Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

An answer to the question

What is enlightenment? (1784)

Bibliographic Data

ID23318781
AuthorsImmanuel Kant, Allen W Wood (Stanford University, corresponding author)
EditorsMary J Gregor
Year2012
Pages11-22
Publication date2012-06-18
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeCHAPTER
VenuePractical Philosophy (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherCambridge University Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1017/cbo9780511813306.005
OpenAlexW2888655269
ISBN9780511813306
LanguageEN
Citations received125

Introduction Since the eighteenth century was the “Age of Enlightenment,” it was appropriate to ask “What is Enlightenment?” Kant's answer to the question appeared in the December 1784 issue of the Berlinische Monatsschrift . As his concluding note indicates, the September issue, which Kant had not yet received, contained an essay on the same topic by Moses Mendelssohn. The occasion for both replies to the question could have been an essay in the December 1783 issue, “Is It Advisable to Sanction Marriage through Religion?” by Johann Friedrich Zöllner, which contained the passage “ What is Enlightenment ? The question, which is almost as important as the question What is truth ?, should be answered before one begins to enlighten others. And yet I have never found it answered anywhere.” As might be expected, Kant's answer and Mendelssohn's were not in agreement. Consistently with his eudaimonism, Mendelssohn had located enlightenment in the cultivation of what Kant would call the theoretical, as distinguished from the practical, use of one's intellectual powers. To this extent, Kant's reply to Garve in “Theory and Practice” would serve against Mendelssohn as well. Kant's insistence upon freedom of the press, in the present context as the instrument of enlightenment, reappears in virtually all his political writings. A number of points introduced here – Kant's distinction between the public and the private use of reason, his principles of scriptural exegesis, his views about what kind of sect a government could sanction consistently with its own interest – were elaborated in a treatise written in 1794, which had to be withheld from publication because of the repressive measures of Frederick the Great's nephew and successor.

Enlightenment · Epistemology · Scottish Enlightenment · History · Kantian Philosophy and Modern Interpretations · Philosophical Ethics and Theory · Philosophy · Philosophy and Historical Thought

  • Cynicism

    Ansgar Allen•Cynicism•2020

  • Against Critical Thinking in Health, Social Care and Social Work

    Tom Grimwood•Against Critical Thinking in…•2023

  • Königsberg city as a factor in the development of Kant-philosopher

    Open Access•Tatyana Rumyantseva•Urbis et Orbis Microhistory and…•2023

  • The Performative Dimensions of Academic and Public Philosophy

    Open Access•Mariia Lihus•NaUKMA Research Papers History…•2023

  • Forgetting To Forget

    Open Access•Yaara Rosolio, Miri Rozmarin•interconnections journal of…•2025

  • Self-Care and Truth-Telling

    Open Access•Gerald Posselt•Le foucaldien•2021

  • Monsters and the pantomime

    Open Access•Robert Marsden•Palgrave Communications•2020

  • Mysteries, Conspiracies, and Inquiries

    Open Access•Simon Susen•SocietàMutamentoPolitica•2021

  • Here I Stand

    Terence Dawson•Jung Journal•2012

  • Contemporary Consciousness as Reflected in Images of the Vampire

    Yoshitaka Inoue•Jung Journal•2011

  • Prilog interpretaciji Feuerbachove nesumnjive prisutnosti

    Open Access•Darko Kovačić•In medias res•2023

  • Relational Autonomy in Spinoza. Freedom and Joint Action

    Claudia Aguilar•Comparative and Continental…•2023

  • Kant's Concept of Nostalgia

    Open Access•Gabriel Leiva Rubio•Emotion Review•2025

  • Egyptian Literary Culture and Egyptian Modernity

    Caroline Rooney•Journal of Postcolonial Writing•2011

  • Institutions and Shadows

    Open Access•James Ward•Estudios Irlandeses•2023

  • Sobre a autonomia relativa da Comunicação de Ciência

    Open Access•Diana Cunha, Diogo Cunha•Estudos em Comunicação•2015

  • The Inherent Tolerance of the Democratic Process

    Open Access•Emanuela Ceva, Rossella De Bernardi•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2023

  • Democratic, caring and disciplinary values in Danish preschools

    Open Access•Ole Henrik Hansen, Anders Skriver Jensen et al.•Contemporary Issues in Early…•2020

  • A pedagogy of data and Artificial Intelligence for student subjectification

    Mary Loftus, Michael G Madden•Teaching in Higher Education•2020

  • The voice(s) of reason

    Michael Seats•Teaching in Higher Education•2022

  • Is a Non-metaphysical Religious Thought Possible? – Possibility of Religious Thought within the Scope of Heidegger’s Onto-theology Criticism

    Open Access•Kasım Küçükalp•Ilahiyat Studies•2010

  • Towards an Epistemology of Reading

    Open Access•Datta Arun, Arun D M•Rupkatha Journal on Interdisciplina…•2021

  • Anonymity and commitment

    Open Access•Soraj Hongladarom•AI & Society•2019

  • Emancipation and liberation as normative horizons in critical theory

    Open Access•José Fernando Andrade Costa•Thesis Eleven•2024

  • How to Deal with Kant's Racism—In and Out of the Classroom

    Victor Fabian Abundez-Guerra, Philosophy Documentation Center•Teaching Philosophy•2018

  • In defence of epistemic vices

    Open Access•Steven Bland•Synthese•2022

  • Hackathon

    Open Access•Sonia Massari, Sara Roversi et al.•Handbook Transdisciplinary Learning•2023

  • Human Bondage in the Cultural Contact Zone. Transdisciplinary Perspectives on Slavery and Its Discourses

    Open Access•Raphael Hörmann, Raphael Hoermann et al.•Human Bondage in the Cultural…•2010

  • Heritage and Festivals in Europe

    Open Access•Ullrich Kockel, Cristina Clopot et al.•Heritage and Festivals in Europe•2019

  • Migration, Education and Employment

    Open Access•Marianne Teräs, Ali Osman et al.•Migration, Education and Employment•2024

  • Politonomy

    Martin Loughlin, Jens Meierhenrich et al.•The Oxford Handbook of Carl Schmitt•2014

  • Freedom Without Responsibility

    Open Access•Thomas Bustamante, Conrado Hübner Mendes•Jus Cogens•2021

  • The Challenge of Postdigital Literacy

    Open Access•Cary Campbell, Alexandra Olteanu•Postdigital Science and Education•2024

  • Biosemiotics for postdigital living

    Open Access•Alexandra Olteanu, Alin Olteanu et al.•Chinese Semiotic Studies•2023

  • Rethinking critical thinking in the dawn of dark times

    Yulong Li, Xiaojing Liu•Teaching in Higher Education•2025

  • Wikipedia and AI

    Open Access•Zachary J Mcdowell•Convergence The International…•2024

  • Socrates’ Pedagogical Methods in his Geometry Lesson to the Slave-Boy

    Open Access•Adam Weiler Gur Arye•Interchange•2025

  • Distinguishing Three Concepts of the Societal Good

    Open Access•Sara Mandray, Daryl Koehn et al.•Journal of Business Ethics•2025

  • Adorno’s Critique of Fichte’s Idealism

    Open Access•David James•Archiv für Geschichte der…•2025

  • Fichte’s Politics of Cultural Awakening

    Open Access•Reidar Maliks•Kantian Review•2025

  • The Cambridge Handbook of the Capability Approach

    Open Access•Des Gasper, D R Gasper et al.•Cambridge Handbook of the…•2020

  • The Apt Curation Model

    Open Access•Tiegue Vieira Rodrigues•Philosophy & Technology•2026

  • The political economy of suspicion

    Open Access•Marco Briziarelli•Critical Sociology•2026

  • Kant’s Philosophical Ascesis

    Open Access•I Hunter•History of European Ideas•2026

  • Sobre el concepto de cultura en El malestar en la cultura (1930) de Sigmund Freud (On the Concept of Culture in Sigmund Freud's Civilization and Its Discontents (1930))

    Open Access•Marcelo F Ponce•SSRN Electronic Journal•2018

  • Saving Liberalism from Itself

    Open Access•Timothy Stacey•Saving Liberalism from Itself•2022

  • Saving Liberalism from Itself

    Open Access•T Stacey•Saving Liberalism from Itself•2022

  • May 1968

    Open Access•Robert J C Young•Interventions•2020

  • Rethinking Political Judgement

    Open Access•Maša Mrovlje•Rethinking Political Judgement•2018

  • Abir's Enlightenment Revolution is the basic element leading to the end of the corrupt regime resulting from the poisoned Tunisian revolution 2011

    Open Access•Hassen Chaabani•International Journal of Modern…•2021

  • Compulsory Creativity

    Open Access•Steen Nepper Larsen•Culture Unbound Journal of…•2014

  • Social inclusion, a challenge for deliberative democracy? Some reflections on Habermas's political theory

    Open Access•Isabelle Aubert•European Journal of Social Theory•2021

  • The question of recentring Africa

    Pascah Mungwini•South African Journal of Philosophy•2016

  • The Post-Secular Turn

    Open Access•Agata Bielik‐robson•Eidos A Journal for Philosophy of…•2019

  • Characterization and Categorization of Colombian Protestants in the Late 2010s

    Open Access•William Mauricio Beltrán, Sonia Patricia Larotta Silva et al.•International Journal of Latin…•2025

  • Think You Right

    Open Access•Benjamin B Taylor•SPECTRA the Social Political…•2018

  • Black Skin, White Masks and the Paradoxical Politics of Black Historiography

    Open Access•Tacuma Peters•Journal of French and Francophone…•2023

  • The Fifth Antinomy

    Open Access•Roy Ben-Shai•Journal of French and Francophone…•2017

  • The Becoming-Other of Politics

    Open Access•Benjamin Arditi•Contemporary Political Theory•2003

  • Reflexive modernization' and other mythical realities

    Open Access•Vassos Argyrou•Anthropological Theory•2003

  • O que é a crítica decolonial

    Open Access•N Maldonado-Torres, Fábio Amorim Vieira et al.•Fronteiras Revista Catarinense de…•2024

  • The Postmodern Left

    Open Access•Niall Lucy, Steve Mickler•Cultural Studies Review•1970

  • Genealogia e historicismo crítico

    Open Access•John Abromeit•Cadernos de Filosofia Alemã…•2017

  • Illiberalism and the democratic paradox

    Open Access•E Swyngedouw•European Journal of Social Theory•2022

  • From Kant to Sade

    David James•British Journal for the History…•2018

  • A Social Contract Case for a Carbon Tax

    Open Access•Elisabeth Ellis•Revista de ciencia política•2024

  • Re‐Reading the Post‐Kantian Tradition with Milbank

    Open Access•Gordon E Michalson•Journal of Religious Ethics•2004

  • Spectral Inheritance

    Open Access•Ruben Hordijk•Spectral Inheritance•2024

  • The Antinomy of the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Haram Lee•Theory Culture & Society•2024

  • Modern Times

    Achim Landwehr•History of European Ideas•2024

  • Foucault's Kantian critique

    Open Access•Christina Hendricks•Philosophy & Social Criticism•2008

  • Kant, Copyright and Communicative Freedom

    Open Access•Arthur Barron, Anne Barron•Law and Philosophy•2011

  • In search of a strong European public sphere

    Open Access•Slavko Splichal•Media Culture & Society•2006

  • What Is a Book? Kant and the Law of the Letter

    Alain Pottage, Mario Biagioli•Critical Inquiry•2023

  • Agrarian Modernity—Coda

    Open Access•Christian Lund, Hilary Oliva Faxon et al.•Antipode•2025

  • Aufklärung', freemasonry, the public sphere and the question of Enlightenment

    Open Access•Tim Mehigan, Helene De Burgh•Journal of European Studies•2008

  • Pact with the People

    Jonas Teupert•Qui Parle•2020

  • Wang Yangming, Descartes, and the Sino-European juncture of Enlightenment

    Zemian Zheng•Asian Philosophy•2021

  • Critiquing the Modern Western Theory of Knowledge and Insights into a Qur’anic Epistemology

    Open Access•Farhan Mujahid Chak•American Journal of Islamic…•2012

  • The Post-Enlightenment Moral Crisis and the Emergence of Secular Tyranny in the Middle East

    Open Access•Farhan Mujahid Chak•American Journal of Islamic…•2017

  • The Post-Enlightenment Moral Crisis and the Emergence of Secular Tyranny in the Middle East

    Open Access•Farhan Mujahid Chak•American Journal of Islamic…•2017

  • Education, Philosophy, and Morality

    Open Access•Laura J Mueller•Eidos A Journal for Philosophy of…•2020

  • How to Handle Humility? Audaciously

    Open Access•Tibor Solymosi, Bill Bywater•Eidos A Journal for Philosophy of…•2019

  • Russia and the Missing World

    Open Access•Sergei Prozorov•New Perspectives•2016

  • Characteristics of Discussion in "Public Sphere" of Vietnam Electronic Newspaper through "News and Opinion" Column – Tuoi Tre Newspaper

    Open Access•Phan Van Kien•Sociology and Anthropology•2018

  • In the eye of the potentially non-confirm-structuring beholder

    Martin Javornicky•Journal of Political Power•2019

  • Tradition' as an element in the discourse of political philosophy

    Open Access•Mariya Fedorova•Filosofskii Zhurnal•2017

  • The spirit of social pedagogy

    Open Access•Magnus Frampton•Critical and Radical Social Work•2022

  • An evaluation of the potential impact of standardised assessments on the promotion of pupil autonomy in Scottish education, from the perspective of Dearden’s view of autonomy

    Open Access•Jill Steel•Citizenship Social and Economics…•2019

  • Seeds of divinity

    James Mensch•Intellectual History Review•2019

  • Kant’s warning about self-observation in Anthropology from a Pragmatic Point of View

    J Colin Mcquillan•Intellectual History Review•2024

  • Ignorância moral e o papel das virtudes

    Open Access•Denis Coitinho•ethic@ - An international Journal…•2020

  • Freedom of speech and cognitive vices. Kant's and current Kantian perspectives

    Open Access•Jean‐Christophe Merle•ethic@ - An international Journal…•2023

  • From wonder to being

    Open Access•Callum David Scott•Verbum et Ecclesia•2025

  • Epistemic justice and experiential self

    Open Access•V Hari Narayanan•Mind & Society•2023

  • Paternalism and the Public Household. On the Domestic Origins of Public Economics

    Open Access•Maxime Desmarais-Tremblay•SSRN Electronic Journal•2017

  • An Answer to the Question

    Open Access•Bernard E Harcourt•SSRN Electronic Journal•2007

  • Nationalism and the Spanish Dilemma

    Open Access•José Joaquín Jiménez Sánchez•Politics & Policy•2006

  • The African novel and the question of communalism in African philosophy

    Zeyad El Nabolsy•Safundi•2023

  • Rumor and Media

    Stefan Andriopoulos•Grey Room•2023

Unique citing works125
Citations per year2,23
Citation span1970 - 2026 (57)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 99

Tools

Open DOILibgen
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae