Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Silent Instruments

Syntax, semantics, and acquisition of the instrumental role in Italian

Bibliographic Data

ID24226841
AuthorsAlice Suozzi (Ca' Foscari University of Venice)
Year2026
Publication date2026-03-26
Open AccessNo
TypeBOOK
VenueSilent Instruments (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherJohn Benjamins Publishing Company (PUBLISHER • NL)
DOI10.1075/la.293
OpenAlexW7141611909
ISBN9789027234209
LanguageEN
References cited215

This book offers the first systematic investigation of the instrumental role across syntax, semantics, and language acquisition. Focusing primarily on Italian within a comparative perspective, the book addresses a long-standing puzzle: why Instruments can be syntactically omitted even when they remain semantically present. Combining theoretical analysis with experimental evidence, corpus data, and innovative methodologies, the study redefines the status of Instruments with respect to the argument-adjunct distinction and introduces a new, principled account of their syntactic omission based on semantic recoverability. It proposes a refined typology of Instruments, grounded in verb meaning and contextual factors, and tests its predictions through behavioral experiments and large-scale corpus analyses. The book also breaks new ground in acquisition research, presenting the first experimental investigation of how Italian-speaking children acquire Instruments. The results reveal a striking dissociation between early syntactic mastery and the slower development of Instrument semantic recoverability, shedding new light on the acquisition of syntactically optional elements. By integrating syntax, semantics, and acquisition, Silent Instruments provides a robust and empirically grounded framework that is readily applicable to cross-linguistic research and to other phenomena at the syntax-semantics interface. It will be of interest to linguists working on argument structure, optionality, language acquisition, and experimental and corpus-based approaches to grammar.

argument structure · instrumental case · Italian · Language acquisition · syntax-semantics interface · verb semantics · Language Development and Disorders · Linguistic Studies and Language Acquisition · Syntax, Semantics, Linguistic Variation

  • Argument Realization

    Open Access•Beth Levin, Malka Rappaport Hovav•Argument Realization•2005

  • Lexical Functional Grammar

    Mary Dalrymple•Lexical Functional Grammar•2001

  • The Generative Lexicon

    James Pustejovsky•The Generative Lexicon•1995

  • Word Meaning and Montague Grammar

    Open Access•David R Dowty•Word Meaning and Montague Grammar•1979

  • Intonation and Meaning

    Daneel Buring, Daniel Büring•Intonation and Meaning•2016

  • Transformational Grammar

    Open Access•Andrew Radford•Transformational Grammar•1988

  • Cognitive Linguistics

    Open Access•William Croft, Diana Cruse et al.•Cognitive Linguistics•2004

  • Phrase Structure in Natural Language

    Open Access•Margaret Speas, M J Speas•Phrase Structure in Natural…•1990

  • Prototypical Transitivity

    Åshild Næss•Prototypical Transitivity…•2007

  • Exploring the Syntax-Semantics Interface

    Open Access•Robert D Van Valin, Jr Robert D Van Valin et al.•Exploring the Syntax-Semantics…•2005

  • Structure and Strategy in Learning to Talk

    Katherine Nelson•Monographs of the Society for…•1973

  • A cross-linguistic study of early lexical development

    Open Access•María Cristina Caselli, Elizabeth Bates et al.•Cognitive Development•1995

  • Enriching Word Vectors with Subword Information

    Open Access•Piotr Bojanowski, Edouard Grave et al.•Transactions of the Association…•2017

  • Redundancy and reduction

    Open Access•T Florian Jaeger•Cognitive Psychology•2010

  • Acquiring and processing verb argument structure

    Open Access•Elizabeth Wonnacott, Elissa L Newport et al.•Cognitive Psychology•2008

  • Structure and Variation in Child Language

    Lois Bloom, Patsy M Lightbown et al.•Monographs of the Society for…•1975

  • Audience Design in Meaning and Reference

    Herbert H Clark, Gregory L Murphy•Language and comprehension•1982

  • Modeling the Influence of Thematic Fit (and Other Constraints) in On-line Sentence Comprehension

    Open Access•Ken Mcrae, Michael J Spivey-Knowlton et al.•Journal of Memory and Language•1998

  • The effect of verb semantic class and verb frequency (entrenchment) on children’s and adults’ graded judgements of argument-structure overgeneralization errors

    Open Access•Ben Ambridge, Julian M Pine et al.•Cognition•2008

  • The lexical nature of syntactic ambiguity resolution.

    Maryellen C Macdonald, Neal J Pearlmutter et al.•Psychological Review•1994

  • The Logical Form of Action Sentences

    Donald Davidson•The Logic of Decision and Action•1967

  • Word lengths are optimized for efficient communication

    Open Access•Steven T Piantadosi, Harry Tily et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2011

  • The time-course of prediction in incremental sentence processing

    Open Access•Yuki Kamide, Gerry T M Altmann et al.•Journal of Memory and Language•2003

  • The WaCky wide web

    Open Access•Mario Baroni, Marco Baroni et al.•Language Resources and Evaluation•2009

  • The Structural Sources of Verb Meanings

    Lila R Gleitman, Lila Gleitman•Language Acquisition•1990

  • References in conversation between experts and novices.

    Ellen A Isaacs, Herbert H Clark•Journal of Experimental…•1987

  • Do young children have adult syntactic competence?

    Open Access•M Tomasello•Cognition•2000

  • Logic and Conversation

    H P Grice•Speech Acts•1975

  • Topic Continuity in Discourse

    Talmy Givón•Topic continuity in discourse•1983

  • Pronouns in Germanic and Romance languages

    Anna Cardinaletti•Clitics in the Languages of Europe•1999

  • Syntax

    Open Access•Robert D Van Valin, Randy J Lapolla et al.•Syntax•1997

  • The Instrumental Case in English

    Don L F Nilsen, Don L Nilsen•Instrumental Case in English•1973

  • What with? The Anatomy of a (Proto)-Role

    Jean-Pierre Koenig, Gail Mauner et al.•Journal of Semantics•2007

  • Ingredients of Instrumental Meaning

    Lilia Rissman, Kyle Rawlins•Journal of Semantics•2017

  • Verbs describing routines facilitate object omission in English

    Open Access•Lelia Gla•Proceedings of the Linguistic…•2020

  • The Information-Structural Status of Adjuncts

    Open Access•Lisa Brunetti, Kordula De Kuthy et al.•Discours•2021

  • The acquisition of the clitic ci among typically developing Italian preschoolers

    Open Access•Alice Souzzi, Gloria Gagliardi•Linguistik Online•2022

  • Infant-directed speech becomes less redundant as infants grow

    Open Access•Shira TAL, Eitan Grossman et al.•Cognition•2024

  • A constructional account of genre-based argument omissions

    Josef Ruppenhofer, Laura A Michaelis•Constructions and Frames•2010

  • Conditions on Chinese A-not-A questions

    Open Access•Thomas Ernst•Journal of East Asian Linguistics•1994

  • Vocabulary development in Italian children

    Open Access•Laura D'Odorico, Laura D’Odorico et al.•Journal of Child Language•2001

  • The role of performance limitations in the acquisition of verb-argument structure

    Open Access•A L Theakston, Elena Lieven et al.•Journal of Child Language•2001

  • Toward mastery of Italian morphology

    Open Access•María Cristina Caselli, Laurence B Leonard et al.•Journal of Child Language•1993

  • The acquisition of Italian morphology

    Open Access•Elena Pizzuto, Elena Antinoro Pizzuto et al.•Journal of Child Language•1992

  • Remarks on Lexical Structure and DRS Construction

    Hans Kamp, Antje Roßdeutscher•Theoretical Linguistics•1994

  • Prosodic Characteristics of Early Multi-Word Utterances in Italian Children

    Open Access•Laura D'Odorico, Laura D’Odorico et al.•First Language•2003

  • Object associations of early-learned light and heavy English verbs

    Open Access•Josita Maouene, Aarre Laakso et al.•First Language•2011

  • Why You Can’t Do So Into the Sink

    George Lakoff, John Robert Ross•Notes from the Linguistic…•1976

  • A Canonical Approach to the Argument/Adjunct Distinction

    Open Access•Diana Forker•Linguistic Discovery•2014

  • Locative-Related Roles and the Argument-Adjunct Distinction in Balinese

    Open Access•I Wayan Arka•Linguistic Discovery•2014

  • Arguments and Adjuncts as Language-Particular Syntactic Categories and as Comparative Concepts

    Open Access•Martin Haspelmath•Linguistic Discovery•2014

  • What’s New (and What’s Given) in the Theory of Focus

    Open Access•Daneel Buring, Daniel Büring•Proceedings of the Annual Meeting…•2008

  • Pragmatically Controlled Zero Anaphora

    Open Access•Charles J Fillmore•Proceedings of the Annual Meeting…•1986

  • Do We Need a Distinction between Arguments and Adjuncts? Evidence from Psycholinguistic Studies of Comprehension

    Open Access•Damon Tutunjian, Julie E Boland•Language and Linguistics Compass•2008

  • Surface generalizations

    Open Access•Adele E Goldberg, Adele Ε Goldberg•Cognitive Linguistics•2002

  • Learning argument structure generalizations

    Open Access•Adele E Goldberg, Adele Ε Goldberg et al.•Cognitive Linguistics•2004

  • Locality Constraints on the Interpretation of Roots

    Open Access•Maya Arad•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2003

  • Prosody–Syntax Interaction in the Expression of Focus

    Open Access•Vieri Samek-Lodovici•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2005

  • Inferring Indirect Objects in Sentences

    Open Access•Carole A Cotter•Language and Speech•1984

  • Deletion and proform reduction

    Open Access•D J Allerton•Journal of Linguistics•1975

  • Instruments as agents

    Open Access•I M Schlesinger•Journal of Linguistics•1989

  • The KEY to lexical semantic representations

    Open Access•Jean-Pierre Koenig, Anthony R Davis•Journal of Linguistics•2006

  • Young children extend novel words at the basic level

    Roberta Michnick Golinkoff, Margaret Shuff-Bailey et al.•Developmental Psychology•1995

  • Nonevent -er nominals

    Open Access•Beth Levin, MALKA RAPPAPORT•Linguistics•1988

  • Force Dynamics in Language and Cognition

    Open Access•Léonard Talmy•Cognitive Science•1988

  • The Smooth Signal Redundancy Hypothesis

    Open Access•Matthew P Aylett, Matthew Aylett et al.•Language and Speech•2004

  • Categorization of Natural Objects

    Carolyn Β Mervis, C B Mervis et al.•Annual Review of Psychology•1981

  • Distributional Models of Word Meaning

    Open Access•Alessandro Lenci•Annual Review of Linguistics•2017

  • Radical Construction Grammar

    William Croft•Radical Construction Grammar•2001

  • Patient arguments of causative verbs can be omitted

    Open Access•Adele E Goldberg, Adele Ε Goldberg•Language Sciences•2001

  • Coercion in a general theory of argument selection

    Open Access•James Pustejovsky•Linguistics•2011

  • On the validity of the complement-adjunct distinction in valency grammar

    Open Access•Harold L Somers, Harold Somers•Linguistics•1984

  • A theory of focus interpretation

    Open Access•Mats Rooth•Natural Language Semantics•1992

  • Distributional Structure

    Zellig S Harris•WORD•1954

  • Very early parameter setting and the unique checking constraint

    Open Access•Ken Wexler•Lingua•1998

  • Disentangling sources of difficulty associated with the acquisition of accusative clitics in French

    Open Access•Hélène Delage, Stephanie Durrleman et al.•Lingua•2016

  • Clitic pronoun production as a measure of atypical language development in French

    Open Access•Laurice Tuller, Hélène Delage et al.•Lingua•2011

  • The development of an appreciation of specific linkages between linguistic and conceptual organization

    Open Access•Sandra R Waxman•Lingua•1994

  • Linguistic determinism and the part of speech

    Roger W Brown, Roger Brown et al.•Journal of Abnormal & Social…•1957

  • The case of the intransitive subject in Tsova-Tush (Batsbi)

    Open Access•Dee Ann Holisky•Lingua•1987

  • Comparative concepts and descriptive categories in crosslinguistic studies

    Open Access•Martin Haspelmath•Language•2010

  • Canonical Typology, Suppletion, and Possible Words

    Open Access•Greville G Corbett•Language•2007

  • Clitics and Particles

    Arnold M Zwicky•Language•1985

  • Thematic Proto-Roles and Argument Selection

    David R Dowty, David Dowty•Language•1991

  • Prosodic Structure in Young Children's Language Production

    Louann Gerken•Language•1996

  • Prototypes Revisited

    Robert E Maclaury, R Maclaury•Annual Review of Anthropology•1991

Highly citedNo

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae