Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

On the Locality and Motivation of Move and Agree

An Even More Minimal Theory

Bibliographic Data

ID3200232
AuthorsZeljko Boskovic (University of Connecticut, corresponding author)
Year2007
Volume38
Issue4
Pages589-644
Publication date2007-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueLinguistic Inquiry (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0024-3892 • E-ISSN: 1530-9150
PublisherMIT Press - Journals (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1162/ling.2007.38.4.589
OpenAlexW2160708028
LanguageEN
Citations received155
References cited60

The article proposes a new theory of successive-cyclic movement that reconciles the early and the current minimalist approaches to it. As in the early approach, there is no feature checking in intermediate positions of successive-cyclic movement. However, as in the current approach and unlike in early minimalism, successive-cyclic movement starts before the final target of movement enters the structure, and Form Chain is eliminated. The locality of Move and the locality of Agree are shown to be radically different, Agree being free from several mechanisms that constrain Move, namely, phases and the Activation Condition. However, there is no need to take phases to define locality domains of syntax or to posit the Activation Condition as an independent principle. They still hold empirically for Move as theorems. The Generalized EPP (the "I need a Spec" property of attracting heads) and the Inverse Case Filter are also dispensable. The traditional Case Filter, stated as a checking requirement, is the sole driving force of A-movement. More generally, Move is always driven by a formal inadequacy (an uninterpretable feature) of the moving element, while Agree is target driven. The system resolves a lookahead problem that arises under the EPP-driven movement approach, where the EPP diacritic indicating that X moves is placed on Y, not X, although X often needs to start moving before Y enters the structure

Computer vision · Distinctive feature · Epistemology · Feature (linguistics) · Filter (signal processing) · Geometry · Inverse · Linguistics · Locality · Minimalism (technical communication) · Minimalist program · Movement (music) · Physics · Principle of locality · Property (philosophy) · Pure mathematics · Quantum nonlocality · Syntax · Artificial Intelligence · Computer Science · Logic, programming, and type systems · Mathematics · Philosophy · semigroups and automata theory · Syntax, Semantics, Linguistic Variation

  • O sincretismo passivo-reflexivo

    Open Access•João Paulo Lazzarini Cyrino, João Paulo Lazzarini-Cyrino•2015

  • The Structure of the Determiner Phrase in Moroccan Arabic

    Open Access•Ayoub Zrari, Zrari Ayoub•International Journal of…•2023

  • A relativized probing approach to person encoding in local scenarios

    Dieter Georgi, Doreen Georgi•Linguistic Variation•2012

  • The relationship between subject position, focus and agreement in passive constructions in Brazilian Portuguese

    Open Access•Leonor Simioni•Estudos da língua(gem•2010

  • A note on Wh-islands and Finite Control in Brazilian Portuguese

    Open Access•Jairo Nunes•Estudos da língua(gem•2010

  • The Rise of an Indefinite Article in Polish

    Open Access•Krzysztof Hwaszcz, Hanna KÄ dzierska et al.•Studies in Polish Linguistics•2018

  • On the Unmarked Position for Greek Subjects

    Open Access•George Kotzoglou•Journal of Greek Linguistics•2013

  • Null operators, ellipsis, and scrambling

    Open Access•Masanori Nakamura•Acta Linguistica Hungarica•2016

  • Rise of the Auxiliaries

    William Harwood•The Linguistic Review•2014

  • A derivational ellipsis approach to ATB-movement

    Martin Salzmann•The Linguistic Review•2012

  • SNAP judgments

    Kyle Mahowald, Peter Graff et al.•Language•2016

  • A Minimalist Analysis of Coordination

    Open Access•Shin Oshima, Katsunori Kotani•ENGLISH LINGUISTICS•2008

  • The Oxford handbook of case

    A L MalÊ1chukov, Andrej L Malchukov et al.•The Oxford handbook of case•2008

  • Merging features

    Jill De Villiers, Smith College et al.•Merging features•2008

  • Affectedness

    Open Access•Mona Anderson•The Wiley Blackwell Companion to…•2017

  • Long‐Distance Agreement

    Open Access•Rajesh Bhatt, Stefan Keine•The Wiley Blackwell Companion to…•2017

  • Subextraction

    Open Access•Norbert Corver•The Wiley Blackwell Companion to…•2017

  • Phase Theory

    Open Access•Barbara Citko•Phase Theory•2014

  • Case In Iranian

    Donald Stilo•The Oxford handbook of case•2012

  • From Greek to Germanic

    Thomas Leu•Merging features•2009

  • Linkers and agreement

    Luis Franco, Franco Ludovico et al.•The Linguistic Review•2015

  • Interrogative and standard disjunction in Mandarin Chinese

    Open Access•Michael Yoshitaka Erlewine•Journal of Semantics•2025

  • Specificity Effects and Object Movement In Turkish and Uyghur

    Open Access•Robin Jenkins•Proceedings of the Workshop on…•2021

  • The closeness constraint on focus association and the syntax of Q-particles

    Open Access•Muyi Yang•Proceedings of the Linguistic…•2022

  • Marking Mirativity in Syntax

    Open Access•Murdhy Rada Alshamari, Manal Saleh Alghannam et al.•Advances in Language and Literary…•2021

  • Derivation and Interpretation of Expressiveness Devices in North Hail Arabic

    Open Access•Murdhy Alshamari, Murdhy R Alshamari•International Journal of English…•2020

  • EPP, Labeling and Word Order in Arabic

    Open Access•Ameen Alahdal•International Journal of English…•2021

  • PF-Representation of Tense Feature on DPs

    Open Access•Murdhy R Alshamari, Naif S Alshammari•Theory and Practice in Language…•2022

  • Undoing Wh-Movement

    Open Access•Jacek Witkoś•Philosophies•2021

  • Agreeing and Moving across Traces

    Open Access•Jairo Nunes•Philosophies•2021

  • Subject and non-subject ex-situ focus in Dagbani

    Open Access•Samuel Alhassan Issah, Peter W Smith•Glossa a journal of general…•2020

  • A principled exception to the Müller-Takano Generalization

    Open Access•Stanislao Zompì•Glossa a journal of general…•2024

  • Dispositional middle constructions with accusative objects in Slovenian

    Open Access•Jakob Lenardič•Glossa a journal of general…•2024

  • The Person Case Constraint, Person Ordering Constraint and Pronominal Clusters in Polish

    Open Access•Jacek Witkoś, Paulina Łęska•Glossa a journal of general…•2024

  • On EPP effects and the properties of Core Functional Categories

    Open Access•Gerardo Fernández‐salgueiro, Gerardo Fernández-Salgueiro•Glossa a journal of general…•2020

  • Agreeing to bind

    Open Access•Eric Reuland, Peter Zubkov•Glossa a journal of general…•2022

  • On the position of subjects in Spanish

    Open Access•Bradley Hoot, Shane Ebert•Glossa a journal of general…•2021

  • Facilitator effects in middles and more

    Open Access•Elise Newman•Glossa a journal of general…•2020

  • XP- and X 0 -movement in the Latin verb

    Open Access•Erik Zyman, Nick Kalivoda•Glossa a journal of general…•2020

  • The derivation of highest subject questions and the nature of the EPP

    Open Access•Troy Messick•Glossa a journal of general…•2020

  • Dialectal variation in the expression of que in sí-que ‘yes that’ contexts across Spanish

    Open Access•Julio Villa-García, Raquel González Rodríguez•Glossa a journal of general…•2020

  • Phasal transfer and anti-locality

    Open Access•Megumi Takahashi•Glossa a journal of general…•2023

  • Licensing and anaphora in Tenyidie

    Open Access•Andrew Murphy, Savio M Meyase•Glossa a journal of general…•2022

  • On the locus and licensing of edge features

    Open Access•Jairo Nunes•Glossa a journal of general…•2021

  • Japanese wh-phrases as operators with unspecified quantificational force

    Open Access•Mamoru Saito•Language and Linguistics 語言暨語言學•2022

  • D-Linked wh-phrase in Arabic

    Open Access•Murdhy Alshamari, Naif Alshammari•Folia Linguistica•2026

  • On the Deduction of the EPP from Labeling

    Open Access•Manabu Mizuguchi•Studia Linguistica•2022

  • Satisfying the composite probe on the Topic head in Mandarin Chinese

    Open Access•Chao-Ting Tim Chou•Studia Linguistica•2025

  • A last Resort Approach to (Number) Feature Inheritance1

    Open Access•Chao-Ting Tim Chou, Gerardo Fernández‐salgueiro•Studia Linguistica•2020

  • Discourse‐Feature‐Driven Movement in Spanish and the Revised PGU

    Open Access•Jiahui Yang•Studia Linguistica•2023

  • Labeling Defective T

    Open Access•Yoshio Sugimoto•Studia Linguistica•2021

  • External Set‐Merge of Heads and Composite Probing

    Open Access•Chao-Ting Tim Chou, Chao‐ting Tim Chou•Studia Linguistica•2020

  • Latin Dominant Participles

    Open Access•Jarosław Jakielaszek•Studia Linguistica•2021

  • Case Conflict in Arabic Relative Clauses

    Open Access•Mamdouh A Alenazy•International Journal of…•2023

  • Raising out of Finite Clauses (Hyperraising)

    Open Access•Erik Zyman•Annual Review of Linguistics•2022

  • Successive Cyclicity and the Syntax of Long-Distance Dependencies

    Coppe Van Urk•Annual Review of Linguistics•2019

  • What is sent to spell-out is phases, not phasal complements

    Open Access•Zeljko Boskovic•Linguistica•2016

  • Case, Phases, and Nominative/Accusative Conversion in Japanese

    Open Access•Megumi Takahashi, Masahiko Takahashi•Journal of East Asian Linguistics•2010

  • Double complement unaccusatives in Japanese

    Open Access•Yuji Takano•Journal of East Asian Linguistics•2011

  • Labeling and verb-initial word order in Seediq

    Open Access•Edith Aldridge•Journal of East Asian Linguistics•2019

  • The blocking effect in Vietnamese

    Open Access•Quy Ngoc Thi Doan, Eric Reuland et al.•Journal of East Asian Linguistics•2024

  • Negative structure and object movement in Japanese

    Open Access•Yoshiyuki Shibata•Journal of East Asian Linguistics•2015

  • ECM subjects in Japanese

    Open Access•Hideki Kishimoto•Journal of East Asian Linguistics•2021

  • (A) Case for labeling

    Mamoru Saito•The Linguistic Review•2016

  • Grammaticalization of auxiliaries and parametric changes

    Gabriela Alboiu, Virginia Hill•The Linguistic Review•2017

  • On wh and subject positions, the EPP, and contextuality of syntax

    Zeljko Boskovic•The Linguistic Review•2024

  • Labeling through Spell-Out

    Kensuke Takita, Nobu Goto et al.•The Linguistic Review•2016

  • From the Complex NP Constraint to everything

    Zeljko Boskovic•The Linguistic Review•2015

  • Seeking an optimal design of Search and Merge

    Open Access•Nobu Goto, Toru Ishii•The Linguistic Review•2024

  • Parameterization in labeling

    Kumiko Murasugi, Keiko Murasugi•The Linguistic Review•2020

  • On the timing of labeling

    Zeljko Boskovic•The Linguistic Review•2016

  • Dative intervention is a gang effect

    Andrew Murphy•The Linguistic Review•2018

  • Large-scale pied-piping in the labeling theory and conditions on weak heads

    Hiromune Oda•The Linguistic Review•2024

  • On Phase-over-Phase Configurations and phase collapsing

    Gabriel Martínez Vera•The Linguistic Review•2020

  • The T-Extension Condition

    Open Access•Ivona Kučerová•The Canadian Journal of…•2012

  • Negative Concord and locality in Russian

    Open Access•Ekaterina Lyutikova, Anastasia Gerasimova et al.•The Canadian Journal of…•2023

  • Partial Wh -Movement in Indonesian, Criterial Freezing, and Sub-Extraction

    Open Access•Yosuke Sato•The Canadian Journal of…•2024

  • Minimalist approach to symmetric and asymmetric double object constructions

    Open Access•Fawwaz An-Nashef, Jeroen Van De Weijer•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2020

  • Multi-Functionality of the Discourse Marker haweɪh in Ghamdi Dialect of Hijazi Arabic

    Open Access•Murdhy Alshamari, Al-Ghamdi Naimah et al.•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2021

  • The Finnish accusative

    Open Access•Anne Vainikka, Pauli Brattico•Linguistics•2014

  • Revisiting Universal Grammar in L2 acquisition

    Open Access•Takayuki Kimura•Second language Research•2025

  • Agreement without agree

    Javier Ormazabal, Juan Romero•The Linguistic Review•2025

  • On primary and secondary movement

    Open Access•Saara Huhmarniemi, Pauli Brattico•Acta Linguistica Hungarica•2013

  • In defense of the clause-internal phase

    Open Access•Asia Pietraszko•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2026

  • Scrambling in the nominal domain

    Open Access•Qiushi Chen•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2026

  • Locative inversion and T-movement in English

    Open Access•K S Kim, Kwang-Sup Kim•The Linguistic Review•2026

  • The relativized EPP

    Open Access•Christopher Hammerly•The Canadian Journal of…•2026

  • Possessive pronouns, Condition C and Anti-Cataphora Effects

    Open Access•Jacek Witkoś•Lingua•2021

  • On T-Movement in English

    Open Access•K S Kim, Kwang-Sup Kim•Lingua•2022

  • On Sinhala subject case marking and A-movement

    Open Access•Chao-Ting Tim Chou, Sujeewa Hettiarachchi•Lingua•2016

  • Long distance Case assignment and intervention

    Open Access•Pauli Brattico•Lingua•2014

  • Syntactic doubling and the structure of wh -chains

    Open Access•Sjef Barbier, Sjef Barbiers et al.•Journal of Linguistics•2009

  • On the licensing of complementizer agreement with nominals in the left periphery

    Open Access•Basem Ibrahim Malawi Al-Raba'A, Marwan Jarrah•Journal of Linguistics•2025

  • Recomplementation as a paratactic phenomenon

    Open Access•Julio Villa-García, Dana Ott•Journal of Linguistics•2022

  • Freezing effects and objects

    Open Access•Terje Lohndal•Journal of Linguistics•2010

  • Clause size as a metric for null-subject licensing with defective tense in Slavic

    Open Access•Alberto Frasson, Antonina Mocniak et al.•Journal of Linguistics•2026

  • Restructuring and focus in Japanese

    Mina Sugimura, Yoichi Miyamoto•Journal of Japanese Linguistics•2025

  • Taking case out of the Person-Case Constraint

    Open Access•Adrian Stegovec•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2020

  • Synchronizing meaning with sound and beyond

    Open Access•Thomas Grano, Yoshihisa Kitagawa•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2025

  • An agreement-based analysis of extraction from nominals

    Open Access•Matthew Reeve, Matthew M Reeve•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2019

  • Phrasal and Clausal Architecture

    Simin Karimi, Vida Samiian et al.•Phrasal and Clausal Architecture•2007

  • Derivation and Explanation in the Minimalist Program

    Open Access•Samuel David Epstein, T Daniel Seely•Derivation and Explanation in the…•2002

  • Linearization of Chains and Sideward Movement

    Jairo Nunes•Linearization of Chains and…•2004

  • Parameters of Slavic Morphosyntax

    Steven Franks•Parameters of Slavic morphosyntax•1995

  • Phrasal Movement and Its Kin

    David Pesetsky•Phrasal Movement and Its Kin•2000

  • Locality in WH Quantification

    Open Access•Veneeta Dayal•Locality in WH Quantification•1996

  • Ellipsis

    Anne Lobeck, Anne C Lobeck•Ellipsis•1995

  • Connectedness and binary branching

    Richard S Kayne•Connectedness and Binary Branching•1984

  • Studies in Comparative Germanic Syntax

    Open Access•Hoskuldur Thrainsson, Höskuldur Þráinsson et al.•Studies in Comparative Germanic…•1996

  • Syntax

    Arnim Stechow von, Joachim Jacobs et al.•Syntax•1993

  • On the Nature of the Syntax-Phonology Interface

    Zeljko Boskovic•On the Nature of the Syntax-phonolo…•2001

  • The Role of Economy Principles in Linguistic Theory

    Hans‐martin Gärtner, Chris Wilder et al.•Role of Economy Principles in…•1996

  • Long distance scrambling in Japanese

    Open Access•Mamoru Saito•Journal of East Asian Linguistics•1992

  • Cyclic Linearization of Syntactic Structure

    Danny Fox, David Pesetsky•Theoretical Linguistics•2005

  • Questions, quantifiers and crossing

    James Higginbotham, Robert May•The Linguistic Review•1981

  • A word order paradox resolved by copy deletion at PF

    Sandra Stjepanović•Linguistic Variation Yearbook•2003

  • Long Distance Agreement in Hindi-Urdu

    Open Access•Rajesh Bhatt•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2005

  • The Domain of Agreement

    Open Access•Jonathan David Bobaljik, Susi Wurmbrand•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2005

  • Generalized Inversion

    Open Access•John Frederick Bailyn•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2004

  • Inflection and conjunction in Modern Irish

    Open Access•Joanne Mccloskey, James Mccloskey•Natural Language and Linguistic…•1986

  • The order of verbal complements

    Open Access•Adriana Belletti, Ur Shlonsky•Natural Language and Linguistic…•1995

  • Be careful where you float your quantifiers

    Open Access•Zeljko Boskovic•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2004

  • On the operator freezing effect

    Open Access•Zeljko Boskovic•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2008

  • Object positions

    Open Access•Kyle Johnson•Natural Language and Linguistic…•1991

  • Long-Distance Agreement And Topic In Tsez

    Open Access•Maria Polinsky, Eric Potsdam•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2001

  • Government and Binding Theory and the Minimalist Program

    Open Access•Lindsay J Whaley, Gert Webelhuth•Language•1997

  • Linguistic Studies of Native Canada

    M Dale Kinkade, Eung-Do Cook et al.•Language•1980

  • Alternative Conceptions of Phrase Structure

    Thomas Wasow, Mark R Baltin et al.•Language•1990

  • Logical form

    Daniel L Everett, Norbert Hornstein•Language•1998

  • Case and word order in Lithuanian

    Open Access•Steven Franks, James Lavine et al.•Journal of Linguistics•2006

  • Possessive clitics and the structure of nominal expressions

    Open Access•Penka Stateva, Penka Stateva∗•Lingua•2002

  • On the Nature of Default Case

    Open Access•Carson T Schutze•Syntax•2001

  • Across-the-board Movement and LF

    Open Access•Željko Bošović, Steven Frank et al.•Syntax•2000

  • Case Checking versus Case Assignment and the Case of Adverbial NPs

    Zeljko Boskovic•Linguistic Inquiry•2006

  • Quantifier Float andWh-Movement in an Irish English

    Joanne Mccloskey, James Mccloskey•Linguistic Inquiry•2000

  • Primitives of Binding

    Eric Reuland•Linguistic Inquiry•2001

  • Successive cyclicity as residual wh-scope marking

    Open Access•Arthur Stepanov, Penka Stateva•Lingua•2006

  • On Multiple Wh-Fronting

    Zeljko Boskovic•Linguistic Inquiry•2002

  • English Expletive Constructions Are Not Infected

    Carson T Schutze•Linguistic Inquiry•1999

  • Lethal Ambiguity

    Martha Mcginnis•Linguistic Inquiry•2004

  • Wh-Subjects in English and the Vacuous Movement Hypothesis

    Brian Agbayani•Linguistic Inquiry•2000

  • Head-ing toward PF

    Cedric Boeckx, Sandra Stjepanović•Linguistic Inquiry•2001

  • A Gap in the ECM Paradigm

    Cedric Boeckx, Norbert Hornstein•Linguistic Inquiry•2005

  • Some Interface Properties of the Phase

    Julie Anne Legate•Linguistic Inquiry•2003

  • Null Case and the Distribution of PRO

    Roger Martins, Róger Martín•Linguistic Inquiry•2001

  • Successive-Cyclic Movement and Island Repair

    Danny Fox, Howard Lasnik•Linguistic Inquiry•2003

  • EPP in T

    Open Access•Samuel David Epstein, Acrisio Pires et al.•Syntax•2005

  • Cyclicity and Extraction Domains

    Open Access•Jairo Nunes, Juan Uriagereka•Syntax•2000

  • Cyclic Computation, A Computationally Efficient Minimalist Syntax

    Open Access•John Frampton, Sam Gutmann•Syntax•1999

  • The Fine Structure of Cyclic Agree

    Open Access•Milan Rezac•Syntax•2003

  • A-movement and the EPP

    Open Access•Zeljko Boskovic•Syntax•2002

  • Agreement and Clausal Arguments

    Open Access•M Carme Picallo•Syntax•2002

  • Clauses in Noncanonical Positions at the Syntax-Phonology Interface

    Open Access•Duk‐ho An•Syntax•2007

  • Altruism, Ā-Movement, and Object Agreement in Innu-aimûn

    Phil Branigan, Marguerite Mackenzie•Linguistic Inquiry•2002

  • Scrambling and Last Resort

    Zeljko Boskovic, Daiko Takahashi•Linguistic Inquiry•1998

  • Multiple Case Checking

    Open Access•Susana Bejar, Diane Massam•Syntax•1999

  • A Smuggling Approach to Raising in English

    Chris Collins•Linguistic Inquiry•2005

Unique citing works155
Citations per year8,61
Citation span2008 - 2026 (19)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 144

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae