The Rise and Fall of Urban Movements and the Role of Comparative Analysts

Bibliographic Data

ID4475255
AuthorsChris Pickvance (University of Kent, corresponding author)
Year1985
Volume3
Issue1
Pages31-53
Publication date1985-03-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEnvironment and Planning D Society and Space (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0263-7758 • E-ISSN: 1472-3433
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1068/d030031
OpenAlexW2045097303
LanguageEN
Citations received48
References cited34

The paper is concerned with the changing incidence and militancy of urban movements since the 1960s, The diversity of experience between countries, and within countries over time, poses a problem of comparative analysis. This can be tackled by advancing a single model applying in highly diverse situations-as in Castells's The City and the Grassroots-or by constructing a series of submodels each of which applies in specific conditions. Castells's work is criticized for stressing movement characteristics at the expense of contextual characteristics, and an alternative approach is argued for in which urban movement experience is shaped by five contextual features: urbanisation conditions, state action, the political context, the development of middle class, and the general economic and social conditions. Submodels drawing on these features are used to make a comparative analysis of urban movement experience in France, Italy, and Spain. A typology of urban movements is drawn up: movements for the provision of and access to housing and urban services, for control and management, and for the defense of housing and neighbourhood. These relate to three distinct notions of urban-collective consumption, local political process, and spatial proximity-and the differential impact of the contextual features on each type of movement is shown. The paper is concerned with all types of urban movement, and uses the term 'urban social movement' to refer only to the extremely rare cases of a major change in urban power relations

Collective action · Context (archaeology · Economic geography · Economic growth · Economics · Geography · Grassroots · Movement (music · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Regional science · Social movement · Sociology · Typology · Urbanization · Political and Economic history of UK and US

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub