Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Local Citizenship

Welfare Reform Urban/Rural Status, and Exclusion in China

Bibliographic Data

ID4140797
AuthorsA Smart (0000-0001-7880-9799, University of Calgary, corresponding author), Josephine Smart (University of Calgary, corresponding author)
Year2001
Volume33
Issue10
Pages1853-1869
Publication date2001-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEnvironment and Planning A Economy and Space (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0308-518X • E-ISSN: 1472-3409
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1068/a3454
OpenAlexW1973577063
LanguageEN
Citations received69
References cited42

After 1949 China's welfare system developed on the basis of a status division between urban and rural residents. Urban and rural societies were profoundly influenced by the respective organization of their welfare systems, which shared the feature of being fixed to specific places (rural) or enterprises (urban). Reform of core institutions is constrained by path dependency. Knowledge of those constraints, however, can aid efforts to shape new paths. In this paper we examine how institutional legacies of urban - rural status differentiation continue to structure economic and welfare reform. China's reform process has been characterized by an unusual degree of decentralization and local experimentation. As a result, the nature of change is not easily seen by examining only laws and policies related to welfare. Instead, broader changes in the economy and the loosening of controls on mobility have interacted with the locality/enterprise welfare systems to generate diverse local outcomes. After an overview of the welfare institutions and the reform process, we draw on field research in industrializing rural areas in Guangdong to describe a pattern we label 'local citizenship' where welfare benefits are elaborated for the locally born while excluding migrants

China · Citizenship · Decentralization · Development economics · Economic growth · Economic system · Economics · Political science · Politics · Rural area · Welfare · Welfare reform · China's Socioeconomic Reforms and Governance · Law · Migration and Labor Dynamics · Migration, Ethnicity, and Economy

  • Comparing Knowledge and Use of Health Services of Migrants From Rural and Urban Areas in Kunming City, China

    Open Access•Xiaolin Wei, Stephen Pearson et al.•Journal of Biosocial Science•2010

  • Border Management and Growth Coalitions in the Hong Kong Transborder Region

    A Smart, George C S Lin et al.•Identities•2004

  • Rural Citizenship

    Open Access•Richard Yarwood•International Encyclopedia of…•2017

  • Long-term impacts of parental migration on Chinese children’s psychosocial well-being

    Open Access•Chenyue Zhao, Feng Wang et al.•Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric…•2017

  • Extended case across time and borders

    Open Access•Kaxton Siu, Anita Koo•Critical Sociology•2026

  • A Long Financial March

    Open Access•Daniel Béland, Ka Man Yu et al.•Journal of Social Policy•2004

  • Property rights and market participation

    Dongwei He, Guangcai Zhang et al.•Journal of Chinese Governance•2022

  • Mobilities of Older Chinese Rural-Urban Migrants

    Open Access•Yang Cheng, Mark W Rosenberg et al.•International Journal of…•2019

  • The equitable aging in health conceptual framework

    Open Access•Angela K Perone, Leixuri Urrutia-Pujana et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2025

  • The performativity of the state in China’s land transformation

    Yimin Zhao•Oxford Development Studies•2022

  • Continuities and changes of media construction of citizenship rights in China

    Stephanie Na Liu, Tsan‐kuo Chang et al.•Asian Journal of Communication•2020

  • Land titling in China

    Lixing Li•China Economic Journal•2012

  • Community-based approaches to social exclusion among rural-to-urban migrants in China

    Julian Chun‐chung Chow, Christine Lou•China Journal of Social Work•2015

  • Can Travelling Mothers Ever Arrive? Articulating Internal and International Migration within a Transnational Perspective of Care

    Open Access•Shu‐mei Huang•Population Space and Place•2015

  • Toward a Post-Socialist City? Economic Tertiarization and Urban Reformation in the Guangzhou Metropolis, China

    George C S Lin•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2004

  • Rural transformation and the persistence of rurality in China

    Him Chung•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2013

  • Space to maneuver

    Jing Song•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2014

  • Dairy and diaspora

    Taomo Zhou•Inter-Asia Cultural Studies•2023

  • Well‐being of migrant and left‐behind children in C hina

    Open Access•Shuang Lu, Yi‐Ting Lin et al.•International Journal of Social…•2015

  • Unequal cities of spectacle and mega-events in China

    Hyun Bang Shin•City•2012

  • A multilevel analysis of the role of the family and the state in self-rated health of elderly Chinese

    Open Access•Zhixin Feng, Wenfei Winnie Wang et al.•Health & Place•2013

  • Co-benefits, contradictions, and multi-level governance of low-carbon experimentation

    Open Access•Karl Lo, Vanesa Castán Broto•Global Environmental Change•2019

  • Whose games? The costs of being “Olympic citizens” in Beijing

    Open Access•Hyun Bang Shin, Bingqin Li•Environment and Urbanization•2013

  • Promotion tournament 2.0”

    Open Access•Yuxi Zhang•Governance•2020

  • The gaps between policy design and peasant migrants' intention of citizenization

    Open Access•Wei Xiong, Meijiao Huang et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2023

  • Geography and social policy

    Open Access•John Mohan•Progress in Human Geography•2003

  • Industrial clustering, income and inequality in rural China

    Open Access•Di Guo, Kun Jiang et al.•World Development•2022

  • Chinese Urbanism in Question

    George C S Lin•Urban Geography•2007

  • When guesthouse meets home

    Open Access•Yawei Zhao•Geoforum•2019

  • Bordering Shanghai

    Open Access•Leif Johnson•Geoforum•2017

  • Emergence of social work practice in rural China

    Open Access•Qian Meng, Mel Gray et al.•International Social Work•2018

  • The diversity of older migrants and their intentions to return

    Open Access•Qiujie Shi, T Liu•International Migration•2025

  • Falling Into the Second-Generation Decline? Evidence From the Intergenerational Differences in Social Identity of Rural–Urban Migrants in China

    Open Access•Xiangming Leng, Min Zhong et al.•SAGE Open•2020

  • Making Hidden Exclusions

    Open Access•Shuting Zhang•SAGE Open•2025

  • Land for welfare in China

    Open Access•Meina Cai•Land Use Policy•2016

  • Exploring the relationship between rural village characteristics and Chinese return migrants' participation in farming

    Open Access•Hongsheng Chen, Xingping Wang•Cities•2019

  • Failing entrepreneurial governance

    Open Access•Desheng Xue, Fulong Wu•Cities•2015

  • Transforming China's globalizing cities

    Open Access•Fulong Wu, Laurence J C Ma et al.•Habitat International•2006

  • Access to social insurance in urban China

    Zhiming Cheng, Ingrid Nielsen et al.•Habitat International•2014

  • Social Exchange in Mate Selection of Female Migrants in China

    Liqun Zeng, T F Liao•Marriage & Family Review•2022

  • The Right to the City and Critical Reflections on China's Property Rights Activism

    Open Access•Hyun Bang Shin•Antipode•2013

  • Data-driven governance, smart urbanism and risk-class inequalities

    Open Access•Dean Curran, A Smart•Urban Studies•2021

  • Welfare migration or migrant selection? Social insurance participation and rural migrants’ intentions to seek permanent urban settlement in China

    Open Access•Shenghua Xie, Juan Chen et al.•Urban Studies•2021

  • Rural migrants in villages-in-the-city in Guangzhou, China

    Open Access•Him Chung•Urban Studies•2018

  • Exploring Migrant Integration Through Local Governance

    Open Access•Fabio Maratia, Martina Arcadu et al.•Social Policy and Administration•2026

  • Commentary

    Open Access•Josiah Heyman•Dialectical Anthropology•2014

  • Legitimating exclusion and inclusion

    Sophia Woodman•Citizenship Studies•2017

  • Comparing the development of free movement and social citizenship for internal migrants in the European Union and China – converging trends

    Vesela Kovacheva, Dita Vogel et al.•Citizenship Studies•2012

  • Dividing the People

    Samantha A Vortherm, Samantha A Vortherms•Comparative Politics•2023

  • The Land-Use Diversity in Urban Villages in Shenzhen

    Open Access•Pu Hao, Stan Geertman et al.•Environment and Planning A…•2012

  • Cultures of labour

    Open Access•Samuel Berlin•Social & Cultural Geography•2024

  • Differentiating citizenship in urban China

    Zhonghua Guo, Tuo Liang•Citizenship Studies•2017

  • The local state andnongmingongcitizenship in Guangdong

    Yoon Jongseok•Citizenship Studies•2020

  • In the name of the nation

    Rogers Brubaker•Citizenship Studies•2004

  • Local Capitalisms, Local Citizenship and Translocality

    Open Access•A Smart, George C S Lin et al.•International Journal of Urban…•2007

  • Migrant Workers in the Urban Labour Market of Shenzhen, China

    Open Access•Mark Wang, Mark Y Wang et al.•Environment and Planning A…•2010

  • Spatial governmentality and the rhetoric of scarce resources

    Open Access•Anne-Christine Trémon•Environment and Planning A…•2025

  • China's Restless Urban Landscapes 1

    Open Access•George C S Lin, Y D Wei et al.•Environment and Planning A…•2002

  • From the Mountains and the Fields

    Open Access•A Smart, Li Zhang•China Information•2006

  • Rural Family Backgrounds, Higher Education, and Marriage Negotiations in Northwest China

    Open Access•Helena Obendiek•Modern Asian Studies•2016

  • Stratified financial inclusion in China based on hukou and its interaction with city and province development

    Open Access•Aihong Li•New Community•2023

  • Temporary migrants and public space

    Yining Tan•New Community•2021

  • Urbanization and the Global Perspective

    A Smart, Josephine Smart•Annual Review of Anthropology•2003

  • Gender Inequalities in Employment and Wage-earning among Economic Migrants in Chinese Cities

    Open Access•Min Qin, James Brown et al.•Demographic Research•2016

  • Old age insurance participation among rural-urban migrants in China

    Open Access•Min Qin, Yaer Zhuang et al.•Demographic Research•2015

  • Morality, Cosmopolitanism, or Academic Attainment? Discourses on "Quality" and Urban Chinese-Only-Children's Claims to Ideal Personhood

    Open Access•Vanessa L Fong•City & Society•2007

  • Urban Space and Exclusion in Asia

    E Harms•Annual Review of Anthropology•2016

  • The Unbearable Discretion of Street-Level Bureaucrats

    A Smart•Current Anthropology•2018

  • Does Urban Shrinkage Inhibit Residents' Welfare? From the Perspective of Urban-Rural Development in China

    Open Access•Rui Ding, Yuqi Zhu et al.•Social Indicators Research•2024

  • Citizenship

    J M Barbalet•Citizenship•1988

  • Contesting Citizenship in Urban China

    Dorothy J Solinger•Contesting Citizenship in Urban…•1999

  • From Organized Dependence to Disorganized Despotism

    Open Access•Ching Kwan Lee•The China Quarterly•1999

  • The Hukou System and Rural-Urban Migration in China

    Open Access•Kam Wing Chan, Li Zhang•The China Quarterly•1999

  • The “Rule of Law” Policy in Guangdong

    Open Access•Linda Chelan Li•The China Quarterly•2000

  • Authority and Welfare in China

    Open Access•Michael Twohey•Authority and Welfare in China•1999

  • Powers of Freedom

    Open Access•Nikolas Rose, Nikolas S Rose•Powers of Freedom•1999

  • Inheritors of the Boom

    Jonathan Unger, Anita Chan•The China Journal•1999

  • Reassessing the Role of the Local State

    Sally Sargeson, Jian Zhang•The China Journal•1999

  • Who Gets What, How

    X L Ding, Xinge Ding•Problems of Post-Communism•1999

  • Towards a Schumpeterian Workfare State? Preliminary Remarks on Post-Fordist Political Economy

    B Jessop•Studies in Political Economy•1993

  • Migration in a Socialist Transitional Economy

    Open Access•C Cindy Fan•International Migration Review•1999

  • China's Quiet Revolution

    Donald S Zagoria•Foreign Affairs•1984

  • The Political Economy of China's Financial Reforms

    Donald Zagoria, Donald S Zagoria et al.•Foreign Affairs•1994

  • Personal Politics in the Chinese Danwei under Reform

    Lowell Dittmer, X Lu et al.•Asian Survey•1996

  • Fiscal Reform and the Economic Foundations of Local State Corporatism in China

    Open Access•Jean C Oi•World Politics•1992

  • Chinese Rural Women in the Shift in the Rural Labor Force from Agricultural to Nonagricultural Work

    Meng Xianfan•Chinese Sociology & Anthropology•1998

  • The Political Economy of Rural Industrialization in China

    Open Access•Weixing Chen, Weixing Chen Weixing Chen•Modern China•1998

  • Personal Relations and Divergent Economies

    Open Access•Josephine Smart, A Smart•International Journal of Urban…•1991

  • State, Capital, and Space in China in an Age of Volatile Globalization

    Open Access•George C S Lin•Environment and Planning A…•2000

  • Reconstructing China's National Identity

    Open Access•E Friedman•The Journal of Asian Studies•1994

  • Transforming China's Economy in the Eighties, Volume I

    Barry Naughton, Feuchtwang et al.•Pacific Affairs•1989

  • Flexible Citizenship

    Aihwa Ong•Flexible Citizenship•2012

  • The Modernity of Power in the Chinese Socialist Order

    Open Access•Mayfair Mei-Hui Yang, Miao-Miao Yang•Cultural Anthropology•1988

  • Land Rents and the Rise of a Petty Bourgeoisie in Contemporary China

    Open Access•Josephine Smart•Anthropology of Work Review•1993

  • Migration and Privatization of Space and Power in Late Socialist China

    Open Access•Li Zhang•American Ethnologist•2001

  • And How Are We Supposed to Pay for Health Care? Views of the Poor and the Near Poor on Welfare Reform

    Open Access•Jo Anne Schneider•American Anthropologist•1999

  • Cities and Citizenship

    James Holston, A Appadurai•Public Culture•1996

  • Friedman's Revenge

    Open Access•John Myles, Paul Pierson•Latin American Politics and Society•1997

  • Local Governments as Industrial Firms

    Andrew G Walder•American Journal of Sociology•1995

  • Towards a Schumpeterian workfare postnational regime

    Jacob Torfing•Economy and Society•1999

  • Redefining Chinese citizenship

    Michael Keane•Economy and Society•2001

  • Transnationalization in international migration

    T Faist•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2000

  • The erosion of citizenship

    Open Access•B Turner, Bryan S Turner•British Journal of Sociology•2001

  • Popular Belief in State Intervention for Social Protection in China

    Open Access•Chack Kie Wong, Nan Shong Peter Lee•Journal of Social Policy•2000

  • Local market socialism

    Open Access•Nan Lin•Theory and Society•1995

Unique citing works69
Citations per year2,88
Citation span2002 - 2026 (25)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 67

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae