Charting the Skies from a Moving Earth

Relativity and Position in Comparative Law

Bibliographic Data

ID22065934
AuthorsJames C Fisher (0000-0002-8244-0688, Sophia University, corresponding author)
Year2021
Volume8
Issue2
Pages127-45
Publication date2021-12-08
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueCritical Analysis of Law (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 2291-9732 • E-ISSN: 2291-9732
PublisherUniversity of Toronto Libraries - UOTL (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.33137/cal.v8i2.37857
OpenAlexW4385590475
LanguageEN
References cited2

This article brings the insights produced by comparative legal analysis to bear on comparative legal discourse itself, in order instructively to recontextualize enduring methodological debates taken to concern the “philosophy” of comparative law. It grounds several such methodological arguments in fundamental positions of legal theory and philosophy, reflecting in doing so on the broader philosophical consequences of specific positions, and emphasizing the resulting problems of incommensurable positionality. It challenges the unvoiced but widely exhibited assumption within comparative law that sufficient reflection, abstraction and care can avoid the privileged reification of contingent legal concepts and categories. It explores the inevitable positionality of all comparative inquiry particularly in connection with the comparatist’s status as both product and reconstituter of legal facts and ideation. It introduces a focus on relative perspective, urging increased attention to how the axioms of general jurisprudence which ground methodological positions within comparative law express a system of law’s relative position within the legal historical process

Comparative law · Epistemology · Jurisprudence · Philosophy of law · Political science · Sociology · Comparative and International Law Studies · Conflict of Laws and Jurisdiction · European and International Contract Law · Law · Philosophy

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access