Outlaws and Misfits

The images of the writer as exile and outlaw were central to modernism's cultural positioning. As the Scrutiny circle's ‘literary criticism’ became the dominant way of reading in the University English departments and then in the grammar-schools, it took over these outsider images as models for the apprentice-critic. English pedagogy offered students not only an approach to texts, but an implicit identity and affective stance, which combined alert resistance to the pervasive effects of mechanised society with a rhetoric of emotional ‘maturity’, belied by a chilly judgementalism and gender anxiety. In exchanges over the close reading of intransigent, difficult texts, criticism's seminars sought a stimulus to develop the emotional autonomy of its participants against the ‘stock response’ promulgated by industrial capitalism. But refusal to reflect on its own method meant such pedagogy remained unconscious of the imitative pressures that its own reading was placing on its participants

Aesthetics · Art · Close reading · Criticism · Linguistics · Literature · Modernism (music · Narrative · Political science · Psychoanalysis · Rhetoric · Scrutiny · Sociology · Unconscious mind · Law · Philosophy · Political theory and Gramsci · Postcolonial and Cultural Literary Studies · Psychology · Theatre and Performance Studies