Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Emotions in the doing of science

Exploring epistemic affect in elementary teachers' science research experiences

Bibliographic Data

ID21392884
AuthorsShannon G Davidson (0000-0003-3583-4147, School of Teacher Education Florida State University Tallahassee Florida USA, corresponding author), Lama Z Jaber (0000-0002-5809-7330, School of Teacher Education Florida State University Tallahassee Florida USA), Sherry A Southerland (0000-0002-0824-4611, School of Teacher Education Florida State University Tallahassee Florida USA)
Year2020
Volume104
Issue6
Pages1008-1040
Publication date2020-11-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueScience Education (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0036-8326 • E-ISSN: 1098-237X
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1002/sce.21596
OpenAlexW3092052819
LanguageEN
Citations received47
References cited61

A critical component to disciplinary engagement in science is that of epistemic affect—learning how to feel as scientists do when engaged in their work. The emotional responses, feelings, and dispositions that emerge as one participates in the construction of knowledge are part and parcel to the experiences of scientists and, we argue, should be integral to the experiences of science learners—and their teachers—as well. As such, this study takes the position that teachers must have opportunities to encounter, understand, and appreciate the epistemic affect in science to support students in navigating their affect in the science classroom. Through analysis of field observations and semistructured interviews conducted during a 6‐week Research Experience for Teachers program, this study examines how four elementary teachers experience an epistemic affect over the course of their engagement in scientific research. The findings of the study highlight that engaging in science research afforded teachers rich opportunities to experience epistemic affect, ranging from frustration, perseverance, and ultimately pride in their work. We argue such firsthand affective experiences within professional development programs featuring participation in science research hold important implications for teachers' instructional practice and orientations to their students as thinkers, doers, and learners of science

Affect (linguistics) · Discipline · Feeling · Mathematics education · Nature of Science · Pedagogy · Political science · Pride · Science education · Social science · Sociology · Education and Critical Thinking Development · Educational Strategies and Epistemologies · Psychology · Science Education and Pedagogy · Social Psychology

  • Justiça epistêmica e afetos epistêmicos na Educação em Ciências

    Open Access•Eloísa Cristina Gerolin•2024

  • Aprendizaje Basado en Proyectos en la indagación científica en estudiantes de secundaria

    Open Access•Gina Jesús Vega Lezama, Freddy Neptali Castro Luján et al.•Revista Tribunal•2025

  • Shaping people-place bonds in citizen science

    Open Access•Benjamin Haywood, Benjamin K Haywood et al.•Conservation Ecology•2024

  • Epistemic agency in introductory biology

    Open Access•Shane A Thomas, Susan D Hester et al.•International Journal of STEM…•2026

  • Teacher Research Experiences

    Open Access•Eric Lindley, Elizabeth Edmondson et al.•Journal of Science Teacher…•2026

  • Identifying and Classifying Observed Emotions in Informal Science Learning Environments Using the Emotions Observational Tool (Emotool)

    Open Access•Neta Shaby, Luisa Medeiros Massarani et al.•Research in Science Education•2026

  • An instrument for measuring scientific empathy in students’ disciplinary engagement

    Open Access•Heesun Yang, Dean P Anderson et al.•Frontiers in Education•2023

  • The influence of emotions on science teaching

    Open Access•Florencia Natalia Praderio Gaias, Melina Furman et al.•Frontiers in Education•2024

  • Enhancing relevance and authenticity in school science

    Open Access•Francesco De Zuani Cassina, Emma D’Orto et al.•Frontiers in Education•2023

  • Experiential Learning in Upper Elementary Science Classrooms

    Open Access•Neyoulla T AlJurdi, Sara Salloum•Journal of Experiential Education•2025

  • “He got a glimpse of the joys of understanding” – The role of epistemic empathy in teacher learning

    Lama Z Jaber•Journal of the Learning Sciences•2021

  • Scientific Thinking and Critical Thinking in Science Education

    Open Access•Antonio García‐Carmona•Science & Education•2025

  • Cultivating Science Teachers’ Understandings of Science as a Discipline

    Open Access•Shannon G Davidson, Lama Z Jaber et al.•Science & Education•2022

  • Exploring the Nature of Science Conceptions of University Science Professors Using the Family Resemblance Framework

    Open Access•Rana Issam Baddour, Saouma Boujaoude•Science & Education•2025

  • Antecedents of Chilean in-service science teachers’ emotions

    Pedro Membiela Iglesia, Katherine Acosta et al.•European Journal of Teacher…•2025

  • For the Love of Water. Designing and Assessing a Sand Filter for Integral Sustainability Education

    Open Access•Laura Salahange, Jesús Sánchez-Martín et al.•European Journal of Education•2026

  • Motivation for science learning as an antecedent of emotions and engagement in preservice elementary teachers

    Open Access•Pedro Membiela Iglesia, Manuel Miguel Jordán Vidal et al.•Science Education•2022

  • Navigating student uncertainty for productive struggle

    Open Access•Ying-Chih Chen, Michelle Jordan et al.•Science Education•2024

  • Motivation to learn science, emotions in science classes, and engagement towards science studies in Chilean and Spanish compulsory secondary education students

    Open Access•Pedro Membiela Iglesia, Katherine Acosta et al.•Science Education•2023

  • Emotional configurations in STEM classrooms

    Open Access•Ashlyn Pierson, Corey Brady et al.•Science Education•2023

  • Emotion, place, and practice

    Open Access•Kathryn Lanouette•Science Education•2022

  • Development of the science teaching anxiety scale for preservice elementary teachers

    Open Access•Elena Novak, Ilker Soytürk et al.•Science Education•2022

  • Unpacking PCK Relationships and Development in Science Teachers

    Open Access•Soonhye Park, Kennedy Kam Ho Chan•Review of Educational Research•2025

  • Becoming‐STEMM Educator‐With a Unit on Germs Implemented in a Haunted Kindergarten Classroom

    Open Access•Katherine Ann Ayers, Katherine Ayers et al.•Journal of Research in Science…•2026

  • Which Knowledge Do Pre‐Service Teachers Need to Meaningfully Engage in Modeling

    Open Access•Paul Engelschalt, Erik Maslyak et al.•Journal of Research in Science…•2026

  • A self‐reported instrument to measure and foster students' science connection to life with the Care ‐ KNOW ‐ DO model and open schooling for sustainability

    Open Access•Alexandra Okada•Journal of Research in Science…•2024

  • Connected by emotion

    Open Access•Guopeng Fu, Anthony Clarke•Journal of Research in Science…•2024

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Grace A Chen, Dana Vedder-Weiss et al.•Instructional Science•2026

  • We never even touched plants this way”

    D Dutta, Sanjay Chandrasekharan•Environmental Education Research•2024

  • Students’ epistemic emotions in a science classroom

    Moonhyun Han, Phil Seok Oh•International Journal of Science…•2024

  • Break out” – learning about disability and the inclusive city through emotion and affect

    Open Access•Bettina Van Hoven•Journal of Geography in Higher…•2025

  • Desirable uncertainty in science teaching

    Open Access•Emily Starrett, Michelle Jordan et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2024

  • Pedagogical and epistemic uncertainty in collaborative teacher learning

    Open Access•Ido Gideon, Gideon Dishon et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2022

  • Filming scientific entanglements in the Coorong

    Lindsay Bryant, Alex Cothren et al.•Journal of Environmental Media•2026

  • Collective and Decolonial Practices in Narrative Approaches

    Open Access•Chiara Fiscone, G Veronese•Human Arenas•2026

  • Identifying Emotional Expressions During Family Science Engagement at Home—A Case Study From a Parent's Perspective

    Open Access•Neta Shaby, Nancy Staus et al.•Journal of Research in Science…•2025

  • Emotions Experienced by Preservice Early Childhood Teachers During a Training Program in Inquiry‐Based Science Education

    Open Access•María Marta Alarcón‐Orozco, Antonio-Joaquín Franco-Mariscal et al.•Journal of Research in Science…•2025

  • Science teachers' perceptions and practice of uncertainty in science learning

    Open Access•Emily Starrett, Michelle Jordan et al.•Journal of Research in Science…•2025

  • Oh my god this is the worst!”—Exploring the complexities of teacher vexation and resistance

    Open Access•Lama Z Jaber, Carla Finkelstein et al.•Instructional Science•2025

  • Attitude Problems

    Open Access•Kathryn L Kirchgasler•Science Education•2026

  • Elevating Configurations of Data and Emotion

    Open Access•Kathryn Lanouette•Science Education•2026

  • That's Just Gonna Make Them Upset

    Open Access•Rishi Krishnamoorthy, Ravit Golan Duncan et al.•Science Education•2026

  • I Feel Like a Real Chemist Right Now

    Open Access•Hendra Y Agustian, Bente Gammelgaard et al.•Science Education•2025

  • Impact of Teachers With Research Experiences

    Open Access•John Keller, Sanlyn Buxner et al.•Science Education•2025

  • The Emotional Valence of Hyperrationality in STEM Learning

    Open Access•Natalie R Davis, Thomas M Philip•Science Education•2026

  • Centering Affect and Emotion Toward Dignity and Justice in Science Education

    Open Access•Tanner Vea, Lama Z Jaber•Science Education•2026

  • Troubleshooting as an Inquiry Activity

    Open Access•A Lynn Stephens•Science Education•2025

  • Basics of qualitative research

    Anselm Strauss, Juliet Corbin et al.•Basics of qualitative research•2008

  • Science as Practice and Culture

    Andrew Pickering•Science As Practice and Culture•1992

  • The Managed Heart

    Arlie Russell Hochschild•Managed Heart•2012

  • Supporting teachers to negotiate uncertainty for science, students, and teaching

    Open Access•Eve Manz, Enrique Suarez•Science Education•2018

  • Learning to Feel Like a Scientist

    Open Access•Lama Z Jaber, David Hammer•Science Education•2016

  • Examining Classroom Science Practice Communities

    Open Access•David Stroupe•Science Education•2014

  • The laboratory in science education

    Open Access•Avi Hofstein, Vincent N Lunetta•Science Education•2004

  • Epistemologies in practice

    Open Access•Leema K Berland, Christina V Schwarz et al.•Journal of Research in Science…•2016

  • Disciplinary authority and accountability in scientific practice and learning

    Open Access•Michael Ford, Michael J Ford•Science Education•2008

  • Guiding Principles for Fostering Productive Disciplinary Engagement

    Randi A Engle, Faith R Conant•Cognition and Instruction•2002

  • A Review of Empirical Literature on Inquiry Professional Development

    Daniel K Capps, Barbara A Crawford et al.•Journal of Science Teacher…•2012

  • The Enigma of Severe Mental Illness

    Maria Nyström, Karin Dahlberg et al.•Issues in Mental Health Nursing•2002

  • Engaging in Science

    Lama Z Jaber, David Hammer•Journal of the Learning Sciences•2016

  • Strategies for ensuring trustworthiness in qualitative research projects

    Andrew K Shenton•Education for Information•2004

  • Research design

    Open Access•Marcellus Caldas, Miguel Pinto Caldas•Revista de Administração…•2003

  • Representing and Intervening

    Open Access•Ian Hacking•Representing and Intervening•1983

  • Passionate Minds

    Lewis Wolpert, Alison Richards•Passionate minds•1997

  • The Social Dimensions of Scientific Knowledge

    Open Access•Boaz Miller•Social Dimensions of Scientific…•2025

  • Countering science reluctance in elementary science education

    Derek Hodson•Canadian Journal of Science…•2002

  • Theory and methodology in researching emotions in education

    M Zembylas•International Journal of Research…•2007

  • Positionality

    Open Access•Brian Bourke•Qualitative Report•2014

  • Mixed emotions

    Open Access•Anna Hargreaves, Andy Hargreaves•Teaching and Teacher Education•2000

  • Cultivating epistemic empathy in preservice teacher education

    Open Access•Lama Z Jaber, Sherry A Southerland et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2018

  • To conform or not to conform? An examination of perceived emotional display rule norms among international sojourners

    Open Access•Nicole L Gullekson, Jeffrey B Vancouver•International Journal of…•2010

  • Touchy Subjects

    Open Access•Erica Mcwilliam•British Educational Research…•1996

  • Unpacking a Liturgical Framing of Desire for the Purposes of Educational Research

    Ian Parker Renga•Educational Studies•2017

  • Learning to See Teaching in New Ways

    Open Access•Miray Tekkumru Kisa, Mary Kay Stein•American Educational Research…•2015

  • The Social Construction of What

    Ian Hacking•Social Construction of What?•2000

  • Discursive practices, genealogies, and emotional rules

    Open Access•M Zembylas•Teaching and Teacher Education•2005

  • Criteria for assessing the trustworthiness of naturalistic inquiries

    Open Access•Egon G Guba•Educational Technology Research…•1981

  • Defining affect

    Open Access•G Loewenstein•Social Science Information•2007

  • The Mangle of Practice

    Andrew Pickering•Mangle of Practice•1995

  • Situated Learning

    Open Access•Jean Lave, Etienne Wenger•Situated Learning•1991

  • Epistemic Cultures

    Karin Knorr Cetina, K Knorr-Cetina•Epistemic Cultures•1999

  • Mapping Expressive Differences Around the World

    Open Access•D Matsumoto, Seung Hee Yoo et al.•Journal of Cross-Cultural…•2008

Unique citing works47
Citations per year9,4
Citation span2021 - 2026 (6)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 44

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae