Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Theocratic Secularism

Religion and Government in Shiâi Thought

Bibliographic Data

ID23765637
AuthorsNaser Ghobadzadeh (0000-0002-4632-5391, Australian Catholic University, corresponding author)
Year2023
Publication date2023-02-12
Open AccessNo
TypeBOOK
VenueTheocratic Secularism vs. Governmental Shiism (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherOxford University PressNew York (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1093/oso/9780197606797.001.0001
OpenAlexW4311468099
ISBN9780197606797
LanguageEN
Citations received1
References cited142

This book articulates a religious rationale for political secularism in the Iranian/Shīʿī context. The genealogy of Twelver Shīʿī political theology shows that the bitter experience and lack of success of the Shīʿa in governance during the early centuries of Islamic history led them to link the realization of their ideal political system to transcendental factors. Belief in theocracy has been the basis of Shīʿī political theology, but with the messianic conception of the twelfth Imām in the fourth/tenth century, its realization came to depend on divine will and intervention. As a result, Shīʿī leaders, while awaiting the return of the twelfth Imām, not only do not have the authority or responsibility to take over government but have been forbidden to do so. For more than thirteen hundred years, the political thought and action of Shīʿī religious leaders were shaped by the political theology formulated in this book as theocratic secularism. In opposition to orthodox Shīʿī theology, a new politico-religious discourse emerged at the initiative of Ayatollah Khomeini toward the end of the twentieth century, referred to in this book as governmental Shīʿism. Governmental Shīʿism considers the occupation of the government apparatus as the duty of Shīʿī religious leaders. This book argues that governmental Shīʿism was neither the product of a theological transformation of Shīʿī orthodoxy nor used as a blueprint to establish the Islamic Republic. Rather, the formation of the Islamic Republic and the clergy’s rise to power led to the birth of governmental Shīʿism and bestowed importance on Khomeini’s wilāyat-i faqīh doctrine.

Opposition (politics) · Political science · Politics · Secularism · Sociology · Theocracy · Theology · Islamic Studies and History · Law · Philosophy · Religion and Society Interactions · Religious studies · Turkey's Politics and Society

  • Public Interest (Maslahat) in Shiʿi Theocracy

    Open Access•Bahman Khodadadi•Iranian Studies•2025

  • The turban for the crown

    Saïd Amir Arjomand•The turban for the crown•1988

  • The Origins of Muhammadan Jurisprudence

    Joseph Schacht•The Origins of Muhammadan…•2001

  • Iran

    M M J Fischer•Iran•2003

  • The Minor Dynasties of Northern Iran

    Open Access•Wilferd Madelung•The Cambridge History of Iran•1975

  • The Unthinkable Revolution in Iran

    C Kurzman•Unthinkable Revolution in Iran•2004

  • Society must be defended

    Michel Foucault•Society Must Be Defended•2003

  • Discipline and Punish

    Michel Foucault, Simon Prebble•Surveiller et punir•2019

  • The sacred canopy

    Peter L Berger•The sacred canopy•1990

  • The Ayatollahs and the Republic

    Mohammad Ali Kadivar•2017

  • Iran

    Open Access•Yann Richard•Iran•2019

  • Agents of the Hidden Imam

    Open Access•Edmund Hayes•Agents of the Hidden Imam•2022

  • Spokesmen of Intellectual Decolonization

    Esmaeil Zeiny•Ali Shariati and the Future of…•2017

  • Portrayals of the Later Abbasid Caliphate

    Patrick Scharfe•Journal of Abbasid Studies•2014

  • Thou Shalt Emulate the Most Knowledgeable Living Cleric

    Zackery Mirza Heern•Journal of Shi'a Islamic Studies•2014

  • Ali Shariati’s Critique of Durkheim’s Sociology of Religion

    Seyed Javad Miri•Ali Shariati and the Future of…•2017

  • The Fundamental Problem in the Clerical Establishment

    Morteza Motahhari, Hamid Dabashi•The most learned of the Shiʻa•2001

  • Negotiating Popular Mandate and the Sovereignty of God in Iran

    Open Access•Shahram Akbarzadeh, James Barry•The Politics of Islamism•2018

  • The Politics of Shahīd-E Jāwīd

    Evan Siegel•The Twelver Shia in Modern Times•2001

  • The Rebel and the Imam

    Robert Gleave•The ʿAbbasid and Carolingian…•2017

  • Struggling with Political Limitation

    Ali Ahmad Rasekh•Journal of Shi'a Islamic Studies•2016

  • Re-thinking shīʿī political theology

    Naser Ghobadzadeh•Routledge Handbook of Middle East…•2020

  • Khomeinism

    Fakhreddin Azimi, Ervand Abrahamian•The American Historical Review•1995

  • Shī'ī Ḥadīth

    Open Access•E Kohlberg•Arabic literature to the end of…•1983

  • Biopower

    Open Access•Chloë Taylor•Michel Foucault•2010

  • Iran's Intellectual Revolution

    Open Access•Mehran Kamrava•Iran's Intellectual Revolution•2008

  • Religious Forces in Eighteenth- And Nineteenth-Century Iran

    Open Access•Hamid Algar•The Cambridge history of Iran.•1991

  • Political Participation in Iran from Khatami to the Green Movement

    Open Access•Paola Rivetti•Political Participation in Iran…•2020

  • Iran Between Two Revolutions

    Open Access•Ervand Abrahamian•Iran Between Two Revolutions•1982

  • An Introduction to Shi'i Islam

    Mehnaaz Momen, Moojan Momen•Introduction to Shi'i Islam•2017

  • The Origins and Evolution of Islamic Law

    Open Access•Wael B Hallaq•Origins and Evolution of Islamic…•2004

  • The Divine, the People, and the Faqih

    Open Access•Behrooz Ghamari-Tabrizi, Behrooz Ghamari‐tabrizi•Critical Introduction to Khomeini•2014

  • Twelve Infallible Men

    Matthew Pierce•Twelve Infallible Men•2016

  • CHAPTER 9 Alternative Conceptions of Civil Society A Reflective Islamic Approach

    Ḥasan Ḥanafī•Alternative Conceptions of Civil…•2002

  • Islam and the Foundations of Political Power

    Ali Abdel Razek, Abdou Filali-Ansary et al.•Islam and the Foundations of…•2012

  • Medieval Islamic Political Thought

    Patricia Crone•Medieval Islamic Political Thought•2004

  • Disciplinary power

    Open Access•Marcelo Hoffman•Michel Foucault•2010

  • Modern Islamic Political Thought

    Open Access•Hamid Enayat•Modern Islamic Political Thought•1982

  • Foucault's theory of power

    Open Access•Richard A Lynch•Michel Foucault•2010

  • To Rule, or Not to Rule? An Alternative Look at the Political Life of Ayatollah Khomeini between 1960 and 1980

    Open Access•Zibakalam Sadegh, Sadegh Zibakalam•Critical Introduction to Khomeini•2014

  • Makers of Contemporary Islam

    John L Esposito, John Esposito et al.•Makers of Contemporary Islam•2001

  • Secularism and its discontents

    Tabassum Fahim Ruby•Muslim Women's Rights•2019

  • “I’m Only a Village Farmer and a Dervish”

    Alessandro Cancian•Political Quietism in Islam•2019

  • Shari'ati and Marx

    Assef Bayat آصف بيات, Assef Bayat/ آصف بيات et al.•Alif: Journal of Comparative…•1990

  • Secularism and state policies toward religion

    Serdar Kaya•Journal of Southeast European and…•2010

  • Radical Islam

    Mansour Farhang, Ervand Abrahamian•Middle East Report•1990

  • Al-Ma'mūn's Choice of 'Alī al-Riḍā as His Heir

    Mehmet Ali Büyükkara•ISLAMIC STUDIES•2002

  • Muslim Secular Democracy

    Open Access•Lily Zubaidah Rahim•Muslim Secular Democracy•2013

  • Iran's Quiet Revolution

    Open Access•Ali Mirsepassi•Iran's Quiet Revolution•2019

  • Islam and Political Legitimacy

    Shahram Akbarzadeh, Abdullah Saeed•Islam and Political Legitimacy•2003

  • Montazeri

    Open Access•Sussan Siavoshi•Montazeri•2017

  • The Miḥna of 218 A. H./833 A. D. Revisited

    John Nawas, John A Nawas•Journal of the American Oriental…•1996

  • Religion in Modern Europe

    G Davies, Grace Davie•Religion in modern Europe•2000

  • The Reign of the Ayatollahs

    Annabelle Sreberny‐mohammadi, Annabelle Sreberny-Mohammadi et al.•MERIP Middle East Report•1986

  • 'Ali Shari'ati

    Ervand Abrahamian•MERIP Reports•1982

  • The Order of Things

    Michel Foucault•The Order of Things•2018

  • Toward Desacralizing Secularization Theory

    Jeffrey K Hadden•Social Forces•1987

  • The Hedging Mullah

    Open Access•Shahram Kholdi•Constellations•2010

  • State-sponsored Persecution of Baha’is in the Islamic Republic of Iran

    Open Access•Siyamak Zabihi-Moghaddam•Contemporary Review of the Middle…•2016

  • Multivocality in Shia Seminary

    Abbas Mehregan•Sociology of Islam•2017

  • Sovereign power, disciplinary power and biopower

    M Lilja, Stellan Vinthagen•Journal of Political Power•2014

  • The Iranian Revolution at 30

    Homa Katouzian•Middle East Critique•2010

  • Iran's Constitutional Revolution

    Philip O Hopkins•Iran and the Caucasus•2011

  • Uses of video in social research

    Frederick Erickson•International Journal of Social…•2011

  • Secularisation in the Christian World

    Thomas P Jenkins, Timothy Jenkins•Journal of Contemporary Religion•2011

  • Revolutionary Iran. A History of the Islamic Republic

    Paola Rivetti•British Journal of Middle Eastern…•2013

  • The legitimation of the Clergy's right to rule in the Iranian constitution of 1979

    Said Saffari•British Journal of Middle Eastern…•1993

  • Foucault in Iran

    Arash Davari•British Journal of Middle Eastern…•2017

  • The evolution of the Iranian presidency

    Mohsen M Milani•British Journal of Middle Eastern…•1993

  • Iran

    Kouross Esmaeli•Comparative Studies of South Asia…•2008

  • The Mutilated Body of the Modern Nation

    Negar Mottahedeh•Comparative Studies of South Asia…•1998

  • Visual Evidence in Qualitative Research

    Open Access•Sorrel Penn‐Edwards, Sorrel Penn-Edwards•Qualitative Report•2015

  • Where is the Islamic republic of Iran heading

    Shahram Akbarzadeh•Australian Journal Of International…•2005

  • The Collection and Synthesis of “Tradition” and the Second-Century Invention of Christianity

    William Arnal•Method & Theory in the Study of…•2011

  • Pragmatism and Naturalism in Religious Studies

    Jason Blum, Jason N Blum•Method & Theory in the Study of…•2011

  • From popular revolution to theocratic absolutism

    Mohssen Nodjomi•Socialism and Democracy•1988

  • The Succession to Muhammad. A Study of the Early Caliphate

    Claude Gilliot, Wilfred Madelung•Studia Islamica•1997

  • Sectarianism and the prevalence of ‘othering’ in Islamic thought

    Naser Ghobadzdeh, Shahram Akbarzadeh•Third World Quarterly•2015

  • Public Religions in the Modern World

    R H Williams, Jose Casanava•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1995

  • "The "Floating Signifier

    Jeffrey Mehlman•Yale French Studies•1972

  • Zakāt in Imāmi Shī'ī jurisprudence, from the tenth to the sixteenth century A.D

    Open Access•Norman Calder•Bulletin of the School of…•1981

  • Presidential Elections in Iran

    Open Access•Eric Lob•Political Science Quarterly•2022

  • Moderate Secularism, Religion as Identity and Respect for Religion

    Open Access•T Modood•The Political Quarterly•2010

  • The legitimacy of the early Qajar rule as viewed by the shi'i religious leaders

    Abdul‐hadi Hairi•Middle Eastern Studies•1988

  • Akhund Khurasani and the Iranian Constitutional Movement

    Denis Hermann•Middle Eastern Studies•2013

  • Islamic Utopia in pre‐revolutionary Iran

    Sohrab Behdad•Middle Eastern Studies•1997

  • Religionization of politics in Iran

    Naser Ghobadzadeh, Shahram Akbarzadeh•Middle Eastern Studies•2020

  • The State and Khomeini's Islamic Order

    Open Access•Saïd Amir Arjomand•Iranian Studies•1980

  • The Establishment of the Position of Marja'iyyt-i Taqlid in the Twelver-Shi'i Community

    Open Access•A Moussavi, Ahmad Kazemi Moussavi•Iranian Studies•1985

  • The Thought and Role of Ayatollah Hossein'ali Montazeri in the Politics of Post-1979 Iran

    Open Access•Shahrough Akhavi•Iranian Studies•2008

  • The Constitutional Ideas of a Shi'ite Mujtahid

    Open Access•Fereshte M Nouraie•Iranian Studies•1975

  • Camouflage, Conspiracy, and Collaborators

    Open Access•Karen L Pliskin•Iranian Studies•1980

  • Shi'i Clerics in Iraq and Iran, 1722–1780

    Open Access•Juan Cole•Iranian Studies•1985

  • Iran, Islam, and Democracy

    Louis A Delvoie, Ali M Ansari•International Journal Canada s…•2001

  • The battle of the ayatollahs in Iran

    Open Access•Hassan Ahmadian•International Affairs•2022

  • Reinventing Khomeini

    L Carl Brown, Daniel Brumberg•Foreign Affairs•2001

  • Methodological Atheism, Methodological Agnosticism and Religious Experience

    Open Access•Douglas V Porpora•Journal for the Theory of Social…•2006

  • The Separation of State and Religion in the Development of Early Islamic Society

    Open Access•Ira M Lapidus, Ira M Lapıdus•International Journal Middle East…•1975

  • A Supply-Side Reinterpretation of the "Secularization" of Europe

    Rodney Stark, L R Iannaccone•Journal for the Scientific Study…•1994

  • Diverging Approaches of Political Islamic Thought in Iran since the 1960s

    Seyed Mohammad Lolaki•Diverging Approaches of Political…•2019

  • One man, one vote, one time? A model of democratization in the Middle East

    Open Access•Lisa Blaydes, James Lo•Journal of Theoretical Politics•2012

Unique citing works1
Citations per year1
Citation span2025 - 2025 (1)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 1

Tools

Open DOILibgen
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae