"Between Genocide and "Genocide

The two books discussed here join a current pushback against the concept (thus also against claims for the historical occurrence) of genocide. Nichanian focuses on the Armenian "Aghed" ("Catastrophe"), inferring from his view of that event's undeniability that "genocide is not a fact" (since all facts are deniable). May's critique assumes that groups don't really-"objectively"-exist, as (by contrast) individuals do; thus, genocide-group murder-also has an "as if" quality so far as concerns the group victimized. On the one hand, then, uniqueness and sacralization; on the other hand, reductionism and diffusion. Alas, the historical and moral claims in "defense" of both genocide and "genocide" survive

Ancient history · Armenian · Criminology · Genocide · Political science · Sociology · Global Peace and Security Dynamics · History · Law · Post-Soviet Geopolitical Dynamics · Turkey's Politics and Society