Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Comment Clause in English

Syntactic Origins and Pragmatic Development

Bibliographic Data

ID23389491
AuthorsLaurel J Brinton (0000-0001-9319-7786, University of British Columbia, corresponding author)
Year2008
Publication date2008-11-20
Open AccessYes
TypeBOOK
VenueComment Clause in English (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherCambridge University Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1017/cbo9780511551789
OpenAlexW109628746
ISBN9780511551789
Open LibraryOL34442000M
LanguageEN
Citations received104
References cited7

Although English comment clauses such as I think and you know have been widely studied, this book constitutes the first full-length diachronic treatment, focusing on comment clauses formed with common verbs of perception and cognition in a variety of syntactic forms. It understands comment clauses as causal pragmatic markers that undergo grammaticalisation, and acquire pragmatic and politeness functions and subjective and intersubjective meanings. To date, the prevailing view of their syntactic development, which is extrapolated from synchronic studies, is that they originate in matrix clauses which become syntactically indeterminate and are reanalysed as parenthetical. In this corpus-based study, Laurel J. Brinton shows that the historical data do not bear out this view, and proposes a more varied and complex conception of the development of comment clauses. Researchers and students of the English language and historical linguistics will certainly consider Brinton's findings to be of great interest.

Linguistics · Computer Science · Language, Discourse, Communication Strategies · Natural Language Processing Techniques · Philosophy · Syntax, Semantics, Linguistic Variation · Clauses · English language · English language, syntax · Historical linguistics

  • Diachronic change and synchronic variation of the Chinese discourse marker shishishang

    Xiao He•East Asian Pragmatics•2021

  • Parentéticos, "hedging" y sintaxis del enunciado

    Open Access•Catalina Fuentes Rodríguez•Círculo de lingüística aplicada a…•2013

  • Macrosintaxis de las "comment clauses"

    Open Access•Catalina Fuentes Rodríguez•Círculo de lingüística aplicada a…•2015

  • On an emerging paradigm of sentence-final particles of discontent

    Open Access•Hyun Jung Koo, Seongha Rhee•Language Sciences•2013

  • On establishing I think as a final particle in interactions

    Open Access•Shie Sato•Journal of Pragmatics•2017

  • Dialogicity in dialogue

    Open Access•Jiajun Chen•Journal of Pragmatics•2017

  • Comment clauses and the emergence of new discourse markers

    Catalina Fuentes Rodríguez•Journal of Pragmatics•2014

  • World Lexicon of Grammaticalization

    Open Access•Tania Kuteva, Bernd Heine et al.•World Lexicon of Grammaticalization•2019

  • The emergence of a discourse construction in the internet

    Xinjia Peng•Chinese Language and Discourse An…•2018

  • A crosslinguistic study of some extended uses of what -based interrogative expressions in Chinese, English, and Korean

    Heeju Lee, Danjie Su et al.•Chinese Language and Discourse An…•2017

  • The Imperative of Say as a Pragmatic Marker in English and Dutch

    Open Access•Daniel Van Olmen•Journal of Germanic Linguistics•2013

  • General Extenders and Grammaticalization

    Stephen Levey•Applied Linguistics•2012

  • Pragmatic Language Development

    Open Access•Ahmed Alduais, Issa Al-Qaderi et al.•Children•2022

  • Epistemic Stance in the Kavanaugh Confirmation Hearing

    Open Access•Magdalena Szczyrbak•Discourse and Interaction•2019

  • Speaker-orientation meaning and positional shifts of discourse structuring markers

    Open Access•Haiping Long, Lei Wang•Russian Journal of Linguistics•2024

  • Formation of Modern Chinese speech-quotative nǐ shuō ‘you say’ and feedback-seeking nǐ shuō ‘you tell me’

    Open Access•Haiping Long, Xianhui Wang et al.•Language and Linguistics 語言暨語言學•2022

  • Lone pronoun tags in Early Modern English

    Open Access•Louise Mycock, JAMES MISSON•English Language and Linguistics•2021

  • Gonna et le métadiscours en anglais oral spontané

    Open Access•Leela AZORIN•Cahiers d’études germaniques•2025

  • The emergence of last I checked fragments

    Open Access•Ozan Mustafa, Gunther Kaltenböck•Folia Linguistica•2025

  • Tania Kuteva, Bernd Heine, Bo Hong, Haiping Long, Heiko Narrog and Seongha Rhee

    Open Access•Yue Zhang, Lei Wang•Folia Linguistica•2021

  • Left and right peripheries in discourse

    Open Access•Matthias Klumm, Augustin Speyer•Folia Linguistica•2025

  • Left-peripheral bottom line sequences

    Mathilde Pinson•Folia Linguistica•2025

  • Les verbes recteurs faibles dans l’expression de l’opinion en français et en espagnol

    Juliette Delahaie, Laurence Rouanne et al.•Travaux de linguistique•2023

  • Conditional clauses as polite modifiers in Latin

    Open Access•Chiara Fedriani•Transactions of the Philological…•2021

  • According to NP

    Open Access•Debra Ziegeler•Journal of English Linguistics•2023

  • Decompositionalization and Partial Recompositionalization

    Open Access•Mathilde Pinson•Journal of English Linguistics•2023

  • Could Be it’s Grammaticalization

    Open Access•David Lorenz•Journal of English Linguistics•2023

  • Hedged Performatives in Spoken American English

    Open Access•Ilse Depraetere, Gunther Kaltenböck•Journal of English Linguistics•2023

  • Interview with Laurel J. Brinton

    Open Access•Merja Kytö•Journal of English Linguistics•2024

  • N-is Focalizers as Semi-fixed Constructions

    Open Access•Marianne Hundt•Journal of English Linguistics•2022

  • Proposition d’une classification des marqueurs discursifs comme membres d’un paradigme

    Kirsten Jeppesen Kragh•Langue française•2021

  • Evidentiality in Early Modern English Medical Treatises (1500–1700)

    Richard J Whitt•Journal of Historical Sociolinguist…•2016

  • Investigating “periphery” from a functionalist perspective

    Elizabeth Closs Traugott•Linguistics Vanguard•2015

  • Discourse-level phenomena in construction grammars

    Open Access•Renata Enghels, María Sol Sansiñena•Constructions and Frames•2021

  • Construcciones con verbos de comunicación. Valores pragmáticos y discursivos

    Open Access•María del Pilar Garcés Gómez, María Pilar Garcés Gómez•Círculo de lingüística aplicada a…•2020

  • Discursive functions and constructionalization of independent "subordinate" sentences in Spanish

    Open Access•Catalina Fuentes Rodríguez•Círculo de lingüística aplicada a…•2021

  • Quotation and Advances in Understanding Syntactic Systems

    Alex D’arcy•Annual Review of Linguistics•2015

  • The functions of grammaticalized complement-taking-predicate clauses in interrogatives

    Jiqiang Lu, Kristin Davidse•Text and Talk•2025

  • Getting attention in different languages

    Open Access•Daniel Van Olmen, Vittorio Tantucci•Intercultural Pragmatics•2022

  • “Are you saying …?”

    Open Access•Foluke O Unuabonah•Pragmatics Quarterly Publication…•2017

  • Variation in the expression of stance across varieties of English

    Open Access•Gabriella Mazzon•World Englishes•2019

  • From separate clause to epistemic adverbial, the neglected source construction and initial-to-medial pathway

    Open Access•Haiping Long, Francesco-Alessio Ursini et al.•Australian Journal of Linguistics•2022

  • Prosody and formation of Modern Chinese parenthetical CTMP ni xiang ‘ you think’

    Haiping Long, Bernd Heine et al.•Australian Journal of Linguistics•2020

  • Sisterhood construction through commenting by Chinese women

    Open Access•Bin Wang•Pragmatics & Cognition•2024

  • Is commenting an expositive illocutionary act

    Open Access•Marina Sbisà•Pragmatics & Cognition•2024

  • Cause and comment

    Open Access•Martin Konvička•Pragmatics & Cognition•2024

  • The functions of “I think” in TED Talks and their Turkish translations

    Open Access•Aytaç Çeltek•Pragmatics & Cognition•2024

  • Practices of indexing discrepant assumptions with German ich dachte (‘I thought’) in talk-in-interaction

    Open Access•Arnulf Deppermann, Silke Reineke•Functions of Language•2020

  • Do ‘say’ verbs really grammaticalize into complementizers through clause combination

    Open Access•Haiping Long, Chuanlin Deng•Functions of Language•2023

  • I think , I mean and I believe in political discourse

    Anita Fetzer•Functions of Language•2014

  • Variation between modal adverbs in British English

    Daisuke Suzuki•Functions of Language•2018

  • On the formation of a conjecturing clause-taking predicate in Modern Chinese

    Open Access•Haiping Long, Fang Wu et al.•Functions of Language•2021

  • Potential grammaticalization of epistemic phrases

    Open Access•David Lorenz•Functions of Language•2024

  • Two opposite implicatures of a focus particle

    Open Access•Minju Kim•Studies in Language•2025

  • Creating versatility in Thai demonstratives

    Open Access•Shoichi Iwasaki, Parada Dechapratumwan•Studies in Language•2022

  • ‘Mehn ! This wins the award’

    Open Access•Foluke O Unuabonah•English Today•2022

  • Weaving together the diverse threads of category change

    Open Access•Ezra la Roi•Diachronica•2022

  • The development of confirmation/agreement markers away from the RP in Japanese

    Yuko Higashiizumi•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2016

  • I hope you will write”

    Emma Moreton•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2015

  • The evolution of the Ancient Greek deverbal pragmatic markers áge, íthi and phére

    Samuel Zakowski•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2018

  • Evidentiality and propositional scope in Early Modern German

    Richard J Whitt•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2018

  • Periphery

    Noriko O Onodera, Elizabeth Closs Traugott•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2016

  • Factive” parenthetical clauses

    Caroline Gentens•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2015

  • LP and RP in the development of discourse markers from “what” in Korean

    Seongha Rhee•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2016

  • The rise of what -general extenders in English

    Open Access•Laurel J Brinton•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2023

  • From clause to pragmatic marker

    María José López-Couso, Belén Méndez-Naya•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2014

  • The development of the modal and discourse marker uses of ( there / it is / I have ) no doubt

    Kristin Davidse, Simon De Wolf et al.•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2015

  • Anyway in Irish English

    Open Access•Raymond Hickey•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2024

  • Parenthetical “I say (you)” in Late Medieval Greek vernacular

    Jorie Soltic•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2015

  • Para colmo , scalar operator and additive connector

    Catalina Fuentes Rodríguez•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2016

  • From affirmation to concession

    Open Access•Haiping Long, Weihua Zhou•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2024

  • On the rise of types of clause-final pragmatic markers in English

    Elizabeth Closs Traugott•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2016

  • Descriptive and diachronic aspects of the Old Irish quotative marker ol

    Carlos García Castillero•Journal of Historical Pragmatics•2017

  • You betcha I’m a ’Merican”

    Open Access•Tomoharu Hirota, Laurel J Brinton•International Journal of Corpus…•2023

  • Multi-word discourse markers and their corpus-driven identification

    Kaja Dobrovoljc•International Journal of Corpus…•2017

  • Oya let’s go to Nigeria”

    Open Access•Foluke O Unuabonah•International Journal of Corpus…•2021

  • A quantitative approach to the grammaticalization of discourse markers

    Christian Koops, Arne Lohmann•International Journal of Corpus…•2015

  • Verb Patterns in Trial Discourse

    Open Access•Magdalena Szczyrbak•Discourse and Interaction•2020

  • But, you see, the problem is … Perception verbs in courtroom talk

    Open Access•Magdalena Szczyrbak•Topics in Linguistics•2019

  • Elément de macro-syntaxe

    Gunther Kaltenböck•Modèles linguistiques•2016

  • À l’interface des plans micro- et macro-discursifs

    Blandine Pennec•Modèles linguistiques•2016

  • Micro- et macro-syntaxe

    Alexander Haselow, La rédaction de Modèles linguistiques•Modèles linguistiques•2016

  • Commentary pragmatic markers in Ghanaian and Ugandan Englishes

    Open Access•Foluke O Unuabonah•English Today•2026

  • Revisiting presentative particles

    Open Access•Leon Shor, Anna Inbar et al.•Linguistics•2026

  • Bilingual pragmatic markers in Nigerian English

    Open Access•Foluke O Unuabonah, Rotimi O Oladipupo•World Englishes•2020

  • Parentheticals in spoken Indian and Sri Lankan English

    Open Access•Julia Degenhardt•World Englishes•2025

  • Comment markers in world Englishes

    Open Access•P Collins•World Englishes•2022

  • Diachronic Research on Chinese Discourse Markers in China

    Open Access•Guoping Yang, Mian Jia•SAGE Open•2025

  • Modality from a Historical Perspective

    Open Access•Elizabeth Closs Traugott•Language and Linguistics Compass•2011

  • Pragmatic markers in English and Italian film dialogue

    Open Access•Liviana Galiano•Pragmatics Quarterly Publication…•2024

  • The role of pragmatic function in the grammaticalization of English general extenders

    Open Access•Maryann Overstreet•Pragmatics Quarterly Publication…•2015

  • Voilà , membre du paradigme des marqueurs discursifs

    Kirsten Jeppesen Kragh•Langages•2022

  • Les clauses parenthétiques dans les textes de la Nouvelle-France du 17e et du 18e siècle

    Stefan Schneider•Linx•2009

  • Les parenthétiques comme « Unités Illocutoires Associées »

    Sylvain Kahane, Paola Pietrandrea•Linx•2009

  • Flou phraséologique, quasi-grammaticalisation et pseudo marqueurs de discours

    Catherine Bolly•Linx•2010

  • Peripheries and their internal structure

    Open Access•Matthias Klumm•Linguistics•2025

  • Metalinguistic conditionals and the role of explicit content

    Open Access•Chi-Hé Elder•Linguistics•2019

  • Commentary pragmatic markers in Nigerian English

    Foluke O Unuabonah, Ulrike Gut•English World-Wide A Journal of…•2018

  • Seeing is believing

    Open Access•L Keevallik, Marri Amon•Interactional Linguistics•2024

  • Discourse markers in the making

    Open Access•Gunther Kaltenböck, Elnora Ten Wolde•Functions of Language•2025

  • Pragmatic Markers in English

    Laurel J Brinton•Pragmatic Markers in English•1996

  • On some principles of grammaticization

    Paul J Hopper•Approaches to grammaticalization.•1991

  • I think — an English modal particle

    Karin Aijmer•Modality in Germanic Languages•1997

  • A Comprehensive grammar of the English language

    Geoffrey N Leech, Jan Svartvik et al.•A Comprehensive grammar of the…•1985

  • The development of I mean

    Laurel J Brinton•Methods in Historical Pragmatics•2007

  • Dynamischer Strukturalismus. Rezension von

    Open Access•Martin Haase, Martin Haase Martin Haase•Zeitschrift für Sprachwissenschaft•1995

  • Imperatives, interruption in conversation, and the rise of discourse markers

    Open Access•Richard Waltereit•Linguistics•2002

Citations per year6.12
Citation span2009 - 2026 (18)
Highly citedYes

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae