Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Getting Out of Deficit

Pedagogies of reconnection

Bibliographic Data

ID23323903
AuthorsBarbara Comber (0000-0002-8364-1676, University of South Australia, corresponding author), Barbara Kamler (Deakin University)
Year2004
Volume15
Issue3
Pages293-310
Publication date2004-09-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueTeaching Education (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1047-6210 • E-ISSN: 1470-1286
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/1047621042000257225
OpenAlexW2024523609
LanguageEN
Citations received57
References cited11

The fact that children growing up in poverty are likely to be in the lower ranges of achievement on standardised literacy tests is not a new phenomenon. Internationally there are a myriad of intervention and remedial programmes designed to address this problem with a range of effects. Frequently, sustainable reforms are curtailed by deficit views of families and children growing up in poverty. This article describes an ongoing research study entitled “Teachers Investigate Unequal Literacy Outcomes: Cross‐Generational Perspectives”, which made teacher researchers central in examining this long‐standing dilemma. It outlines the research design and rationale, and analyses how two early career teachers worked their ways out of deficit analyses of two children they were most worried about. It argues that disrupting deficit discourses and re‐designing new pedagogical repertoires to reconnect with children's lifeworlds is a long‐term project that can best be achieved in reciprocal research relationships with teachers.

Dilemma · Epistemology · Intervention (counseling) · Literacy · Mathematics education · Pedagogy · Phenomenon · Political science · Poverty · Reciprocal · Remedial education · Sociology · Educational Theory and Curriculum Studies · Global Educational Policies and Reforms · Literacy, Media, and Education · Psychology

  • Practicing Teachers’ Reflections

    Open Access•Beverley Moriarty, Maria Bennet•Social Inclusion•2016

  • Pedagogies for justice in health and physical education

    Alison Wrench, Robyne Garrett•Asia-Pacific Journal of Health…•2016

  • Challenges, benefits and policy implications of multilingualism in educational contexts

    Open Access•Kirstin Anthony, Margaret Funke Omidire et al.•Discover Education•2026

  • A Synthesis of the Research on Community Service Learning in Preservice Science Teacher Education

    Open Access•Samia Khan, Samia A Khan et al.•Frontiers in Education•2020

  • Being with a Puppet

    Open Access•Olivia Karaolis•Education Sciences•2023

  • Laying Foundations for Islamic Teacher Education

    Open Access•Nadeem Memon, M Abdalla et al.•Education Sciences•2024

  • Reading the Word and the World

    Open Access•Gui Ying Annie Yang-Heim•Education Sciences•2025

  • Beautiful Wastelands

    Kelly Cheung, Kerry-Ann O’Sullivan•English in Education•2023

  • Critical encounters

    Open Access•Joss Rankin, Robyne Garrett et al.•The Australian Educational…•2021

  • The profession(al) in professional learning

    Open Access•Wayne Sawyer•The Australian Educational…•2025

  • Are we there yet? Research with and for teachers and children and the possibilities of schooling in a complex world

    Open Access•Annette Woods•The Australian Educational…•2021

  • ‘I’m not from a country, I’m from Australia.’ Costumes, scarves, and fruit on their heads

    Open Access•Helen Adam, Matthew Byrne•The Australian Educational…•2024

  • Funds of courage

    Open Access•N Kucirkova, Teresa Cremin•Cambridge Journal of Education•2024

  • “Because the rules out there are different…”

    Garth D Stahl, Cynthia Helen Brock et al.•Asia Pacific Journal of Education•2024

  • A Synthesis of Funds of Identity Research

    Open Access•L Hogg, Monique Volman•Review of Educational Research•2020

  • Religious Literacy as a Literacy ? Conceptual Elaboration in a 21st Century Learning Framework

    Open Access•Martin Ubani•Religious Education•2025

  • Classroom participation

    Open Access•Barbara Comber, Debra Hayes•Journal of Curriculum Studies•2023

  • The “fullness of life”

    Open Access•Helen Hedges•Learning Culture and Social…•2019

  • Children resisting deficit

    Open Access•Aspa Baroutsis, Annette Woods•Global Studies of Childhood•2018

  • The question of access and design – Elin and Hassan walk the line of the four resources model

    Open Access•Catarina Schmidt•Education Inquiry•2013

  • What counts and matters in early childhood

    Open Access•Helen Hedges•Journal of Early Childhood Research•2020

  • Case writing for collaborative practice in education studies

    Open Access•Amanda Carr, Gwen Gilmore et al.•Qualitative Research Journal•2015

  • Critical conversations

    Open Access•Annette Woods•Qualitative Research Journal•2025

  • Learners, environments and differences – insights from literacy research

    Barbara Comber•Qualitative Research Journal•2025

  • Non-traditional students in tertiary education

    Angela Daddow, Peter Moraitis et al.•International Journal of…•2012

  • Designing online assessment tools for disengaged youth

    Andy Brader, Allan Luke et al.•International Journal of…•2013

  • Hard to teach

    Open Access•Melanie Nind, Sarah Lewthwaite•International Journal of…•2017

  • Inspire to aspire

    Alison Wrench, Cathryn Hammond et al.•International Journal of…•2012

  • Fostering inclusion in school through creative and body-based learning

    Robyne Garrett, Belinda Macgill•International Journal of…•2019

  • If they can say it they can write it’

    Robyne Garrett, Alison Wrench•International Journal of…•2015

  • Developing capabilities for social inclusion

    Linda J Graham, Valerie Harwood•International Journal of…•2011

  • Diversity and inclusion in the early years

    Anne Petriwskyj•International Journal of…•2009

  • Using narrative biography to explore how the formation of ‘funds of knowledge’ mediate coach developer practice

    Open Access•Shaun Williams, Shaun Peter Williams et al.•Sport Education and Society•2025

  • Redesigning pedagogy for boys and dance in physical education

    Open Access•Robyne Garrett, Alison Wrench•European Physical Education Review•2016

  • Wordsworth’s ‘We Are Seven’

    Duncan Driver•Changing English•2019

  • Making a Difference

    Barbara Kamler, Barbara Comber•Changing English•2008

  • Discursively complex identities of New Zealand teachers of writing in times of contestation and change

    Open Access•Stephanie Dix•Teaching and Teacher Education•2011

  • Tools that come from within

    Open Access•MELISSA MOSLEY, Melody Zoch•Teaching and Teacher Education•2011

  • Teacher identity in the context of literacy teaching

    Open Access•LEIGH A HALL, Amy Suzanne Johnson et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2009

  • Mexican Students

    Melissa A Martinez•Journal of Latinos and Education•2024

  • ‘Teaching from the Heart’

    Open Access•Daniel Stern, C Burge et al.•The Australian Journal of…•2020

  • Relational pedagogy and the policy failure of contemporary Australian schooling

    A Hickey, Stewart Riddle et al.•Journal of Educational…•2021

  • The lived experience of autistic teachers

    Cat StEvens•International Journal of…•2024

  • Complicating Understandings of Students' Multiliterate Practices With Practitioner Inquiry

    Open Access•Susan Sandretto, Jane Tilson•Journal of Adolescent & Adult…•2016

  • Critical Literacy and Social Justice

    Open Access•Barbara Comber•Journal of Adolescent & Adult…•2015

  • After the Testing

    Open Access•Allan Luke•Journal of Adolescent & Adult…•2012

  • Teaching within and against the circle of privilege

    Lawrence Angus•Journal of Education Policy•2012

  • They make time for you’

    Garth D Stahl•Research Papers in Education•2022

  • Funds of knowledge—a conceptual critique

    Helen Oughton•Studies in the Education of Adults•2010

  • Attributions for underachievement among students experiencing disadvantage and support for public assistance to them

    Open Access•Jung‐sook Lee, Jihyun Lee et al.•Australian Journal of Social Issues•2023

  • Corporate practices and ethical tensions

    Open Access•Garth D Stahl•British Educational Research…•2020

  • Spatially framed metaphoric concepts, educational attainment and locations of poverty

    Open Access•Aspa Baroutsis•Australian Geographer•2021

  • The Behavior Kids”

    Open Access•Julie E Learned•American Educational Research…•2016

  • The place of pedagogy in an uncertain world

    Open Access•Stewart Riddle, Georgina Barton et al.•Discourse Studies in the Cultural…•2025

  • Mobilising community? Place, identity formation and new teachers' learning

    Open Access•Margaret Somerville, Margaret J Somerville et al.•Discourse Studies in the Cultural…•2012

  • Mapping discourses in teachers' talk about using digital texts in classrooms

    Open Access•Eileen Honan•Discourse Studies in the Cultural…•2010

  • Sharing Place, Learning Together

    Open Access•Sally Caroline Godinho, Sally Godinho et al.•The Australian Journal of…•2015

  • Literacy in the New Media Age

    Gunther Kress, Gunther R Kress•Literacy in the New Media Age•2003

  • The Reading Crisis

    Jeanne Sternlicht Chall, Vicki A Jacobs et al.•Reading Crisis•1990

  • Relationships of Knowledge and Practice

    Marilyn Cochran‐smith, Marilyn Cochran-Smith et al.•Review of Research in Education•1999

  • Ways with Words

    Open Access•Shirley Brice Heath•Ways with Words•1983

  • Langage et pouvoir symbolique

    Pierre Bourdieu, John B Thompson•Langage et pouvoir symbolique•2001

  • Boys and Literacy

    Nola Alloway, Pam Gilbert•Gender and Education•1997

  • Funds of knowledge for teaching

    Luis C Moll, Cathy Amanti et al.•Theory Into Practice•1992

  • Social Class and Reading

    Open Access•Peter Freebody•Discourse Studies in the Cultural…•1992

Unique citing works57
Citations per year3,17
Citation span2008 - 2026 (19)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 56

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae