Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Religious revelation, secrecy and the limits of visual representation

Bibliographic Data

ID2401686
AuthorsBirgit Meyer (0000-0003-4883-7937, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, The Netherlands)
Year2006
Volume6
Issue4
Pages431-453
Publication date2006-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAnthropological Theory (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1463-4996 • E-ISSN: 1741-2641
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/1463499606071596
OpenAlexW2104561623
LanguageEN
Citations received49
References cited46

This article seeks to contribute to a more adequate understanding of the adoption of modern audiovisual mass media by contemporary religious groups. It does so by examining Pentecostal-charismatic churches as well as the Christian mass culture instigated by its popularity, and so-called traditional religion in Ghana, which develop markedly different attitudes towards audiovisual mass media and assume different positions in the public sphere. Taking into account the complicated entanglement of traditional religion and Pentecostalism, approaching both religions from a perspective of mediation which regards media as intrinsic to religion, and seeking to avoid the pitfall of overestimating the power of modern mass media to determine the world, this article seeks to move beyond an unproductive recurrence to oppositions such as tradition and modernity, or religion and technology. It is argued that instead of taking as a point of departure more or less set ideas about the nexus of vision and modernity, the adoption of new mass media by religious groups needs to be analyzed by a detailed ethnographic investigation of how these new media transform existing practices of religious mediation. Special emphasis is placed on the tension between the possibilities of gaining public presence through new media, and the difficulty in authorizing these media, and the experiences they induce, as authentic

Aesthetics · Epistemology · Mass media · Media culture · Media studies · Mediation · Modernity · Nexus (standard · Political science · Popularity · Revelation · Social science · Sociology · Theology · African Sexualities and LGBTQ+ Issues · Anthropological Studies and Insights · Computer Science · Law · Philosophy · South Asian Cinema and Culture

  • Media and Religious Diversity

    P Eisenlohr•Annual Review of Anthropology•2012

  • Institutions, Infrastructures, and Religious Sociality

    Courtney Handman, Minna Opas•Anthropological Quarterly•2019

  • Media and the Sacralization of Leaders and Events

    Open Access•Mihai Coman•Open Theology•2023

  • Documentary as ritual pedagogy

    Emmanuel Dankwah, Benjamin Prempeh et al.•African Identities•2026

  • Vérité révélée, vérité cachée

    Open Access•J Robbins, Emir Mahieddin•Revue des sciences sociales•2022

  • The power of things in a Catholic charismatic movement at Lake Chambri, Papua New Guinea

    Open Access•C Falck•Hau Journal of Ethnographic Theory•2026

  • Media, mediation, religion

    Open Access•Charles Hirschkind•Social Anthropology•2011

  • The anthropology of media and the question of ethnic and religious pluralism

    Open Access•P Eisenlohr•Social Anthropology•2011

  • “Again you will plant vineyards”

    Open Access•I Mcgonigle•Hau Journal of Ethnographic Theory•2022

  • Mediation and immediacy

    Open Access•Birgit Meyer•Social Anthropology•2011

  • (Not) Made by the human hand

    Open Access•M Van De Port•Social Anthropology•2011

  • Thou shalt not worship idols

    Open Access•Timo Kallinen•Suomen Antropologi Journal of the…•2022

  • Christianity, Presence, and the Problem of History

    Open Access•Jan Jensen•Suomen Antropologi Journal of the…•2021

  • Revelation is Unlimited

    Open Access•Asfa Widiyanto•KOMUNITAS INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL…•2016

  • Religion and the media turn

    Open Access•Matthew Engelke•American Ethnologist•2010

  • To God be the glory”

    Open Access•Chijioke Azuawusiefe•Communication and the Public•2025

  • My Media Studies

    Open Access•Faye Ginsburg•Television & New Media•2008

  • Panem et circenses

    G Sanders•Culture and Religion•2012

  • Parables as indicators of popular wisdom

    Open Access•Nuran Erol Işık•European Journal of Cultural…•2013

  • A literature review

    Jonathan Haynes•Journal of African Cultural Studies•2010

  • Continuity and Change in the Luba Christian Movement, Katanga, Belgian Congo, c. 1915–50

    Open Access•David Maxwell•The Journal of Ecclesiastical…•2017

  • Revealing the secrets of others (on YouTube)

    Open Access•Timo Kallinen•Suomen Antropologi Journal of the…•2019

  • Enchantment, migration and media

    Open Access•Amber Gemmeke•European Journal of Cultural…•2011

  • Re–scripting the Legends of Tuḷjā Bhavānī

    Open Access•Kiran Shinde, Kiran A Shinde•International Journal of Hindu…•2013

  • Historical Routes Towards Religious Television Fiction in Post-Mobutu Kinshasa

    Open Access•K Pype•Studies in World Christianity•2009

  • Response to Charles Hirschkind Religion and transduction

    Open Access•Matthew Engelke•Social Anthropology•2011

  • Pratiques religieuses africaines et médias numériques

    Open Access•K Pype•Emulations - Revue de sciences…•2018

  • Toward an Archaeology of Secrecy

    Open Access•Sandra Blakely•Archeological Papers of the…•2011

  • Powerful Pictures

    B Meyer•Journal of the American Academy…•2008

  • Queer African Cinemas

    Open Access•Lindsey B Green-Simms•Queer African Cinemas•2022

  • Divine Rulers in a Secular State

    Open Access•Timo Kallinen•Divine Rulers in a Secular State•2016

  • Media authenticity and authority in Mauritius

    Open Access•P Eisenlohr•Language & Communication•2011

  • Media and the senses in the making of religious experience

    B Meyer•Material Religion•2008

  • Quiet beauty

    Anna Stewart•Religion•2016

  • The book that killeth and the book that giveth life the spirit of 2 corinthians 3

    Adam H Becker•Material Religion•2014

  • Practices and Narratives of Breakthrough

    Primus M Tazanu•Journal of Religion in Africa•2016

  • Media, Religion, and the Public Sphere

    Open Access•Coman Mihai•Religions•2023

  • Mediação e Imediatismo

    Open Access•B Meyer•CAMPOS - Revista de Antropologia…•2017

  • Christianity, fetishism, and the development of secular politics in Ghana

    Open Access•Timo Kallinen•Anthropological Theory•2014

  • Technologies of the spirit

    Open Access•P Eisenlohr•Anthropological Theory•2009

  • Considering the glass case

    Open Access•Steph Bern, Steph Berns•Journal of Material Culture•2016

  • Of Polluted Spirits and Compromised Identity

    Open Access•Primus M Tazanu•Journal of Asian and African…•2018

  • How religious is the public sphere? A critical stance on the debate about public religion and post-secularity

    Open Access•Jens Köhrsen•Acta Sociologica•2012

  • Secrecy

    Graham M Jones•Annual Review of Anthropology•2014

  • Keeping God's distance

    Open Access•Joel Robbins•American Ethnologist•2017

  • A prophet but not for profit

    Open Access•Girish Daswani•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2016

  • Un/making difference through performance and mediation in contemporary Africa

    Heike Becker, Dorothea E Schulz et al.•Journal of African Cultural Studies•2017

  • New media entrepreneurs and changing styles of public communication in Africa

    Tilo Grätz•Journal of African Cultural Studies•2013

  • Photography and the Religious Encounter

    Open Access•David Maxwell•Comparative Studies in Society…•2011

  • Iconoclash

    Bruno Latour, Peter Weibel•ICONOCLASH•2002

  • Carnal Thoughts

    Vivian Sobchack•Carnal Thoughts•2004

  • Magic and Modernity

    Birgit Meyer, Peter Pels•Magic and Modernity•2003

  • Introduction

    Open Access•S Brent Plate•Representing Religion in World…•2003

  • Religious Encounter and the Making of the Yoruba

    J D Y Peel•Religious Encounter and the…•2001

  • African Christianity

    Paul Gifford•African Christianity•1998

  • The Global Resurgence of Religion and the Transformation of International Relations

    Open Access•Scott Thomas, Scott M Thomas•Global Resurgence of Religion and…•2005

  • Contesting Silence

    R Van Dijk•Ghana Studies•2001

  • Ghana's new christianity

    Cédric Mayrargue•Critique internationale•2005

  • Insight, Secrecy, Beasts, and Beauty

    Marleen Witte, Marleen De Witte•Postscripts The Journal of Sacred…•2005

  • The Underneath of ThingsViolence, History, and the Everyday in Sierra Leone

    Mariane Ferme, Mariane C Ferme•The Underneath of Things•2001

  • Imperial Encounters

    Peter Van Der Veer•Imperial Encounters•2001

  • Underneath of Things

    Mariane C Ferme•Underneath of Things•2001

  • Religious Remediations

    Birgit Meyer•Postscripts The Journal of Sacred…•2005

  • Defacement

    Michael Taussig, Michael J Taussig•Defacement•1999

  • The spectacular and the spirits

    Marleen Witte, Marleen De Witte•Material Religion•2005

  • The crusade is the vision

    Tamar Gordon, Mary Hancock•Material Religion•2005

  • Photo Magic

    Heike Behrend•Journal of Religion in Africa•2003

  • Charisma and Brotherhood' Revisited

    Dorothea E Schulz, Dieter Schulz et al.•Journal of Religion in Africa•2003

  • Altar Media's Living Word

    Marleen Witte, Marleen De Witte•Journal of Religion in Africa•2003

  • Charismatic/Pentecostal Appropriation of Media Technologies in Nigeria and Ghana

    Rosalind I J Hackett•Journal of Religion in Africa•1998

  • Mass mediating the spiritual battle

    M Oosterbaan•Material Religion•2005

  • Aisthesis & An-Aesthesia

    Open Access•Jojada Verrips•Ethnologia Europaea•2005

  • Culture, Globalization, Mediation

    W Mazzarella•Annual Review of Anthropology•2004

  • Make a Complete Break with the past.' Memory and Post-Colonial Modernity in Ghanaian Pentecostalist Discourse

    Birgit Meyer•Journal of Religion in Africa•1998

  • Religious Language

    W Keane•Annual Review of Anthropology•1997

  • Imagined Communities. Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism

    Anthony Reid, Benedict Anderson•Pacific Affairs•1985

  • Delivered from the powers of darkness

    Open Access•Birgit Meyer•Africa•1995

  • Historicity and pluralism in some recent studies of Yoruba religion

    Open Access•J D Y Peel•Africa•1994

  • Circling around the Really Real

    Open Access•M Van De Port•Ethos•2005

  • Sincerity, "Modernity," and the Protestants

    Open Access•W Keane•Cultural Anthropology•2002

  • Visualizing the sacred

    Open Access•M Van De Port•American Ethnologist•2006

  • Praise the Lord

    Open Access•Birgit Meyer•American Ethnologist•2004

  • The Ethics of Listening

    Open Access•Charles Hirschkind•American Ethnologist•2001

  • Translating the Devil

    Birgit Meyer•Translating the Devil•2019

  • Viscerality, faith, and skepticism

    Open Access•M Taussig•Hau Journal of Ethnographic Theory•2016

  • Religion and/as Media

    Open Access•Jeremy Stolow•Theory Culture & Society•2005

  • Christianity in Africa

    Birgit Meyer•Annual Review of Anthropology•2004

Unique citing works49
Citations per year2,72
Citation span2008 - 2026 (19)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 47

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae