Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Uses of Comparative History in Macrosocial Inquiry

Bibliographic Data

ID2107172
AuthorsT Skocpol (0000-0002-3866-8108, Harvard University Press), Margaret R Somers (0000-0003-4751-6808, Harvard University Press), Margaret Somers
Year1980
Volume22
Issue2
Pages174-197
Publication date1980-04-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueComparative Studies in Society and History (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0010-4175 • E-ISSN: 1475-2999
PublisherCambridge University Press (CUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1017/s0010417500009282
OpenAlexW2109860650
LanguageEN
Citations received438
References cited28

Comparative history is not new. As long as people have investigated social life, there has been recurrent fascination with juxtaposing historical patterns from two or more times or places. Part of the appeal comes from the general usefulness of looking at historical trajectories in order to study social change. Indeed, practitioners of comparative history from Alexis de Tocqueville and Max Weber to Marc Bloch, Reinhard Bendix, and Barrington Moore, Jr. have typically been concerned with understanding societal dynamics and epochal transformations of cultures and social structures. Attention to historical sequences is indispensable to such understanding. Obviously, though, not all investigations of social change use explicit juxtapositions of distinct histories. We may wonder, therefore: What motivates the use of comparisons as opposed to focussing on single historical trajectories? What purposes are pursued-and how-through the specific modalities ofcomparativehistory

Aesthetics · Appeal · Comparative history · Epistemology · Modalities · Order (exchange · Political science · Social science · Sociology · Wonder · History · Law · Philosophy · Political Conflict and Governance · Political Science Research and Education · Qualitative Comparative Analysis Research

  • Decentering Comparative Analysis in a Globalizing World

    Olivier Giraud, Michel Lallement•Decentering Comparative Analysis…•2022

  • Brown and White

    Open Access•Claire Whitlinger, Gary Alan Fine•Sociological Forum•2026

  • Reach and Retrenchment of the Environmental State

    Livio Silva‐muller, Livio Silva-Muller•American Journal of Sociology•2026

  • Accumulation of Knowledge in Theoretical History

    Open Access•Sergey V Tsirel, С В Цирель•Cliodynamics The Journal of…•2010

  • Riqueza mineral e desenvolvimento social

    Open Access•Beni Trojbicz•Desenvolvimento em Questão•2016

  • Reflections in colonial glass? women factory inspectors in Britain and New Zealand 1893-1921

    Barbara Harrison, Melanie Nolan•Women s History Review•2004

  • Interpretive Methods

    Open Access•R Stryker•International Encyclopedia of the…•2015

  • Bibliographie

    Alain Caillé•La Sociologie historique…•2002

  • Skocpol, Theda (1947–)

    Open Access•Ian Sheinheit•International Encyclopedia of the…•2015

  • A historical, not comparative, method

    Open Access•Jack A Goldstone, Jack Α Goldstone•Anatomy of Power•2006

  • "Weltbeziehung"

    Open Access•Bettina Hollstein, Hartmut Rosa et al.•"Weltbeziehung"•2023

  • Women and States

    Open Access•Ann E Towns•Women and States•2010

  • Sex and the State

    Open Access•M Htun•Sex and the State•2003

  • Democracy in Europe

    Vivien A Schmidt•Democracy in Europe•2006

  • Race and Regionalism in the Politics of Taxation in Brazil and South Africa

    Open Access•Evan S Lieberman, Eva Lieberman•Race and Regionalism in the…•2003

  • Strategies of Causal Assessment in Comparative Historical Analysis

    Open Access•James Mahoney•Comparative Historical Analysis…•2003

  • Not All Events Are Attended Equally

    Andrew J Hoffman, William Ocasio•Organization Science•2001

  • Mobilizing community energy

    Open Access•Elizabeth Bomberg, Nicola Mcewen•Energy Policy•2012

  • Monopoly Politics

    Erik Peinert•Monopoly Politics•2025

  • Comparing Across Political Systems

    Hans Keman•Vergleichen in der Politikwissensch…•2005

  • Manuscript and Print in the Islamic Tradition

    Scott Steven Reese, THE THE et al.•Manuscript and Print in the…•2022

  • Is America Becoming More Exceptional?

    Open Access•Frank Dobbin•Restructuring the Welfare State•2002

  • Neue Historische Soziologie

    Rainer Schützeichel•Handbuch Soziologische Theorien•2009

  • The Politics of Electoral Reform

    Open Access•Alan Renwick•Politics of Electoral Reform•2010

  • Redistributing the Poor

    Armando Lara-Millán, Armando Lara‐millán•Redistributing the Poor•2021

  • Comparative Grand Strategy

    Peter J Dombrowski, Thierry Balzacq et al.•Comparative Grand Strategy•2019

  • Women, the State, and Welfare

    Teresa L Amott, Paula Baker et al.•Women, the State, and Welfare•2012

  • The ‘meaning’ of children in Dutch and German family policy

    Open Access•Trudie Knijn, Ilona Ostner•Childhood•2009

  • The rise of work-based academic education in Austria, Germany and Switzerland

    Open Access•Lukas Graf•Journal of Vocational Education…•2016

  • What We Know About the Development of Social Policy

    Open Access•E Amenta•Comparative Historical Analysis…•2003

  • Comparative Historical Analysis

    Open Access•James Mahoney, Dietrich Rueschemeyer•Comparative Historical Analysis…•2003

  • Orchestrators of coordination

    Open Access•Marius R Busemeyer, Martin B Carstensen et al.•European Journal of Industrial…•2022

  • Co-evolution of skills and welfare in coordinated market economies? A comparative historical analysis of Denmark, the Netherlands and Switzerland

    Open Access•Christine Trampusch•European Journal of Industrial…•2010

  • Employers and collectively negotiated occupational pensions in Sweden, Denmark and Norway

    Open Access•Christine Trampusch•European Journal of Industrial…•2013

  • Liberalization by Exhaustion

    Marius R Busemeyer, Christine Trampusch•Zeitschrift für Sozialreform•2016

  • No ordinary press owners

    Open Access•Jean K Chalaby•Media Culture & Society•1997

  • The Sex Wage Gap in Japan and Sweden

    Johanna Kumlin•European Sociological Review•2006

  • Commoning mobilizations and institutional outcomes in Indian forests from colonial to postcolonial periods

    Open Access•Fiona Gladstone, Arun Agrawal•Ecological Economics•2026

  • Comparative Area Studies and the Study of the Global South

    Open Access•Rounak Sil, Rudra Sil et al.•Vestnik RUDN International…•2020

  • La comparación de las desigualdades sociales entre Europa y América Latina

    Open Access•Leticia Muñiz Terra, Pablo Molina Derteano•Cuestiones de sociología•2021

  • China's Political Influence in Turkey and Iran during the Cold War

    Open Access•Agah Hazır•İran Çalışmaları Dergisi•2021

  • Migrant mineworkers and South Africa’s diplomatic relations with Botswana and Lesotho , 1906-2006

    Open Access•Kekgaoditse Suping•Cogent Social Sciences•2022

  • University Spaces as Agents of National Belonging

    Open Access•Laraib Niaz, Kusha Anand•Education Sciences•2021

  • Instituciones políticas y análisis comparativo

    Open Access•Martin Armelino, Santiago L Cunial•Ciencia Política•2021

  • Sino–American relations and the ‘new cold war’

    Open Access•Barbara Friedman, Ori Sela•Global Policy•2023

  • ‘Failures’ in a failing education system

    Open Access•Nicola Savvides, Sandrina Milhano et al.•British Journal of Education & Work•2021

  • ‘It doesn’t take much force’ – The negotiation of gender by two women motor mechanic apprentices through the biographical lens

    Michaela Brockmann•Journal of Vocational Education…•2021

  • Teologías situadas en Corea del Sur y Argentina. Un estudio comparativo de la Teología Minjung y la Teología del pueblo durante los regímenes autoritarios del siglo XX

    Open Access•María Del Pilar Álvarez, Pablo Forni et al.•Ilu Revista de Ciencias de las…•2025

  • On the scientific study of small samples

    Open Access•Rose Mcdermott•The Leadership Quarterly•2023

  • Implementing the transformative innovation policy in the European Union

    Mattia Casula•European Planning Studies•2022

  • Contemporary planning and emergent futures

    Open Access•Alan Mabin, Philip Harrison•Progress in Planning•2023

  • Uneven recognition

    Open Access•Andi Rahmat Hidayat, Otto Hospes et al.•Land Use Policy•2026

  • Beyond the average effect of the innovation subsidies

    Open Access•Maciej Koniewski, Seweryn Krupnik et al.•Evaluation and Program Planning•2024

  • From How to Why

    Open Access•Naoki Nishida•Japanese Sociological Review•2023

  • Because we were angry

    Open Access•Stephanie Kristine Decker, Anna Curtis•International Journal of…•2026

  • Regulatory Territory and General Deterrence Across Borders

    Open Access•Emmanuelle Reuter, Florian Überbacher et al.•Administrative Science Quarterly•2025

  • Mustafa İslamoğlu, Adam Smith’de Rasyonalite, Filiz Kitabevi, 2021, 372 s

    Open Access•Onur Dündar•Journal of Humanity and Society…•2023

  • Falsificationism redux

    Simeon J Newman•Journal of Critical Realism•2024

  • Learning from the Future

    Jorge Rivas•Journal of Critical Realism•2009

  • Periodizing, paths and probabilities

    Erik Peinert•Review of International Political…•2018

  • Gender, States, and Social Policies

    Open Access•Bruce G Carruthers•Law & Social Inquiry•1993

  • Business Models for Sustainable Technology

    Open Access•Emmanuelle Reuter, Tao Krauspe•Organization & Environment•2023

  • Technological Change and Productivity Growth in Livestock Systems

    Jorge Alvarez, María de las Mercedes Menéndez•Scandinavian Economic History…•2024

  • Comparisons

    Open Access•Jennifer Robinson•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2011

  • Case Selection for Case‐Study Analysis

    John Gerring•The Oxford handbook of political…•2009

  • “Provincializing” Sociology

    Open Access•Manu Goswami•Postcolonial Sociology•2013

  • Aligning Ontology and Methodology in Comparative Politics

    Open Access•Peter A Hall•Comparative Historical Analysis…•2003

  • On Revolutions

    Colin J Beck, Mlada Bukovansky et al.•On Revolutions•2022

  • Hope and Honor

    R L Einwohner•Hope and Honor•2022

  • How Terrorist Groups End

    Seth G Jones, Martin C Libicki•How terrorist groups end•2008

  • Ideology and Mass Killing

    Jonathan Leader Maynard•Ideology and Mass Killing•2022

  • From Peril to Partnership

    Paul Angelo, Paul J Angelo•From Peril to Partnership•2023

  • Roman Artisans and the Urban Economy

    Open Access•Cameron Hawkins•Roman Artisans and the Urban…•2016

  • Practising Comparison

    Open Access•Ozden Sahin, J Deville et al.•Practising Comparison•2016

  • Coercive Distribution

    Open Access•Michael Albertus, Sofia Fenner et al.•Coercive Distribution•2018

  • Transitional Justice and Corporate Accountability from Below

    Open Access•Leigh A Payne, Gabriel Pereira et al.•Transitional Justice and…•2020

  • El método comparativo en la investigación social y en el análisis histórico

    Open Access•Danilo Torres Reina•Historia Y Espacio•2021

  • A Multidimensional Theory of Early Modern Western Childhood

    G David Johnson•Journal of Comparative Family…•1990

  • The Old Social History and the New Social Sciences

    Herbert S Kein, H S Klein•Journal of Social History•2006

  • The Role of General Theory in Comparative-Historical Sociology

    Edgar Kiser, Michael Hechter•American Journal of Sociology•1991

  • Making the Country Work for the City

    Open Access•Daniel Block, E Melanie Dupuis•American Journal of Economics and…•2001

  • Instituições Participativas No Brasil

    Debora Rezende De Almeida•DESIGUALDADE E DIVERSIDADE•2019

  • Komparation i kritisk realistisk perspektiv

    Peter Wad•Dansk Sociologi•2006

  • Economías ilegales y redes transnacionales del cártel de Sinaloa con Colombia

    Open Access•Yeni Girón Galeano•Estado & comunes•2026

  • Home heating transition in Finland, Romania, Sweden and the United Kingdom through the combined lens of energy democracy, energy citizenship and energy justice

    Open Access•J Palm, Anna Ambrose et al.•Energy Sustainability and Society•2026

  • Social Movements and International Order Formation

    Open Access•Alejandro M Peña, Thomas Davies•International Organization•2026

  • The US Minimum Wage in Comparative Perspective

    Open Access•Teri L Caraway, İbrahim Öker•Perspectives on Politics•2026

  • The formation and transformation of the Korean art world

    Open Access•Joon Han•International Sociology•2026

  • Historical Research and Social Movements

    Open Access•Mathieu Deflem, April Lee Dove•The Wiley-Blackwell Encyclopedia…•2013

  • Rome, Tenochtitlan, and Beyond

    Open Access•Walter Scheidel•SSRN Electronic Journal•2015

  • The New Breed in Japan

    Open Access•Laurel Anderson, Marsha Wadkins•Canadian Journal of Administrative…•1992

  • Globally Themed Organizations as Labor Market Intermediaries

    E A Marantz, A Kalev et al.•Social Forces•2014

  • State migrant-exporting schemes and their implications for the rise of Illicit migration

    Open Access•Christina Siracusa, Kristel Acacio•Journal of International…•2004

  • Forced Migration, Sexual and Gender-based Violence and Integration

    Open Access•J Phillimore, Katharina Block et al.•Journal of International…•2023

  • Artefactos Culturales E Identidades

    Open Access•Giovanna María Aldana Barahona, Ambar Varela Mattute•Chungara•2023

  • L'Histoire Comparative et le Champ des Études Migratoires

    Open Access•Nancy L Green•Annales Histoire Sciences Sociales•1990

  • Health-Related Lifestyle

    Open Access•Yana Roshchina•Journal of Economic Sociology•2016

  • Gamification - the Way of Motivation or Way of Control over the Labor Process

    Open Access•Elena Tcyplakova•Journal of Economic Sociology•2016

  • Digital Labor and the Sharing Economy

    Open Access•Ivana Pais•Journal of Economic Sociology•2016

  • Dictators Against Dependence

    Open Access•Lynn T White, Aileen S P Baviera•Asian Politics & Policy•2018

  • Comparative Methods in the Social Sciences

    Neil J Smelser•Comparative Methods in the Social…•2013

  • Comparative Methods in Sociology

    Ivan Vallier•Comparative Methods in Sociology•1971

  • Lineages of the Absolutist State

    Perry Anderson•Lineages of the Absolutist State•2013

  • Kings or People

    Reinhard Bendix•Kings or People•1978

  • The Rebellious Century

    Charles Tilly, Louise A Tilly et al.•Rebellious Century•1975

  • Conquest and Commerce

    Douglas Greenberg, James Lang•Journal of American History•1976

  • Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-Industrial Europe

    Robert Brenner•Past & Present•1976

  • Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy

    Barrington Moore, Jr Barrington Moore•Social Origins of Dictatorship…•1974

  • The modern world-system

    Immanuel Maurice Wallerstein, Antonio Resines•The Modern World-System I:…•1974

  • Agrarian revolution

    Jeffery M Paige•Agrarian revolution•1975

  • The Political Systems of Empires

    Bernice Martins, Bernice Martin et al.•British Journal of Sociology•1964

  • Chinese Consumption of Foreign Commodities

    Gary G Hamilton•American Sociological Review•1977

  • Economic Growth of Brazil, India and Japan

    R O Buchanan, Robert Buchanan et al.•Geographical Journal•1957

  • Marc Bloch and the Logic of Comparative History

    William H Sewell•History and Theory•1967

  • Conquest and Commerce

    John J Tepaske, James Lang•The William and Mary Quarterly•1976

  • Comparative Politics and the Comparative Method

    Open Access•Arend Lijphart•American Political Science Review•1971

  • Islam Observed

    I M Lewis, Clifford Geertz•Man•1969

  • The Limits of Agronomic Determinism

    Open Access•Margaret R Somers, Walter L Goldfrank•Comparative Studies in Society…•1979

  • France, Russia, China

    Open Access•T Skocpol•Comparative Studies in Society…•1976

  • The Rise and Future Demise of the World Capitalist System

    Open Access•Immanuel Wallerstein•Comparative Studies in Society…•1974

  • States and Social Revolutions

    Open Access•T Skocpol•States and Social Revolutions•1979

Unique citing works438
Citations per year8,11
Citation span1972 - 2026 (55)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 432

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae