Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Teacher questioning in science classrooms

Approaches that stimulate productive thinking

Bibliographic Data

ID23317872
AuthorsChristine Chin (0000-0002-9524-5881, Nanyang Technological University, corresponding author)
Year2007
Volume44
Issue6
Pages815-843
Publication date2007-08-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Research in Science Teaching (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0022-4308 • E-ISSN: 1098-2736
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1002/tea.20171
OpenAlexW1965442895
LanguageEN
Citations received100
References cited35

The purpose of this study was to find out how teachers use questions in classroom discourse to scaffold student thinking and help students construct scientific knowledge. The study was conducted in large‐class settings where the medium of instruction was English although the students were non‐native speakers of the language. Six teachers teaching grade 7 science classes from four schools participated in the study. Thirty‐six lessons covering a range of topics were observed across a variety of lesson structures such as expository teaching, whole‐class discussions, and laboratory work. The lessons were audiotaped and videotaped. Verbal transcripts of classroom discourse were analyzed interpretively. Particular attention was paid to questioning exchanges that stimulated productive thinking in students, as manifested by their verbal responses. A framework was developed that included four questioning approaches adopted by the teachers. This included Socratic questioning, verbal jigsaw, semantic tapestry, and framing. This paper describes these various questioning approaches, their features, and the conditions under which they were used. It also discusses the implications of these approaches for instructional practice. The findings from this study have potential in translating research insights into practical advice for teachers regarding tactical moves in classroom discourse, and provide guidelines for teachers to increase their repertoire of questioning skills. © 2007 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Res Sci Teach 44: 815–843, 2007

Class (philosophy) · Construct (python library) · Critical thinking · Framing (construction) · Jigsaw · Mathematics education · Pedagogy · Science education · Socratic method · Socratic questioning · Teaching method · Variety (cybernetics) · Computer Science · Education and Critical Thinking Development · Educational Strategies and Epistemologies · Psychology · Science Education and Pedagogy

  • Using Video and Multimodal Classroom Interaction Analysis to Investigate How Information, Misinformation, and Disinformation Influence Pedagogy

    Open Access•John-Paul Riordan, John‐Paul Riordan et al.•Video Journal of Education and…•2023

  • Is Consuming Avocados Equally Sustainable Worldwide? An Activity to Promote Eco-Social Education from Science Education

    Open Access•Irene Guevara-Herrero•Education Sciences•2024

  • Asking for more

    Annerose Willemsen, Myrte N Gosen et al.•Research on Children and Social…•2021

  • A Teacher Questioning Activity

    Open Access•Mela Aziza•Qualitative Research in Education•2021

  • Developing a Framework for Understanding Lecturer-Student Interaction in English-Medium Undergraduate Lectures in Sri Lanka

    Open Access•A M M Navaz•International Journal of English…•2020

  • Classroom Discourse and Teachers’ Experience

    Open Access•Bibi Malihe Vamagh Shahi•Theory and Practice in Language…•2021

  • English Teachers’ Practice of Classroom Discourse in Light of Zone of Proximal Development Theory and Scaffolding Techniques

    Open Access•Rashed Zannan Alghamdy•Journal of Language Teaching and…•2023

  • Learning to Teach Argumentation

    Shirley Simon, Sibel Erduran et al.•International Journal of Science…•2006

  • Teacher–Student Dialogue During Classroom Teaching

    Christine Howe, Sara Hennessy et al.•Journal of the Learning Sciences•2019

  • Measuring Cognitive Engagement With Self-Report Scales

    Barbara A Greene•Educational Psychologist•2015

  • Managing uncertainty in scientific argumentation

    Open Access•Ying-Chih Chen, Matthew J Benus et al.•Science Education•2019

  • Scientific discourse in three urban classrooms

    Open Access•Katherine L Mcneill, Diane Silva Pimentel•Science Education•2010

  • We are bonded over physics

    Open Access•Mihwa Park, Weverton Ataíde Pinheiro•Discover Education•2026

  • Teachers’ noticing and social interactions in the classroom

    Open Access•Tuğçe Kozaklı Ülger, Zeynep Kıryak et al.•Thinking Skills and Creativity•2026

  • Shaping maker education through design thinking

    Open Access•Jiajia Li, Sui Lin Goei et al.•Thinking Skills and Creativity•2026

  • Investigating preservice teachers’ emotions and dialogic teaching practices in simulation-based learning with artificial intelligence-powered virtual student agents

    Open Access•Chih‐Pu Dai, Fan Ke et al.•Learning and Instruction•2026

  • English language teachers' development of questioning skills

    Open Access•Mostafa Nazari, Özgehan Uştuk et al.•RELC Journal•2026

  • Facilitating Classroom Discussions across Content Areas

    Lynsey K Gibbons, Lynsey Gibbons et al.•The Elementary School Journal•2026

  • Implementing a POE–Socratic ChatGPT routine in Jordanian Tawjihi physics (Grades 11–12)

    Open Access•Jehan Albataineh•SN Social Sciences•2026

  • The dimensionality of the epistemic orientation survey and longitudinal measurement invariance for the short form of EOS (EOS-SF)

    Open Access•Chenchen Ding, Gavin W Fulmer et al.•Frontiers in Education•2023

  • The Socratic method in mathematics learning

    Open Access•Reni Nuraeni, Rizky Rosjanuardi et al.•Frontiers in Education•2026

  • Exploring the Complexity of Adaptive Teaching Expertise within Knowledge Generation Environments

    Open Access•Jee Kyung Suh, Brian Hand et al.•Education Sciences•2024

  • An Analysis of the Type of Questions Posed by Teachers in English-Medium Instruction at University Level

    Open Access•Aintzane Doiz, David Lasagabaster•Education Sciences•2023

  • Is It Possible to Apply Inquiry in the First Level of Primary School without Hindering the Acquisition of Scientific Competencies? Perspectives of Pupils and Their Pre-Service Teacher

    Open Access•Jaime Delgado-Iglesias, Javier Bobo-Pinilla et al.•Education Sciences•2024

  • The Use of Question Modification Strategies to Differentiate Instruction in Eritrean Mathematics and Science Classrooms

    Open Access•Desalegn Zerai, Sirpa Eskelä-Haapanen et al.•Education Sciences•2023

  • Identifying Student Teachers’ Inquiry-Related Questions in Biology Lessons

    Open Access•Matti Hiltunen, Sirpa Kärkkäinen et al.•Education Sciences•2021

  • How does teacher-student interaction shape students’ verbal participation initiative? A multimodal analysis of 2 018 classroom video recordings

    L Crystal Jiang, Li Jiang et al.•Interactive Learning Environments•2026

  • Pioneering quantitative assessment of questioning competency in elementary pre-service teachers using Likert-scale questions

    Jianlan Wang, Yuanhua Wang et al.•International Journal of Science…•2026

  • Exploring science teachers’ questioning patterns for learning support through a computational grounded theory approach

    Tongtong Guan, Liqiang Zhang et al.•International Journal of Science…•2026

  • Epistemic network analysis of novice and expert chemistry teachers’ multimodal questioning and feedback behaviours

    Qianwen SONG, Yunshui Zheng et al.•International Journal of Science…•2025

  • Forms and functions of on-the-fly formative assessment conversations in physics inquiry lessons

    Pasi Nieminen, Markus Hähkiöniemi et al.•International Journal of Science…•2021

  • Moving talk forward

    Tammy D Lee, Bonnie Glass•International Journal of Science…•2021

  • The epistemic dimension in the approach to questioning in chemistry classes

    Rivaldo Lopes da Silva, Bruno Ferreira Dos Santos•International Journal of Science…•2021

  • Conceptualising a science toolkit for systematic educational dialogue analysis (SciT-Seda)

    Long Yun, Yun Long et al.•International Journal of Science…•2025

  • Secondary science teachers’ use of discourse moves to work with student ideas in classroom discussions

    Stacey L Carpenter, Jiwon Kim et al.•International Journal of Science…•2020

  • Teachers’ perspectives on scaffolding open inquiry in primary school science

    Open Access•Lotta Leden, Lena Hansson•International Journal of Science…•2026

  • Exploring coherence and authorship in pedagogical link-making in science

    Open Access•Sami Lehesvuori, Jaume Ametller•International Journal of Science…•2021

  • Features and trends of teaching strategies for scientific practices from a review of 2008–2017 articles

    Suarman Halawa, Ying‐Shao Hsu et al.•International Journal of Science…•2020

  • Exploring Middle School Science Teachers’ Error-Reaction Patterns by Classroom Discourse Analysis

    Open Access•Yilmaz Soysal•Science & Education•2024

  • Talking Science

    Open Access•Yilmaz Soysal•Science & Education•2021

  • Dialogic Pathways to Manage Uncertainty for Productive Engagement in Scientific Argumentation

    Open Access•Ying-Chih Chen•Science & Education•2020

  • Quality Indicators of an Experienced Middle School Science Teacher’s Argument‐Based Inquiry Teaching

    Open Access•Yilmaz Soysal•Science & Education•2023

  • Teacher Talk Supporting Student Progressive Discourse in Science

    Open Access•Kraig A Wray, Scott Mcdonald•Science & Education•2025

  • Science Teachers’ Challenging Questions for Encouraging Students to Think and Speak in Novel Ways

    Open Access•Yilmaz Soysal•Science & Education•2024

  • Making Argumentation-Based Learning and Teaching Happen

    Open Access•Ebru Altun, Tuncay Ozsevgec•Science & Education•2025

  • Developing a Phenomenographic Argument for Science Teacher Educators’ Conceptions Regarding Question-Asking

    Open Access•Yilmaz Soysal•Science & Education•2025

  • Technology‐Embedded Argument‐DrivenInquiry in Preservice Chemistry Teacher Education

    Open Access•Putu Anindita Widhiya Putri, Sri Rahayu et al.•Science & Education•2025

  • Analyzing classroom discourse in social justice mathematical modeling contexts

    Open Access•Hong Zhang, Hyunyi Jung et al.•Linguistics and Education•2025

  • Students’ beliefs about the role of interaction for science learning and language learning in EMI science classes

    Open Access•Jiangshan An, Nathan Thomas•Linguistics and Education•2021

  • Detecting the factors affecting classroom dialogue quality

    Open Access•Chrysi Rapanta, Andrea Miralda-Banda et al.•Linguistics and Education•2023

  • An analysis of teacher questioning practices in dialogic lessons

    Open Access•Maria Vrikki, María Evagorou•International Journal of…•2023

  • “Failure is just another try”

    Open Access•Jaakko Hilppö, Reed Stevens•International Journal of…•2020

  • Instructional design of scaffolded online learning modules for self-directed and inquiry-based learning environments

    Open Access•Md Abdullah Al Mamun, Gwendolyn Lawrie et al.•Computers & Education•2020

  • STEM in the classroom

    Open Access•James Deehan, Lena Danaia et al.•The Australian Educational…•2024

  • Elementary Pre‐Service Teachers' Responsiveness to Students Ideas When Facilitating Scientific Argumentation Discussions

    Open Access•Shreyashi Halder, Jamie N Mikeska et al.•Journal of Computer Assisted…•2026

  • Mapping the lesson

    Fei Victor Lim•Journal of Education for Teaching…•2024

  • Searching for the impact of teaching quality and dialogic behaviour on student learning outcome / En busca del impacto de la calidad de la enseñanza y del comportamiento dialógico en los resultados del aprendizaje de los estudiantes

    Open Access•Maria Vrikki, Leonidas Kyriakides et al.•Journal for the Study of…•2025

  • The Classroom‐Research‐Mentoring Framework

    Open Access•Alexandra Christine Cooper, Molly S Bolger et al.•Science Education•2024

  • Teacher strategies to support student navigation of uncertainty

    Open Access•Heesoo Ha, Ying-Chih Chen et al.•Science Education•2024

  • Characterizing the formative assessment enactment of experienced science teachers

    Open Access•Vesal Dini, Hannah Sevian et al.•Science Education•2020

  • Plan‐Draw‐Evaluate (PDE) pattern in students' collaborative drawing

    Open Access•Joonhyeong Park, Kok‐sing Tang et al.•Science Education•2021

  • An analytical instrument for coding and assessing argumentative dialogues in science teaching contexts

    Open Access•Marina Martins, Fabrizio Macagno•Science Education•2022

  • Children's concepts of gears and their promotion through play

    Open Access•Timo Reuter, Miriam Leuchter•Journal of Research in Science…•2021

  • Preservice elementary teachers' perceptions of their science laboratory instructors in a phenomena‐based laboratory and how it impacts their conceptual development

    Open Access•Alvir S Sangha, Dermot Donnelly‐hermosillo et al.•Journal of Research in Science…•2024

  • Developing deep learning in science classrooms

    Open Access•Ying-Chih Chen, Ratrapee Techawitthayachinda•Journal of Research in Science…•2021

  • Improving teacher questioning in science using Icap theory

    Open Access•Joshua Morris, Michelene T H Chi et al.•The Journal of Educational Research•2020

  • Patterns of Interactions in Science Classrooms at the Colleges of Education in Ghana

    Open Access•Ebenezer Appah Bonney•Journal of Education•2023

  • Exploring interconnections between communicative activities, situational stress reactions and cognitive engagement in undergraduate mathematics lesson

    Open Access•Sami Lehesvuori, Miitta Järvinen et al.•Instructional Science•2026

  • Research on the correlation between teacher classroom questioning types and student thinking development from the perspective of discourse analysis

    Open Access•Xiarizhati Niyazi, Xiaopeng Wu•Instructional Science•2024

  • Reflections on dialogicity

    Open Access•Sami Lehesvuori, Markus Hähkiöniemi et al.•Learning Culture and Social…•2021

  • Student-centredness in physics laboratory teaching sessions

    Open Access•Sami Lehesvuori, Antti Lehtinen et al.•Learning Culture and Social…•2023

  • An investigation of museum educators' questioning during field trips

    Open Access•Johanna M Tigert, Golnar Fotouhi et al.•Learning Culture and Social…•2021

  • Dialogic teaching in secondary classrooms in China

    Open Access•Zi Yang, Sisi Wang•Learning Culture and Social…•2022

  • Back to basics

    Open Access•Vasilia Christidou, Maria Birbili et al.•Education Inquiry•2025

  • Teachers’ use of open questions

    Open Access•Ingvill Krogstad Svanes, Emilia Andersson-Bakken•Education Inquiry•2021

  • Influence of motivation, self-beliefs, and instructional practices on science achievement of adolescents in Canada

    Open Access•Shaljan Areepattamannil, John G Freeman et al.•Social Psychology of Education•2010

  • Asking meaningful questions in digital outdoor learning tool - a way to support conceptual change

    Elina Malleus, Grete Arro et al.•Environmental Education Research•2023

  • Enhancing University Students' Questioning Techniques in Dialogic and Argumentative Practices

    Open Access•Christiana Karousiou, María Evagorou et al.•Higher Education Quarterly•2026

  • Classroom interaction in EMI high schools

    Open Access•Jiangshan An, Ernesto Macaro et al.•System•2021

  • Investigating teacher questioning in Hong Kong secondary EMI classrooms

    Open Access•Xuejun Ye, Özgehan Uştuk et al.•System•2025

  • Questioning and responding in the classroom

    G Hu, Hu Guangwei et al.•International Journal of…•2019

  • Informal formative assessment

    Open Access•Maria Araceli Ruiz-Primo, Maria Araceli Ruiz‐Primo•Studies In Educational Evaluation•2011

  • Is teacher judgment accuracy of students’ characteristics beneficial for verbal teacher-student interactions in classroom

    Open Access•Maralena Pielmeier, Sina Huber et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2018

  • The validity and reliability of a tool for measuring educational innovative thinking competencies

    Open Access•Sigal Morad, Noa Ragonis et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2020

  • Thinking through talk

    Open Access•Ruiguo Cui, Peter Teo•Teaching and Teacher Education•2023

  • Development and validation of Teacher Intentionality of Practice Scale (Tips)

    Open Access•Jeff C Marshall, Julie Smart et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2016

  • My job is to unsettle folks”

    Open Access•Ashley Moore, Ashley E Moore•Teaching and Teacher Education•2021

  • Questioning as an instructional method

    Open Access•Gamze Nur İnönü, Hasibe Özlen Demircan•Teaching and Teacher Education•2023

  • Exploring the development of core teaching practices in the context of inquiry-based science instruction

    Open Access•Jill Mcnew-Birren, Leigh A van den Kieboom•Teaching and Teacher Education•2017

  • What Do I Say Next? Using the Third Turn to Build Productive Instructional Discussions

    Open Access•Evelyn Ford‐Connors, David Alan Robertson et al.•Journal of Adolescent & Adult…•2017

  • The relationship between teaching and learning conceptions, preferred teaching approaches and questioning practices

    Maria Helena Pedrosa‐de‐Jesus, Betina Da Silva Lopes•Research Papers in Education•2011

  • How does dialogic teaching facilitate students' creative thinking? Evidence from a sequential analysis of teacher–student dialogue in primary language classrooms

    Open Access•Tao Yang, Yang Tao et al.•British Educational Research…•2026

  • Climate Change and Tesol

    Open Access•Jason Goulah•TESOL Quarterly•2017

  • Questions as Dialogue Games. The Pragmatic Dimensions of “Authentic” Questions

    Open Access•Fabrizio Macagno•Studies in Philosophy and Education•2023

  • Young Children's Epistemic Operations and Emergent Argumentation in Inquiry‐Based Discussions

    Open Access•Lidia Caño-Pérez, Josu Sanz•Journal of Research in Science…•2025

  • Understanding compatibilities and inconsistencies between science teachers’ professed beliefs and practices about question-asking in science lessons

    Open Access•Yilmaz Soysal•Instructional Science•2026

  • Differences between a teacher educator’s and prospective classroom teacher’s talk-based strategies for fostering academically productive classroom talk

    Open Access•Yilmaz Soysal, Somayyeh Soysal•Education Inquiry•2026

  • Examining Teacher Questioning in English‐Medium Instruction Classrooms

    Open Access•Özgehan Uştuk, Xuejun Ye et al.•TESOL Quarterly•2025

  • Ways of questioning, ways of gesturing

    Zhenzhen Zhang, Bingjun Yang et al.•International Journal of Science…•2025

  • Exploring Science Teacher Questions' Influence on the Students' Talk Productivity

    Open Access•Yilmaz Soysal, Somayyeh Soysal•SAGE Open•2022

  • Classroom Discourse and the Space of Learning

    Ference Marton, Amy B M Tsui et al.•Classroom Discourse and the Space…•2004

  • Classroom Interaction in Science

    Christine Chin•International Journal of Science…•2006

  • Frames of mind

    Howard Gardner•Frames of mind•1983

  • The Discovery of Grounded Theory

    Barney G Glaser, Anselm L Strauss•Discovery of Grounded Theory•2017

  • Those Who Understand

    Open Access•Lee S Shulman•Educational Researcher•1986

  • Learning Lessons

    Hugh Mehan•Learning Lessons•1979

  • Using questions to foil discussion

    Open Access•J T Dillon•Teaching and Teacher Education•1985

  • Chinese conceptions of learning and teaching

    Daniel D Pratt•International Journal of Lifelong…•1992

  • Naturalistic inquiry

    Open Access•Yvonna S Lincoln, Egon G Guba et al.•International Journal of…•1985

  • Wait Time

    Open Access•Mary Budd Rowe•Journal of Teacher Education•1986

Unique citing works100
Citations per year5
Citation span2006 - 2026 (21)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 93

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae