Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Critique of the State

Bibliographic Data

ID23157204
AuthorsJens Bartelson (0000-0002-8633-9798, Stockholm University, corresponding author)
Year2001
Publication date2001-01-01
Open AccessYes
TypeBOOK
VenueCritique of the State (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherCambridge University Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1017/cbo9780511490170
OpenAlexW394151878
Open LibraryOL34436850M
ISBN9780511490170
GOOGLE_BOOK_IDrBk7o4rIpmAC
LanguageEN
Citations received87
References cited158

What kind of political order would there be in the absence of the state? Jens Bartelson argues that we are currently unable to imagine what might lurk 'beyond', because our basic concepts of political order are conditioned by our experience of statehood. In this study, he investigates the concept of the state historically as well as philosophically, considering a range of thinkers and theories. He also considers the vexed issue of authority: modern political discourse questions the form and content of authority, but makes it all but impossible to talk about the foundations of authority. Largely due to the existing practices of political and scientific criticism, authority appears to be unquestionable. First published in 2001, Bartelson's wide-ranging and readable discussion of the suppositions and presuppositions of statehood will be of interest to scholars and upper-level students of political theory and social theory, and philosophy of social science.

Criticism · Epistemology · Order (exchange) · Political authority · Political philosophy · Political science · Politics · Presupposition · Social science · Sociology · State (computer science) · Law · Philosophy · Political Philosophy and Ethics · Political Theory and Influence · Seventeenth-Century Political and Philosophical Thought · Essays · Etat · General · Government · National · Politische Theorie · Reference · Staat · Staatslehre · The State

  • Power in sovereignty and its self-legitimation

    Open Access•Jiri Priban•International Journal of Law in…•2015

  • Pitkin's Dilemma

    Ruth Lane•Perspectives on Politics•2004

  • Reconsidering the Idea of the State

    Sebastiaan Tijsterman•Administrative Theory & Praxis•2008

  • The Pursuit of International Recognition After Kosovo

    Nina Caspersen•Global Governance A Review of…•2015

  • Nagorno Karabakh

    Open Access•Nina Caspersen•Nordisk øst-forum/Nordisk østforum•2010

  • A non-sovereign modernity

    Open Access•Peter Haldén•Review of International Studies•2013

  • Re-enacting the international order, or

    Open Access•Janis Grzybowski•Review of International Studies•2021

  • Custom and the Politics of Sovereignty in South Africa

    Clifton Crais•Journal of Social History•2006

  • Nordisk IR

    Open Access•Jörg Friedrichs•Internasjonal politikk•2012

  • Degrees of legitimacy

    Open Access•Nina Caspersen•Geoforum•2014

  • The Forum: Human Being(s) in International Relations

    Open Access•Daniel Jacobi, Annette Freyberg-Inan et al.•International Studies Review•2012

  • Democratic theory and the present/absent international

    Open Access•R B J Walker, R B Walker•Ethics & Global Politics•2010

  • A Theory of World Politics

    Open Access•Mathias Albert•Theory of World Politics•2016

  • Cosmopolitanism and the world state

    Open Access•William E Scheuerman•Review of International Studies•2014

  • The Settler Coloniality of Free Speech

    Open Access•Darcy Leigh•International Political Sociology•2022

  • Drawing Out the Leviathan

    David Polansky•International Studies Review•2016

  • Global Civil Society and Its Discontents

    Open Access•Olaf Corry, T Olaf Corry•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2006

  • Another Way for Deepening Democracy Without Shortcuts

    Open Access•Tetsuki Tamura•Journal of Deliberative Democracy•2020

  • Sovereign power beyond the state

    Oscar Larsson, Oscar L Larsson•Critical Policy Studies•2013

  • Drowning under

    Open Access•Milla Vaha•Journal of International…•2015

  • Caught between vulgar and effete realists

    Open Access•Timothy W Luke•Journal of International…•2016

  • Generic universalism in world politics

    Open Access•Sergei Prozorov•International Theory•2009

  • The paradox of state identification

    Open Access•Janis Grzybowski•International Theory•2019

  • Sovereignty and sovereign power

    Open Access•Arjun Chowdhury, Raymond Duvall•International Theory•2014

  • Outsiders Inside the State. Post-Conflict Liberia between Trusteeship and Partnership

    Louise Riis Andersen•Journal of Intervention and…•2010

  • Public law and the value of conceptual analysis

    Open Access•Barbara Mauthe•International Journal of Law in…•2014

  • Rethinking Sovereignty

    Open Access•Raia Prokhovnik•European Political Science•2015

  • Facing Europe

    Jens Bartelson•Distinktion Journal of Social…•2004

  • Political Theory within and without Political Science

    Open Access•Nathan H Feldman•Perspectives on Politics•2025

  • The normative loop at the heart of sovereignty

    Open Access•Alessandro Volpi•European Journal of Political…•2026

  • Christian Realism and the State as Idol

    Laura E Alexander, Laura E Crotty Alexander•Political Theology•2021

  • One state-one nation

    Open Access•Moran M Mandelbaum•Journal of International…•2012

  • The paradox of peace and power

    Open Access•Oliver Richmond•International Politics•2017

  • Political Science and the American Empire

    Open Access•Brian C Schmidt•International Politics•2008

  • Understating the (nationalist) state

    C Leddy-Owen•Identities•2020

  • Trouble in paradise

    Open Access•Matt Mcdonald, Lee Wilson•Security Dialogue•2017

  • The everydayness of spectacle violence under the Islamic Republic

    Open Access•Kamal Soleimani, Ahmad Mohammadpour•Security Dialogue•2023

  • Designing (de)security

    Open Access•Vibeke Schou Tjalve•Security Dialogue•2011

  • A Journey Westward

    Nataša Zambelli•Europe Asia Studies•2010

  • The South Caucasus after Kosovo

    Nina Caspersen•Europe Asia Studies•2013

  • International law and hegemony

    Martti Koskenniemi•Cambridge Review of International…•2004

  • (Re-)conceptualising the international

    Zeynep Gulsah Capan, Janis Grzybowski•Cambridge Review of International…•2022

  • All That Is Holy

    Open Access•Jon Wittrock•Rethinking Marxism•2020

  • Crisis of Authority

    Open Access•Henrik Enroth•International Journal of Politics…•2021

  • Social Agency, Spatial Practices, and Power

    Open Access•Nir Gazit•International Journal of Politics…•2009

  • The Problem of Pluralist Authority

    Open Access•Víctor M Muñiz-Fraticelli•Political Studies•2013

  • Forum

    Open Access•Halvard Leira, Rebecca Adler-Nissen et al.•Cooperation and Conflict•2025

  • The principle of recognition

    Open Access•Michael Byrne, Michael F Byrne•Irish Journal of Sociology•2016

  • L’État de société

    Open Access•Dominique Linhardt•État et société politique•2018

  • L’embarras de la sociologie avec l’État

    Open Access•Dominique Linhardt•Qu’est-ce qu’un collectif•2010

  • “In [Them] We Will Find Very Desirable Tributaries for Our Commerce”

    Open Access•Francois G Richard, François Richard•The archaeology of capitalism in…•2011

  • Governance and Interpretation

    Open Access•Mark Bevir•Public Administration•2004

  • Theorizing Migration Policy

    Open Access•Christina Boswell•International Migration Review•2007

  • Humanitarian symbolic exchange

    Morgan Briggs, Morgan Brigg•Third World Quarterly•2018

  • The sword is a mighty pen

    Open Access•Benjamin De Carvalho•European Journal of International…•2026

  • Bootstrapping sovereignty

    Open Access•Janis Grzybowski, B Klem•European Journal of International…•2026

  • Henri Lefebvre and the spatial revolution that never ends

    Open Access•Hamish Kallin•Transactions of the Institute of…•2026

  • Symbiotic rivals? Writing state sovereignty through its contestation in the struggle between Australia and the digital giants

    Open Access•Eric Repetto•European Journal of International…•2026

  • The Persistence of the Political

    Rafael Khachaturian•Polity•2025

  • TheRealat the Origin of Sovereignty

    Open Access•J Peter Burge, J Peter Burgess•Political Psychology•2017

  • Anarchy, power and death

    Duncan S A Bell, Duncan Bell•Journal of Political Ideologies•2002

  • Internationalisation and the nation‐state

    Open Access•Kjell Goldmann•European Journal of Political…•2002

  • Anarchism

    Open Access•teven, Simon Stevens et al.•Contemporary Political Theory•2025

  • Statist political science and American Marxism

    Open Access•Rafael Khachaturian•Contemporary Political Theory•2018

  • Beyond unity in plurality

    Open Access•Henrik Enroth•Contemporary Political Theory•2010

  • Protecting the Right of Local Self-Government

    Open Access•Warren Magnusson•Canadian Journal of Political…•2005

  • Bringing the State Back into the Sociology of Nationalism

    Open Access•C Leddy-Owen•Sociology•2020

  • Differentiated Decoupling and Human Rights

    Nitza Berkovitch, Neve Gordon•Social Problems•2016

  • Ten Years of IPS

    J Huysmans, João P Nogueira•International Political Sociology•2016

  • World Society, Social Differentiation and Time

    Open Access•Oliver Kessler•International Political Sociology•2012

  • Space, Boundaries, and the Problem of Order

    Open Access•Jan Helmig, Oliver Kessler•International Political Sociology•2007

  • Rethinking governmentality

    Open Access•Mark Bevir•European Journal of Social Theory•2010

  • Taking the 'Ism' Out of Cosmopolitanism

    Open Access•Robert Fine•European Journal of Social Theory•2003

  • What is the decentered state

    Open Access•Mark Bevir•Public Policy and Administration•2022

  • The Complexity of British–Irish Interdependence

    Paul Gillespie•Irish Political Studies•2014

  • State, nation, society

    Moran M Mandelbaum•Critical Studies on Security•2016

  • Cutting off the King's head

    Open Access•Lee Wilson, L Bakker•Conflict Security and Development•2016

  • Towards a political ontology of state power

    Open Access•B Jessop•British Journal of Sociology•2014

  • The Global/Local Politics of the Great Bear Rainforest

    Karena Shaw•Environmental Politics•2004

  • Madness, Diasporic Difference, and State Violence

    Open Access•Sharmila Rudrappa•Cultural Dynamics•2007

  • Biopolitics, Biopower, and the Return of Sovereignty

    Open Access•M Coleman, Kevin Grove•Environment and Planning D…•2009

  • The Symbiosis of the Urban and the Political

    Open Access•Warren Magnusson•International Journal of Urban…•2014

  • Secularism Beyond the State

    Open Access•Humeira Iqtidar•Modern Asian Studies•2011

  • The histories buildings tell

    Open Access•Julia Gallagher, Daniel Mulugeta et al.•Journal of Eastern African Studies•2022

  • The Imaginary of Borders

    Open Access•Ákos Kopper•International Political Sociology•2012

  • Imagining the state

    Open Access•Shu-Yuan Yang, Shuyuan Yang•Ethnography•2005

  • The State of State Theory

    Open Access•Nicholas J Rowland•Social Forces•2021

  • General theory of law and state

    Hans Kelsen•General theory of law and state•1961

  • The state tradition in Western Europe

    Kenneth H F Dyson•The state tradition in Western…•1980

  • Nietzsche and Political Thought

    Mark Warren•Nietzsche and Political Thought•1991

  • Nationalism

    Liah Greenfeld•Nationalism•1992

  • Political Theory and Modernity. By William E. Connolly. New York

    Open Access•Lawrence A Scaff•American Political Science Review•1989

  • The Ferment of Knowledge

    Open Access•George Sebastian Rousseau, Roy Porter•Ferment of Knowledge•1980

  • Meaning and understanding in the history of ideas

    Quentin Skinner•Visions of Politics•2010

  • The Enlightenment and the French Revolutionary Birth Pangs of Modernity

    Robert Wokler•Rise of the Social Sciences and…•1998

  • From Politics to Reason of State

    Open Access•Maurizio Viroli•From Politics to Reason of State•1992

  • Pluralism and the Personality of the State

    Open Access•David Runciman•Pluralism and the Personality of…•1997

  • Natural Right and History

    Leo Strauss•Natural Right and History…•1965

  • The Taming of Chance

    Open Access•Ian Hacking•Taming of Chance•1990

  • Austin

    Open Access•John Austin, Wilfrid E Rumble•Austin•1995

  • Liberty before Liberalism

    Open Access•Quentin Skinner•Liberty Before Liberalism•1997

  • A Genealogy of Sovereignty

    Open Access•Jens Bartelson•Genealogy of Sovereignty•1995

  • Inside/Outside

    Open Access•R B J Walker•Inside/outside•1992

  • The Logic of the History of Ideas

    Open Access•Mark Bevir•Logic of the History of Ideas•1984

  • The Foundations of Modern Political Thought

    Open Access•Quentin Skinner•Foundations of Modern Political…•1978

  • The Power Elite.

    A T Wright, C W Mills•Military Affairs•1956

  • Intellectual History after the Linguistic Turn

    John E Toews, Jean-Christophe Agnew et al.•The American Historical Review•1987

  • Bringing the State Back In

    Open Access•T Skocpol•Bringing the State Back In•1985

  • Futures Past

    Keith Tribe, Reinhart Koselleck•Futures Past•2004

  • Essence of Decision

    Graham T Allison•Essence of Decision•1972

  • The Sovereign State and Its Competitors

    Hendrik Spruyt•Sovereign State and Its Competitors•1994

  • The Languages of Political Theory in Early-Modern Europe

    Open Access•Anthony Pagden•Languages of Political Theory in…•1987

  • State and Society in International Relations

    Fred Halliday•Study of International Relations•1989

  • Recent theories of the capitalist state

    B Jessop•Cambridge Journal of Economics•1977

  • Theses on the Theory of the State

    Claus Offe, Volker Ronge•Classes, Power, and Conflict•1982

  • The History of Political and Social Concepts

    Melvin Richter•The history of political and…•1995

  • Virtue, Commerce, and History

    Open Access•J G A Pocock•Virtue, Commerce, and History•1985

  • The metaphysics of morals (1797)

    Immanuel Kant, Allen W Wood et al.•Practical Philosophy•2012

  • Does Order Exist in World Politics?

    Hedley Bull•The Anarchical Society•1977

  • International Theory

    Open Access•Adam Watson, James Der Derian•International Theory•1995

  • Sovereignty, Identity, Community

    R B J Walker•Contending Sovereignties•1990

  • The Study of International Relations

    Open Access•Hugh C Dyer, Leon Mangasarian•Study of International Relations•1989

  • That Noble Science of Politics

    Open Access•Stefan Collini, Donald Winch et al.•That Noble Science of Politics•1983

  • Social Theory of International Politics

    Open Access•Alexander Wendt•Social Theory of International…•1999

  • Contending Sovereignties

    R B J Walker, Saul H Mendlovitz•Contending Sovereignties•1990

  • Reason, Truth and History

    Open Access•Hilary Putnam•Reason, Truth and History•1981

  • Cosmopolitanism and Sovereignty

    Thomas Pogge, Thomas W Pogge•Ethics•1992

  • Bringing the State Back In

    Open Access•Peter B Evans, Dietrich Rueschemeyer et al.•Bringing the State Back In•1985

  • The Pragmatic Politics of Mr. H. J. Laski

    Open Access•W Y Elliott•American Political Science Review•1924

  • Essays

    Herbert Spencer-González, Herbert Spencer•Essays•2021

  • Nicos Poulantzas

    Open Access•B Jessop•Nicos Poulantzas•1985

  • The Elements of Politics

    Open Access•Henry Sidgwick•Elements of Politics•2012

  • The Anarchical Society

    Open Access•Hedley Bull•The Anarchical Society•1977

  • The State and Political Theory

    Martin Carnoy•State and Political Theory•1984

  • Michel Foucault

    Hubert L Dreyfus, Michel Foucault et al.•Michel Foucault•1983

  • Potentialities

    Giorgio Agamben, Daniel Heller-Roazen•Potentialities•2000

  • The Rise of the Social Sciences and the Formation of Modernity

    Open Access•Lennart Magnusson, Johan Heilbron et al.•Rise of the Social Sciences and…•1998

  • On the Originality, Legacy, and Actuality of Nicos Poulantzas

    B Jessop•Studies in Political Economy•1991

  • Security, Sovereignty, and the Challenge of World Politics

    Open Access•R B J Walker•Alternatives Global Local Political•1990

  • When will the State Wither Away

    Open Access•Bhikhu Parekh•Alternatives Global Local Political•1990

  • The Geopolitics of Geopolitical Space

    Open Access•Richard K Ashley•Alternatives Global Local Political•1987

  • Reflections on Global Order and Sociohistorical Time

    Open Access•Stephen Gill•Alternatives Global Local Political•1991

  • Discourses of Disintegration, Texts of Transformation

    Open Access•Timothy W Luke•Alternatives Global Local Political•1993

  • Beyond the Great Divide

    Open Access•Ian Clark•Review of International Studies•1998

  • The historiography of academic international relations

    Open Access•Brian C Schmidt, Brain C Schmidt•Review of International Studies•1994

  • The origins of modern international relations theory

    Open Access•J L Holzgrefe•Review of International Studies•1989

  • Short circuits

    Open Access•Jens Bartelson•Review of International Studies•1996

  • Is There a Marxist Theory of the State

    Norberto Bobbio•Telos•1978

  • The Concept of the State as Power

    George H Sabine•The Philosophical Review•1920

  • The Genesis of the Concept of Physical Law

    Edgar Zilsel•The Philosophical Review•1942

  • Emmanuel Sieyes, Benjamin Constant et le « gouvernement des modernes ». Contribution à l'histoire du concept de représentation politique

    Pasquale Pasquino•Revue française de science…•1987

  • Diplomatic Investigations

    Open Access•Hans J Morgenthau•Political Science Quarterly•1967

  • Hegel's Dialectic

    Joyce Beck Hoy, Hans-Georg Gadamer et al.•The Philosophical Review•1978

  • Recent Developments in Marxist Theories of the Capitalist State, Part I

    David Gold, David A Gold et al.•Monthly Review•1975

  • The American Science of Politics

    Open Access•George Catlin, George E G Catlin•Political Science Quarterly•1960

  • The Political System

    Open Access•Oliver Garceau•Political Science Quarterly•1953

  • The Process of Government

    Open Access•Charles A Beard•Political Science Quarterly•1908

  • National Culture and Political Legitimacy

    F M Barnard•Journal of the History of Ideas•1983

  • The Trial of Judgment

    Jens Bartelson•International Studies Quarterly•1995

  • Stress and Contradiction in Modern Capitalism

    M J Murray•American Journal of Sociology•1978

  • Discourses on Society

    Open Access•Bjö Wittrock, Richard P Whitley et al.•Discourses on Society•1991

  • What Is Philosophy

    Gilles Deleuze, Félix Guattari et al.•What Is Philosophy?•1991

  • Social Rules and the State as a Social Actor

    Open Access•Bruce Andrews•World Politics•1975

  • The Deification of The State

    Open Access•Carl J Friedrich•The Review of Politics•1939

  • The Progress of Political Science

    John S Dryzek•The Journal of Politics•1986

  • Francis Lieber and the Interpretation of American Political Science

    James Farr•The Journal of Politics•1990

  • III. Some Problems in the Analysis of Political Thought and Action

    Open Access•Quentin Skinner•Political Theory•1974

  • Conceptual History (Begriffsgeschichte) and Political Theory

    Open Access•Melvin Richter•Political Theory•1986

  • Making Exceptions

    Open Access•Jens Bartelson•Political Theory•1997

  • The Revolution in the Concept of Politics

    Open Access•Maurizio Viroli•Political Theory•1992

  • The Political System Besieged by the State

    Open Access•David Easton•Political Theory•1981

  • Contextualizing Hegel's Phenomenology of the French Revolution and the Terror

    Open Access•Robert Wokler•Political Theory•1998

  • The Permanent Crisis of a Divided Mankind

    Open Access•Istvan Hont•Political Studies•1994

  • Lessons from the Past

    Brian C Schmidt•International Studies Quarterly•1998

  • What's at stake in the agent-structure debate

    Open Access•David Dessler•International Organization•1989

  • Globalization and the changing logic of collective action

    Open Access•Philip G Cerny•International Organization•1995

  • The second image reversed

    Open Access•Peter Gourevitch•International Organization•1978

  • The agent-structure problem in international relations theory

    Open Access•Alexander Wendt, Alexander E Wendt•International Organization•1987

  • The State in an Era of Cascading Politics

    Open Access•James N Rosenau•Comparative Political Studies•1988

  • The History of Political Science

    James Farr•American Journal of Political…•1988

  • On the Ontological Status of the State

    Open Access•Erik Ringmar•European Journal of International…•1996

  • Second Natures

    Open Access•Jens Bartelson•European Journal of International…•1998

  • The Foucault Effect

    Graham Burchell, C Gordon et al.•The Foucault Effect•1991

  • Continuity and Transformation in the World Polity

    Open Access•John Gerard Ruggie•World Politics•1983

  • The poverty of neorealism

    Open Access•Richard K Ashley•International Organization•1984

  • Political power beyond the State

    Nikolas Rose, Peter Miller•British Journal of Sociology•1992

  • Conventions and the Understanding of Speech Acts

    Quentin Skinner•The Philosophical Quarterly•1970

Unique citing works87
Citations per year3,63
Citation span2002 - 2026 (25)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 77

Tools

Open DOILibgen
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae