Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Crucible of Cultural Politics

Reworking "Development" in Zimbabwe's Eastern Highlands

Bibliographic Data

ID2467999
AuthorsDonald S Moore (University of California, Berkeley, corresponding author)
Year1999
Volume26
Issue3
Pages654-689
Publication date1999-08-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Ethnologist (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0094-0496 • E-ISSN: 1548-1425
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1525/ae.1999.26.3.654
OpenAlexW2077407341
LanguageEN
Citations received145
References cited127

In this article, I examine the cultural politics of development in a Zimbabwean resettlement scheme, situating state interventions in the deep histories of colonial efforts to discipline rural livelihoods. Popular memories of resistance to colonial conservation, shaped by transnational circuits and constitutive of Zimbabwean nationalism, animate the cultural idioms of entitlement and state power in the 1990s. The contingent micro-politics of agrarian struggle counter a recent tendency toward discursive determinism in anthropological perspectives on development. [development, cultural politics, practice, nationalism, spatiality, governmentality, southern Africa

Agrarian society · Colonialism · Entitlement (fair division · Governmentality · Livelihood · Nationalism · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Power (physics · Social science · Sociology · State (computer science · African history and culture studies · African studies and sociopolitical issues · Anthropological Studies and Insights · Gender Studies · History · Law

  • Refugees and Squatters

    David Mcdermott Hughes, David Hughes•Journal of Southern African Studies•1999

  • Reencountering Development

    Anthony J Bebbington, Anthony Bebbington•Annals of the Association of…•2000

  • Moral Orgasm and Productive Sex

    Open Access•Vincanne Adams•Sex in Development•2005

  • Simians, Savages, Skulls, and Sex

    Open Access•Zine Magubane•Race, Nature, and the Politics of…•2003

  • Moral Science and the Management of “Sexual Revolution” in Russia

    Open Access•M Rivkin-Fish•Sex in Development•2005

  • Family Planning, Human Nature, and the Ethical Subject of Sex in Urban Greece

    Open Access•Heather Paxson•Sex in Development•2005

  • Masyarakat Adat, Difference, and the Limits of Recognition in Indonesia’s Forest Zone.

    Open Access•Tania Murray Li•Race, Nature, and the Politics of…•2003

  • Beyond Ecoliberal “Common Futures”

    Giovanna Di Chiro•Race, Nature, and the Politics of…•2003

  • “Ordinary” Sex, Prostitutes, and Middle-Class Wives

    Open Access•Heather Dell, Heather S Dell•Sex in Development•2005

  • Sexuality, the State, and the Runaway Wives of Highlands Papua, Indonesia

    Open Access•Leslie Butt•Sex in Development•2005

  • Men in Paradise

    Open Access•Steven Gregory•Race, Nature, and the Politics of…•2003

  • Culture for biodiversity conservation? Untangling engagements with pastoralism in northern Kenya's private conservancies

    Open Access•Natalie D L York•Environment and Planning E Nature…•2026

  • Lessons in a bottle

    Open Access•Daniel Abrahams•Journal of International…•2022

  • Racial neoliberal philanthropy and the arts for social change

    Open Access•Adam Saifer•Organization•2023

  • Thinking with the Blood

    Open Access•Michael Watts•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2003

  • Spatial (re)organization and places of the Brao in southern Laos and northeastern Cambodia

    Open Access•Ian G Baird•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2009

  • Beyond antidevelopment

    Open Access•David Simon•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2007

  • “On the Raggedy Edge of Risk”

    Open Access•Bruce Braun•Race, Nature, and the Politics of…•2003

  • From Auntie to Disco

    Open Access•Shanti Parikh, Shanti A Parikh•Sex in Development•2005

  • Intimate Publics

    Robyn Wiegman•Race, Nature, and the Politics of…•2003

  • “The More You Kill the More You Will Live”

    Open Access•D M Nelson•Race, Nature, and the Politics of…•2003

  • The Kothi Wars

    Open Access•L Cohen•Sex in Development•2005

  • ‘Not Suspended in Mid-Air’

    Open Access•Alf Gunvald Nilsen•Social Movements in the Global…•2011

  • For the Love of a Good Dog

    Open Access•Donna Haraway•Race, Nature, and the Politics of…•2003

  • Colonial World of Postcolonial Historians and the Neoliberal Reinvention of Tribal Identity in India

    Open Access•Bhabani Shankar Nayak•Political Economy of Development…•2022

  • After the Great White Error … The Great Black Mirage

    Open Access•Paul Gilroy•Race, Nature, and the Politics of…•2003

  • Inventing the Heterozygote

    Open Access•Keith Wailoo•Race, Nature, and the Politics of…•2003

  • Globalizing the Facts of Life

    Open Access•Stacy Leigh Pigg•Sex in Development•2005

  • Pulp Fictions of Indigenism

    Open Access•Alcida Rita Ramos, Alcida Ramos•Race, Nature, and the Politics of…•2003

  • “There Is a Land Where Everything Is Pure”

    Open Access•Uli Linke•Race, Nature, and the Politics of…•2003

  • Uses and Pleasures

    Open Access•Vinh-Kim Nguyen•Sex in Development•2005

  • The Micropolitics of the Ban on Shahtoosh

    Open Access•Saloni Gupta•Contesting Conservation•2018

  • Localizing global sport for development

    Open Access•Iain Lindsey, Tess Kay et al.•Localizing global sport for…•2017

  • Development and the Life Story of a Thai Farmer Leader

    Open Access•Henry D Delcore•Ethnology•2004

  • Debating the Land Question in Africa

    Open Access•Sara Berry•Comparative Studies in Society…•2002

  • La Sécheresse

    Open Access•Kent Glenzer•Canadian Journal of African…•2002

  • Intimate Publics

    Robyn Wiegman•American Literature•2002

  • Development and Governmentality

    Open Access•Michael Watts•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2003

  • Resilience and the creative economy in Kingston, Jamaica

    Meaghan Frauts•Cultural Studies•2019

  • “Settlers” and Zimbabwe

    B Rutherford•Identities•2004

  • Locating the Political in Political Ecology

    Paulson, Susan Paulson et al.•Human Organization•2003

  • “They Are Not Understanding Sustainability”

    T Mcnamara•Human Organization•2017

  • Rezoned for Business

    Open Access•David Mcdermott Hughes, David Hughes•Journal of Agrarian Change•2001

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Emelie A Olson, ElizabethA Olson et al.•Conservation and Society•2014

  • Doing ′Conservation

    Open Access•KerryE Grimm•Conservation and Society•2013

  • Natures of concern

    Open Access•Gisselle Vila-Benites•The Extractive Industries and…•2022

  • The Influence of Context on Occupational Selection in Sport-for-Development

    Open Access•Janet Njelesani, Lauren Fehlings et al.•Societies•2016

  • Producing society or the self-producing of society? A study of an NGO’s difficult situation on poverty reduction

    Open Access•Feiyu Sun, Huijuan Chu et al.•Chinese Journal of Sociology•2017

  • The politics of rural access and settler colonialism

    Open Access•Thiruni Kelegama•Dialogues in Human Geography•2025

  • Governing rural Indonesia

    Tania Murray Li•Critical Policy Studies•2015

  • The story of blue pee

    Yoshiko Konishi•Critical Studies in Education•2009

  • Village politics, culture and community-driven development

    Open Access•Anthony J Bebbington, Anthony Bebbington et al.•Progress in Development Studies•2004

  • What to Expect When You Don’t Know What You are Expecting

    Open Access•Rob Goble, Edward R Carr et al.•American Journal of Evaluation•2022

  • Against the Current, From Below

    Alf Gunvald Nilsen•Journal of Poverty•2013

  • Discourses matter

    Open Access•Rong Fu, Ting Zuo et al.•Sustainable Development•2009

  • Subjects of Development

    Open Access•Karuna Morarji•European Journal of Development…•2014

  • Beyond Discourse and Competence

    Open Access•Roy Gigengack•European Journal of Development…•2014

  • Power, Resistance and Development in the Global South

    Open Access•Alf Gunvald Nilsen•International Journal of Politics…•2016

  • Introduction to symposium on rethinking farmer participation in agricultural development

    Open Access•Kent Glenzer, Nicole Peterson et al.•Agriculture and Human Values•2010

  • Gaborone is Growing like a Baby

    Open Access•Mieka S Ritsema•Africa Development•2011

  • (Post)development and Post-colonialism

    David Simon•Forum for Development Studies•2005

  • The Institutional Condition of Contested Hydropower

    Jerome Whitington•Forum for Development Studies•2012

  • On New Social Movements and ‘The Reinvention of India’

    Alf Gunvald Nilsen•Forum for Development Studies•2007

  • Development Eco-Logics

    Reade Davis•Studies in Political Economy•2003

  • Development critiques in the 1990s

    Open Access•Gillian Hart•Progress in Human Geography•2001

  • Jonathan Crush (1995) Power of Development

    Open Access•Gillian Hart•Progress in Human Geography•2016

  • Fragmented marginalities

    Open Access•Ritanjan Das, Nilotpal Kumar•The Journal of Peasant Studies•2024

  • Paper Works

    Open Access•Mattias Borg Rasmussen•World Development•2017

  • Development and divergent post-disaster trajectories in a mountain village

    Open Access•Mahmood Fayazi, E T Yeh et al.•World Development•2019

  • Conflict in abundance and peacebuilding in scarcity

    Open Access•Daniel Abrahams•World Development•2020

  • The negotiability of state legal and bureaucratic authority during land occupations in Zimbabwe

    Arnold Rangarirayi Chamunogwa, Arnold Chamunogwa•Review of African Political Economy•2019

  • Zimbabwean Farm Workers in Northern South Africa

    Open Access•B Rutherford, L Addison•Review of African Political Economy•2007

  • Strange powers

    Open Access•Michael L Cepek•Anthropology Today•2012

  • In the name of sovereignty

    Amanda Hammar•Journal of Contemporary African…•2008

  • This time it’s different

    Anna C Revette, Anna Revette•Third World Quarterly•2017

  • Colonised minds? Post-development theory and the desirability of development in Africa

    Sally Matthews•Third World Quarterly•2017

  • Foucault in the Landscape

    Luís Silva, Luís Miguel Sousa Silva•Landscape Research•2015

  • Performing Development in Street Markets

    Open Access•John Lauermann•Antipode•2012

  • The Duty of Water

    Open Access•Maira Hayat•Antipode•2024

  • Sentimental Capitalism in Contemporary India

    Open Access•Dia Da Costa•Antipode•2015

  • Pumpkins Just Got in There”

    Open Access•Guy Thompson•International Review of Social…•2010

  • Articulating sedimented subjectivities

    Open Access•Judith Verweijen, Sara Geenen et al.•Geoforum•2022

  • Grassland management and views of nature in China since 1949

    Open Access•Hong Jiang•Geoforum•2005

  • Hydrocarbons, popular protest and national imaginaries

    Open Access•T Perreault, Gabriela Valdivia•Geoforum•2010

  • Wetland conservation

    Open Access•Cerian Gibbes, James Southworth et al.•Geoforum•2008

  • Sustainable developmentality

    Open Access•Steven Orchard•Geoforum•2021

  • Cooperation, Land Use, and the Environment in Uxin Ju

    Hong Jiang•Annals of the Association of…•2004

  • Tropes of Indolence and the Cultural Politics of Development in Lhasa, Tibet

    E T Yeh•Annals of the Association of…•2007

  • Custom and Contradiction

    T Perreault•Annals of the Association of…•2008

  • Contested understandings of yaks on the eastern Tibetan Plateau

    Open Access•Gaerrang Gaerrang•Area•2017

  • The unbearable modernity of ‘development’? Canal irrigation and development planning in Western India

    Open Access•Vinay Gidwani•Progress in Planning•2002

  • Place-based understanding of Chilika fishery

    Kabita Baral•Environmental Sociology•2024

  • Imagined Borders

    Open Access•F Lu, Néstor L Silva et al.•Social Sciences•2015

  • Circular Migration and the Spaces of Cultural Assertion

    Vinay Gidwani, K Sivaramakrishnan•Annals of the Association of…•2003

  • Situating Zimbabwe's natural resource governance systems in history

    Open Access•A Mandondo, Mandondo A•2000

  • The Provocations of Neoliberalism

    Open Access•Gillian Hart•Antipode•2008

  • Geography and development

    Open Access•Gillian Hart•Progress in Human Geography•2004

  • Performative citizenship and the politics of scale

    Open Access•Farai Chipato•Political Geography•2021

  • Is Good Policy Unimplementable? Reflections on the Ethnography of Aid Policy and Practice

    Open Access•David Mosse•Development and Change•2004

  • State Making and the Politics of the Frontier in Central Benin

    Open Access•P Y Le Meur, Pierre-Yves Le Meur•Development and Change•2006

  • Guns and rain

    David Lan•Guns and rain•1985

  • The Roots of rural poverty in Central and Southern Africa

    Neil Parsons, Robin H Palmer•The Roots of rural poverty in…•1977

  • Land in African agrarian systems

    Donald Crummey, Thomas J Bassett•Land in African agrarian systems•1993

  • The social consequences of resettlement

    Elizabeth Colson•The social consequences of…•1971

  • Peasant consciousness and guerrilla war in Zimbabwe.

    Terence O Ranger•Peasant consciousness and…•1984

  • Peasants, traders, and wives

    Elizabeth Schmidt•Peasants, traders, and wives•1992

  • The Development dictionary

    Wolfgang Sachs•The Development dictionary•1992

  • The rise & fall of development theory

    Colin Leys•The rise & fall of development…•1996

  • This Fissured Land

    Madhav Gadgil, Ramachandra Guha•This Fissured Land Second Edition•2012

  • Governance and Development

    Open Access•R Ballard•International Encyclopedia of…•2017

  • Peasant and Nation

    Florencia E Mallon•Peasant and Nation•2023

  • Doctrines Of Development

    Michael Cowen, M P Cowen et al.•Doctrines Of Development•2003

  • Misreading the African Landscape

    Open Access•James Fairhead, Macedward Leach et al.•Misreading the African Landscape•1996

  • Crafting the Third World

    Joseph L Love•Crafting the Third World•1996

  • State Politics in Zimbabwe

    Jeffrey Herbst•State Politics in Zimbabwe•1990

  • The surplus people

    Cherryl Walker, Laurine Platzky•The surplus people•1985

  • Economy and society in pre-industrial South Africa

    Anthony Atmore, Shula Marks•Economy and society in…•1980

  • Europe and the people without history

    Eric R Wolf•Europe and the people without…•1982

  • A Preponderance of Power

    Melvyn P Leffler•A Preponderance of Power•1992

  • Peasant Intellectuals

    Steven Feierman, Steven M Feierman•Peasant Intellectuals•1990

  • The Dual Mandate in British Tropical Africa

    Lord Frederick J D Lugard, Frederick John Dealtry Baron Lugard•Dual Mandate in British Tropical…•2013

  • Power of Development

    J Crush•Power of Development•2005

  • America's Egypt

    Tim Mitchell•Middle East Report•1991

  • From African Socialism to Scientific Capitalism

    James Ferguson•Debating Development Discourse•1995

  • The Imperial Impact

    Geoff Simons•Cuba•1996

  • Africa's Colonial Legacy

    Crawford Young•Strategies for African Development•1986

  • Marxism, Ideology and Literature

    Open Access•Cliff Slaughter•Marxism, Ideology and Literature•1980

  • Transforming the Indonesian Uplands

    Tania Li•Transforming the Indonesian uplands•2005

  • Involuntary Migration and Resettlement

    Art Hansen, Anthony Oliver-Smith•Involuntary Migration and…•2019

  • Transition to Modernity

    Open Access•Colin Renfrew, Ernest Gellner et al.•Transition to Modernity•1992

  • Territory and State Power in Latin America

    Open Access•David Slater•Territory and State Power in…•1989

  • Zimbabwe's Guerrilla War

    Open Access•Norma Kriger, Norma J Kriger•Zimbabwe's guerrilla war•1991

  • Gramsci's Political Thought

    Carlos Nelson Coutinho•Gramsci's political thought•2012

  • Anthropological Approaches to Resettlement

    Michael M Cernea, Scott E Guggenheim•Anthropological Approaches to…•2019

  • Reflections on Development in Southeast Asia

    Lim Teck Ghee•Reflections on Development in…•1988

  • Uncertain terms

    Faye Ginsburg•Choice Reviews Online•1991

  • Colonialism and Culture

    Open Access•Nicholas B Dirks, Nicholas Dirks•Colonialism and culture•1992

  • Tensions of Empire

    Frederick Cooper, Ann Laura Stoler•Tensions of Empire•1997

  • An Anthropological Critique of Development

    Mark Hobart•An Anthropological Critique of…•2002

  • Ethnography through Thick and Thin

    George E Marcus•Ethnography Through Thick and Thin•1999

  • Water Used to be Scattered in the Landscape

    K B Wilson, Kirsty Wilson•Environment and History•1995

  • Coercing conservation

    Open Access•Nancy Lee Peluso•Global Environmental Change•1993

  • Western hegemony over african agriculture in Southern Rhodesia and its continuing threat to food security in independent zimbabwe

    Open Access•Sam Page, Sam L J Page et al.•Agriculture and Human Values•1991

  • Agrarian Change from above

    Victor E M Machingaidze•The International Journal of…•1991

  • Development narratives, or making the best of blueprint development

    Open Access•Emma Roe, Emery M Roe•World Development•1991

  • Implementing strategies for the rural economy

    Open Access•Robert E Christiansen•World Development•1993

  • False forest history, complicit social analysis

    Open Access•James Fairhead, Macedward Leach et al.•World Development•1995

  • The conservation issue in Zimbabwe

    Open Access•Lionel Cliffe•Review of African Political Economy•1988

  • The Governance of the Third World

    Open Access•Marc Dubois•Alternatives Global Local Political•1991

  • Discourse and Power in Development

    Open Access•Arturo Escobar•Alternatives Global Local Political•1984

  • Are There Histories of Peoples Without Europe? A Review Article

    Open Access•Talal Asad•Comparative Studies in Society…•1987

  • Sensual Surfaces and Stylistic Excess

    Open Access•Cathy Schwichtenberg•Journal of Communication Inquiry•1986

  • The Problem of Ideology-Marxism without Guarantees

    Open Access•Stuart Hall•Journal of Communication Inquiry•1986

  • On Postmodernism and Articulation

    Open Access•L Grossberg•Journal of Communication Inquiry•1986

  • The Imperial Impact

    Patrick Manning, Clive Dewey et al.•African Economic History•1979

  • Post-Cold War capitalism

    Mark T Berger•Third World Quarterly•1995

  • Europe between the Super Powers

    Charles R Foster, Anton W DePorte et al.•The Western Political Quarterly•1980

  • Modernist discourse and the crisis of development theory

    Open Access•Kate Manzo•Studies in Comparative…•1991

  • Uprooting poverty

    Colin Stoneman•International Affairs•1990

  • Reimagining the Geopolitics of Development

    David Slater•Transactions of the Institute of…•1994

  • Nationalizing the local past in Sri Lanka

    Open Access•Michael D Woost•American Ethnologist•1993

  • Depression, Dust Bowl, Demography, and Drought

    David Anderson, David L Anderson•African Affairs•1984

  • Development I

    Open Access•M Watts, Michael J Watts•Progress in Human Geography•1993

  • Postcolonial Developments

    Akhil Gupta•Postcolonial Developments•1998

  • Paradigms and politics

    Open Access•Allan Hoben•World Development•1995

  • Images of Community

    Open Access•Tania Murray Li•Development and Change•1996

  • Technical development and peasant impoverishment

    Michael Drinkwater, M J Drinkwater•Journal of Southern African Studies•1989

  • Scottish missionaries, evangelical discourses and the origins of conservation thinking in Southern Africa 1820-1900

    Richard Grove•Journal of Southern African Studies•1989

  • Maps, names, and ethnic games

    Eric Worby•Journal of Southern African Studies•1994

  • Soil erosion, conservationism and ideas about development

    W Beinart•Journal of Southern African Studies•1984

  • Peasants, businessmen, and moral economy in the Chiweshe reserve, colonial Zimbabwe, 1930-1968

    Leslie Bessant, Elvis Muringai•Journal of Southern African Studies•1993

  • Culture, Voice and Development

    Open Access•Ashis Nandy, Leonard Frank et al.•Thesis Eleven•1994

  • On Development Theory and the Warren Thesis

    Open Access•David Slater•Environment and Planning D…•1987

  • Understandings of 'Development

    Open Access•Kate Crehan, Achim Von Oppen•Sociologia Ruralis•1988

  • Colonialism and Development

    Peter Cain, Michael Havinden et al.•The Economic History Review•1994

  • The Origin and Course of Fabian Colonialism in Africa

    Open Access•Michael Cowen, Robert Shenton•Journal of Historical Sociology•1991

  • The New Cultural Politics of Difference

    Cornel West•October•1990

  • Giving Orders in Rural Southern Rhodesia

    Carol Summers•The International Journal of…•1998

  • Coercive Development

    Leonard Leslie Bessant•The International Journal of…•1992

  • The White Man's Task in Tropical Africa

    Frederick D Lugard•Foreign Affairs•1926

  • The Phantom Gringo Boat

    Bartholomew Dean, Kane et al.•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•1996

  • Imagining a Post-Development Era? Critical Thought, Development and Social Movements

    Arturo Escobar•Social Text•1992

  • Seeing Like a State

    James C Scott•Seeing Like a State•2017

  • The Anthropology of Colonialism

    P Pels•Annual Review of Anthropology•1997

  • Ecological Change and the Politics of African Land Use

    P Richards•African Studies Review•1983

  • Colonial Governmentality

    Diane L Scott, David Scott•Social Text•1995

  • Production and Autonomy

    David Harrison, John W Bennett et al.•Man•1990

  • Forever Gained

    Open Access•Bill Kinsey, B H Kinsey•Africa•1982

  • Subaltern Struggles and the Politics of Place

    Open Access•Donald S Moore•Cultural Anthropology•1998

  • The Credible and the Credulous

    Open Access•Stacy Leigh Pigg•Cultural Anthropology•1996

  • Power and Visibility

    Open Access•Arturo Escobar•Cultural Anthropology•1988

  • Discourse, Politics, and the Development Process

    Open Access•P D Little, Michael Painter•American Ethnologist•1995

  • Blurred Boundaries

    Open Access•Akhil Gupta•American Ethnologist•1995

  • Anthropology and the development encounter

    Open Access•Arturo Escobar•American Ethnologist•1991

  • Rituals of Development

    Open Access•N Serena Tennekoon•American Ethnologist•1988

  • The Fractured Community

    Open Access•James A Pritchett, James Pritchett•American Anthropologist•1998

  • The Politics of Difference

    Open Access•Begoña Aretxaga•American Anthropologist•1997

  • Whose Cultural Studies

    Open Access•Renato Rosaldo•American Anthropologist•1994

  • Peasant and Nation

    Paul J Vanderwood, Florencia E Mallon•Hispanic American Historical Review•1996

  • Gender and Land Reform

    Open Access•Susie Jacob, Susie Jacobs•International Sociology•1992

Unique citing works145
Citations per year5,37
Citation span1999 - 2026 (28)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 143

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae