Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Basic Income in a Small Town

Understanding the Elusive Effects on Work

Bibliographic Data

ID2245145
AuthorsD Calnitsky (0000-0002-0828-1957, University of Bremen), Jonathan P Latner (0000-0002-9771-1276, University of Bremen)
Year2017
Volume64
Issue3
Pages456-456
Publication date2017-08-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueSocial Problems (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0037-7791 • E-ISSN: 1533-8533
PublisherOxford University Press (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1093/socpro/spx024
OpenAlexW2474620265
LanguageEN
Citations received29
References cited76

This paper examines the impact of a guaranteed annual income experiment from the 1970s called the Manitoba Basic Annual Income Experiment (Mincome). We examine Mincome’s “saturation” site located in Dauphin, Manitoba, where all town residents were eligible for payments. Would people work less if their basic needs were guaranteed outside the market? Never before or since the Dauphin experiment has a rich country tested a guaranteed annual income at the level of an entire town. A community-level experiment accounts for the fact that people make decisions in a social context, not in isolation. Using hitherto unanalyzed data we find an 11.3 percentage point reduction in labor market participation, and nearly 30 percent of that fall can be attributed to “community context” effects. Additionally, we show that withdrawals were driven disproportionately by young and single-headed households. Participants who provide qualitative explanations for work withdrawals typically cite care work, disability and illness, uneven employment opportunities, or educational investment.

Basic income · Context (archaeology) · Demographic economics · Economics · Geography · Income Support · Investment (military) · Labour economics · Low income · Market economy · Payment · Political science · Sociology · Work (physics) · Employment and Welfare Studies · Engineering · Finance · Gender, Labor, and Family Dynamics · Labor market dynamics and wage inequality · Social Policy and Reform Studies

  • An unconditional basic income is necessary but insufficient to transition towards just food futures

    Open Access•Elaine Power, Aric McBay•Canadian Food Studies / La Revue…•2022

  • Basic Income as a preventive, health-promoting and motivating resource in the psychosocial welfare environment

    Anna-Carin Fagerlind Ståhl•Global Discourse•2024

  • If the Work Requirement is Strong”

    Open Access•D Calnitsky•The Canadian Journal of Sociology•2018

  • Universal Basic Income in the United States and Advanced Countries

    Hilary Hoynes, Jesse Rothstein•Annual Review of Economics•2019

  • Zero Poverty Society

    Sarah Marchal, Ive Marx•Zero Poverty Society•2024

  • Social Democratic Capitalism

    Open Access•Lane Kenworthy•Social Democratic Capitalism•2020

  • The Finnish Basic Income Experiment

    Open Access•Jurgen De Wispelaere, Antti Halmetoja et al.•The Palgrave International…•2019

  • ‘Improving, not leaving’

    Open Access•Vibhor Mathur, Neil Howard•Socio-Economic Review•2026

  • The employer response to the guaranteed annual income

    Open Access•D Calnitsky•Socio-Economic Review•2018

  • Welfare versus Work under a Negative Income Tax

    Chris Riddell, W Craig Riddell•Journal of Labor Economics•2024

  • Universal Basic Income as a Promoter of Real Freedom in a Digital Future

    Giuseppe Allegri, Renato Foschi•World Futures•2021

  • The Impact of Canada's Working Income Tax Benefit on the Labor Supply of Low‐Income Workers

    Open Access•Kourtney Koebel, Dionne Pohler•Industrial Relations A Journal of…•2026

  • An Analysis of the Factors Influencing Public Attitudes toward Implementing Basic Income (BI) from an Individual Perspective

    Open Access•Jiaqi Yang, Geetha Mohan et al.•Societies•2020

  • Employment success of social assistance recipients

    Open Access•Elena Draghici, Anders Holm et al.•Canadian Review of Sociology/Revue…•2023

  • Basic Income and the Social Investment State

    Open Access•Luke Martinelli, Yannick Vanderborght•European Journal of Social Security•2022

  • Economic Security and Fertility

    Tuna Dökmeci, Carla Rainer et al.•Canadian Public Policy•2023

  • Towards climate resilient peace

    Open Access•Christie Nicoson•Sustainability Science•2021

  • Universal basic income and the purpose of work and labour

    Open Access•Johannes Kananen•World Development Perspectives•2026

  • Life after Work

    Open Access•D Calnitsky, Jonathan P Latner et al.•Social Science History•2019

  • Basic income trials and the politics of scale

    Open Access•Jurgen De Wispelaere, Marc Doussard et al.•Policy Studies Journal•2025

  • Basic income and its applicability in Turkey

    Open Access•Senem Çakmak Şahin, Ibrahim Engin Kılıç•New Perspectives on Turkey•2021

  • The revolution next door

    Open Access•D Calnitsky, Kaitlin Pauline Wannamaker•British Journal of Sociology•2024

  • Exit, voice and loyalty in the family

    Open Access•P Gonalons-Pons, D Calnitsky•Socio-Economic Review•2022

  • Labour supply reactions to basic income

    Open Access•Cyrille Francisco, Antje Otto et al.•Socio-Economic Review•2024

  • The Impact of an Experimental Guaranteed Income on Crime and Violence

    Open Access•D Calnitsky, P Gonalons-Pons•Social Problems•2021

  • Not that basic

    Open Access•Elise Aerts, Ive Marx et al.•Journal of Social Policy•2025

  • What employers want

    Harry J Holzer•What employers want•1996

  • Evaluating welfare and training programs

    Charles F Manski, Irwin Garfinkel•Evaluating welfare and training…•1992

  • Instruments, Randomization, and Learning about Development

    Angus Deaton•Journal of Economic Literature•2010

  • Some Consequences of Having Too Little

    Open Access•Anuj K Shah, Anuj Shah et al.•Science•2012

  • Toward a theory of behavioral contagion.

    Ladd Wheeler•Psychological Review•1966

  • Identity and Schooling

    George A Akerlof, Rachel E Kranton et al.•Journal of Economic Literature•2002

  • Social Influence

    Robert B Cialdini, Noah J Goldstein•Annual Review of Psychology•2004

  • The adolescent society

    James Samuel Coleman•The adolescent society•1961

  • A New Social Contract for the Elderly?

    John Myles•Why We Need a New Welfare State•2002

  • Comment on van der Veen and Van Parijs

    Open Access•Jon Elster•Theory and Society•1986

  • Randomise This! On Poor Economics

    Sanjay G Reddy•Review of Agrarian Studies•2012

  • Chapter 2 Female labor supply

    Mark R Killingsworth, James J Heckman•Handbook of Labor Economics…•1986

  • Basic Income, Unemployment and Compensatory Justice

    Open Access•Loek Groot, Loek F M Groot•Basic Income, Unemployment and…•2004

  • Poverty and Discrimination

    Kevin Lang•Poverty and Discrimination•2007

  • Independence, Propertylessness, and Basic Income

    Open Access•Karl Widerquist•Independence, Propertylessness,…•2013

  • The Effects of Income Maintenance on Work, Schooling, and Non-Market Activities of Youth

    Steven F Venti•The Review of Economics and…•1984

  • The Effect of Child Care Costs on Married Women's Labor Force Participation

    Rachel Connelly•The Review of Economics and…•1992

  • Correlations between Neighboring Children in Their Subsequent Educational Attainment

    Gary Solon, Marianne E Page et al.•The Review of Economics and…•2000

  • Dissecting the Social

    Open Access•Peter Hedström•Dissecting the social•2005

  • Federalism and the Poor

    Constantine Kapsalis, Derek Hum et al.•Canadian Public Policy•1984

  • Labor Supply and Public Policy

    Open Access•Craig Thornton, Craig V D Thornton et al.•Journal of Policy Analysis and…•1982

  • Cash Transfers, Basic Income and Community Building

    Open Access•Evelyn L Forget, Alexander D Peden et al.•Social Inclusion•2013

  • More Normal than Welfare”

    Open Access•D Calnitsky•Canadian Review of Sociology/Revue…•2016

  • Barriers to Employment and the ‘Hard to Serve’

    Open Access•Sandra K Danziger, Kristin S Seefeldt•Social Policy and Society•2003

  • Social Policy in Canada

    Open Access•Ken Collier, Ernie Lightman•The Canadian Journal of Sociology•2003

  • Canadian Social Welfare Policy

    A M C Waterman, Jacqueline S Ismael•Canadian Public Policy•1986

  • The Manitoba Basic Annual Income Data Base

    Greg Mason•Canadian Public Policy•1985

  • The Town with No Poverty

    Evelyn L Forget•Canadian Public Policy•2011

  • Income Maintenance, Work Effort, and the Canadian Mincome Experiment

    Michael Hoy, Derek Hum et al.•Canadian Public Policy•1992

  • The Changing Role of Social Experiments in Policy Analysis

    David H Greenberg, Philip K Robins•Journal of Policy Analysis and…•1986

  • Poverty Policy and Poverty Research

    Open Access•Robert D Reischauer, Robert Haveman et al.•Journal of Policy Analysis and…•1989

  • The changing role of social experiments in policy analysis

    Open Access•David H Greenberg, Philip K Robins•Journal of Policy Analysis and…•1986

  • The Great Experiment

    Irwin Deutscher, Harold W Watts et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1979

  • Threshold Models of Diversity

    Mark Granovetter, Roland Soong•Sociological Methodology•1988

  • Reforming Public Welfare

    Open Access•Stephen David•Political Science Quarterly•1977

  • Work Incentives and Income Guarantees

    Open Access•Dennis P Sobin•Political Science Quarterly•1976

  • Dynamic models of segregation

    Thomas C Schelling•Journal of Mathematical Sociology•1971

  • The Economics of Welfare

    Arthur Cecil Pigou, Nahid Aslanbeigui•The Economic Journal•2017

  • Basic Income and Productivity in Cognitive Capitalism

    Sonia Lucarelli, Stefano Lucarelli et al.•Review of Social Economy•2008

  • A Framework For The Study of Individual Behavior and Social Interactions

    Steven N Durlauf•Sociological Methodology•2001

  • Normative Social Influence is Underdetected

    Open Access•Jessica M Nolan, P Wesley Schultz et al.•Personality and Social Psychology…•2008

  • Bad Jobs in America

    A L Kalleberg, Barbara F Reskin et al.•American Sociological Review•2000

  • Tantalus on the Road to Asymptopia

    Open Access•Edward E Leamer•The Journal of Economic…•2010

  • Work, Welfare, and Single Mothers' Economic Survival Strategies

    Kathryn Edin, Laura Lein•American Sociological Review•1997

  • Precarious Work, Insecure Workers

    Open Access•A L Kalleberg•American Sociological Review•2009

  • Income, Work and Marital Dissolution

    Derek Hum, Derek P J Hum et al.•Journal of Comparative Family…•1992

  • Work in the Family and in the Labor Market

    A L Kalleberg, Rachel A Rosenfeld•Journal of Marriage and the Family•1990

  • Democratizing Citizenship

    Open Access•Carole Pateman•Latin American Politics and Society•2004

  • Basic Income, Stakeholder Grants, and Class Analysis

    Open Access•Erik Olin Wright•Latin American Politics and Society•2004

  • Assessing 'Neighborhood Effects

    Robert J Sampson, Jeffrey D Morenoff et al.•Annual Review of Sociology•2002

  • Contextual-Effects Models

    H M Blalock, H Blalock•Annual Review of Sociology•1984

  • Threshold Models of Collective Behavior

    Mark Granovetter•American Journal of Sociology•1978

  • The feasibility of universal grants under democratic capitalism

    Open Access•Adam Przeworski•Theory and Society•1986

Unique citing works26
Citations per year3,63
Citation span2018 - 2026 (9)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 24

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae