Two Borderline Works

The theme of the article is two plaster replicas of the miniaturized reproductions of the Parthenon and Bassae friezes made in London by the Scottish sculptor and carver John Henning in the first decades of the 19th century. The reliefs were recently revealed during a new exhibition of the Plaster Cast Gallery, belonging to the Department of Cultures and Societies of the University of Palermo in Italy. Henning based himself on the original marbles transferred to the British capital and, in the case of the Athenian frieze, onthe drawings of the missing parts. Through a long job, his reproductions in miniature were carved in reverse into slate slabs from which plaster casts were easily obtained and finally sold. A lucrative trade of bootlegged copies arose, but Henning gained nothing by that business. The duplicates spread in great numbers not only in plaster casts galleries, but also inside dwelling houses, as an ornament for walls and chimneys in living rooms. These artifacts, although they have seldom captured the attention of the archaeologists, are of particular interest. The casts performed a two fold function: on one hand, they were useful for study; on the other hand,they were used as furnishing elements. The small casts by Henning, furthermore, were suitable for the taste of the time. Despite their astonishing fidelity to the originals, the sharp and chiseled contours of the carved figures emanate more neoclassical than classical aura, especially in the parts of the Parthenon frieze not directly known by the author. In that, we understand how these artifacts, though they are reliable reproductions of sculptures dating from the culminating point of Greek art, are also two typical “industrial” products of the 19th century. Henning’s artwork seems to appear as a real “borderline work”. It stands between the ancient and the modern, art and handicraft, public and private, study and pleasure

Art · Art history · Collectable · Exhibition · Frieze · Nothing · Plaster Casts · Sculpture · Visual arts · 3D Surveying and Cultural Heritage · Archaeological Research and Protection · Art History and Market Analysis · Computer Science · History · Philosophy

• Acquisition and Supply of Casts of the Parthenon Sculptures by the British Museum, 1835–1939

  Open Access•Ian Jenkins•The Annual of the British School…•1990

  Add to list

• Land of the Lost Gods

  John E Ziolkowski, Richard Stoneman•The Classical World•1988

  Add to list

• The Sculptured Frieze from Bassae (A Revised Sequence)

  William Bell Dinsmoor•American Journal of Archaeology•1956

  Add to list