Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Truth in Motion

The Recursive Anthropology of Cuban Divination

Bibliographic Data

ID2686912
AuthorsMartin Holbraad (corresponding author)
Year2012
Pages344
Publication date2012-01-01
Open AccessNo
TypeBOOK
VenueTruth in motion (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherUniversity of Chicago Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.7208/chicago/9780226349220.001.0001
OpenAlexW4234779487
Open LibraryOL25046501M
ISBN9780226349220
LanguageEN
Citations received211

In Truth in Motion, Martin Holbraad takes on the challenge of explaining why Cuban diviners, when consulting the deities orisha, sometimes appear to produce demonstrably false statements. Rather than dismissing such statements as evidence of faulty reasoning, Holbraad argues that they are in fact generative of truth. He draws on ethnographic fieldwork among Cuban Ifá and Santería practitioners to develop a radical, practice-based theory of truth. Holbraad contends that truth is not something that simply corresponds to a given state of affairs but is rather something brought about through specific practices. Divination, he shows, is a recursive practice in which the orisha's pronouncements are not simply descriptive but actively shape the reality they describe. This recursive process, Holbraad argues, is not unique to divination but is a fundamental aspect of human existence. Truth in Motion offers a provocative new approach to anthropological theory and the study of religion, challenging conventional notions of truth, representation, and the nature of ethnographic knowledge

Computer vision · Motion (physics) · Artificial Intelligence · Computer Science · Educational Leadership and Practices · History and Developments in Astronomy · Space Science and Extraterrestrial Life · Cuba · Divination · Ifa (Religion) · Religion

  • Thinking the Problematic

    Open Access•Erich Hörl, Didier Debaise et al.•Thinking the Problematic•2020

  • Color, Song, and Choice Diction

    Open Access•Nicholas J Mizer•Tabletop Role-Playing Games and…•2019

  • Ritual language

    Open Access•David Tavárez•Cambridge Handbook of Linguistic…•2014

  • All the Difference in the World

    Open Access•Paolo Heywood•Philosophy of the Social Sciences•2020

  • Vérité révélée, vérité cachée

    Open Access•J Robbins, Emir Mahieddin•Revue des sciences sociales•2022

  • Adaptation Lived as a Story

    Open Access•Nicole Klenk•Nature and Culture•2018

  • Musicalizing death

    Open Access•Gabriel Torrealba•Desde el Sur Revista de Ciencias…•2026

  • Indigenous Sámi

    Open Access•Britt Kramvig, Solveig Joks et al.•The International Encyclopedia of…•2022

  • Matter

    Open Access•Christopher Witmore•The International Encyclopedia of…•2021

  • New perspective on place and social memory

    Open Access•Vikas Rana, Rajni Devi•SN Social Sciences•2026

  • Reflecting on metaphors and the possibilities of ‘language change’ in teaching and teacher education

    Open Access•Zvi Bekerman, M Zembylas•European Journal of Teacher…•2025

  • Beyond Nature and Culture? / Anapus Gamtos Ir Kultūros

    Open Access•Davide Scarso•Creativity Studies•2014

  • Assemblages, relationality and recursivity. Comments on ‘Archaeology and contemporaneity’ by Gavin Lucas

    Open Access•Andrew Meirion Jones•Archaeological Dialogues•2015

  • Ethnophilology and Colonial Demonology

    Tomás Bartoletti•Global Intellectual History•2020

  • Hope that sustains

    Open Access•Stephen Robertson•Contemporary Japan•2016

  • Revolutionary securitization

    Open Access•Martin Holbraad, M A Pedersen•International Theory•2012

  • From ethnocentrism to policy-centrism

    T Friberg•Ethnography & Education•2017

  • At the Crossroads

    Open Access•Dawn M Rutecki•Archaeologies•2022

  • On the problem of continuity

    Open Access•Paolo Heywood, T Yarrow•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2025

  • Miraculous Evidence

    Yunus Doğan Telliel•Comparative Studies of South Asia…•2019

  • The Black Atlantic Metaphysics of Azealia Banks

    Open Access•E Pérez•Hypatia•2021

  • Caribbean stones and the creation of early-modern worlds

    Pablo F Gómez•History and Technology•2018

  • Fil.le.s de saint » versus « pères du secret »

    Open Access•Emma Gobin•L Homme•2021

  • As perceived, not as known

    W Mccarty•Interdisciplinary Science Reviews•2021

  • A Transforming Ontology of Boundaries? What Is and What Is Not in the Early Middle Kingdom

    Open Access•Anna-Latifa Mourad•The Journal of Egyptian Archaeology•2024

  • Ways to Be Understood

    Open Access•Akos Sivado•Philosophy of the Social Sciences•2020

  • The Shapes of Relations

    Open Access•Martin Holbraad•Philosophy of the Social Sciences•2020

  • Anthropological Epochés

    Open Access•M A Pedersen•Philosophy of the Social Sciences•2020

  • The Animation of Nature and the Nature of Animation—The Life of Made Objects from the “Record of Tool Specters” to the “Night Parade of Hundred Demons”

    Open Access•Fabio Gygi•Religions•2025

  • Religion, Globalization, and Universalism

    K Rio•The Oxford Handbook of the…•2026

  • Death and the Construction of Social Space

    Open Access•Yanique Hume•Passages & afterworlds•2018

  • “The Dead Don’t Come Back Like the Migrant Comes Back”

    Open Access•Paul Christopher Johnson•Passages & afterworlds•2018

  • Plural Entirety

    Allen Abramson•The Oxford Handbook of the…•2026

  • Belief

    Jon P Mitchell•The Oxford Handbook of the…•2026

  • Afterword

    Open Access•Aisha Khan•Passages & afterworlds•2018

  • Political Geology

    Open Access•Adam Bobbette, Amy Donovan•Political Geology•2019

  • Opening Up Relations

    Open Access•M Strathern•World of Many Worlds•2018

  • Of Vital Spirit and Precarious Bodies in Amerindian Socialities

    Open Access•George Mentore•Passages & afterworlds•2018

  • Praktyki lecznicze w prawosławnych monasterach w Bułgarii. Perspektywa antropologii (post)sekularnej

    Magdalena Lubanska•Praktyki lecznicze w prawosławnych…•2019

  • Visual Trust

    R Canals•Anthrovision•2020

  • Position multisituée et récursivité

    Open Access•Anne-Christine Trémon•Ateliers d anthropologie•2023

  • Experiencing presence

    Open Access•Anna I Corwin, Cordelia Erickson‐davi•Hau Journal of Ethnographic Theory•2020

  • Secularism's Names

    Open Access•J Copeman•South Asia Multidisciplinary…•2015

  • Encounters, Trajectories, and the Ethnographic Moment

    Atsuro Morita•East Asian Science Technology and…•2017

  • Res(s)sent(i)ment

    Jürgen Schaflechner, Sjoerd Van Tuinen•Cultural Politics an International…•2025

  • Res(s)ent(i)ment and Nonaffirmative Creativity

    Jürgen Schaflechner•Cultural Politics an International…•2025

  • Experimenting with political materials

    C B Jensen•Distinktion Journal of Social…•2015

  • Disciplinary (Per)Mutations of Ethnography

    Open Access•Thomas F Carter•Culture Studies ↔ Critical…•2018

  • Ontology, 'hauntology' and the 'turn' that keeps anthropology turning

    Open Access•Vassos Argyrou•History of the Human Sciences•2016

  • Portraits, Gifts and Exchange Valuation in Xlendi Bay, Malta

    Open Access•Paola Juan•Visual Anthropology•2022

  • Introducción al dossier

    Open Access•F Tola•Etnografica•2020

  • La espiritualidad como colador

    Open Access•A Dos Santos•Etnografica•2020

  • Temporalization and Ethical Action

    Open Access•Jarrett Zigon•Journal of Religious Ethics•2014

  • Missing the (question) mark? What is a turn to ontology

    Open Access•Steve Woolgar, Javier Lezaun•Social Studies of Science•2015

  • Góry Ałtaju nie mają duchów. Etnografia poza człowiekiem

    Open Access•A Halemba•Etnografia Polska•2022

  • A Decolonial Imagination

    Open Access•M Savransky•Sociology•2017

  • The Subterranean Unsettling of Science, Race, and Religion

    Open Access•Brent Crosson•Comparative Studies in Society…•2024

  • When Is a Thing? Transduction and Immediacy in Afro-Cuban Ritual; or, ANT in Matanzas, Cuba, Summer of 1948

    Open Access•Stephan Palmié•Comparative Studies in Society…•2018

  • Care and choice in dealing with the invasive cane toad in Western Australia

    Open Access•J R Nyquist•The Australian Journal of…•2014

  • Five Limits to Current Autoethnography

    D Sausdal, H Vigh et al.•Current Anthropology•2026

  • The ontological antinomy

    Open Access•T Bartole•Hau Journal of Ethnographic Theory•2020

  • Cosmologies

    Open Access•Allen Abramson•The International Encyclopedia of…•2018

  • Human substances and ontological transformations in the African-inspired ritual complex of Palo Monte in Cuba

    D E Santos, Diana Espírito Santo et al.•Critical African Studies•2013

  • Comparison in Anthropology

    Open Access•M Candea•Comparison in Anthropology•2018

  • Anthropology on trial

    Open Access•Olaf Zenker•International Journal of Law in…•2016

  • It's your family that kills you

    Open Access•E Strange, Stuart Earle Strange•Comparative Studies in Society…•2018

  • Post-Hellenistic Perspectives on Divination, the Individual, and the Cosmos

    Open Access•Elsa Giovanna Simonetti•Social Analysis•2021

  • Tukdam, Different Ontological Bodies, and Making Tibetan Deaths Visible

    Open Access•Donagh Coleman•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•2025

  • Prayer as a History

    Open Access•D Henig•Social Analysis•2017

  • Between Two Truths

    Open Access•Naoki Kasuga•Social Analysis•2017

  • Reflective Ontology and Intuitive Credibility in Chinese Six Lines Prediction

    Open Access•W Matthews•Social Analysis•2021

  • New ontologies? Reflections on some recent ‘turns’ in STS, anthropology and philosophy

    Open Access•C B Jensen, A Ballestero et al.•Social Anthropology•2017

  • Anthropological Entrapments

    Open Access•Alberto Corsín Jiménez•Social Analysis•2021

  • Assemblage Making, Materiality, and Self in Cuban Palo Monte

    Open Access•D E Santos, Diana Espírito Santo•Social Analysis•2018

  • Ingesting indenture

    Martin A Tsang, Martin Tsang•History and Anthropology•2023

  • Beyond Oracular Ambiguity

    Open Access•Olaf Almqvist•Social Analysis•2021

  • Conceptualisations of Legal Otherness in Asylum Evidentiary Practices

    Open Access•Tomáš Ledvinka•Czech Sociological Review•2023

  • The contribution of the ontological turn in education

    M Zembylas•Educational Philosophy and Theory•2017

  • Arqueologia do Axé

    Open Access•Luciana De Castro Nunes Novaes•Vestígios - Revista Latino-American…•2022

  • Territorio relacional (TR)

    Open Access•Ricardo Lozano, José Arturo Méndez et al.•Maguaré•2023

  • Learning to learn in candomblé

    Luana Marques•Religion•2022

  • Pneumatologie und die Konstituierung soziospiritueller Gemeinschaften

    Open Access•Thomas G Kirsch•KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für…•2013

  • Retóricas del momento

    Open Access•Miguel Ángel Ruiz, Albert Moncusí Ferré•Disparidades. Revista de…•2018

  • Anthropology of Science

    Francesca Rochberg•Journal of Near Eastern Studies•2019

  • Knut G. Nustad

    Open Access•B E Bertelsen•Norsk antropologisk tidsskrift•2017

  • Kritisk realistisk antropologi - eksemplifisering av et ikke-konflatorisk perspektiv

    Open Access•Eldar Bråten•Norsk antropologisk tidsskrift•2016

  • Naturalisering på langs og tvers

    Open Access•Kathinka Frøystad•Norsk antropologisk tidsskrift•2015

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Mette M High, Jessica M Smith•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2019

  • An ethics of dwelling and a politics of world‐building

    Open Access•Jarrett Zigon•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2014

  • Ontological Conflicts and the Stories of Peoples in Spite of Europe

    M Blaser•Current Anthropology•2013

  • Présentation

    F Laugrand, Frédéric B Laugrand et al.•Anthropologie et Sociétés•2018

  • Paradigm Lost

    Gavin Lucas, Christopher Witmore•Norwegian Archaeological Review•2022

  • Ontological complexity of interpolity orders

    Open Access•Inho Choi, Minju Kwon•European Journal of International…•2025

  • Posthumanism, New Humanism and Beyond

    Open Access•Guillermo Díaz De Liaño, Manuel Fernández-Götz•Cambridge Archaeological Journal•2021

  • Roads that Separate

    M A Pedersen, Mikkel Bunkenborg•Mobilities•2012

  • Worlding a Mbya-Guarani heritage

    Rodrigo Lacerda•International Journal of Heritage…•2021

  • Religions de l'Afrique noire (ethnologie)

    Open Access•M Houseman•Annuaire - Ecole pratique des…•2019

  • Jeanne Favret-Saada's Minimal Ontology

    Open Access•T Kyriakides•Religion and Society•2016

  • The Vanishing Power Plant

    Open Access•M A Pedersen•The Cambridge Journal of…•2017

  • Detachment, hesitation, indifference

    Open Access•A Piette•Studies in Religion/Sciences…•2024

Unique citing works211
Citations per year14,07
Citation span2011 - 2026 (16)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 210

Tools

Open DOILibgen
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae