Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Developing Cultural Critical Consciousness and Self-Reflection in Preservice Teacher Education

Bibliographic Data

ID4255083
AuthorsGeneva Gay, Kipchoge Kirkland, Kipchoge Neftali Kirkland
Year2003
Volume42
Issue3
Pages181-187
Publication date2003-08-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueTheory Into Practice (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0040-5841 • E-ISSN: 1527-2532
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1353/tip.2003.0029
OpenAlexW4235082218
LanguageEN
Citations received240
References cited1

In this article, the authors argue that developing personal and professional critical consciousness about racial, cultural, and ethnic diversity should be a major component of preservice teacher education. They discuss some maneuvers teacher education students use to avoid engaging with racial issues in education, and suggest some strategies for counteracting them. The resistance strategies include silence, diversion, guilt, and benevolent liberalism. Techniques to offset these and develop critical cultural consciousness and self-reflection include creating learning expectations of criticalness, modeling, providing opportunities to practice critical consciousness, and translating conceptual multicultural education into K-12 instructional possibilities. Woven throughout the specific suggestions is the general directive that critical consciousness learning experiences should take place within the context of guided practice, authentic examples, and realistic situations

Aesthetics · Consciousness · Consciousness raising · Critical consciousness · Cultural competence · Cultural diversity · Cultural pluralism · Multicultural education · Multiculturalism · Pedagogy · Silence · Sociology · Teacher education · Education and Critical Thinking Development · Educational Challenges and Innovations · Psychology · Service-Learning and Community Engagement · Teacher Education and Leadership Studies

  • Co-creating Spaces of Rightful Presence

    Open Access•Katherine L Boice, Justina Rodriguez Jackson et al.•The Urban Review•2026

  • Género y Calidad en Educación Superior

    Open Access•Trinidad Donoso Vázquez, Trinidad Donoso-Vázquez et al.•Revista Electrónica Interuniversita…•2014

  • Challenging beliefs about cultural diversity in education

    Open Access•Sauro Civitillo, Linda Juang et al.•Educational Research Review•2018

  • An “Ideology in Pieces” Approach to Studying Change in Teachers’ Sensemaking About Race, Racism, and Racial Justice

    Thomas M Philip•Cognition and Instruction•2011

  • In Search of Our Mothers’ Gardens

    Open Access•Adrienne D Dixson, Jeannine E Dingus•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2008

  • Beyond Damage-Centered Teacher Education

    Open Access•Dorinda J Carter Andrews, Tashal Brown et al.•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2019

  • Preparing culturally responsive teachers in preK-12

    Open Access•I-Chun Vera Hsiao, Qianyi Gao•Multicultural Education Review•2026

  • ‘You petty’

    M Robert Bell•Journal of Popular Music Education•2026

  • Feasibility, Acceptability, and Preliminary Effectiveness of a Mindfulness-Based Critical Consciousness Training Program for Teachers

    Open Access•Doris F Chang, Fabienne Doucet et al.•Mindfulness•2026

  • The New Dreamkeepers

    Open Access•Corey J Gray•Gifted Child Today•2026

  • Operationalizing critical consciousness

    Open Access•Tahreem Fatima•International Journal of…•2026

  • Teacher Education Students’ Implicit Racial Attitudes and Interpersonal Attribution of Racialized Student Behavior

    Open Access•Nicole Lorenzetti, Helen Johnson•Journal of Contemporary Issues in…•2023

  • Cause-effect modelling of nine pedagogical methods for enhancing students’ critical thinking

    Open Access•Zohre Jaafari-Far, Morteza Rezaei-Zadeh et al.•Social Sciences & Humanities Open•2026

  • Reflective Practices of Teacher Educators in Punjab

    Open Access•Tanzeela Akram, Azhar Majeed Qureshi•Humanities & Social Sciences…•2021

  • Literacy Teacher Educators Creating Space for Children’s Literature

    Open Access•Lydia Menna, Clare Kosnik et al.•Education Sciences•2020

  • Decolonising Environmental Education Pedagogy

    Open Access•Sandra Ajap•Education Sciences•2026

  • Why Do Students Attend STEM Clubs, What Do They Get Out of It, and Where Are They Heading

    Open Access•Margaret R Blanchard, Kristie Gutierrez et al.•Education Sciences•2023

  • Culturally Responsive Professional Development Programs for Teacher Educators Using Community-Based Collaborative Learning

    Open Access•Lydiah Nganga, John Kambutu•Education Sciences•2024

  • Building Science Teacher Leaders for Indigenous Schools

    Open Access•Bhupendra Upadhyay, Saule Sadykova•Education Sciences•2024

  • Implicit Biases and Racial Microaggressions

    Fatima Mabrouk, Gerri Connaught et al.•Social Work in Public Health•2024

  • In(di)visable

    Lauren C Hennig, Lee Schaefer et al.•Physical Education and Sport…•2020

  • Working through contradictions

    Open Access•H Cho, Jonghun Kim et al.•Asia Pacific Education Review•2025

  • Carving out a hybrid space

    Open Access•H Cho•Asia Pacific Education Review•2021

  • Empowering the marginalised

    Open Access•David Puvaneyshwaran•Journal of Social Work•2024

  • Communities of practice as a launchpad for social justice planning in early childhood education

    Open Access•Victoria Damjanovic, Jennifer Ward et al.•Contemporary Issues in Early…•2023

  • Unpacking power

    Open Access•Charlene Montaño Nolan, Carolyn Brennan et al.•Contemporary Issues in Early…•2024

  • Starting with the self

    Open Access•Kerry‐Ann Escayg•Contemporary Issues in Early…•2024

  • Teachers as intercultural bridge‐builders

    Open Access•Thor-André Skrefsrud•Teaching Theology & Religion•2020

  • Implementing the critically compassionate intellectualism framework to foster preservice teachers’ social justice beliefs and empathy

    Megan Hut, D Jake Follmer et al.•Teachers and Teaching•2025

  • Towards a conceptual framework for Country-centred teaching and learning

    Open Access•C Burge, Katrina Thorpe et al.•Teachers and Teaching•2022

  • Towards relational music teacher professionalism

    Open Access•Laura Miettinen•Research Studies in Music Education•2021

  • Transforming Preservice Teacher Perceptions of Immigrant Communities Through Digital Storytelling

    Open Access•Lan Kolano, Anna Sanczyk•Journal of Experiential Education•2022

  • Organizational learning in consciousness-based education schools

    Open Access•Yvonne Lagrosen, Stefan Lagrosen•International Journal of…•2020

  • Using Anthropological Principles to Transform the Teaching of Human “Difference” and Genetic Variation in College Classrooms

    Open Access•Amelia Hubbard, Amelia R Hubbard et al.•Science & Education•2020

  • Latina dual language teacher candidates’ language ideologies in flux

    Open Access•Patricia Ferreyra•Linguistics and Education•2025

  • Unbiased but ideologically unclear

    Open Access•Pramod K Sah, Huseyin Uysal•Linguistics and Education•2022

  • Listening for silences

    Open Access•Ashley N Patterson, Ashley Patterson•Linguistics and Education•2022

  • The potential of on-campus study to support students' intercultural learning and development in higher education

    Open Access•Ming Lei, E David Wong et al.•International Journal of…•2023

  • Teachers’ beliefs and characteristics predictive of their willingness to cultivate a safe, ethnically inclusive school environment

    Open Access•Daria Khanolainen, Yulia Nesterova et al.•International Journal of…•2024

  • Promoting pre-service teachers’ critical cultural and multilingual awareness and responsiveness, and beliefs about multilingualism through practice-oriented, (self‐)reflexive intervention

    Open Access•Lotta Kardel, Timo Ehmke•Teaching and Teacher Education•2026

  • Critical talk moves in critical conversations

    Amy Vetter, Melissa Schieble et al.•English in Education•2021

  • Reframing teacher education around inclusion, equity, and social justice

    Noel Purdy, Kathy Hall et al.•European Journal of Teacher…•2023

  • Towards equity literacy

    Open Access•Hanna Posti-Ahokas, Hille Janhonen-Abruquah et al.•European Journal of Teacher…•2024

  • Teaching to teach civics in fragile times

    Aviv Cohen•European Journal of Teacher…•2021

  • Supporting student-teachers in the multicultural classroom

    Kari Stunell•European Journal of Teacher…•2021

  • Wobbling our way to culturally proactive pedagogies

    Courtney Shimek, Carin Appleget et al.•Journal of Education for Teaching…•2023

  • A Divergence of Interests

    Open Access•Ryan M Crowley, William L Smith•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2020

  • Reflexive Researching

    Open Access•Jason Zagami•European Journal of Education•2026

  • Organizing Possible Futures

    Open Access•Dosun Ko, Dian Mawene et al.•Review of Educational Research•2024

  • The role of teacher critical racial consciousness in cultivating student–teacher relationships and school belonging for Black, Indigenous, and youth of color

    Open Access•Ashley Parra López, Tiffany M Jones et al.•Psychology in the Schools•2024

  • Science for our children

    Open Access•Stefanie L Marshall, Jessica Forrester et al.•Journal of Research in Science…•2024

  • Embracing equity and excellence while constructing science teacher identities in urban schools

    Open Access•Maria Varelas, David San Martín Segura et al.•Journal of Research in Science…•2023

  • Impacting Resilience of Black Students Through Critically Conscious Institutional Leadership and Policy

    Open Access•Jessica Henderson•Journal of Education•2022

  • Teaching Racial History

    Open Access•Abby Reisman, Lightning Peter Jay•Journal of Curriculum Studies•2022

  • A brief diversity training

    Open Access•Franziska Ehrke, Aysan Ashoee et al.•International Journal of Psychology•2020

  • Preparing Teachers to Be Culturally Multidimensional

    Dorinda J Carter Andrews•The Educational Forum•2021

  • Defining Rigor in Justice-Oriented EdD Programs

    Open Access•Jess R Weiler, Kofi Lomotey•Educational Administration…•2022

  • Teachers' perceptions of culturally responsive teaching in technology‐supported learning environments

    Open Access•Hsueh-Hua Chuang, Hsueh‐Hua Chuang et al.•British Journal of Educational…•2020

  • Development of linguistic critical consciousness of multilingual preservice teachers of color

    Laura Mahalingappa•International Multilingual…•2024

  • Supporting Bilingual Teachers To Be Leaders for Social Change

    Deborah K Palmer•International Multilingual…•2018

  • Effects of Intercultural Sensitivity and Critical Thinking Trainings on Teachers’ Professional Development

    Mohammad Mohammadi, Mohammad Hossein Yousefi et al.•Journal of Intercultural…•2023

  • Literacies at the border

    Carol Brochin Ceballos•International Journal of…•2012

  • ‘White ways of being isn’t the only way’

    Kathryn Accurso, Jason D Mizell•Language Awareness•2025

  • Teaching Contested Narratives

    Open Access•Zvi Bekerman, M Zembylas•Teaching Contested Narratives•2011

  • The Cambridge Handbook of Psychology and Human Rights

    Open Access•Neal S Rubin, Roseanne L Flores•Cambridge Handbook of Psychology…•2020

  • It Was Nice To Be Able To Talk to Them Like They Were Family.”

    Open Access•Cori Salmerón•Journal of Teacher Education•2025

  • I want to do the right thing but what is it

    Malik S Henfield, Malik S Henfield Malik S Henfield et al.•The Journal of Negro Education•2012

  • Empowering Students to Engage with Climate Change Action

    Open Access•Gabriel Granco, Yu Chen et al.•The Professional Geographer•2026

  • When students write about race

    Arianna Banack, Rosa Nam•Journal for Multicultural Education•2026

  • Becoming through reflexivity

    Minkyung Choi, Sharon Lai-LaGrotteria•Race Ethnicity and Education•2026

  • ‘Like’ if you support refugees

    Matthew R Deroo, Scott D Farver et al.•Multicultural Education Review•2017

  • Teachers’ understanding of cultural diversity

    Open Access•Ho Cheong Lam•Multicultural Education Review•2022

  • Professional judgement and cultural critical consciousness

    H Cho•Multicultural Education Review•2018

  • ‘Teaching from the Heart’

    Open Access•Daniel Stern, C Burge et al.•The Australian Journal of…•2020

  • Listening to teachers

    Open Access•Deborah Rivas-Drake, Victoria A Vezaldenos et al.•Applied Developmental Science•2026

  • Transformative reflective practice in the intercultural education course

    Anna Sanczyk, Anna Sanczyk-Cruz•Journal of Education for Teaching…•2026

  • The Use of Critical Consciousness for Gender Equality in Pre-Service Teacher Education

    Open Access•Esin Kumlu•SAGE Open•2024

  • English Instructors Navigating Decoloniality with Afro Colombian and Indigenous University Students

    Open Access•Claudia Patricia Gutierrez, Maure Aguirre Ortega•Íkala Revista de Lenguaje y Cultura•2022

  • Critical Consciousness

    Open Access•Alexis Jemal•The Urban Review•2017

  • Drivers of human development

    Open Access•David Osher, Pamela Cantor et al.•Applied Developmental Science•2020

  • Responding to What We Notice

    Open Access•Heather B Cunningham•Urban Education•2019

  • Counter-Mapping in Geographic Education

    Open Access•Seila Soler, Pablo Rosser•Heritage•2024

  • Beginning teachers’ knowledge-in-practice of multicultural science education

    Open Access•Hannah Kye•Journal for Multicultural Education•2020

  • Cultural and functional diversity in the elementary classroom

    Open Access•Rama Cousik•Journal for Multicultural Education•2015

  • Cultivating hope in uncertain times

    Open Access•Sheeba Jacob•Journal for Multicultural Education•2025

  • Imagined innocence meets lived experience

    Open Access•Sarah Campbell Lightner•Journal for Multicultural Education•2021

  • Teacher education and multicultural courses in North Carolina

    Open Access•John A Williams Iii, John A Williams et al.•Journal for Multicultural Education•2019

  • From seeing to believing

    Open Access•Jordan Fullam•Journal for Multicultural Education•2017

  • Millennial teachers and multiculturalism

    Open Access•Heidi L Hallman•Journal for Multicultural Education•2017

  • From salvation to inquiry

    Open Access•Lucinda G Heimer•Global Studies of Childhood•2020

  • Creating More Effective Multiethnic Schools

    Open Access•Sabrina Zirkel•Social Issues and Policy Review•2008

  • Black Student Belonging in K12 Schools

    Open Access•Royel M Johnson, Jessica T Decuir‐gunby et al.•Social Issues and Policy Review•2025

  • Beyond cultural competence

    C Burge•Critical Studies in Education•2017

  • Being’ a critical multicultural pedagogue in the art education classroom

    Joni Boyd Acuff•Critical Studies in Education•2016

  • Building Multicultural Awareness in University Students Using Synchronous Technology

    Open Access•Michele Garabedian Stork, Jingshun Zhang et al.•TechTrends•2017

  • Creativity as Perspective Taking

    Open Access•Sarah F Keenan-Lechel, Danah Henriksen•TechTrends•2019

  • I don’t really see any Asian culture around me”

    Su-Jeong Wee, Su Jeong Wee et al.•Diaspora Indigenous and Minority…•2026

  • Reconceptualizing TPACK to Meet the Needs of Twenty-First-Century Education

    Todd Cherner, David W Smith et al.•The New Educator•2016

  • Teacher Candidates’ Perceptions of Debriefing Circles to Facilitate Self-Reflection During a Cultural Immersion Experience

    Rebecca A Addleman, Carol Jo Brazo et al.•The New Educator•2014

  • Community Mapping as a Tool for Developing Culturally Relevant Pedagogy

    Tambra O Jackson, Brandy S Bryson•The New Educator•2018

  • The reflective practitioner

    Donald A Schon•The reflective practitioner•1991

Unique citing works236
Citations per year11,43
Citation span2005 - 2026 (22)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 237

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae