Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Adoption, Family Ideology, and Social Stigma

Bias in Community Attitudes, Adoption Research, and Practice

Bibliographic Data

ID23324652
AuthorsKatarina Wegar (Oxford University Press (United Kingdom), corresponding author)
Year2000
Volume49
Issue4
Pages363-369
Publication date2000-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueFamily Relations (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0197-6664 • E-ISSN: 1741-3729
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/j.1741-3729.2000.00363.x
OpenAlexW2146138972
LanguageEN
Citations received97
References cited58

This article explores the impact of the dominant North American genetic family ideal on community attitudes toward adoption, on adoption research, and on the beliefs and attitudes of adoption case workers. It examines how the failure to recognize the stigmatized social position of adoptive families has shaped not only current public opinion about adoption, but adoption research and practice as well. In conclusion, the article offers suggestions for erasing negative bias from adoption research and practice.

Business · Ideal (ethics) · Ideology · Political science · Position (finance) · Public opinion · Public relations · Sociology · Stigma (botany) · Child Welfare and Adoption · Intergenerational Family Dynamics and Caregiving · Psychology · Reproductive Health and Technologies · Social Psychology

  • The Framing of Adoption

    Open Access•Cynthia R Morton, Summer Shelton•The Journal of Public Interest…•2019

  • Perceptions of donor-conceived families

    Astrid Indekeu, Claudia Lampic•Families Relationships and…•2019

  • Parentesco, adscripción y crianza. Elaboraciones culturales de la adopción internacional y la circulación de niños

    Open Access•Jorge Grau Rebollo•Revista de Antropología Social•2011

  • Parental perceived discrimination as a postadoption risk factor for internationally adopted children and adolescents

    Raymond M Lee, Minnesota International Adoption Project•Cultural Diversity & Ethnic…•2010

  • White Australian Adoptive Mothers' Understandings of Birth Cultures and Families

    D W Riggs, Clemence Due•Adoption Quarterly•2015

  • Public Perceptions, Beliefs and Experiences of Fostering and Adoption

    Open Access•Tamsen J Rochat, Zitha Mokomane et al.•Children & Society•2016

  • Mental Health Trainees' Explicit and Implicit Attitudes Toward Transracial Adoptive Families Headed by Lesbian, Gay, and Heterosexual Couples

    T X Tan, Brittany Jordan-Arthur et al.•Journal of Homosexuality•2017

  • Attitudes about Childlessness and Infertility Treatments

    Tanya Koropeckyj‐cox, Tanya Koropeckyj-Cox et al.•Journal of Comparative Family…•2015

  • Imaginarios situados

    Open Access•Jorge Grau Rebollo•Disparidades. Revista de…•2017

  • Gay Men

    Open Access•Dana Berkowitz, William Marsiglio•Journal of Marriage and the Family•2007

  • Counseling Adopted Persons in Adulthood

    Open Access•Amanda L Baden, Mary O’Leary Wiley et al.•The Counseling Psychologist•2007

  • Adoption Preferences

    Open Access•Anthony A Volk•Encyclopedia of Evolutionary…•2016

  • Exhausted Parents

    Open Access•Moïra Mikolajczak, Marie-Emilie Raes et al.•Journal of Child and Family Studies•2018

  • Participation in the Adoption Mentoring Partnership

    Open Access•Karin J Garber, Quade Y S French et al.•New Directions for Child and…•2015

  • Narrating Displacement Adoptees’ Challenges Due to Minority Stress

    Open Access•I Grigoropoulos•Journal of Child & Adolescent…•2021

  • American” or “Multiethnic”? Family Ethnic Identity Among Transracial Adoptive Families, Ethnic-Racial Socialization, and Children's Self-Perception

    Open Access•Ellen E Pinderhughes, Xian Zhang et al.•New Directions for Child and…•2015

  • Adoption openness and adoption stigma

    Open Access•I Grigoropoulos•SN Social Sciences•2022

  • Soziale Elternschaft und soziale Zugehörigkeit. Reflexionen der Zürcher Adoptionsstudie

    Open Access•Thomas Gabriel, Samuel Keller•Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissensch…•2020

  • Community Attitudes Toward Adoption in Italy

    Open Access•Cinzia Novara, Laura Ferrari et al.•The Family Journal•2024

  • Connecting to birth culture

    Xian Zhang, Ellen E Pinderhughes et al.•Journal of Family Social Work•2023

  • ‘We do not father another man’s child’

    Open Access•Ndidiamaka Vivian Ugwu, Kanayochukwu Michael Okoye•HTS Teologiese Studies /…•2025

  • Adoptive Parenting Cognitions in the Era of Open Adoption

    Open Access•Albert Y H Lo, Krystal K Cashen et al.•Family Relations•2021

  • Attitudes towards adoption disclosure in Singapore

    Jayashree Mohanty•Asia Pacific Journal of Social…•2012

  • Adoption in the Era of Secrecy

    Open Access•Patricia Robinson•Genealogy•2024

  • Using Symbolic Interactionism to Model Transitions to Adoptive Parenthood

    Open Access•Bethany Willis Hepp, Katie M Hrapczynski et al.•Journal of Family Theory & Review•2019

  • Reinforcing the Motherhood Ideal

    Open Access•Karen March, Charlene E Miall•Canadian Review of Sociology/Revue…•2006

  • Stepfather Involvement and Adolescents’ Disposition Toward Having Sex

    Open Access•Chadwick L Menning, Mellisa Holtzman et al.•Perspectives on Sexual and…•2007

  • Adoptive Parents Navigating Adoption Microaggressions through Discourse Dependency and Preparation for Bias Lenses

    Seungmi Lee, Jianguo Liu et al.•Journal of Family Communication•2022

  • Dear Birth Mother”

    Kristen Norwood, Leslie A Baxter•Journal of Family Communication•2011

  • Defining Family

    Mellisa Holtzman•Journal of Family Communication•2008

  • Narrative Coherence in Online Stories Told by Members of the Adoption Triad

    Leslie A Baxter, Kristen Norwood et al.•Journal of Family Communication•2012

  • Lay Conceptions of “Family”

    Leslie A Baxter, Caro Henauw et al.•Journal of Family Communication•2009

  • Couples undergoing infertility treatment in the Czech Republic

    Open Access•Lenka Slepičková•Social Theory & Health•2010

  • So Many Challenges, So Many Regrets

    Open Access•Benan KURT YILMAZ, Ela Burcu Uçel et al.•Gender Issues•2024

  • Adoptee Experiences of Adoption Stigma

    Open Access•Nicole Davi, Sarah A Font et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2025

  • The Impact of Openness on Adoption Agency Practices

    Susan M Henney, Ruth G Mcroy et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2003

  • Modeling Adoption Attitudes

    J L Gibbons, Carrie M Brown•Adoption Quarterly•2012

  • A Comparison of Biological and Adoptive Mothers and Fathers

    Charlene E Miall, Karen March•Adoption Quarterly•2003

  • Sex Differences in Adoption Attitudes

    J L Gibbons, Christine Rufener et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2006

  • Adopting Commodities

    Jennifer Potter, Jennifer E Potter•Adoption Quarterly•2013

  • I Guess They’re All Real Moms Then”

    Melissa Rizzo Weller•Adoption Quarterly•2019

  • Black and White Thinking? Understanding Negative Responses to Transracial Adoptive Families

    Jennifer Katz, Emily K Doyle•Adoption Quarterly•2013

  • Adoption as a Diversity Issue in Professional Preparation

    Juliana M Taymans, Juliana M Taymans∗ et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2008

  • The Disability of Adoption

    Kim Nelson, Kim Nelson-Miles et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2018

  • Ethical Considerations in Adoption Research

    Albert Y H Lo, Harold D Grotevant et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2019

  • Families by Adoption and Birth

    Joan T D Suwalsky, Charlene Hendricks et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2008

  • The Role of Heritage Camps in Identity Development Among Korean Transnational Adoptees

    Tracey H Randolph, Mellisa Holtzman•Adoption Quarterly•2010

  • Do You Know Your Real Parents?” and Other Adoption Microaggressions

    Amanda L Baden•Adoption Quarterly•2015

  • Adoption as a Contingency of Self-worth

    Quade Y S French•Adoption Quarterly•2013

  • Microaggressions experienced by adoptive families and internationally adopted adolescents in France

    Laurie C Miller, Marie-Odile Pérouse de Montclos et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2020

  • Parents and Their Adopted Chinese Children

    Amanda L Baden, Xian Zhang et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2022

  • Recent Developments in Adoption Law

    James L Marsh, James Marsh et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2003

  • Deciding Not to Adopt

    Kathleen Slauson-Blevins, Kathleen S Slauson‐Blevins et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2015

  • Adoption of Black children by White parents in heterosexual and homosexual relationships

    T X Tan, Vernon L Smith et al.•Journal of Gay & Lesbian Social…•2017

  • No‐man's Land

    Open Access•Denise Blake, Leigh Coombes•Journal of Community & Applied…•2015

  • Definitions of the Family as an Impetus for Legal Change in Custody Decision Making

    Open Access•Mellisa Holtzman•Law & Social Inquiry•2006

  • What Do You Say to Your Mother When Your Mother's Standing Beside You?” Birth and Adoptive Family Contributions to Adoptive Identity via Relational Identity and Relational–Relational Identity Gaps

    Colleen Colaner, Colleen Warner Colaner et al.•Communication Monographs•2014

  • Adoptive parents’ experiences of social support and attitudes towards adoption

    Open Access•Sabina R Weistra, Sabina Weistra et al.•Adoption & Fostering•2017

  • The Human Being in Social and Cosmic Orders. Categories of Traditional Culture and the Problems of Contemporary Buryat Identity

    Ayur Zhanaev•The Human Being in Social and…•2020

  • Race Made Salient

    Lynn Gidluck, Sonya Corbin Dwyer•Journal of Social Distress and…•2008

  • Search and Reunification

    Open Access•Julie Samuels•Adoption in the Digital Age•2018

  • The Medical Nonnecessity of In Vitro Fertilization

    Carolyn McLeod•International Journal of Feminist…•2017

  • Uncovering the Challenges and Needs of Chinese Adoptive Parents in Hong Kong

    Open Access•Anita Kit Wa Chan, Tevin Shuhan Fang et al.•Child & Family Social Work•2024

  • Deprived of Adoptive Parenthood

    Pia Eriksson•Adoption Quarterly•2024

  • Crafting Identity out of Uncertainty

    Limor Lotan, Charles W Greenbaum et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2023

  • Mental Health Outcomes of Abortion and Its Alternatives

    Open Access•Sara L Kornfield, Pamela A Geller•Women s Health Issues•2010

  • Perception and Internalization of Adoption Stigma among Gay, Lesbian, and Heterosexual Adoptive Parents

    A E Goldberg, Lori A Kinkler et al.•Journal of GLBT Family Studies•2011

  • Transracial Korean Adoptee, Korean American, and South Korean Adolescent Conceptions of Family and Coming of Age in the Family Context

    Diane Sookyoung Lee, Sheri Hembree et al.•Adoption Quarterly•2026

  • Similar psychosis risks in adoptees and immigrants

    Open Access•Mary V Seeman•International Journal of Social…•2020

  • Reporting Microaggressions

    Open Access•J Wilkes, Susan Speer et al.•Journal of Language and Social…•2020

  • Narrativas de mujeres que adoptan monoparentalmente en Chile

    Open Access•Irene Salvo Agoglia•Revista de Estudios Sociales•2018

  • How Men and Women Experience Infertility

    Open Access•Lenka Slepičková•Czech Sociological Review•2009

  • The Social Context of Attitudes towards Various Infertility Strategies

    Open Access•Lenka Slepičková, Petr Fučík•Czech Sociological Review•2009

  • The transition to adoptive parenthood

    Open Access•Katherine McKay, L E Ro et al.•Children and Youth Services Review•2010

  • Parenting adoptive children

    Open Access•Esperanza León, M Steele et al.•Children and Youth Services Review•2018

  • Factors affecting post-permanency adjustment for children in adoption or guardianship placements

    Open Access•Minli Liao•Children and Youth Services Review•2016

  • Children for sale? The blurred boundary between intercountry adoption and sale of children in the United States

    Open Access•Robin Shura, Elle Rochford et al.•International Journal of…•2016

  • Just Beyond my Front Door”

    Open Access•Maryna Vashchenko, M D'Aleo et al.•American Journal of Community…•2012

  • How Do Social Workers Define the Concept of Family

    Belle Gavriel-Fried, Guy Shilo et al.•The British Journal of Social Work•2014

  • Welcome to parenthood!? An examination of the far-reaching effects of perceived adoption stigma in the workplace

    Open Access•Kaylee Hackney, Matthew J Quade et al.•Human Relations•2024

  • Breaking the Silence

    Open Access•Kathy P Zamostny, Mary O’Leary Wiley et al.•The Counseling Psychologist•2003

  • YOU Were Adopted?!”

    Open Access•Karin J Garber, Harold D Grotevant•The Counseling Psychologist•2015

  • Understanding Adoptive Families

    Open Access•Karen M O’brien, Karen M O'Brien et al.•The Counseling Psychologist•2003

  • The Practice of Adoption

    Open Access•Kathy P Zamostny, Karen M O’brien et al.•The Counseling Psychologist•2003

  • Lesbian and heterosexual preadoptive couples' openness to transracial adoption

    A E Goldberg•American Journal of Orthopsychiatry•2009

  • Are Same-Sex and Single Adoptive Parents More Likely to Adopt Transracially? A National Analysis of Race, Family Structure, and the Adoption Marketplace

    Open Access•Elizabeth Raleigh•Sociological Perspectives•2012

  • I Don't Look Like Her

    Open Access•C D L Waring, Samit Dipon Bordoloi•Sociological Perspectives•2019

  • Is Adoption an Option? The Role of Importance of Motherhood and Fertility Help-Seeking in Considering Adoption

    Open Access•Nicholas K Park, Patricia Wonch Hill•Journal of Family Issues•2014

  • Childlessness, Parenthood, and Depressive Symptoms Among Middle-Aged and Older Adults

    Open Access•Regina M Bures, Tanya Koropeckyj‐cox et al.•Journal of Family Issues•2009

  • Open Adoption as a Family Form

    Open Access•Charlene E Miall, Karen March•Journal of Family Issues•2005

  • L'adoption et les liens familiaux expliqués par des enfants québécois

    Geneviève Pagé, Isabel Côté et al.•Anthropologie et Sociétés•2022

  • Adoption and Feminism

    Denise Cuthbert, Kate Murphy et al.•Australian Feminist Studies•2009

  • Adoptive Parents, Adaptive Parents

    Open Access•L T Hamilton, Laura Hamilton et al.•American Sociological Review•2007

  • Re)visitando a la madre (des)naturalizada

    Open Access•Irene Salvo Agoglia, Beatriz San Román•Revista de Estudios Sociales•2019

  • "Constructing Gay and Lesbian Parent Families "Beyond the Closet

    Open Access•Maura Ryan, Dana Berkowitz•Qualitative Sociology•2009

  • The Attribution of Parental Competence to Lesbian, Gay, and Heterosexual Couples

    Dirk Kranz•Journal of Homosexuality•2022

  • People's Heads Do Not Even Go There

    Devon R Go, Devon R Goss•Sociological Quarterly•2018

  • The Black family

    Robert Staples•The Black family•1978

  • Shared fate

    H David Kirk•Shared fate•1964

  • Fallen women, problem girls

    Regina G Kunzel•Fallen women, problem girls•1993

  • Kinship with strangers

    Judith Schachter Modell•Kinship with strangers•1994

  • Brave New Families

    Judith Stacey•Brave New Families•1991

  • Children's Adjustment to Adoption

    David M Brodzinsky, David Brodzinsky et al.•Children's Adjustment to Adoption•1998

  • The DNA Mystique

    Dorothy Nelkin, M Susan Lindee et al.•The DNA Mystique•2004

  • The Stigma of Adoptive Parent Status

    Charlene E Miall•Family Relations•1987

  • A Stress and Coping Model of Adoption Adjustment

    David M Brodzinsky•The Psychology of adoption•1990

  • Social Relationships and Health

    Open Access•James S House, Karl R Landis et al.•Science•1988

  • All our kin

    Carol B Stack•All our kin•1975

  • The psychology of interpersonal relations.

    Fritz Heider•1958

  • The relationship of research to clinical practice

    George Stricker•American Psychologist•1992

  • Mothering

    Evelyn Nakano Glenn, Grace Change et al.•Canadian Journal of Communication•1995

  • Community constructs of involuntary childlessness

    Open Access•Charlene E Miall•Canadian Review of Sociology/Revue…•1994

  • Long-Term Outcomes in Adoption

    David M Brodzinsky•The Future of Children•1993

  • In search of bad mothers

    Open Access•Katarina Wegar•Women s Studies International Forum•1997

  • Gay and Lesbian Adoptions

    Thom Reilly•The Journal of Sociology & Social…•1996

  • Adoptive parents' hostility toward their adopted children

    Open Access•Stanley Schneider, Esti Rimmer•Children and Youth Services Review•1984

  • The Sociological Imagination

    C W Mills•The Mississippi Valley Historical…•1959

  • Adoption, Identity and Kinship

    Karen March, Katarina Wegar•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1998

  • A Conjugal Study of Kin Relations Outside the Nuclear Family

    Norval D Glenn, Alice S Rossi et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1991

  • Experiences of Black Families as Adoptive Parents

    Gwendolyn S Prater, Gwendolyn Prater et al.•Social Work•1988

  • Adoption and mental health

    Katarina Wegar•American Journal of Orthopsychiatry•1995

  • Birthparent romances and identity formation in adopted children

    Elinor B Rosenberg, Thomas M Horner•American Journal of Orthopsychiatry•1991

  • Meaning Construction and Social Work Practice

    Dorothy Scott•Social Service Review•1989

  • History and the Family

    Glen H Elder•Journal of Marriage and the Family•1981

  • Does adopted mean different? An attributional analysis

    Kathlyn S Marquis, Richard A Detweiler•Journal of Personality and Social…•1985

  • Shared Fate

    Alfred C Clarke, H David Kirk et al.•American Sociological Review•1965

  • Mother-infant bonding

    Open Access•Diane E Eyer•Human Nature•1994

  • Multidimensional Developmental Pathways

    Open Access•Jon Bernardes•The Sociological Review•1986

  • Effects of psychotherapy with children and adolescents revisited

    John R Weisz, Bahr Wei et al.•Psychological Bulletin•1995

  • Family Ideology

    Open Access•Jon Bernardes•The Sociological Review•1985

  • Feminism and the American Family Ideal

    Margaret L Andersen•Journal of Comparative Family…•1991

  • Single Mothers and Child Neglect, 1880-1920

    Open Access•Leonard Gordon, Linda Gordon•American Quarterly•1985

  • American Kinship

    David M Schneider•American kinship•1980

  • Perception of Adoption as Social Stigma

    Karen March•Journal of Marriage and the Family•1995

  • Anthropology and Adoption

    Open Access•John Edward Terrell, John Terrell et al.•American Anthropologist•1994

  • It Takes an Entire Village

    Open Access•Marilyn Lovett-Tisdale, Bruce Anthony Purnell et al.•Journal of Black Psychology•1996

  • Adoption as deviance

    Dana Katherine Kressierer, Clifton D Bryant•Deviant Behavior•1996

Unique citing works97
Citations per year4,22
Citation span2003 - 2026 (24)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 86

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae