Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Racial Orders in American Political Development

Bibliographic Data

ID3287367
AuthorsDesmond S King (0000-0002-3296-0407), Desmond King (0000-0002-8763-2179, University of Oxford), R M Smith (0000-0001-6983-9232, University of Pennsylvania)
Year2005
Volume99
Issue1
Pages75-92
Publication date2005-02-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Political Science Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0003-0554 • E-ISSN: 1537-5943
PublisherCambridge University Press (CUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1017/s0003055405051506
OpenAlexW2100433431
LanguageEN
Citations received250
References cited74

American political science has long struggled to deal adequately with issues of race. Many studies inaccurately treat their topics as unrelated to race. Many studies of racial issues lack clear theoretical accounts of the relationships of race and politics. Drawing on arguments in the American political development literature, this essay argues for analyzing race, and American politics more broadly, in terms of two evolving, competing "racial institutional orders": a "white supremacist" order and an "egalitarian transformative" order. This conceptual framework can synthesize and unify many arguments about race and politics that political scientists have advanced, and it can also serve to highlight the role of race in political developments that leading scholars have analyzed without attention to race. The argument here suggests that no analysis of American politics is likely to be adequate unless the impact of these racial orders is explicitly considered or their disregard explained

Argument (complex analysis · Economics · Environmental ethics · Epistemology · Order (exchange · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Politics of the United States · Race (biology · Racial formation theory · Racial politics · Sociology · Transformative learning · White (mutation · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Gender Studies · Law · Race, History, and American Society · Social Policy and Reform Studies

  • America's Political Crisis

    Open Access•Lawrence R Jacobs, Lawrence Jacobs et al.•PS Political Science & Politics•2009

  • Color Consciousness

    Open Access•Jason Smith, Jason A Smith•Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia of…•2015

  • Unfreedom for All

    Thomas J Donahue•Unfreedom for All•2019

  • The Schematic State

    Open Access•Debra Thompson•The Schematic State•2016

  • Asset Manager Capitalism as a Corporate Governance Regime

    Open Access•Bonnie Braun•American Political Economy•2021

  • The Criminalization of Immigrants as a Racial Project

    Open Access•Doris Marie Provine, Roxanne Lynn Doty•Journal of Contemporary Criminal…•2011

  • The Role of the Law in the American Political Economy

    Open Access•K Sabeel Rahman, Kathleen Thelen•American Political Economy•2021

  • Black Rights/White Wrongs

    C W Mills•Black Rights/White Wrongs•2017

  • Historical Institutionalism in Political Science

    Orfeo Fioretos, Tulia Gabriela Falleti et al.•Oxford Handbook of Historical…•2016

  • The Political Economies of Red States

    Open Access•Jacob M Grumbach, Jacob S Hacker et al.•American Political Economy•2021

  • Immigration and public attitudes towards social assistance

    Open Access•Shen Yang, Bo Miao et al.•Journal of Economic Policy Reform•2022

  • Rethinking Rules

    Open Access•Adam Sheingate•Explaining Institutional Change•2009

  • The American Political Economy

    Open Access•Alex Hertel-Fernandez, Kathleen Ann Thelen et al.•American Political Economy•2021

  • Racial Liberalism

    Open Access•C W Mills•PMLA/Publications of the Modern…•2008

  • New Urbanism as Urban Political Development

    Open Access•Yonn Dierwechter•Urban Planning•2020

  • Close Race

    Open Access•Joseph English, Jasmine English•Political Behavior•2026

  • Finding leading scholars in mobile phone behavior

    Open Access•Zheng Yan, Wenqian Robertson et al.•Scientometrics•2021

  • Policing the Uptown

    Tari Ajadi•Journal of Canadian Studies•2024

  • Ironies of State Building

    Open Access•Desmond King, Robert C Lieberman•World Politics•2009

  • Inequality on Top of the Hill

    Open Access•James R Jones, M Triguero Roura•Socius Sociological Research for…•2025

  • The Reed Rules and Republican Party Building

    Open Access•Richard M Valelly, Richard Valelly•Studies in American Political…•2009

  • American While Black

    Niambi Michele Carter•American While Black•2019

  • The Hidden Rules of Race

    Andrea Flynn, Dorian T Warren et al.•Hidden Rules of Race•2017

  • Walls, Cages, and Family Separation

    Open Access•Sophia Jordán Wallace, Chris Zepeda Millán et al.•Walls, Cages, and Family Separation•2020

  • The Prison and the Gallows

    Open Access•Marie Gottschalk•Prison and the Gallows•2001

  • Du Bois and James at Harvard

    Open Access•Saladin Ambar•The Journal of Race Ethnicity and…•2019

  • Incorporation is Not Enough

    Open Access•P C Peay•The Journal of Race Ethnicity and…•2021

  • Racialized Anti-Statism and the Failure of the American State

    Open Access•L L Miller•The Journal of Race Ethnicity and…•2021

  • Proudly for Brooke

    Open Access•Richard T Johnson•The Journal of Race Ethnicity and…•2018

  • Racialized Preferences in Context

    Open Access•Nina M Yancy•The Journal of Race Ethnicity and…•2019

  • Unequal values

    Open Access•Rodney E Hero, Morris Levy•The Journal of Race Ethnicity and…•2021

  • Racial Reparations against White Protectionism

    Open Access•R M Smith, Desmond King•The Journal of Race Ethnicity and…•2021

  • Black Social Capital

    Open Access•Quintin Gorman•Sociology of Race and Ethnicity•2026

  • On the Interdependence of Liberal and Illiberal/Authoritarian Legal Forms in Racial Capitalist Regimes…The Case of the United States

    Michael Mccann, Filiz Kahraman•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2021

  • ‘Race still matters , however … ’

    T Craemer, Todd C Shaw et al.•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2011

  • Party Matters

    Open Access•Wesley Hiers•Social Science History•2013

  • Callous Cruelty and Blow Back

    Open Access•Gregory Hooks, Michael Lengefeld•Environmental Justice•2022

  • What about the White People

    Quinn Lester•Qui Parle•2017

  • Police Unionism, Accountability, and Misconduct

    Open Access•Abdul Nasser Rad, David S Kirk et al.•Annual Review of Criminology•2022

  • The ladder of disproportionate policy

    Open Access•Moshe Maor•European Policy Analysis•2024

  • Fight the Power? How Black Adults’ Racial Capital Associates With Their Political Activities

    Open Access•Quintin Gorman•Social Currents•2024

  • Social Class As Racialized Political Experience

    Open Access•James Michener•The Forum•2017

  • Representation on the Periphery

    Elliot Mamet•American Political Thought•2021

  • When race no longer predicts minority status and identity

    P T Lien•Politics Groups and Identities•2014

  • Thinking through race

    Kathleen Cole•Politics Groups and Identities•2016

  • Seeing around corners”

    Harwood K Mcclerking, Ray Block•Politics Groups and Identities•2025

  • The foresight of Frontlash

    P C Peay, Reginald Pulley•Politics Groups and Identities•2025

  • How racial cues affect support for American racial hierarchy among African Americans and Whites

    Monique L Lyle•Politics Groups and Identities•2014

  • From strategy to sentiment

    Open Access•Marisa A Smith, Meredith D Clark et al.•Politics Groups and Identities•2025

  • The neo-Redemption Era? APD in the age of #Black lives matter

    Kimberley Johnson•Politics Groups and Identities•2018

  • American Political Development in the Era of Black Lives Matter

    Debra Thompson, Chloe Thurston•Politics Groups and Identities•2018

  • The Strange Fruit of American Political Development

    Megan Ming Francis•Politics Groups and Identities•2018

  • Dear political science

    Open Access•Elizabeth Jordie Davies•Politics Groups and Identities•2025

  • The Way of Progress and Civilization”

    Open Access•Stephen Pampinella•Journal of Global Security Studies•2020

  • National Insecurity

    Open Access•DAVID B EBNER•The Journal of Race Ethnicity and…•2025

  • Racial remembering in urban politics

    Open Access•Meghan V Doran•American Journal of Cultural…•2017

  • It's not the rotten apples! Why family scholars should adopt a structural perspective on racism

    Open Access•E Bonilla-Silva•Journal of Family Theory & Review•2023

  • Theorizing the US Racial State

    Open Access•Moon‐kie Jung, Yaejoon Kwon•Sociology Compass•2013

  • Imperial designs

    Open Access•Victoria Hattam•Memory Studies•2015

  • Law and American Political Development

    Open Access•Pamela Brandwein•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2011

  • Race, Law, and Inequality, 50 Years After the Civil Rights Era

    Open Access•Frank W Munger, Carroll Seron•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2017

  • The Persistence of Authoritarianism

    Open Access•Markus Bernhard, Daniel I O’neill•Perspectives on Politics•2018

  • Lethal Violence and the Racialized Failure of the American State

    Open Access•Rebekah Jones, L L Miller•Perspectives on Politics•2025

  • How the U.S. State Works

    Open Access•Desmond King, Marc Stears•Perspectives on Politics•2011

  • Changing Attitudes and Provoking Action

    Open Access•Mackenzie Israel-Trummel•Perspectives on Politics•2025

  • Race, power, and policy

    Open Access•James Michener•Policy and Society•2022

  • What is so American about the American empire

    Open Access•Srdjan Vucetic•International Politics•2011

  • Policing the police

    Open Access•Vasabjit Banerjee, Charley Willison et al.•The British Journal of Politics…•2024

  • Mobilizing Liberalism in Defense of Racism

    Julie Novkov•The Good Society•2007

  • Racial Governance in Postwar Chicago

    Open Access•Joel Rast•Urban Affairs Review•2024

  • Classifying Black Suburbs

    Open Access•Kimberley Johnson•Urban Affairs Review•2026

  • Segregation and “Out-of-Placeness”

    Open Access•Laura Schenker, David Sylvan et al.•Political Research Quarterly•2023

  • A Resistance Framework for Racially Minoritized Youth Behaviors During the Transition to Adulthood

    Open Access•Dawn T Bounds, Patricia D Posey et al.•Journal of Research on Adolescence•2022

  • Rogers M. Smith

    Open Access•Keith E Whittington•PS Political Science & Politics•2018

  • Tolerance for the Free Speech of Outgroup Partisans

    Open Access•R F Carlos, Geoffrey Sheagley et al.•PS Political Science & Politics•2023

  • Comparing American perceptions of post-Civil War Ku Klux Klan and transnational violence

    Open Access•Michael E Newell•Security Dialogue•2020

  • Gentrification and Integration

    Open Access•Jamie Draper•Journal of Political Philosophy•2023

  • Black banker, white banker

    Srdjan Vucetic•Cambridge Review of International…•2013

  • Transatlantic Anxieties

    Open Access•David A Bateman•Studies in American Political…•2019

  • Naturalizing affection, securing property

    Open Access•Gwendoline M Alphonso•Studies in American Political…•2021

  • Constructive Welfare

    Open Access•Jennifer Erkulwater, Jennifer L Erkulwater•Studies in American Political…•2019

  • Judicial Partisanship and the Slaughterhouse Cases

    Open Access•Gregory Elinson•Studies in American Political…•2017

  • Racial Orders, Congress, and the Agricultural Welfare State, 1865–1940

    Open Access•Kimberley S Johnson, Kimberley Johnson•Studies in American Political…•2011

  • From Politics to Protest

    Open Access•Kimberley S Johnson, Kimberley Johnson•Studies in American Political…•2017

  • The Beginning of the End for Authoritarian Rule in America

    Open Access•Robert Mickey, Robert W Mickey•Studies in American Political…•2008

  • Race, the Canadian Census, and Interactive Political Development

    Open Access•Debra Thompson•Studies in American Political…•2020

  • Policy Feedback in the Public–Private Welfare State

    Open Access•Chloe Thurston, Chloe N Thurston•Studies in American Political…•2015

  • This Crisis of Our History”

    Open Access•Paul E Herron•Studies in American Political…•2022

  • The Reinvention of Vouchers for a Color-Blind Era

    Open Access•Ursula Hackett, Desmond King•Studies in American Political…•2019

  • When Think Tanks Refuse Thinking

    Open Access•Benedikt Springer•Studies in American Political…•2021

  • Racism Is Not Enough

    Open Access•Jae Yeon Kim•Studies in American Political…•2020

  • Vote Dilution and Suppression in Indian Country

    Open Access•Jean Reith Schroedel, Jean Schroedel et al.•Studies in American Political…•2015

  • Our Future at Risk

    Open Access•Daniel Kryder, Ryan LaRochelle•Studies in American Political…•2022

  • The March on Washington Movement, the Fair Employment Practices Committee, and the Long Quest for Racial Justice

    Open Access•Sidney M Milki, Katherine Rader•Studies in American Political…•2023

  • Democratic Representation of all “the People”

    Open Access•John D Griffin, Grace Sager•Studies in American Political…•2020

  • A Mission Without Precedent”

    Open Access•Ryan LaRochelle•Journal of Policy History•2023

  • Reform’s Mating Dance

    Open Access•Sidney M Milki, Daniel J Tichenor•Journal of Policy History•2011

  • How the Nation’s Largest Minority Became White

    Open Access•Jennifer Erkulwater, Jennifer L Erkulwater•Journal of Policy History•2018

  • Law's Allure and the Power of Path‐Dependent Legal Ideas

    Open Access•Charles R Epp•Law & Social Inquiry•2010

  • Slavery and Just Compensation in American Constitutionalism

    Open Access•Stephan Stohler•Law & Social Inquiry•2018

  • Black visions

    Michael C Dawson•Black visions•2001

  • Slaves without masters

    Ira Berlin•Slaves without masters•1992

  • The shaping of Southern politics

    J Morgan Kousser•The shaping of Southern politics•1974

  • Reconstruction

    Eric Foner•Reconstruction•2005

  • North of slavery

    Leon F Litwack•North of slavery•1961

  • The American kaleidoscope

    Lawrence H Fuchs•The American kaleidoscope•1990

  • Worse than slavery

    David M Oshinsky•Worse than slavery•1996

  • New people

    Joel Williamson•New people•1980

  • Civic Ideals

    Rogers M Smith•Civic Ideals•2008

  • Making Race and Nation

    Open Access•Anthony W Marx•Making Race and Nation•1997

  • The Search for American Political Development

    Open Access•Karen Orren, Stephen Skowronek•Search for American Political…•2004

  • Why Americans Hate Welfare

    Martin Gilens•Why Americans hate welfare•1999

  • Building a New American State

    Open Access•Stephen Skowronek•Building a New American State•1982

  • The Forging of Bureaucratic Autonomy

    Daniel Carpenter, Daniel P Carpenter•Forging of Bureaucratic Autonomy•2002

  • Dividing Lines

    Daniel J Tichenor•Dividing Lines•2002

  • The Corporate Reconstruction of American Capitalism, 1890–1916

    Open Access•Martin J Sklar•Corporate Reconstruction of…•1988

  • A Final Promise

    Frederick E Hoxie•A Final Promise•2001

  • Stirrings in the jug

    Adolph L Reed•Stirrings in the jug•1999

  • Forced synthesis of trace amounts of juvenile hormone II from propionate by corpora allata of a juvenile hormone III-producing insect

    Open Access•Ira Katznelson, R Feyereisen et al.•Experientia•1988

  • Half a Man. The Status of the Negro in New York

    Alexander F Chamberlain, Mary White Ovington•The Journal of Race Development•1912

  • Black Reconstruction in America, 1860–1880

    W E B Du Bois•Racism•2001

  • Pullman Porters and the Rise of Protest Politics in Black America, 1925-1945

    Beth Tompkins Bates, Beth Bates•Pullman porters and the rise of…•2001

  • Hammer and Hoe

    R D G Kelley•Hammer and hoe•2015

  • The White Image In The Black Mind

    Mia Bay•The white image in the black mind•2000

  • Reconsidering Roosevelt on Race

    Kevin J Mcmahon•Reconsidering Roosevelt on Race•2003

  • Thinking Orientals

    Henry Yu•Thinking Orientals•2001

  • Divided We Stand

    Benjamin Nelson, Bruce Nelson•Divided We Stand•2021

  • Old Labor and New Immigrants in American Political Development

    Gwendolyn Mink•Old Labor and New Immigrants in…•2019

  • Legislative History of American Immigration Policy, 1798-1965

    E P Hutchinson, Eric Hutchinson•Legislative History of American…•1981

  • The Minority Rights Revolution

    Open Access•John D Skrentny•Minority Rights Revolution•2009

  • Race and Manifest Destiny

    Reginald Horsman•Race and Manifest Destiny•1981

  • The Ironies of Affirmative Action

    John D Skrentny•Ironies of Affirmative Action•1996

  • Black Identities

    Mary C Waters•Black Identities•1999

  • The Scar of Race

    Paul M Sniderman, Thomas Piazza et al.•Scar of Race•1993

  • The Race Card

    Open Access•Tali Mendelberg•Race Card•2001

  • White Supremacy and Racism in the Post-Civil Rights Era

    Eduardo Bonilla-Silva, Eduardo Bonilla‐silva•White Supremacy and Racism in the…•2001

  • Political Culture and American Political Development

    Open Access•J David Greenstone•Studies in American Political…•1986

  • Choosing Sides

    Open Access•John Mark Hansen•Studies in American Political…•1987

  • Editors' Preface

    Open Access•Karen Orren, Stephen Skowronek•Studies in American Political…•1986

  • Industrial Concentration, Sectional Competition, and Antitrust Politics in America, 1880–1980

    Open Access•Elizabeth Sanders•Studies in American Political…•1986

  • Black Moses

    Leslie H Fishel, Edmund David Cronon•The Mississippi Valley Historical…•1955

  • The Frontier Against Slavery

    Charles Desmond Hart, Charles Hart et al.•The Journal of Southern History•1968

  • Nixon's Piano

    Steven F Lawson, Kenneth O’reilly et al.•The Journal of Southern History•1997

  • The Naacp Crusade Against Lynching, 1909-1950

    Daniel W Crofts, Robert L Zangrando•The Journal of Southern History•1981

  • The Debate over Slavery

    Dan R Frost, David F Ericson•Journal of American History•2002

  • Unreconstructed Democracy

    Lawrie Balfour•American Political Science Review•2003

  • United States Indian Policy and the Debate over Philippine Annexation

    Walter L Williams•Journal of American History•1980

  • Half a Man. The Status of the Negro in New York. Mary White Ovington

    P Breckinridge, S P Breckinridge•American Journal of Sociology•1911

  • The New White Nationalism in America

    Open Access•Carol M Swain•Nations and Nationalism•2003

  • The Color of Welfare

    Jill Quadagno, Jill S Quadagno•The color of welfare•1994

  • The Architecture of Race in American Immigration Law

    Mae M Ngai•Journal of American History•1999

  • The Sources of Anti-Slavery Constitutionalism in America, 1760-1848

    Open Access•William M Wiecek•Sources of Anti-Slavery…•2018

  • States and Social Revolutions

    Open Access•T Skocpol•States and Social Revolutions•2015

  • The Negro and the New Freedom

    Open Access•Nancy J Wei, Nancy J Weiss•Political Science Quarterly•1969

  • State Capacity and Economic Intervention in the Early New Deal

    Open Access•T Skocpol, Kenneth Finegold•Political Science Quarterly•1982

  • Limiting Liberalism

    Open Access•Ira Katznelson, Kim Geiger et al.•Political Science Quarterly•1993

  • Ideas, Institutions, and Political Order

    Open Access•Robert C Lieberman•American Political Science Review•2002

  • The Boundaries of Blackness

    Cathy J Cohen, Cathy Cohen•The boundaries of blackness•1999

  • Whiteness of a Different Color

    Matthew Frye Jacobson•Whiteness of a Different Color•1999

  • The Racial Triangulation of Asian Americans

    Open Access•Claire Jean Kim•Latin American Politics and Society•1999

  • States and Social Revolutions

    Open Access•T Skocpol•States and Social Revolutions•1979

Unique citing works250
Citations per year10
Citation span2001 - 2026 (26)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 249

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae