Controlled trials of vitamin D, causality and type 2 statistical error

Two recent studies published in The Lancet (Autier et al. (2013) Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol 2 , 76–89 and Bolland et al. (2014) Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol 2 , 307–320) have concluded that low levels of vitamin D are not a cause but a consequence of ill health brought about by reduced exposure to the sun, an association known as ‘reverse causality’. The scientific evidence and reasoning for these conclusions are examined here and found to be faulty. A null result in a clinical trial of vitamin D in adults need not lead to a conclusion of reverse causation when low vitamin D is found in observational studies of the same disease earlier in life. To assume an explanation of reverse causality has close similarities with type 2 statistical error. For example, a null result in providing vitamin D for treatment of adult bones that are deformed in the pattern of the rachitic rosary would not alter the observation that lack of vitamin D can cause rickets in childhood and may have lasting consequences if not cured with vitamin D. Other examples of diseases considered on a lifetime basis from conception to adulthood are used to further illustrate the issue, which is evidently not obvious and is far from trivial. It is concluded that deficiency of vitamin D in cohort studies, especially at critical times such as pregnancy and early life, can be the cause of a number of important diseases. Denial of the possible benefits of vitamin D, as suggested by insistent interpretation of studies with reverse causation, may lead to serious harms, some of which are listed

Biology · Causation · Cohort · Denial · Diabetes mellitus · Disease · Econometrics · Epistemology · Null hypothesis · Observational study · Physics · Pregnancy · Rickets · Vitamin · Vitamin D and neurology · vitamin D deficiency · Healthcare cost, quality, practices · Mathematics · Medicine · Meta-analysis and systematic reviews · Philosophy · Psychology · Vitamin D Research Studies · Endocrinology · Internal Medicine · Pediatrics · Physiology

• On the pitfalls of disclosure statements

  Open Access•Marilyn Tseng, Allison Hodge et al.•Public Health Nutrition•2016

  Add to list

• Evaluation, Treatment, and Prevention of Vitamin D Deficiency

  Open Access•Michael F Holick, Neil Binkley et al.•The Journal of Clinical…•2011

  Add to list

• Resurrection of vitamin D deficiency and rickets

  Open Access•Michael F Holick•Journal of Clinical Investigation•2006

  Add to list

• Distribution of Paget's disease in England, Wales and Scotland and a possible relationship with vitamin D deficiency in childhood

  D J P Barker, D J Barker et al.•Journal of Epidemiology and…•1974

  Add to list