Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Power, Hegemony, and World Society Theory

A Critical Evaluation

Bibliographic Data

ID2423926
AuthorsL Downey (0000-0002-4549-3190, University of Colorado Boulder, corresponding author), Elizabeth M Lawrence (0000-0001-9176-3991, University of Nevada, Las Vegas), Micah Pyles, Micah A Pyles (0000-0002-5060-8124, University of Colorado Boulder), Derek Lee (0000-0002-1042-9543, University of Colorado Boulder)
Year2020
Volume6
Publication date2020-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueSocius Sociological Research for a Dynamic World (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 2378-0231 • E-ISSN: 2378-0231
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/2378023120920059
OpenAlexW3023138801
LanguageEN
Citations received15
References cited60

World society theory has been one of the better published theoretical paradigms of the past 30 to 40 years. But despite its publishing successes, world society theory and research are beset by a number of theoretical and empirical problems that call into question the theory's ability to accurately describe and explain the global diffusion of government practices, policies, and structures. The authors summarize world society theory's key claims, demonstrate that the theory has trouble explaining a set of diffusion outcomes that it needs to be able to explain, and show that a key reason for this is that the actors highlighted by the theory are embedded in hierarchical and power-laden organizations, networks, and fields that strongly limit the kinds of actions these actors can take and the kinds of cultural scripts they can follow

Critical theory · Diffusion theory · Economics · Epistemology · Government (linguistics · Hegemony · Key (lock · Knowledge management · Management science · Political science · Positive economics · Power (physics · Scripting language · Set (abstract data type · Sociology · Computer Science · Elite Sociology and Global Capitalism · International Development and Aid · Law · World Systems and Global Transformations

  • When hazards don’t make law

    Open Access•Maoxin Ye, Daniel P Aldrich•Social Forces•2026

  • Indigenous Inclusion in Latin American Constitutions

    Open Access•Andrés Rodríguez-Cáceres•Social Science History•2026

  • Women STEM faculty’s intentions to engage in entrepreneurship education programs

    Open Access•Prateek Shekhar, Jacqueline Handley et al.•Higher Education•2024

  • Meaning structures in the world polity

    Open Access•Kyle Puetz, Andrew P Davis et al.•Poetics•2021

  • Differential Effectiveness of Regional Trade Agreements, 1958-2012

    Min Zhou•Sociological Quarterly•2022

  • Who Supports Global Cooperation? Cooperative Internationalism at the Intersection of Social Class and Economic Development

    Open Access•Brandon Gorman, Charles Seguin•Sociological Science•2020

  • Combining world-system and world polity approaches to analyze international environmental governance

    Patrick Coatarpeter, Brian J Gareau•Environmental Sociology•2022

  • Immanuel Wallerstein’s Lasting Legacies

    Open Access•M Moghadam•Journal of World-Systems Research•2023

  • Gender regimes, polities, and the world-system

    Open Access•M Moghadam•Women s Studies International Forum•2023

  • Varying Vistas

    Kajol Patel•International Journal of Sociology•2024

  • The Promise of John W. Meyer’s World Society Theory

    Open Access•Pavel S Sorokin•The American Sociologist•2020

  • Business as usual

    Stephanie Limoncelli•Globalizations•2024

  • The Diffusion of Exclusion

    Open Access•Kerice Doten-Snitker•Comparative Political Studies•2025

  • Scales of violence

    Open Access•Omid Ghaderzadeh, M Moghadam•International Sociology•2025

  • Domains of Diffusion

    Andreas Wimmer•American Journal of Sociology•2021

  • India's green revolution

    Francine R Frankel•India's green revolution•1971

  • Policy-planning organizations

    Joseph G Peschek•Policy-planning organizations•1987

  • The Transnational Capitalist Class

    Leslie Sklair•The Transnational Capitalist Class•2000

  • Silent Revolution

    James M Boughton•Silent Revolution•2001

  • Private Power, Public Law

    Open Access•Susan K Sell•Private Power, Public Law•2003

  • Behind the Development Banks

    Sarah Babb, Sarah L Babb•Behind the Development Banks•2009

  • Hypocrisy Trap

    Catherine Weaver, Catherine E Weaver•Hypocrisy Trap•2008

  • The World Bank and Africa

    Gail Harrison, Graham Harrison•The World Bank and Africa•2004

  • Constructing World Culture

    John Boli, George M Thomas•Constructing World Culture•1999

  • From Smoke and Mirrors to Walking the Talk

    Patricia Bromley, Walter W Powell•Academy of Management Annals•2012

  • Political Economy and the Changing Global Order

    Open Access•Richard Stubbs, Geoffrey R D Underhill•Political Economy and the…•1994

  • World Society

    John W Meyer, Georg Krücken et al.•World society•1999

  • American Foundations

    Mark Dowie•American Foundations•2001

  • Development and Democracy in India

    Shalendra D Sharma•Development and Democracy in India•1999

  • Neverending Wars

    Ann Hironaka•Neverending Wars•2015

  • A Theory of Global Capitalism

    William I Robinson, William Robinson•A Theory of Global Capitalism•2004

  • Information Feudalism

    Peter Drahos, John Braithwaite•Information Feudalism•2017

  • A quarter century of neoliberal thinking in education

    Steven J Klees•Globalisation Societies and…•2008

  • Hegemony and Humanitarian Norms

    Open Access•Eric Bonds•Journal of World-Systems Research•2013

  • Nongovernmental Organizations, Democracy, and Deforestation

    John M Shandra, Louis Edgar Esparza et al.•Society & Natural Resources•2011

  • Do Commercial Debt‐for‐Nature Swaps Matter for Forests? A Cross‐National Test of World Polity Theory 1

    Open Access•John M Shandra, Michael Restivo et al.•Sociological Forum•2011

  • Ideas, interest and institutions in policy change

    Open Access•Ashutosh Varshney•Policy Sciences•1989

  • The Transnational Organization of Production and Uneven Environmental Degradation and Change in the World Economy

    Open Access•James Rice•International Journal of…•2009

  • The Institutionalization of Human Rights and its Discontents

    Open Access•Michael A Elliott•Cultural Sociology•2014

  • Politics and IMF Conditionality

    Open Access•Axel Dreher, Jan-Egbert Sturm et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2015

  • The Political Economy of Intellectual Property Protection

    Open Access•Kenneth C Shadlen, Andrew Schrank et al.•International Studies Quarterly•2005

  • Norms, culture, and world politics

    Open Access•Martha Finnemore•International Organization•1996

  • Between Faith and Science

    Stephen Carney, Jeremy Rappleye et al.•Comparative Education Review•2012

  • The Iron Cage Revisited

    P Dimaggio, Paul J Dimaggio et al.•American Sociological Review•1983

  • The Worldwide Expansion of Higher Education in the Twentieth Century

    Open Access•Evan Schofer, J W Meyer•American Sociological Review•2005

  • The Nation-State and the Natural Environment over the Twentieth Century

    D J Frank, Ann Hironaka et al.•American Sociological Review•2000

  • Seeds of Change

    N W Pirie, Lester R Brown•Population Studies•1971

  • Trustees of development from conditionality to governance

    Open Access•Lindsay Whitfield•The Journal of Modern African…•2005

  • Expulsions

    Sassen, Saskia Sassen•Expulsions•2014

  • Human Rights and the Triumph of the Individual in World Culture

    Open Access•Michael A Elliott•Cultural Sociology•2007

  • The World Bank, contradictory lending, and forests

    Open Access•Jamie M Sommer, Jamie Sommer et al.•International Sociology•2017

  • The Global Diffusion of Public Policies

    Frank Dobbins, Frank Dobbin et al.•Annual Review of Sociology•2007

  • World Society, Institutional Theories, and the Actor

    J W Meyer•Annual Review of Sociology•2010

  • Stanford School on Sociological Institutionalism

    Open Access•Didem Buhari Gulmez, Didem Buhari-Gulmez•International Political Sociology•2010

  • World Economy, World Society, and Environmental Harms in Less-Developed Countries

    Open Access•A K Jorgenson, Christopher W Dick et al.•Sociological Inquiry•2011

  • The Typical Tools for the Job

    Open Access•Marc Schneiberg, Elisabeth S Clemens•Sociological Theory•2006

  • The 'Actors' of Modern Society

    Open Access•J W Meyer, Ronald L Jepperson•Sociological Theory•2000

  • The Sacralization of the Individual

    Matthew Donald Mathias•American Journal of Sociology•2013

  • Human Rights in a Globalizing World

    Emilie M Hafner‐burton, Kiyoteru Tsutsui•American Journal of Sociology•2005

  • World Society and the Nation-State

    J W Meyer, John Boli et al.•American Journal of Sociology•1997

  • Decoupling reconsidered

    Open Access•Wesley Longhofer, A K Jorgenson et al.•Social Science Research•2017

  • Individual environmental concern in the world polity

    Open Access•Jennifer E Givens, A K Jorgenson•Social Science Research•2013

  • Institutional conditions for diffusion

    Open Access•David Strang, J W Meyer•Theory and Society•1993

Unique citing works15
Citations per year2,5
Citation span2020 - 2026 (7)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 14

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae