Strangers in the Land

Patterns of American Nativism, 1860-1925

Bibliographic Data

ID19606519
AuthorsCarl Wittke, John Higham (0000-0003-1405-7035)
Year1956
Volume61
Issue3
Pages657-657
Publication date1956-04-01
Open AccessNo
TypeREVIEW
Review ofStrangers in the Land Patterns of American Nativism 1800-1925, John Higham, 1973
VenueThe American Historical Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0002-8762 • E-ISSN: 1937-5239
PublisherOxford University Press (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.2307/1847639
OpenAlexW1999388699
LanguageEN

Higham's work stands as the seminal work in the history of American nativism. The work is a careful, well-documented study of nationalism and ethnic prejudice, and chronicles the power and violence of these two ideas in American society from 1860 to 1925. He significantly moves beyond previous treatments of nativism, both in chronology and in interpretive sophistication. Higham defines nativism as a defensive type of nationalism or intense opposition to internal minority on the grounds of the group's foreign connections. By defining nativism as a set of attitudes or a state of mind, he sets the course for his book as tracing emotionally charged impulse rather than an actual social process or condition. As he argues that the ideological content of nativism remained consistent, he uses emotional intensity as a measure to trace in detail public opinion from the relative calm following the Civil War to the Johnson-Reed act of 1924 that severely limited European immigration. Strangers in the Land is, then, a history of public opinion, whose purpose is to show how nativism evolved in society and in action. Higham seeks to explain what could inflame xenophobia and who resisted it. He saw his work as part of a renewed interest in the study of nationalism following the national upheavals in the wake of the McCarthy hearings. Surely Higham's mentor at the University of Wisconsin, intellectual historian Merle Curti, influenced Higham's approach in seeking to examine the power of nationalism as idea. Also influential was the intellectual climate of the 1950s with its of distrust of ideology and distain of prejudice. Higham admits being repelled by the nationalist delusions of the Cold War, again helping to explain why his study concentrates on seeking some explanation for the irrational and violent outbreaks. The book thus focuses on points of conflict, antagonisms that belong within ideologies of passionate national consciousness. For example, Higham's explains the 100 percent American movement in terms of progressive ideals and the desire of Americans to shape immigrants into a particular ideal of Americanness through education and assimilation. This intellectual construct eventually gave way to the racial thinking to which Higham assigns much influence in the efforts to restrict immigration. Ideology is also central to his chapter on the history of the idea of racism in which he argues that Anglo-Saxon nationalism, literary naturalism and a nascent understanding of genetics combined to bring forth arguments for immigration restriction to preserve the racial purity of the American people. Thus, key for Higham's argument is the power of ideas in shaping individual behavior and thereby shaping history. This text is absolute must-read for anyone seeking to understand American nativism and the darker side of nationalism

Criminology · Ideology · Immigration · Nationalism · Opposition (politics) · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Psychological nativism · Radicalization · Sociology · Xenophobia · History · Italian Fascism and Post-war Society · Law · Political theory and Gramsci · Race, History, and American Society

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub