emlyn Stam et al.•Small Business Economics•2017

  • Hierarchical and relational governance and the life cycle of entrepreneurial ecosystems

    Open Access•Alessandra Colombelli, Emilio Paolucci et al.•Small Business Economics•2019

  • Three waves and counting

    Open Access•Friederike Welter, Ted Baker et al.•Small Business Economics•2019

  • Looking inside the spiky bits

    Open Access•Ross Brown, Colin Mason•Small Business Economics•2017

  • A trajectory of early-stage spinoff success

    Open Access•Christopher S Hayter•Small Business Economics•2016

  • Rebalancing the Spatial Economy

    Ron Martins•Territory Politics Governance•2015

  • The evolution of entrepreneurial ecosystems and the critical role of migrants. A Phase-Model based on a Study of IT startups in the Greater Tel Aviv Area

    Open Access•Susann Schäfer, Sebastian Henn•Cambridge Journal of Regions…•2018

  • Policy and collective action in place

    Open Access•Mitchell Feldman, Maryann Feldman et al.•Cambridge Journal of Regions…•2018

  • Deconstructing clusters

    Ron Martins, R Martin et al.•Journal of Economic Geography•2002

  • The failure of market failure

    Open Access•Richard O Zerbe, Howard E Mccurdy•Journal of Policy Analysis and…•1999

  • The evolutionary dynamics of entrepreneurial ecosystems

    Open Access•Elizabeth A Mack, Elizabeth Mack et al.•Urban Studies•2016

  • Fuzzy Concepts, Scanty Evidence, Policy Distance

    Ann Markusen•Regional Studies•2003

  • Creating entrepreneurial communities

    Deborah M Markley, Thomas S Lyons et al.•Community Development•2015

  • An effectual leadership perspective for developing rural entrepreneurial ecosystems

    Open Access•Morgan P Miles, Mark Morrison•Small Business Economics•2018

  • Institutional life within an entrepreneurial region

    Open Access•Nichola Lowe, Mitchell Feldman et al.•Geography Compass•2017

  • Entrepreneurship and entrepreneurial ecosystems

    Open Access•Edward J Malecki•Geography Compass•2018

  • Where do innovations come from? Transformations in the US economy, 1970-2006

    F Block, Matthew R Keller•Socio-Economic Review•2009

  • When Ideas Trump Interests

    Open Access•Dani Rodrik•The Journal of Economic…•2014

  • Institutional Thickness Revisited

    Elena Zukauskaite, Michaela Trippl et al.•Economic Geography•2017

  • Industrial Policy in the United States

    Open Access•Andrew Schrank, Josh Whitford•Latin American Politics and Society•2009

  • Swimming Against the Current

    Open Access•F Block•Latin American Politics and Society•2008

  • The Anatomy of Network Failure

    Open Access•Andrew Schrank, Josh Whitford•Sociological Theory•2011

Unique citing works28
Citations per year4
Citation span2019 - 2026 (8)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 27

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae