Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

They're part of what we are

Interspecies belonging, animal life and farming practice on the Isle of Skye

Bibliographic Data

ID4464474
AuthorsTom Fry (University of Cambridge, corresponding author)
Year2023
Volume6
Issue4
Pages2495-2515
Publication date2023-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEnvironment and Planning E Nature and Space (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 2514-8486 • E-ISSN: 2514-8494
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/25148486231151809
OpenAlexW4321600873
LanguageEN
Citations received17
References cited95

This article develops the concept of interspecies belonging: a process of co-habitation between humans and non-humans achieved through material, affective and situated practises. This dynamic is generative of an intimate, personal sense of belonging and a socio-spatial politics of belonging. The article is based on ethnographic fieldwork amongst hill farmers and the animals they live alongside on the Isle of Skye, North-West Scotland. It considers how farming work is an embodied and sensorial immersion in more-than-human worlds, undergirded by affective intensities that produce a feeling of being right with the world, but also of the farming self as producer of commodity goods. Within the fraught political ecologies of a post-productivist uplands, and the growing influence of nature conservation in farming life, they animate a political belonging aimed at protecting access to natural resources. I demonstrate how the imbrication of animal behaviours, mobilities and bodies within this dynamic of belonging shapes how they are understood as legitimate or illegitimate presences within upland landscapes. Through this, I consider how the recently reintroduced sea eagle is engaged with by farmers as an exemplar of exogenous institutional intervention that marginalises an already precarious way of life

Agriculture · Archaeology · Embodied cognition · Environmental ethics · Ethnography · Feeling · Geography · Political science · Politics · Situated · Sociology · Anthropology · Geographies of human-animal interactions · Human-Animal Interaction Studies · Psychology · Social Psychology · Wildlife Ecology and Conservation

  • Perceptions and expectations for the persistence of elephants in Knysna, South Africa

    Open Access•Lizette Moolman, Graham I H Kerley et al.•Ecosystems and People•2026

  • Feral pigs or wild boar? Emerging interpretations of belonging and coexistence in the Scottish Highlands

    Open Access•Toryn Whitehead, Kate Schreckenberg et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2026

  • Peopled landscapes

    Open Access•Jennifer M Atchison, Jenny Pickerill et al.•People and Nature•2024

  • Reimagining habituation

    Open Access•Ethan Doney, T Fry et al.•People and Nature•2025

  • Eager about beavers? Understanding opposition to species reintroduction, and its implications for conservation

    Open Access•George Holmes, Gabriel Rowland et al.•People and Nature•2024

  • Beavers in paradise

    Open Access•J Turnbull, T Fry et al.•Environment and Planning E Nature…•2026

  • Camels and Cosmopolitanism

    Marek Wieczorek, Anke Reichenbach•Journal of Arabian Studies•2025

  • Rewilding relationships

    Open Access•Kristy M Ferraro, Toryn Whitehead•AMBIO•2026

  • (Re)wilding London

    Open Access•J Turnbull, T Fry et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•2025

  • From biopower to affirmative biopolitics

    Open Access•Valerio Donfrancesco, C Sandbrook•Transactions of the Institute of…•2025

  • Gender and Rewilding

    Open Access•Nadia Bartolini•Area•2025

  • The Radical Edge of More-Than-Human Political Ecology

    Open Access•Valerio Donfrancesco•Progress in Environmental Geography•2025

  • Renegotiating Species Belonging in a Changing World

    Open Access•Aisling Rayne, Marc Tadaki et al.•Progress in Environmental Geography•2025

  • Casual killing in the home

    Open Access•Orlando Woods, J Qian•Environment and Planning E Nature…•2025

  • (Co)producing landscapes of coexistence

    Open Access•Valerio Donfrancesco•Geoforum•2024

  • Genealogies of scientifically induced biomobilities

    Open Access•Ferran Pons-Raga, I Vaccaro•Social Science Information•2025

  • Beekeeping, stewardship and multispecies care in rural contexts

    Open Access•Siobhan Maderson, Emily Elsner‐adam•Sociologia Ruralis•2024

  • The Routledge Companion to Landscape Studies

    Peter Howard, Ian Thompson et al.•Routledge International Handbooks•2013

  • Solitary Confinement

    Lisa Guenther•Solitary Confinement: Social…•2013

  • Emotional political ecology

    Farhana Sultana•International Handbook of…•2015

  • Rewilding Abandoned Landscapes in Europe

    Open Access•Laetitia M Navarro, Henrique M Pereira•Ecosystems•2012

  • Title unavailable

    Open Access•null null•Philosophy study•2016

  • Whose Discourse Is It Anyway? Understanding Resistance through the Rise of “Barstool Biology” in Nature Conservation

    Emma Von Essen, Erica Von Essen•Environmental Communication•2017

  • Redefining Nature

    R F Ellen, Roy Ellen et al.•Redefining Nature•2021

  • The Good Farmer

    Rob J F Burton, Jérémie Forney et al.•Good Farmer•2020

  • Belonging

    Bell Hooks•Belonging•2008

  • Solitary Confinement

    Lars Guenther, Lisa Guenther•Solitary Confinement•2010

  • From productivism to post‐productivism … and back again? Exploring the (un)changed natural and mental landscapes of European agriculture

    Open Access•Geoff A Wilson•Transactions of the Institute of…•2001

  • The king of the forest

    Open Access•Nicolas Lescureux, John D C Linnell et al.•Conservation and Society•2011

  • Deceptive Landscapes

    Ben Garlick•GeoHumanities•2019

  • Affective adaptation = effective transformation? Shifting the politics of climate change adaptation and transformation from the status quo

    Open Access•Andrea J Nightingale, Noémi Gonda et al.•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2021

  • The cultural model of “the good farmer” and the environmental question in Finland

    Open Access•Tiina Silvasti•Agriculture and Human Values•2003

  • Farmer autonomy and the farming self

    Open Access•Paul V Stock, Jérémie Forney•Journal of Rural Studies•2014

  • Injecting social psychology theory into conceptualisations of agricultural agency

    Open Access•Rob J F Burton, Geoff A Wilson•Journal of Rural Studies•2005

  • Family farms in the Scottish borders

    Open Access•John Gray•Journal of Rural Studies•1998

  • Perspectives on the `alien' versus `native' species debate

    Open Access•Charles R Warren•Progress in Human Geography•2007

  • The Great Highland famine

    Open Access•Carl Withers•Journal of Historical Geography•1990

  • The reintroduction of the white-tailed sea eagle to Ireland

    Open Access•Eileen O’rourke•Land Use Policy•2014

  • Future nature

    Open Access•Michael Winter•Land Use Policy•1997

  • Special issue on pastoral landscapes caught between abandonment, rewilding and agro-environmental management. Is there an alternative future

    Werner Krauß, Kenneth R Olwig•Landscape Research•2018

  • Belonging and the politics of belonging

    Nira Yuval-Davis•Patterns of Prejudice•2006

  • Decolonizing nature—strategies for conservation in a post-colonial era

    Open Access•Eilidh Johnston•Land Use Policy•2004

  • Positive parochialism”, local belonging and ecological concerns

    Open Access•Patrick Devine‐wright, Jos Smith et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•2018

  • Suffering for water, suffering from water

    Open Access•Farhana Sultana•Geoforum•2011

  • Furthering post-human political ecologies

    Open Access•Joseph Margulies, Brock Bersaglio•Geoforum•2018

  • Wild horses and the political ecology of nature restoration in the Missouri Ozarks

    Open Access•J Sanford Rikoon•Geoforum•2005

  • An essay on ascending Glastonbury Tor

    Open Access•Jonathan Wylie, John Wylie•Geoforum•2002

  • In quest of a new humanism

    Open Access•Kirsten Simonsen•Progress in Human Geography•2012

  • Political ecology III

    Open Access•Roderick P Neumann•Progress in Human Geography•2011

  • Introduction

    Open Access•NeeraM Singh•Conservation and Society•2018

  • Intensities of feeling

    Nigel Thrift•Geografiska Annaler Series B…•2004

  • Encountering Affect

    Ben Anderson•Encountering Affect•2014

  • Animal landscapes

    Open Access•David Matle, David Matless et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•2005

  • Animals’ mobilities

    Open Access•Timothy Hodgetts, Jamie Lorimer•Progress in Human Geography•2018

  • How is space made in sound? Spatial mediation, critical phenomenology and the political agency of sound

    Open Access•George Revill•Progress in Human Geography•2015

  • The affective labor of growing forests and the becoming of environmental subjects

    Open Access•Neera M Singh•Geoforum•2013

  • Is post-phenomenology a critical geography? Subjectivity and difference in post-phenomenological geographies

    Open Access•Eden Kinkaid•Progress in Human Geography•2020

  • More-than-human, emergent belongings

    Open Access•Sarah E Wright, Sarah Wright•Progress in Human Geography•2014

  • Animal geographies I

    Open Access•Leah Gibbs•Progress in Human Geography•2019

  • Practice, Spatiality and Embodied Emotions

    Kirsten Simonsen•Human Affairs•2007

  • Storied-places in a multispecies city

    Open Access•T Van Dooren, Deborah Bird Rose•Humanimalia•2012

  • Who let the wolves out? Narratives, rumors and social representations of the wolf in Greece

    Ilektra Theodora Theodorakea, Emma Von Essen•Environmental Sociology•2016

  • Neoliberal natures on the farm

    Open Access•Paul V Stock, Jérémie Forney et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2014

  • Emotions, power, and environmental conflict

    Open Access•Marien González‐hidalgo, Marien González-Hidalgo et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2019

  • Co-becoming Bawaka

    Open Access•Bawaka Country, Sarah E Wright et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2015

  • Cultural geography

    Open Access•Hayden Lorimer, Hester Parr•Progress in Human Geography•2005

  • Ways of Walking

    Jo Lee Vergunst, Tim Ingold•Ways of Walking•2016

  • Introducing new feminist political ecologies

    Open Access•Rebecca Elmhirst•Geoforum•2011

  • Animal geographies I

    Open Access•Henry Buller•Progress in Human Geography•2013

  • Spacing the subject

    Open Access•P Simpson•Geography Compass•2017

  • Searching for Belonging - An Analytical Framework

    Open Access•M Antonsich•Geography Compass•2010

  • The Interruption

    Open Access•Leila Dawney•Environment and Planning D…•2013

  • Gifted Places

    Open Access•Julia Bennett•Environment and Planning D…•2014

  • Illuminated Atmospheres

    Open Access•T Edensor•Environment and Planning D…•2012

  • A Wolf at the Gate

    Open Access•Ketil Skogen, Olve Krange•Sociologia Ruralis•2003

  • Herding Memories of Humans and Animals

    Open Access•Hayden Lorimer, Hester Parr•Environment and Planning D…•2006

  • Bio-Geo-Graphy

    Open Access•Merry Barua, Maan Barua•Environment and Planning D…•2014

  • Atmospheric Attunements

    Open Access•Kathleen Stewart•Environment and Planning D…•2011

  • The Nature of Gender

    Open Access•Andrea Nightingale, Andrea J Nightingale•Environment and Planning D…•2006

  • Becoming and Being Hopeful

    Open Access•Ben Anderson•Environment and Planning D…•2006

  • Seeing Through the 'Good Farmer's' Eyes

    Open Access•Rob J F Burton•Sociologia Ruralis•2004

  • Geographies of Belonging

    Open Access•Kathy Mee, Kathleen Mee et al.•Environment and Planning A…•2009

  • Nonhuman citizens on trial

    Open Access•Sarah L Crowley, Sarah Crowley et al.•Environment and Planning A…•2017

  • Fishing for Nature

    Open Access•Andrea Nightingale, Andrea J Nightingale•Environment and Planning A…•2013

  • A Space to Care, a Space of Care

    Open Access•Kathy Mee, Kathleen Mee•Environment and Planning A…•2009

  • Making and Gifting Belonging

    Open Access•Edward Hall•Environment and Planning A…•2013

  • Urban foraging and the relational ecologies of belonging

    Melissa R Poe, Joyce K Lecompte et al.•Social & Cultural Geography•2014

  • Of place' or 'of people

    Lauren E Van Patter, Alice J Hovorka•Social & Cultural Geography•2018

  • Towards the necessity of a new interactive approach integrating ethnology, ecology and ethology in the study of the relationship between Kyrgyz stockbreeders and wolves

    Open Access•Nicolas Lescureux•Social Science Information•2006

  • The Perception of the Environment

    T Ingold•The Perception of the Environment•2002

  • In Amazonia

    Hugh Raffles•In Amazonia•2003

  • From pest to partner

    Open Access•Shaun Mckiernan, Lesley Instone•Cultural Geographies•2016

  • Engineering affective atmospheres on the moving geographies of the 1897 Andrée expedition

    Open Access•Derek P Mccormack•Cultural Geographies•2008

  • Searching for Paradise in the Florida Everglades

    Open Access•Laura A Ogden•Cultural Geographies•2008

  • From lived experience to political representation

    Open Access•Steven B Emery, Michael Carrithers et al.•Ethnography•2016

  • Street Phenomenology

    Open Access•Margarethe Kusenbach•Ethnography•2003

  • Performativity and Belonging

    Open Access•Vikki Bell•Theory Culture & Society•1999

  • Collective Feelings

    Open Access•Sara Ahmed•Theory Culture & Society•2004

  • Social representations of the wolf

    Open Access•Helene Figari, Ketil Skogen•Acta Sociologica•2011

  • The Nature/s of Belonging

    Stephanie Lavau•Ethnos•2011

Unique citing works17
Citations per year8,5
Citation span2024 - 2026 (3)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 15

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae