Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

‘Doing being an expert’

A conversation analysis of expertise enactments in experience discussions in medical education

Bibliographic Data

ID21582425
AuthorsMarije Van Braak (0000-0003-2938-1508, Erasmus University Rotterdam, corresponding author), Mike Huiskes (0000-0001-9381-6428, University of Groningen)
Year2022
Volume69
Pages101052
Publication date2022-06-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueLinguistics and Education (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0898-5898 • E-ISSN: 1873-1864
PublisherElsevier BV (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1016/j.linged.2022.101052
OpenAlexW4224238253
LanguageEN
Citations received10
References cited51

Traditionally, medical experts are key actors in the socialization of future doctors. In this paper, we focus on how medical teachers and residents enact for the teachers the institutionally provided identity of ‘expert’, and how that enactment contributes to the socialization of medical professionals. Using Conversation Analysis, we analyze a collection of instances where teachers ‘do being an expert’ in group discussions about experiences from practice in the context of Dutch postgraduate training of General Practitioners. We show how enactment of expertise is an interactional accomplishment. Participants enact expertise in two sequential contexts, which are consequential for the interactional function of the displays of expertise and contribute to socialization in various ways. Theoretically, this detailed description of contributes to our understanding expertise in educational context. The practical suggestions derived from the analyses can contribute to training of future medical professionals in a variety of educational contexts

Conversation · Conversation analysis · Discourse analysis · Linguistics · Medical education · Pedagogy · Socialization · Computer Science · Counseling, Therapy, and Family Dynamics · Discourse Analysis in Language Studies · Language, Discourse, Communication Strategies · Medicine · Psychology · Social Psychology

  • Epistemic positioning and knowledge-building in postgraduate neuroscience classroom interaction

    Open Access•Merve Bozbiyik, Tom Morton•Journal of Pragmatics•2024

  • Sharing procedural knowledge in manual work environments

    Open Access•Paweł Urbanik•Language & Communication•2024

  • Understanding Chinese Zhuoyue (expert) teachers’ professional self-understandings

    Yangbang Hu, Yafei Hu et al.•Teachers and Teaching•2025

  • A conversation analytic investigation into displays of expertise of different tutors in small group clinical skills training

    Open Access•Meral Demirören, Merve Bozbiyik et al.•Linguistics and Education•2024

  • Word searches in L2 peer interaction at language cafés

    Open Access•Linda N Narfström•Linguistics and Education•2025

  • ‘Oh yes, that is also reflection’—Using discursive psychology to describe how GP registrars construct reflection

    Open Access•Sven P C Schaepken, Anne de la Croix et al.•Medical Education•2024

  • Between teacher candidates’ reflection and teacher educators’ evaluation

    Open Access•Pınar Turan, Nur Yigitoglu Aptoula•Modern Language Journal•2023

  • A Micro‐Analytic Investigation of Managing “Revoicing” When Delivering Dispreferred Evaluative Peer Feedback During Microteaching Post‐Observation Conferences

    Open Access•Dennis Murphy Odo•International Journal of Applied…•2026

  • Teacher professional development in focus

    Open Access•Semih Ekin, Fatma Badem•System•2026

  • A pragmatic study of teacher dialogues with a large language model-based AI chatbot

    Open Access•Seng Chee Tan, Yee Yin Tan et al.•Linguistics and Education•2026

  • Structures of Social Action

    Open Access•John Heritage, J Maxwell Atkinson•Structures of Social Action•1985

  • Doing Conversation Analysis

    Paul Ten Have•Doing Conversation Analysis•2007

  • Interaction and Grammar

    Open Access•Elinor Ochs, Emanuel A Schegloff et al.•Interaction and Grammar•1996

  • Reframing Medical Education to Support Professional Identity Formation

    Richard L Cruess, Sylvia R Cruess et al.•Academic Medicine•2014

  • The Morality of Knowledge in Conversation

    Open Access•Tanya Stivers, L Mondada et al.•Morality of Knowledge in…•2011

  • ‘Being the Teacher’

    Katharine Richards, Keith Richards•Applied Linguistics•2006

  • When I say… socialisation

    Open Access•Megan E L Brown, Gabrielle M Finn•Medical Education•2021

  • Risking Ourselves in Education

    Open Access•Gert Biesta•Educational Theory•2020

  • Construction of institutional identities by male individuals in subordinate positions in the Japanese workplace

    Open Access•Junko Saito•Pragmatics Quarterly Publication…•2022

  • Epistemics in Action

    J Heritage•Research on Language and Social…•2012

  • Zones of Expertise and the Management of Uncertainty in Genetics Risk Communication

    Sarangi, A Clarke•Research on Language and Social…•2002

  • The Conversation Analytic Role-play Method (Carm)

    E Stokoe•Research on Language and Social…•2014

  • Displays of Epistemic Access

    Tom Koole•Research on Language and Social…•2010

  • The Terms of Agreement

    Open Access•J Heritage, G Raymond•Social Psychology Quarterly•2005

  • The dynamics of embodied participation and language choice in multilingual meetings

    Open Access•L Mondada•Language in Society•2012

  • It׳s quite simple, really

    Open Access•Jan Chovanec•Discourse Context & Media•2016

  • Negotiation of expertise and multifunctionality

    Open Access•Riikka Nissi, Esa Lehtinen•Language & Communication•2016

  • Remembering and understanding with oh-prefaced yes/no declaratives in Dutch

    Open Access•Lucas M Seuren, Mike Huiskes et al.•Journal of Pragmatics•2016

  • Put your fingers right in here

    Open Access•Alan Zemel, Timothy Koschmann•Discourse Studies•2014

  • Metadiscourse in group supervision

    Open Access•Cynthia Gordon, M Luke•Discourse Studies•2016

  • Epistemics in social interaction

    Open Access•Paul Drew•Discourse Studies•2018

  • Communicating information packages in institutional face-to-face consultations

    Open Access•Marloes Herijgers, Tessa Van Charldorp•Discourse Studies•2021

  • Expertise in interaction - Introduction

    Open Access•I Arminen, Tom Koole et al.•Discourse Studies•2021

  • Practices for Reporting and Responding to Test Results during Medical Consultations

    Open Access•A Pomerantz, E Sean Rintel et al.•Discourse Studies•2004

  • Expertise as a domain of epistemics in intensive care shift-handovers

    Open Access•Paulien Harms, Tom Koole et al.•Discourse Studies•2021

  • The Constitution of Expert-Novice in Scientific Discourse

    Sally Jacoby, Patrick Gonzales•Issues in Applied Linguistics•1991

  • Opening up Closings

    Open Access•Emanuel A Schegloff, Harvey Sacks•Semiotica•1973

  • Grammar and Social Organization

    G Raymond•American Sociological Review•2003

  • Mitigation and epistemic positions in troubles talk

    Open Access•Ilaria Riccioni, Ramona Bongelli et al.•Language & Communication•2014

  • What time is it, Denise

    Hugh Mehan•Theory Into Practice•1979

  • The rejection of advice

    Open Access•Gail Jefferson, John R E Lee•Journal of Pragmatics•1981

  • Second stories

    Open Access•I Arminen•Journal of Pragmatics•2004

  • Third turn position in teacher talk

    Open Access•Yo–an Lee, Yo-An Lee•Journal of Pragmatics•2007

  • Towards an analysis of discourse

    Open Access•Robert I Binnick•Lingua•1976

  • Pursuing a question

    Open Access•Alan Zemel, Timothy Koschmann•Journal of Pragmatics•2011

  • The grammaticalization of participant roles in the constitution of expert identity

    Open Access•G Matoesian, Gregory M Matoesian•Language in Society•1999

  • Situated Learning

    Open Access•Jean Lave, Etienne Wenger•Situated Learning•1991

  • Professional Vision

    Open Access•Charles Goodwin•American Anthropologist•1994

  • Enactments of Expertise

    E S Carr•Annual Review of Anthropology•2010

Unique citing works10
Citations per year3,33
Citation span2023 - 2026 (4)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 8

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae