Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Explaining Article-Possessor Complementarity

Economic Motivation in Noun Phrase Syntax

Bibliographic Data

ID2899006
AuthorsMartin Haspelmath (0000-0003-2100-8493, Max Planck Society, corresponding author)
Year1999
Volume75
Issue2
Pages227
Publication date1999-06-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueLanguage (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0097-8507 • E-ISSN: 1535-0665
PublisherJSTOR (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.2307/417260
OpenAlexW1999446944
LanguageEN
Citations received41
References cited24

In many languages the definite article cannot occur when a possessive phrase is present in the NP (e.g. English the my book, John's the book). I argue that these patterns can be understood in terms of economic motivation because possessed NPs are very likely to be definite. A structural explanation in terms of a unique determiner position is insufficient to account for the full range of attested crosslinguistic patterns, and the universal generalizations that do seem to be valid can be derived from the economy-based explanation. Finally I show how the performance motivation of economy creates the competence pattern in diachronic change

Complementarity (molecular biology) · Determiner phrase · Linguistics · Natural language processing · Noun · Noun phrase · Phrase · Syntax · Computer Science · Language, Discourse, Communication Strategies · Linguistic Variation and Morphology · Philosophy · Syntax, Semantics, Linguistic Variation

  • Does linguistic explanation presuppose linguistic description

    Martin Haspelmath•Studies in Language•2004

  • The Possessive NP Construction

    Open Access•Mira Ariel•Proceedings of the Annual Meeting…•2002

  • The semantics of possessives

    Open Access•Stanley Peters, Dag Westerståhl•Language•2013

  • Possessive Constructions in Egyptian and Coptic. Distribution, Definiteness, and the Construct State Phenomenon

    Barbara Egedi•Zeitschrift für Ägyptische…•2010

  • Competing motivations for the ordering of main and adverbial clauses

    Open Access•Holger Diessel•Linguistics•2005

  • Against markedness (and what to replace it with)

    Open Access•Martin Haspelmath•Journal of Linguistics•2006

  • The Oxford handbook of case

    A L MalÊ1chukov, Andrej L Malchukov et al.•The Oxford handbook of case•2008

  • Alignment and Alignment Change in the Indo-European Family

    Eystein Dahl•Alignment and Alignment Change in…•2022

  • Europäische Besitzungen. Zur gespaltenen Possession im europäischen Sprachvergleich

    Open Access•Tilo Stolz, Thomas Stolz•Deutsch im Sprachvergleich•2012

  • Cross-Linguistic Variation and Efficiency

    Open Access•John A Hawkins•Cross-Linguistic Variation and…•2014

  • Exploring the Syntax-Semantics Interface

    Open Access•Robert D Van Valin, Jr Robert D Van Valin et al.•Exploring the Syntax-Semantics…•2005

  • Armenian morphosyntactic alignment in diachrony

    Robin Meyer•Alignment and Alignment Change in…•2022

  • Case In Iranian

    Donald Stilo•The Oxford handbook of case•2012

  • Latin Word Order

    A M Devine, Laurence D Stephens•Latin word order•2006

  • Three Typological Differences Between the North and the West Germanic DPs

    Open Access•Dorian Roehrs•Journal of Germanic Linguistics•2019

  • Concept Types and Determination

    Sebastian Löbner•Journal of Semantics•2011

  • Dem Vater sein Hut – Der Charme des Substandards und wie wir ihm gerecht werden

    Gisela Zifonun•Deutsche Sprache•2003

  • Nominal and pronominal gender

    Thomas Berg•Language Typology and Universals•2020

  • Referentiality and modifiability of incorporated nouns

    Open Access•Marieke Olthof•Language Typology and Universals•2020

  • Determination and the expression of definiteness in indigenous languages of the Americas – an introduction

    Alejandra Vidal•Language Typology and Universals•2025

  • On expanding accountability in the study of genitive variation

    Open Access•Anette Rosenbach•English Language and Linguistics•2025

  • Efficiency in shaping grammars

    Open Access•Xiaolong Yang, Yicheng Wu•Pragmatics and Society•2021

  • I broke a finger”

    Jori Lindley•Intercultural Pragmatics•2015

  • New insights into an old form

    Open Access•Martin Elsig•Language Variation and Change•2017

  • Animacy Versus Weight as Determinants of Grammatical Variation in English

    Open Access•Anette Rosenbach•Language•2005

  • The Circle That Won’t Come Full

    Open Access•Maria Koptjevskaja-Tamm•Linguistic Areas•2006

  • Grammar is Grammar and Usage is Usage

    Open Access•Frederick J Newmeyer•Language•2003

  • Some issues concerning optîmality and diachronic adaptation

    Open Access•Martin Haspelmath, Martin Haspelmath Martin Haspelmath•Zeitschrift für Sprachwissenschaft•1999

  • Why can't we talk to each other

    Open Access•Martin Haspelmath•Lingua•2000

  • Explaining grammatical coding asymmetries

    Open Access•Martin Haspelmath•Journal of Linguistics•2021

  • Possessive adjectives with and without articles

    Riccardo Regis•Linx•2022

  • English possessive ’s

    Open Access•John J Lowe•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2016

  • Description and determination in Tanti Dargwa NPs

    Open Access•Y Lander•Linguistics•2022

  • Prenominal possessives in Yiddish

    Open Access•Dorian Roehrs•Linguistics•2022

  • Discourse, grammar, discourse

    Open Access•Mira Ariel•Discourse Studies•2009

  • Possessed properties in Ulwa

    Open Access•Andrew Koontz-Garboden, Andrew Koontz‐garboden et al.•Natural Language Semantics•2010

  • Donkey Demonstratives

    Open Access•Barbara Abbott•Natural Language Semantics•2002

  • Descriptive and discourse-referential modifiers in a layered model of the noun phrase

    Open Access•Jan Rijkhoff•Linguistics•2008

  • Connecting the typology and semantics of nominal possession

    Open Access•Albert Ortmann•Morphology•2018

  • Frequency and serial order

    Open Access•Thomas Berg•Linguistics•2018

  • Interaction of verbal categories

    Open Access•Andrej Malchukov•Linguistics•2011

  • Typology and Universals

    Open Access•William Croft•Typology and Universals•2002

  • Functionalism and Grammar

    Talmy Givón•Functionalism and grammar•1995

  • Two Functional Categories in Noun Phrases

    Elizabeth Ritter•Perspectives on Phrase Structure:…•1991

  • The temporal structure of spoken language understanding

    Open Access•William Marslen-Wilson, William D Marslen‐Wilson et al.•Cognition•1980

  • A Comprehensive grammar of the English language

    Geoffrey N Leech, Jan Svartvik et al.•A Comprehensive grammar of the…•1985

  • Grundriß der deutschen Grammatik

    Open Access•Peter Eisenberg•Grundriß der deutschen Grammatik•1989

  • Samoan Reference Grammar

    Kenneth William Cook, Ulrike Mosel et al.•Oceanic Linguistics•1994

  • Auf dem Wege zu einer Theorie des Sprachwandels

    Helmut Ludtke•Kommunikationstheoretische…•1979

  • Grundzüge einer deutschen Grammatik

    Gerhart Lindner•Grundlagen und Anwendung der…•1981

  • Definiteness and the Processing of Noun Phrases in Natural Discourse

    Kari Fraurud•Journal of Semantics•1990

  • Definite Possessives and Discourse Novelty

    Chris Barker•Theoretical Linguistics•2000

  • A Grammar of Vai

    Charles S Bird, William E Welmers•Language•1978

  • The Syntactic Phenomena of English

    Andrew Rosta, James D Mccawley•Language•2000

  • A Performance Theory of Order and Constituency

    Open Access•Michael A Covington, John A Hawkins•Performance Theory of Order and…•1995

  • On Language Change

    Reyes I Fidalgo, Rudi Keller•Language•1997

  • Reference Grammar of Amharic

    Sharon Rose, Wolf Leslau•Language•1996

  • The syntax of English genitive constructions

    Open Access•Christopher Lyons•Journal of Linguistics•1986

  • Phrase structure and directionality in Irish

    Open Access•Thomas Ernst•Journal of Linguistics•1992

  • Possessives and the distinction between determiners and modifiers (with special reference to German)

    Open Access•Frans Plank•Journal of Linguistics•1992

  • On (in)definite articles

    Open Access•John A Hawkins•Journal of Linguistics•1991

  • Thoughts on grammaticalization

    Open Access•Christian Lehmann•Thoughts on grammaticalization•2015

  • Some Functions of the Initial Vowel in Nkore-Kiga

    Open Access•Charles V Taylor•Linguistics•1972

  • Iconic and Economic Motivation

    John Haiman•Language•1983

Unique citing works41
Citations per year1,52
Citation span1999 - 2025 (27)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 35

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae