Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Standing in the spaces

Essays on clinical process, trauma, and dissociation.

Bibliographic Data

ID22923944
AuthorsPhilip Bromberg
Year2000
Volume17
Issue2
Pages432-436
Publication date2000-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeREVIEW
Review ofStanding in the Spaces: Essays on Clinical Process, Trauma, and Dissociation, Philip M Bromberg, 2001
VenuePsychoanalytic Psychology (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0736-9735 • E-ISSN: 1939-1331
PublisherAmerican Psychological Association (APA) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1037//0736-9735.17.2.432
OpenAlexW1995162098
LanguageEN

This work recapitulates and extends a unique creative odyssey in modern clinical theory. Advancing no overarching theoretical system, Bromberg moves in ever widening exploratory circles as he works his way into the complexities of personality change. Early in these essays, the author contemplates how one might engage schizoid detachment within an interpersonal perspective. To his surprise, he finds that the road to the patient's disavowed experiences most frequently passes though the analyst's internal conversation, as multiple configurations of self-other interaction, previously dissociated, are set loose first in the analyst and then played out in the interpersonal field. This insight leads to other discoveries. Beneath the dissociative structures seen in schizoid patients and also in other personality disorders, Bromberg regularly finds traumatic experience - even in patients not otherwise viewed as traumatized. This discovery allows interpersonal notions of psychic structure to emerge in a new light, as Bromberg arrives at the view that all severe character pathology masks dissociative defenses erected to ward off the internal experience of trauma and to keep the external world at bay to avoid retraumatization. These insights, in turn, open to a new understanding of dissociative processes as intrinsic to the therapeutic process per se. For Bromberg, it is the unanticipated eruption of the patient's relational world, with its push-pull impact on the analyst's effort to maintain a therapeutic stance, that makes possible the deepest and most therapeutically fruitful type of analytic experience.

Conversation · Dissociative · Interpersonal communication · Psychic · Psychoanalysis · Psychotherapist · Surprise · Clinical Psychology · Communication · Mental Health and Psychiatry · Personality Disorders and Psychopathology · Psychology · Psychotherapy Techniques and Applications · Social Psychology

  • Living History

    Margy Sperry•Psychoanalysis Self and Context•2020

  • In the Interest of History

    Max Cavitch•History of the Present•2022

  • The Encounter with the Identical Other

    Open Access•Michal Tal•Humanities•2018

  • Does God Make Referrals? Orthodox Judaism and Homosexuality

    Alan Slomowitz, Alison Feit•Journal of Gay & Lesbian Mental…•2014

  • Looking at Mosaics in the Alhambra

    Robert Tyminski•Jung Journal•2025

  • Separation in Unity

    Open Access•Kristiina Uriko, Irena Bartels•Integrative Psychological and…•2023

  • Trauma-Related Dissociation Is Linked With Maladaptive Personality Functioning

    Open Access•Antonella Granieri, Fanny Guglielmucci et al.•Frontiers in Psychiatry•2018

  • Coping with Identity Conflict

    Anna Rabinovich, Thomas A Morton•Self and Identity•2015

  • Dreaming Gender

    Vittorio Lingiardi•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2007

  • The Unthought Asian American Subject

    David L Eng, Shinhee Han et al.•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2024

  • A Psychoanalytic Encounter with Nathalie Djurberg's It's the Mother

    Amy Schwartz Cooney•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2012

  • Building a Bridge Across the Ocean

    Velleda C Ceccoli•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2015

  • Blessed are the Beloved”

    Open Access•A Kim•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2024

  • Who Am I? And What Makes Me Hot and Bothered? Notes on Identity, Sexuality, Enigma, and Desire

    Vittorio Lingiardi•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2018

  • Consent, Sexuality, and Self-Respect

    Avgi Saketopoulou•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2011

  • Trans Bodies and the Failure of Mirrors

    J Langer, S J Langer•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2016

  • Ageing and Transageing

    Helene Moglen•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2008

  • Whiteness Catalyzes Character Disorder and Mass Violence

    Carter J Carter•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2023

  • Danger, Pleasure, Vulnerability, Shame

    Steven Botticelli•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2010

  • Time and Timelessness in the Psychoanalysis of an Adult With Severe Childhood Trauma

    William Auerbach•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2014

  • Chinks in the Merged Attachment

    Susie Orbach•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2008

  • Frozen Within, Frozen Without

    Kim Rosenfield•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2012

  • To Whom Does the Subject Speak? Between the Relational and Lacanian Schools of Psychoanalysis

    Adrienne Harris, David Lichtenstein et al.•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2015

  • The Guilty Pleasure of Erotic Countertransference

    Andrea Celenza•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2010

  • Body to Body

    Karen Peoples•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2015

  • Race, Colour, and the Processes of Racialization

    Open Access•Neil Altman•Psychoanalysis Culture & Society•2007

  • Nonviolence meets the depressive position

    Open Access•Neil Altman•Psychoanalysis Culture & Society•2024

  • Object fear

    Open Access•Annie Lee Jones, Megan Obourn•Psychoanalysis Culture & Society•2014

  • Theory

    Ryan Lamothe•International Journal for the…•2004

  • Becoming a Telepathic Tuning Fork

    Sharon K Farber•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2017

  • A Safe Space to Play Dangerously

    Charla R Malamed•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2022

  • On “The Burning Beach”

    Mark Stephens, Michelle Stephens•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2021

  • Credo

    Ken Corbett•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2021

  • The Priest and the Rabbi Meet in a Bar

    Alan Sirote•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2020

  • The Unbound Seed

    Megan Rundel•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2023

  • Donald Winnicott and Stephen Mitchell’s Developmental Tilt Hypothesis Reconsidered

    Steven H Cooper•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2021

  • Expressivity and Transformation through Language in Work with Serious Disorder

    Lisa Director•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2021

  • The Dream Sense, Emergent Clinical Process, and the Question of Symmetry

    Donnel B Stern•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2020

  • Response to the Commentaries of Dominique Scarfone and Jade McGleughlin on “The Untelling”

    Robert Grossmark•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2024

  • Reawakening Desire

    Jody Messler Davies•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2023

  • Synchronicity, Acausal Connection, and the Fractal Dynamics of Clinical Practice

    Terry Marks-Tarlow, Yakov Shapiro•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2021

  • Portals through Liminal Space

    Janine De Peyer•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2021

  • Anorexia Nervosa, Psychic Death, and the Subjugation of Need

    Tom Wooldridge•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2022

  • Asian Americans in a World of White Supremacy and Anti-Black Racism

    Kris Yi•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2023

  • Courageous Transformative Moments in Treatment

    Sandra Buechler•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2025

  • Sense and Sensibility

    Velleda C Ceccoli•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2023

  • What Remains Untold in the Untelling

    Jade Mcgleughlin•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2024

  • Whose Bad Objects Are We Anyway? Repetition and Our Elusive Love Affair with Evil

    Jody Messler Davies•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2004

  • “Eva, Get the Goldfish Bowl”

    Barbara Pizer•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2023

  • The Door in the Wall

    Zvi Steve Yadin•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•2022

  • Re-envisioning Psychoanalytic Content in Social Work Education

    Marilyn S Paul, Rani Varghese•Journal of Teaching in Social Work•2021

  • Differentiating Two Kinds of Neutrality

    Soh Agatsuma•International Forum of…•2014

  • From relation to the field

    Andrea Celenza•International Forum of…•2019

  • Harry Stack Sullivan and Stephen Mitchell in Italy – A historical and a personal account

    Marco Conci•International Forum of…•2023

  • Transforming collapse

    Billie A Pivnick•International Forum of…•2017

  • Getting into mud together

    Etty Cohen•International Forum of…•2014

  • Intimacy in psychotherapy

    Sergey Profis•International Forum of…•2018

  • Integrating the dissociated

    Anna Maria Loiacono•International Forum of…•2020

  • When the body speaks

    Ernesto Mujica, June Her et al.•International Forum of…•2025

  • The relevance of “role reversal” in today's psychoanalytic work

    Franco Borgogno•International Forum of…•2008

  • Post-Cartesian thinking and the dialectic of doubt and belief in the treatment relationship

    Malcolm Owen Slavin•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2002

  • The clinical use of therapeutic disjunctions

    Steven A Frankel•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2006

  • The patient’s contribution to the therapeutic process

    Sidney J Blatt•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2013

  • The failure to preserve potential space in dissociative disorders

    Ruth Zeligman, Bruce L Smith et al.•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2012

  • Trauma, dissociation, and conflict

    Frances Anderson, Frances Sommer Anderson et al.•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2003

  • Freud's memory erased

    Danielle Knafo•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2009

  • Considering "self-ful" desire

    Julia E Davies•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2009

  • Generating subjectivity through the creation of time

    Katie Gentile•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2016

  • "Superblind"

    Mark B Borg•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2005

  • Creating Space

    Ryan Lamothe•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2005

  • The role of subjectivity and intersubjectivity in the reconstruction of dissociated schemas; converging perspectives from psychoanalysis, cognitive science and affective neuroscience

    Wilma Bucci•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2011

  • Intersubjectivity and neuroscience

    Efrat Ginot•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2007

  • Disorganized attachment and the use of fantasy

    Christopher Bonovitz•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2012

  • Psychic retreats or psychic pits

    Adriano Schimmenti, Vincenzo Caretti•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2010

  • Developing a reflective self in cyber space

    Shoshana Ringel, Faye Mishna et al.•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2017

  • Contemporary psychoanalytic views on the experience of immigration

    Ricardo C Ainslie, Pratyusha Tummala-Narra et al.•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2013

  • Linking the overwhelming with the unbearable

    Adriano Schimmenti, Vincenzo Caretti•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2016

  • Exile as a dissociative state

    Andrew Harlem•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2010

  • Memory and responsibility

    Roger Frie•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2012

  • The empathic power of enactments

    Efrat Ginot•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2009

  • Something wicked this way comes

    Philip M Bromberg•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2003

  • Questioning the couch

    Vittorio Lingiardi, Francesco De Bei•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2011

  • Varieties of dissociative experiences

    Wilma Bucci•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2003

  • Parental trauma and adult sibling relationships in Holocaust-survivor families

    Irit V Felsen•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2018

  • Convergence and divergence in the characters of analyst and patient

    Margaret Crastnopol•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2001

  • A Convergence of Treatments and Ideas

    Debra Rothschild•Psychoanalytic Inquiry•2025

  • From an intrapsychic to an interpersonal symptom

    Open Access•Racheli Assaf Bitan•Group Analysis•2020

  • Group-analytic Practice Today

    Open Access•Peter Potthoff•Group Analysis•2017

  • Foulkes and Intersubjectivity

    Open Access•Peter Potthoff•Group Analysis•2014

  • Le transfert dans le traitement des personnes présentant un trouble dissociatif de l’identité

    Open Access•Ann Marie Lambert, Lise Gagnon et al.•Santé mentale au Québec•2014

  • Inside Out

    Jo Stuthridge•Transactional Analysis Journal•2006

  • Ego State Relational Units and Resistance to Change

    Ray Little•Transactional Analysis Journal•2006

  • Integrating Neurological Findings with Transactional Analysis in Trauma Work

    Edward T Novak•Transactional Analysis Journal•2008

  • The Contactful Quad

    Anita Holland, A W Holland et al.•Transactional Analysis Journal•2024

  • Withdrawal, Connection, and Therapeutic Touch

    Richard G Erskine, Helena Hargaden et al.•Transactional Analysis Journal•2001

  • Traversing the Fault Lines

    Jo Stuthridge•Transactional Analysis Journal•2012

  • The Inevitability of Unconscious Engagements and the Desire to Avoid Them

    Ray Little•Transactional Analysis Journal•2012

  • What Is Psychological and What Is Neurological? A Political and Phenomenological Exploration of Neurodivergent Identity and Encounters With Thirdness

    Jo Moores, J B Moores et al.•Transactional Analysis Journal•2024

  • Letter from the Coeditor

    Birgitta Heiller•Transactional Analysis Journal•2012

  • Impasse Clarification within the Transference-Countertransference Matrix

    Ray Little•Transactional Analysis Journal•2011

Citation velocityhistorical
Highly citedNo

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae