Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Why Is Werner Sombart Not Part of the Core of Classical Sociology

From Fame to (Near) Oblivion

Bibliographic Data

ID2404456
AuthorsReiner Grundmann (0000-0003-0266-9296, Aston University, corresponding author), N Stehr (0000-0002-4402-9679)
Year2001
Volume1
Issue2
Pages257-287
Publication date2001-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Classical Sociology (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1468-795X • E-ISSN: 1741-2897
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/14687950122232558
OpenAlexW2108917724
LanguageEN
Citations received37
References cited64

The life and work of Werner Sombart poses an intellectual puzzle in the genealogy of modern social theorists. During his lifetime, Sombart was probably the most influential and prominent social scientist in Germany as well as in many other countries. Today he is among the least known social scientists. Why did he lose his status as one of the most brilliant and influential scholars and intellectuals of the 20th century? Why is his work almost forgotten today? While Weber's thesis about the influence of Protestantism on the development of capitalism is widely known, even beyond sociological circles, few sociologists today know that Sombart had an alternative explanation. An obvious explanation for Sombart's fall from grace is his embrace of Nazism. As Heidegger provides a counter-example, Sombart's fate requires a more complex explanation. In addition, we explore the different reception of his work in economic and sociological circles as compared to cultural theory and history

Capitalism · Epistemology · Politics · Protestant work ethic · Social science · Social theory · Sociology · Critical Theory and Philosophy · German Social Sciences and History · Law · Philosophy · Weber, Simmel, Sociological Theory

  • Fazit

    Open Access•Christopher Adair-Toteff•Werner Sombart und der „Geist“…•2025

  • Conclusion

    Open Access•Christopher Adair-Toteff•Werner Sombart and the 'Spirit'…•2024

  • Sombart über den Kapitalismus 1925–1932

    Open Access•Christopher Adair-Toteff•Werner Sombart und der „Geist“…•2025

  • Sombart on Capitalism 1925–1932

    Open Access•Christopher Adair-Toteff•Werner Sombart and the 'Spirit'…•2024

  • Warum Sombart lesen?“

    Open Access•Christopher Adair-Toteff•Werner Sombart und der „Geist“…•2025

  • Joseph A. Schumpeter?s contributions in the area of fiscal sociology

    Open Access•J rgen G Backhaus, J�rgen G Backhaus•Journal of Evolutionary Economics•2004

  • “Why Read Sombart?”

    Open Access•Christopher Adair-Toteff•Werner Sombart and the 'Spirit'…•2024

  • Capitalism and Judaism in Werner Sombart

    Vitantonio Gioia•Research Annual•2014

  • Apologetics of Culture as an Apologetics of War

    Open Access•Serhii Makeiev•Sociology Theory Methods Marketing•2023

  • Sombart, Werner (1863–1941)

    Open Access•Alan Sica•The Blackwell Encyclopedia of…•2007

  • Sombart, Werner (1863–1941)

    Open Access•Alan Sica•The Blackwell Encyclopedia of…•2015

  • Questioning the Weber Thesis

    Open Access•Sigmund Wagner‐tsukamoto, Sigmund Wagner-Tsukamoto•Sociology Mind•2012

  • Sombart’s Return

    Christopher Adair-Toteff•History of European Ideas•2025

  • Capitalism and criticism

    Open Access•Christopher Adair-Toteff•History of the Human Sciences•2013

  • Precautionary and Proactionary as the New Right and the New Left of the Twenty-First Century Ideological Spectrum

    Open Access•Fuller•International Journal of Politics…•2012

  • The Mainstreaming of Marx

    Phillip Magne, Phillip W Magness et al.•Journal of Political Economy•2022

  • The myth about “myths of the Chicago School”

    Open Access•David A Nock, David Nock•The American Sociologist•2004

  • Parsons as Economist

    Open Access•Christopher Adair-Toteff•The American Sociologist•2021

  • Technik Comes to America

    Eric Schatzberg•Technology and Culture•2006

  • The Spirit of Luxury

    Joanne Armitage, Joanne Roberts•Cultural Politics an International…•2016

  • Elite Distinction

    Jean-Pascal Daloz, Jean‐pascal Daloz•Comparative Sociology•2007

  • Weber’s Protestant Work Ethic

    Kirsten W Kininmonth, Kirsten Kininmonth•Business History•2016

  • Quantifying the exclusionary process of canonisation, or How to become a classic of the social sciences

    Nicole Holzhauser•International Review of Sociology•2021

  • Is there a canon in this class

    Barbara Grüning, Marco Santoro•International Review of Sociology•2021

  • Sinn der Welt

    Christopher Adair-Toteff•Max Weber Studies•2013

  • Cosmopolitan sociology and the classical canon

    Open Access•David Inglis•British Journal of Sociology•2009

  • Capitalism and the Jews

    Jeff Lipkes•History of Political Economy•2019

  • There Is Nothing Wrong about Being Money Grubbing!" Milton Friedman's Provocative "Capitalism and the Jews" in Context, 1972-88

    Nicolas Vallois, Cléo Chassonnery-Zaïgouche•History of Political Economy•2021

  • Afinal, o que é mesmo a Nova Sociologia Económica

    Open Access•João Carlos Graça•Revista crítica de ciências…•2005

  • Werner Sombart

    Open Access•João Carlos Graça•Sociedade e Estado•2022

  • Fiscal crisis and creative destruction

    Open Access•Barry Smart, Benjamin Smart•Journal of Classical Sociology•2012

  • Tradition and innovation in classical sociology

    Open Access•Simon Susen, B Turner et al.•Journal of Classical Sociology•2011

  • The Economics-Sociology Divide

    Open Access•João Carlos Graça•Journal of Classical Sociology•2008

  • An Economic Turn

    Open Access•Barry Smart, Benjamin Smart•Journal of Classical Sociology•2003

  • Better late than modern? Between 'late capitalism' and 'late modernity

    Open Access•David Inglis•European Journal of Social Theory•2024

  • Instrumentum Vocale

    Open Access•Thomas Kemple, Thomas M Kemple•Theory Culture & Society•2005

  • When Baehr met Steffen

    Open Access•Josef Ginnerskov•Acta Sociologica•2021

  • Die Juden und das Wirtschaftsleben

    Werner Sombart•Die Juden und das Wirtschaftsleben•1911

  • The crisis of German ideology

    George L Mosse, Mosse Mosse•The crisis of German ideology•1981

  • The romantic ethic and the spirit of modern consumerism

    Colin Campbell•The romantic ethic and the spirit…•1990

  • Wirtschaftstheorie unter dem Hakenkreuz

    Werner Krause•Wirtschaftstheorie Unter Dem…•1969

  • The Sex of Things

    Victoria De Grazia, Ellen Furlough•Sex of Things•1996

  • Toward a new economics of science

    Open Access•Dasgupta Partha, Paul A David•Research Policy•1994

  • Economy and Society

    Claus Wittich, Guenther Roth et al.•Economy and Society•2013

  • Technical change and economic theory

    Giovanni Dosi•Technical change and economic…•1988

  • The Social construction of technological systems

    T J Pinch, Thomas Parke Hughes et al.•The Social construction of…•1989

  • Structure of Social Action

    Talcott Parsons•Structure of Social Action•1967

  • Beyond the Marketplace

    Roger Friedland, R J Friedland et al.•Beyond the Marketplace•2019

  • Der kapitalistische Unternehmer

    Open Access•Werner Sombart•Die Modernität des Kapitalismus•2018

  • The Place of the Jews in Economic History as Viewed by German Scholars

    T Oelsner•The Leo Baeck Institute Year Book•1962

  • Werner Sombart's

    Paul Mendes-Flohr, P R Mendes-Flohr•The Leo Baeck Institute Year Book•1976

  • The Jewish Merchant

    David S Landes•The Leo Baeck Institute Year Book•1974

  • The Social Life of Things

    Open Access•Arjun Appadurai•Social Life of Things•1986

  • Why is there no Socialism in the United States?

    Open Access•C T Husbands, Werner Sombart et al.•Why Is There No Socialism in the…•1976

  • Kulturgeschichte als Kultursoziologie

    Heinrich Meyer, Alfred L Weber et al.•Books Abroad•1952

  • A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy (1859)

    Karl Marx, S W Ryazanskaya•The Bloomsbury Companion to Marx•2018

  • On the Jewish Question

    Karl Marx•Democracy•2016

  • Why is there no Socialism in the United States

    Werner Sombart, C T Husbands et al.•Why Is There No Socialism in the…•2019

  • The Jews and Modern Capitalism

    Werner Sombart, Samuel Ζ Klausner et al.•Jews and Modern Capitalism•2017

  • The Politics of Cultural Despair

    Fritz Stern, Fritz R Stern•Politics of Cultural Despair•1961

  • Werner Sombart, 1863-1941

    Colin Loader, Friedrich Lenger•The American Historical Review•1995

  • Economy and Society

    Max Weber•Readings in Economic Sociology•2002

  • Max Weber

    B Turner, Bryan S Turner•MAX WEBER•1992

  • Max Weber on ?Jewish rationalism? and the Jewish Question

    Open Access•Gary Abraham, Gary A Abraham•International Journal of Politics…•1988

  • The Jews and Modern Communism

    Irving Louis Horowitz•Modern Judaism - A Journal of…•1986

  • The Religious Kibbutz

    Aryei Fishman•Sociological Analysis•1989

  • Sombart and German (National) Socialism

    Abram L Harris•Journal of Political Economy•1942

  • The State and Labor in Modern America

    Nick Salvatore, Melvyn Dubofsky•Journal of American History•1995

  • Obituary

    M Epstein•The Economic Journal•1941

  • Wirtschaftsleben im Zeitalter des Hochkapitalismus. Zweiter Halbband

    Everett C Hughes•American Journal of Sociology•1927

  • Von der historischen Nationalökonomie zur historischen Soziologie

    Volker Kruse•Zeitschrift für Soziologie•1990

  • Die frühe deutsche Soziologie 1909 bis 1934 und ihre Entstehungs-Milieus

    Open Access•Dirk Kasler, Dirk Kaesler•Die Frühe Deutsche Soziologie…•1984

  • Fate and Utopia in German Sociology, 1870-1923

    Jerome Dowd, James J Dowd et al.•German Studies Review•1992

  • Sociology and Estrangement

    Susanne P Schad-Somer, Susanne P Schad-Somers et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1976

  • Fate and Utopia in German Sociology 1870-1923

    Frank Field•German History•1989

  • Reactionary modernism

    Jeffrey Herf•Reactionary modernism•1984

  • Max Weber

    Wilhelm Hennis•Max Weber•1988

  • A New Social Philosophy

    Dorothy Fosdick, Werner Sombart et al.•American Sociological Review•1939

  • Der proletarische Sozialismus

    W H Dawson, Werner Sombart•The Economic History Review•1928

  • Werner Sombart (1863-1941)-Social Scientist

    Royall Brandis•History of Political Economy•1997

  • Werner Sombart (1863-1941), Social scientist

    Open Access•Colin Loader•Journal of the History of the…•1998

  • Werner Sombart 1863-1941. Eine biographie

    Open Access•Dick Pels•Journal of the History of the…•1998

  • Religion and Capitalism Once Again? Jewish Merchant Culture in the Seventeenth Century

    Natalie Zemon Davis•Representations•1997

  • Luxury and Capitalism

    N Stehr, Werner Sombart et al.•Social Forces•1968

  • The Sociology of Legitimation

    Open Access•Roberto Cipriani•Current Sociology•1987

  • Die Drei Nationalokonomien.Werner Sombart

    Robert E Park•American Journal of Sociology•1931

  • The ?Heidegger affair

    Open Access•Brian Singer, Brian C J Singer•Theory and Society•1993

Unique citing works37
Citations per year1,61
Citation span2003 - 2025 (23)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 37

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae