Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

‘Romantic Poet-Sage of History’

Herodotus and His Arion in the Long Nineteenth Century

Bibliographic Data

ID23444591
AuthorsEdith Hall (0000-0002-8438-6814, corresponding author)
Year2020
Pages46-70
Publication date2020-03-26
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeCHAPTER
VenueHerodotus in the Long Nineteenth Century (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherCambridge University Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1017/9781108562805.003
OpenAlexW3011648317
ISBN9781108562805
LanguageEN
References cited312

This chapter uses the figure of Arion, the lyric poet from Methymna whose story is told early in Herodotus’s Histories , to explore the adoption of Herodotus, in the long nineteenth century, as the ‘Romantic poet-sage of History’. This is the title bestowed upon him by the Anglican priest and hymn-writer John Ernest Bode, who in 1853 (following in the fashion set by Walter Scott’s Minstrelsy of the Scottish Border and Macaulay’s Lays of Ancient Rome ) adapted tales from Herodotus into old English and Scottish ballad forms. Herodotus was seen as the prose avatar of poets – of medieval balladeers, lyric singers, epic bards and even authors of verse drama. These configurations of Herodotus are cast into sharp relief by comparing them with his previous incarnation, in the Early Modern and earlier eighteenth century, as a writer who most strongly resembled a novelist. Isaac Littlebury, Herodotus’s 1709 translator, was attracted to the historian for the simple reason that in 1700 he had enjoyed success with a previous translation. But the earlier work was certainly not a translation of an ancient historian. Littlebury had translated Fénelon’s Télémaque , a work of fantasy fiction derived ultimately from the Posthomerica , perhaps better described as a novel combining a rites-of-passage theme with an exciting travelogue.

Art · Drama · EPIC · Fantasy · Hymn · Knight · Literature · Poetry · Romance · Style (visual arts) · Theme (computing) · Classical Studies and Philology · Classics · History · Medieval Literature and History · Philippine History and Culture

  • Churchill and the Islamic World

    Warren Dockter•Churchill and the Islamic World•2015

  • The Birth of Orientalism

    Urs App•The Birth of Orientalism•2010

  • Zeus

    Arthur Bernard Cook•Zeus•1940

  • The classical foundations of modern historiography

    Arnaldo Momigliano•The classical foundations of…•1990

  • The eighteenth century confronts the gods

    Frank Edward Manuel•The eighteenth century confronts…•1967

  • Thucydides and the Science of History

    Charles Norris Cochrane•Thucydides and the Science of…•1929

  • The Poetic Imagination of Vyacheslav Ivanov

    Open Access•Pamela Davidson, Pamela L Davidson•Poetic Imagination of Vyacheslav…•1989

  • The Last Journals of David Livingstone in Central Africa, from 1865 to his Death

    Open Access•David Livingstone, Horace Waller•Last Journals of David…•2011

  • Classics in Post-Colonial Worlds

    Lorna Hardwick, Carol Gillespie•Classics in Post-Colonial Worlds…•2007

  • African AthenaNew Agendas

    Daniel Orrells, G K Bhambra et al.•African Athena•2011

  • The Zodiac of Paris

    Jed Z Buchwald, Diane Greco Josefowicz•Zodiac of Paris•2010

  • Education, Economic Change and Society in England 1780–1870

    Open Access•Michael Sanderson, Michael J Sanderson•Education, Economic Change and…•1991

  • The Classics and Colonial India

    Phiroze Vasunia•Classics and Colonial India•2013

  • Neoclassical History and English Culture

    Open Access•Philip Hicks•Neoclassical History and English…•1996

  • From Marathon to Waterloo

    Timothy Rood•Cultural responses to the Persian…•2007

  • Enacting History and Patriotic Myth

    GondaVan Steen•Cultural responses to the Persian…•2007

  • Kissing Cousins

    Alan Griffiths•The historian's craft in the age…•2001

  • The Mirage of Greek Continuity

    Suzanne Saïd•Rethinking the Mediterranean•2005

  • Eastern European Nations, Western Culture, and the Classical Tradition

    Asen Kirin•Classics and National Cultures•2010

  • The Persian Wars as the ‘Origin’ of Historiography

    Alexandra Lianeri•Cultural responses to the Persian…•2007

  • Herodotos and Athens

    Robert Fowler•Herodotus and his world•2003

  • Frozen tombs of Siberia

    Sergei Ivanovich Rudenko•Frozen tombs of Siberia•1970

  • Scythians and Greeks

    Ellis Hovell Minns•Scythians and Greeks•2012

  • ‘What's in a name?’ and exploring the comparable

    Open Access•Elizabeth Irwin•Reading Herodotus•2007

  • Aristagoras (5.49–55, 97)

    Open Access•Christopher Pelling•Reading Herodotus•2007

  • The trouble with the Ionians

    Open Access•Rosaria Vignolo Munson•Reading Herodotus•2007

  • The education offered by Athens

    Open Access•Elizabeth Potter•Thucydides and the Modern World•2012

  • The Early Feminists

    Open Access•Kathryn Gleadle•Early Feminists•1995

  • Polybius and his World

    Frank W Walbank, Bruce Gibson et al.•Polybius And His World Essays In…•2013

  • An enquiry into the life and writings of Homer (1735)

    Open Access•Thomas Blackwell•Sublime•1996

  • Herodotus and Persia

    Open Access•Michael Flower•2006

  • Herodotus and foreign lands

    Open Access•Tim Rood•The Cambridge Companion to…•2006

  • The Helen Logos and Herodotus’ Fingerprint

    Irene de Jong•Myth, Truth, and Narrative in…•2012

  • A Noble Alliance

    Emily Baragwanath•Thucydides and Herodotus•2012

  • Bursting the Limits of Time

    Martin J S Rudwick•Bursting the Limits of Time•2005

  • Down from Olympus

    Suzanne Marchand, Suzanne L Marchand•Down from Olympus•1996

  • Legacies of British Slave-Ownership

    Open Access•Catherine Hall, Keith Mcclelland et al.•Legacies of British Slave-Ownership•2014

  • Conflicted Antiquities

    Elliott Colla•Conflicted Antiquities•2007

  • Russia's Own Orient

    Vera Tolz•Russia's own Orient•2011

  • Peoples on Parade

    Salman Qureshi, Sadiah Qureshi•Peoples on Parade•2011

  • The German Historicist Tradition

    Frederick C Beiser•The German historicist tradition•2011

  • Nations and Nationalism since 1780

    Open Access•E J Hobsbawm, Eric Hobsbawm•Nations and Nationalism Since 1780•1992

  • Coins, Bodies, Games, and Gold

    Open Access•Leslie Kurke•Coins, Bodies, Games, and Gold•1999

  • The Oxford Handbook of the History of Nationalism

    John Breuilly•The Oxford Handbook Of The…•2013

  • The Oxford Handbook of Victorian Poetry

    Matthew Bevis•Oxford Handbook Of Victorian Poetry•2013

  • Anthropology and the Greeks

    S C Humphreys•Anthropology and the Greeks•2013

  • Essays on the Greek historians and Greek history

    H D Westlake•Essays on the Greek historians…•1969

  • Velleius Paterculus

    Paterculus Paterculus, Velleius Paterculus et al.•Velleius Paterculus•2004

  • The unwanted

    Aristide R Zolberg, Michael Robert Marrus•The unwanted•1985

  • Victorian Anthropology

    George Stocking•Victorian Anthropology•1991

  • The Edges of the Earth in Ancient Thought

    James Romm, James S Romm•Edges of the Earth in Ancient…•1992

  • The Corrupting Sea

    Sarah Bond, Sarah E Bond•Anti-Corruption in History•2017

  • The Empire Strikes Back?

    A S Thompson•Empire Strikes Back?•2014

  • What Was History?

    Open Access•Anthony Grafton•What Was History?•2012

  • Lawrence of Arabia’s War

    Sneha Reddy•The RUSI Journal•2017

  • Black MinervaAntiquity in Antebellum African American History

    Margaret Malamud•African Athena•2011

  • Classics in Russia 1700-1855

    Marinus A Wes•Classics in Russia 1700-1855•1992

  • The Idea of Europe

    Open Access•Anthony Pagden•Idea of Europe•2002

  • A Handbook to Classical Reception in Eastern and Central Europe

    Open Access•Zara Martirosova Torlone, Dana LaCourse Munteanu et al.•Handbook to Classical Reception…•2017

  • Sacred Words and Worlds

    Zur Shalev•Sacred Words and Worlds•2012

  • Marginal Comment, A Memoir

    Sheldon Rothblatt, K J Dover et al.•Academe•1996

  • Vergil in Russia

    Zara Martirosova Torlone•Vergil in Russia•2014

  • Dionysius of Halicarnassus: On Thucydides

    W Kendrick Pritchett•Dionysius of Halicarnassus : on…•1975

  • "Thucydides or Grote?" Classical Disputes and Disputed Classics in Nineteenth-Century Cambridge

    Christopher Stray•Transactions of the American…•1997

  • Herodotus the Tourist

    James Redfield•Classical Philology•1985

  • Aeschylus’ Persians via the Ottoman Empire to Saddam Hussein

    Edith Hall•Cultural responses to the Persian…•2007

  • Lectures concerning oratory (1758)

    Open Access•John A Lawson, John Lawson•Sublime•1996

  • Mythos and logos

    Open Access•Robert L Fowler•The Journal of Hellenic Studies•2011

  • The Geohistorical Revolution

    Open Access•Steven French•Metascience•2007

  • Edward Gibbon and George Grote

    Open Access•William Johnson, William T G Johnson et al.•Notes and Records the Royal…•1994

  • Lectures on Rhetoric and Belles Lettres

    Adam James Smith•Lectureson rhetoric and belles…•1983

  • Herodotus and His Successors

    Vasiliki Zali•Brill’s Companion to the…•2016

  • The Cylon Conspiracy

    Tim Rood•Thucydides Between History and…•2013

  • To Make a Difference

    Open Access•Charles Steinwedel•Russian Modernity•2000

  • Duris of Samos and a Herodotean Model for Writing History

    Christopher Baron, Christopher A Baron•Brill’s Companion to the…•2016

  • Ethnicity, Nationality and the Masses

    Open Access•Nathaniel Knight•Russian Modernity•2000

  • Genre, Convention, and Innovation in Greco-Roman Historiography

    John Marincola•The Limits of Historiography•1999

  • Herodotus and Athens

    John Moles•Brill's Companion to Herodotus•2002

  • The Anti-Thucydides

    Neville Morley, Νeville Morley•Brill’s Companion to the…•2016

  • Thucydide législateur de l’histoire ? Appréciations antiques et modernes

    Open Access•Guido Schepens•Ombres de Thucydide•2010

  • The ‘Rediscovery’ of Egypt

    Andreas Schwab•Brill’s Companion to the…•2016

  • Sleepless Souls

    Melissa J Macdonald, Michael Macdonald et al.•Sleepless souls•1990

  • The Greek Heritage in Victorian Britain

    Frank M Turner•The Greek Heritage in Victorian…•1981

  • Crossroads in the Black Aegean

    Barbara Goff, Michael Simpson•Crossroads in the Black Aegean•2007

  • The absent-minded imperialists

    Bernard Porter•The Absent-Minded Imperialists•2004

  • Greek Tragedy and the British Theatre 1660-1914

    Edith Hall, Fiona Macintosh•GREEK TRAGEDY AND THE BRITISH…•2005

  • Sacred Stories

    Mark D Steinberg, Heather J Coleman•Sacred Stories•2007

  • The Forging of Races

    Open Access•Colin Kidd•Forging of Races•2006

  • Unthinking the Greek Polis

    Open Access•Kostas Vlassopoulos, Ko ̄stas Vlassopoulos et al.•Unthinking the Greek Polis•2007

  • Imperialism and Popular Culture

    John M Mackenzie•Imperialism and Popular Culture•2017

  • The Cambridge Companion to Xenophon

    Open Access•Michael A Flower•Cambridge Companion to Xenophon•2016

  • Voluntary Associations in Tsarist Russia

    Joseph Bradley•Voluntary Associations in Tsarist…•2009

  • Ancient Greeks West and East

    G R Tsetskhladze•Ancient Greeks West and East•1999

  • Herodotus

    Open Access•Herodotus Herodotus, Reginald Walter Macan•Herodotus : the Seventh, Eighth,…•2010

  • Greeks and Barbarians

    Open Access•Kostas Vlassopoulos•Greeks and Barbarians•2013

  • The Cambridge Companion to Herodotus

    Open Access•Robert Fowler, Jasper Griffin et al.•The Cambridge companion to…•2006

  • At Home with the Empire

    Open Access•Laura Tabili, Christine Kinealy et al.•At Home with the Empire•2006

  • Ancient Ethnography

    Eran Almagor, Joseph Skinner•Ancient ethnography•2013

  • Inventing the barbarian

    Edith Hall•Choice Reviews Online•1990

  • Fragmenta Historicorum Graecorum

    Open Access•Carl Müller•Fragmenta Historicorum Graecorum•2010

Citation velocityhistorical
Highly citedNo

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae