Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Virgil on the Nature of Things

The Georgics , Lucretius and the Didactic Tradition

Bibliographic Data

ID19949595
AuthorsMonica R Gale (0000-0002-6032-5718, Trinity College Dublin, corresponding author)
Year2000
Publication date2000-11-09
Open AccessYes
TypeBOOK
VenueVirgil on the Nature of Things (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherCambridge University Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1017/cbo9780511482182
OpenAlexW4214684578
Open LibraryOL7753524M
ISBN9780511482182
LanguageEN
Citations received93

The Georgics has for many years been a source of fierce controversy among scholars of Latin literature. Is the work optimistic or pessimistic, pro- or anti-Augustan? Should we read it as a eulogy or a bitter critique of Rome and her imperial ambitions? This book suggests that the ambiguity of the poem is the product of a complex and thorough-going engagement with earlier writers in the didactic tradition: Hesiod, Aratus and - above all - Lucretius. Drawing on both traditional, philological approaches to allusion, and modern theories of intertextuality, it shows how the world-views of the earlier poets are subjected to scrutiny and brought into conflict with each other. Detailed consideration of verbal parallels and of Lucretian themes, imagery and structural patterns in the Georgics forms the basis for a reading of Virgil's poem as an extended meditation on the relations between the individual and society, the gods and the natural environment

Allusion · Art · Eulogy · Intertextuality · Linguistics · Literature · Natural (archaeology) · Parallels · Philology · Poetry · Reading (process) · Sociology · Classical Antiquity Studies · Classical Philosophy and Thought · Historical, Religious, and Philosophical Studies · History · Philosophy · Allusions · Allusions in literature · Ancient - Rome · Ancient and Classical · Ancient, Classical & Medieval · Ancient, in literature · Classic Literature · Criticism · Criticism and interpretation · Didactic poetry · Didactic poetry, history and criticism · Didactic poetry, Latin · Fiction · General · Georgica · History & Surveys - Ancient & Classical · History and criticism · in literature · Influence · Knowledge · Knowledge and learning · Language · Latin · Latin Didactic poetry · Latin literature · Latin poetry · Latin poetry, history and criticism · Literary collections · Literary Criticism · Literary studies: classical, early & medieval · Literature - Classics · Lucretius Carus, Titus · Philosophy in literature · Poetry & poets: classical, early & medieval · Roman Literature · Roman Philosophy · Rome · Virgil

  • The Hesiodic Catalogue of Women

    Open Access•Robin Osborne, Jenny Strauss Clay et al.•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • Approaches to Lucretius

    Donncha ca /21 Jhd O'Rourke, Lucretius in Theory Edinburgh et al.•Approaches to Lucretius•2020

  • Amores 1.1–5

    David West, D R F West•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Epic Inclusivity

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • The Historian's Presence, or, There and Back Again

    Cynthia Damon•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Voices of Resistance

    Richard Rutherford•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Roma and Her Tutelary Deity

    Francis Cairns•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Juvenal and the Delatores

    J G F Powell•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Allusion and Contrast in the Letters of Nicias (Thuc. 7.11–15) and Pompey (Sall. Hist. 2.98M)

    Elizabeth A Meyer•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Intra‐Epic Debate

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • Narrative and Speech Problems in Thucydides Book I

    John Moles•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Eros and Empire

    John Marincola•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Seven Passages of the Annals (and One of Manilius)

    E Courtney•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Dionysius of Halicarnassus and Livy on the Horatii and the Curiatii

    S P Oakley•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • On Not Being Archilochus

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • Divide and Conquer

    Christina Shuttleworth Kraus•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Lyric Flexibility

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • Scipio the Matchmaker

    Jane D Chaplin•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Munera uestra cano

    Damien Nelis•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Pompeius Trogus in Tacitus' Annals

    D S Levene, David Levene•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • The Art of Losing

    Elizabeth Keitel•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Ambition to Rise

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • Fathers and Sons

    Denis Feeney•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Rome and Persia 357–9

    Robin Seager•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • The Spur of Fame

    Christopher Pelling•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • The Great Escape

    Rhiannon Ash•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Romani ueteres atque urbani sales

    Anna Chahoud•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Beyond Pastoral? Generic Pressures in Vergil's Eclogues

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • Velleius Mythistoricus

    T P Wiseman•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

  • Introduction

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • The Hesiodic Catalogue and Hellenistic poetry

    Open Access•Richard Hunter•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • A catalogue within a catalogue

    Open Access•Ettore Cingano•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • Gods among men? The social and political dynamics of the Hesiodic Catalogue of Women

    Open Access•Elizabeth Irwin•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • Poetry and Power

    Open Access•Richard Tarrant•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Virgil’s Intertextual Personae

    Open Access•J Farrell•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Virgil

    Open Access•Fiachra Mac Góráin•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Or such as Ovid's Metamorphoses …

    Open Access•Richard Fletcher•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • Character in Virgil

    Open Access•Helen Lovatt•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Virgil in Art

    Open Access•L B T Houghton•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Sons and Lovers

    Open Access•Ellen Oliensis•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Virgil and Tragedy

    Open Access•Philip Hardie•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Rome and its Traditions

    Open Access•James E G Zetzel•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Intertextuality

    Open Access•Donncha O’Rourke, Aaron Pelttari•The Cambridge Critical Guide to…•2024

  • From genealogy to Catalogue

    Open Access•Helen Asquith•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • Virgil’s Style

    Open Access•James J O’Hara•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Virgilian Didaxis

    Open Access•William W Batstone•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • The Virgil Commentary of Servius

    Open Access•Don Fowler, Sergio Casali et al.•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Virgilian Epic

    Open Access•Duncan F Kennedy•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • The beginning and end of the Catalogue of Women and its relation to Hesiod

    Open Access•Jenny Strauss Clay•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • The Death of Virgil

    Open Access•Fiona Cox•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • The Megalai Ehoiai

    Open Access•Giovan Battista D'Alessio•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • The Hesiodic Catalogue of Women and Latin poetry

    Open Access•Philip Hardie•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • Virgilian Narrative

    Open Access•Don Fowler, Alessandro Barchiesi•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Ordered from the Catalogue

    Open Access•Giovan Battista D'Alessio•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • Ordering women in Hesiod's Catalogue

    Open Access•Robin Osborne•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • The Appendix Vergiliana

    Open Access•Scott Mcgill•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Mestra at Athens

    Open Access•Ian Rutherford•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • Abused Bodies in Roman Epic

    Open Access•Andrew M Mcclellan•Abused Bodies in Roman Epic•2019

  • Post-classical Commentary

    Open Access•Sergio Casali, Fabio Stok•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Heracles in the Hesiodic Catalogue of Women

    Open Access•Johannes Haubold•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • Aspects of Virgil’s Reception in Antiquity

    Open Access•Richard Tarrant•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Closure and the Book of Virgil

    Open Access•Elena Theodorakopoulos•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Virgil as a Poet

    Open Access•Victoria Moul•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Virgilian Narrative

    Open Access•Alessandro Barchiesi•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Common Ground in Lucretius’ De Rerum Natura

    Open Access•Barnaby Taylor•Approaches to Lucretius•2020

  • Green Politics

    Open Access•Charles Martindale•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • The Bugonia Ritual in Virgil’s Georgics

    Open Access•Rukiye ÖZTÜRK•International Journal of Ancient…•2026

  • Seneca’s Etna

    Open Access•Myrto Garani•Dictynna•2023

  • Lucretius Franco-Hibernicus

    Fabio Tutrone•Illinois Classical Studies•2020

  • Poets and Readers in Seventh-Century Rome

    Open Access•Dennis Trout•Traditio•2020

  • The Sorrowful Song of Philomela ( Aetna 586–587)

    Lorenzo Vespoli•Philologus•2020

  • Hollow Love

    Kenneth Draper•Classical Philology•2022

  • Glossing the Georgics

    Robert Cowan•Classical Philology•2020

  • Callimachus, Lucretius, and Didactic Elements in Vergil’s Aeneid -Proem

    Jason S Nethercut•Classical Philology•2020

  • Deserta regna

    Brian W Breed•Classical Philology•2024

  • Songs of Monkeys

    Radhakrishna, Sindhu Radhakrishna•Macaque Connection•2013

  • The Cambridge Companion to Virgil

    Open Access•Charles Martindale, Fiachra Mac Góráin•Cambridge Companion to Virgil•2019

  • Oppian's Halieutica

    Open Access•Emily Kneebone•Oppian's Halieutica•2020

  • Camadas de ensinamento na poesia didática romana

    Open Access•Matheus Trevizam•Aletria Revista de Estudos de…•2019

  • Ancient Roman Literary Gardens

    K Sara Myers•Ancient Roman Literary Gardens•2024

  • Vergil’s Physics of Bugonia in Georgics 4

    Peter Osorio•Classical Philology•2019

  • The Secondary Incipit of the Odyssey ( Od. 9.39)

    Massimo Cè•Classical Philology•2022

  • Vergil, Georgics 1.1-42 and the pompa circensis

    Open Access•Damien Nelis, Jocelyne Nelis‐Clément et al.•Dictynna•2011

  • The farmer wants a wife

    Open Access•Robert Cowan•Bulletin of the Institute of…•2023

  • Materiam superabat opus

    Open Access•Alessandro Schiesaro•The Journal of Roman Studies•2014

  • Placement, Gender, Pedagogy

    Open Access•Andrew Wallace•Renaissance Quarterly•2003

  • Bugonia and the Aetiology of Didactic Poetry in Virgil, Georgics 4

    Open Access•Patrick Glauthier•The Classical Quarterly•2019

  • Alas, Poor Io! Bilingual Wordplay in Horace Epode 11

    Robert Cowan•Mnemosyne•2012

  • The Georgics , the Mysteries and the Muses at Rome

    Open Access•Alex Hardie•Proceedings of the Cambridge…•2002

  • Generic Enrichment in Vergil and Horace

    S J Harrison, Shane Harrison•Generic Enrichment in Vergil and…•2007

  • Temple Building, Primus Language, and the Proem to Virgil’s Third Georgic

    David Meban•Classical Philology•2008

  • The Hesiodic Catalogue of Women

    R L Hunter, Elizabeth Irwin et al.•Hesiodic Catalogue of Women•2005

  • Ancient Historiography and its Contexts

    Cynthia Damon, C B R Pelling et al.•Ancient historiography and its…•2010

Unique citing works93
Citations per year3,88
Citation span2002 - 2026 (25)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 93

Tools

Open DOILibgen
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae