Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Mimesis and Motivation

The Two Faces of Fictional Coherence

Bibliographic Data

ID4747485
AuthorsMeir Sternberg (0000-0001-9762-0350, Tel Aviv University, corresponding author)
Year2012
Volume33
Issue3-4
Pages329-483
Publication date2012-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenuePoetics Today (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0333-5372 • E-ISSN: 1527-5507
PublisherDuke University Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1215/03335372-1812153
OpenAlexW2101534641
LanguageEN
Citations received20
References cited88

This paper deals with "motivation" as fiction's twofold logic of patterning and relates it to other concepts or lines of sense-making (e.g., integration, naturalization). The argument is best summarized through the paper's headings.1. Why Is the Discourse Like That? Motivation as Twofold Reason-Giving2. Reality, Artifice, and Motivation: Doctrinal Biases, Variable Products, Universal Modes; 2.1 Aristotle's Mimesis of Nature by Art; or, Why Plot above Character?; 2.2 Viktor Shklovsky and Mimesis Fallen below Art3. How the Extremes Compare: Toward an Alternative Theory4. Conceptualizing Motivation: Basic Requirements5. Motivation and Integration: The Concept of Functional Mediacy; 5.1 Motivation in Tomashevsky's "Thematics": The Shift from Cover to Coherence; 5.2 From Polarity to Threefold: The Typology of Motivation; 5.3 Motivating and Integrating Distinguished in Face of Persistent Mix-Up; 5.4 Naturalization6. Integral and Differential Motivation: The Mimetic Function7. Motivation and Communicative Structure: Point of View as Sense-Making Construct; 7.1 Who Motivates, and from Whose Standpoint?; 7.2 Motivating Fictional as against Factual Discourse: The Difference Made by Quotation; 7.3 Appeal to Existence or to Perspective? Unrealistic World and/or Unreliable Subject?; 7.4 Fictional Motivation under the Proteus Principle; 7.5 Sibling Rivalry and Contingent Resolution within the Family of MimesisI am an art theoretician.... I know what motivation is!Viktor Shklovsky, A Sentimental Journey

Aesthetics · Appeal · Epistemology · Gestalt psychology · Linguistics · Perception · Computer Science · Language, Metaphor, and Cognition · Narrative Theory and Analysis · Philosophy · Psychology · Russian Literature and Bakhtin Studies

  • Entretien avec Hans Färnlöf – La motivation littéraire en débat

    Open Access•Christophe Premat, Hans Färnlöf•Nordic Journal of Francophone…•2023

  • A Narrator, But One With Extremely Pressing Personal Needs”

    David Stromberg•Journal of Narrative Theory•2019

  • Telling in Time (III)

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2006

  • (Un)Reliability in Narrative Discourse

    Meir Sternberg, Tamar Yacobi•Poetics Today•2015

  • Interart Narrative

    Tamar Yacobi•Poetics Today•2000

  • Mimesis and Motivation

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2012

  • Narrativity

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2010

  • Omniscience in Narrative Construction

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2007

  • Universals of Narrative and Their Cognitivist Fortunes (I)

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2003

  • Time Travel Stories as a Challenge to Narratology

    Eyal Segal•Poetics Today•2015

  • Universals of Narrative and Their Cognitivist Fortunes (II)

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2003

  • Factives and Perspectives

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2001

  • Intratextuality, Extratextuality, Intertextuality

    Dan Shen, Dejin Xu•Poetics Today•2007

  • Authorial Presence in Poetry

    Margaret H Freeman•Poetics Today•2015

  • Introduction to the Study of Doxa

    Ruth Amossy•Poetics Today•2002

  • Fiction and Imitation

    Thomas Pavel•Poetics Today•2000

  • Retour à la forme et au fond du récit

    Open Access•Hans Färnlöf•Cahiers de narratologie•2025

  • Mind the Text! Neurohermeneutics for Suspicious Readers

    Margaret H Freeman•Poetics Today•2026

  • Communication Technology and Narrative

    Alistair R Brown, Alistair Brown•Poetics Today•2015

  • The Rhetorics of Plot Function

    Kristina Mikkonen, Kai Mikkonen•Poetics Today•2022

  • The poetics of biblical narrative

    Meir Sternberg•The poetics of biblical narrative•1985

  • The Formal Method in Literary Scholarship

    M M Bakhtin, Pavel Nikolaevich Medvedev•The Formal Method in Literary…•1991

  • Narratology

    Mieke Bal•Narratology•1997

  • Russian formalist criticism

    Lee T Lemon, Marion J Reis•Russian formalist criticism•1965

  • Heterocosmica

    Lubomir Dolezel•Heterocosmica•2000

  • Transparent Minds

    Dorrit Cohn, Dorrit Claire Cohn•Transparent Minds•1978

  • Basic Elements of Narrative

    Open Access•David Herman•Basic Elements of Narrative•2009

  • Structuralist Poetics

    Jonathan Culler, Jonathan D Culler•Structuralist Poetics•1975

  • Problems of Dostoevsky's Poetics

    Mikhail Bakhtin, M M Bakhtin et al.•Problems of Dostoevsky's Poetics•1984

  • The Content of the Form

    Hayden White•Content of the Form•1990

  • Towards a ‘Natural’ Narratology

    Monika Fludernik•Journal of Literary Semantics•1996

  • Aristotle's poetics

    Open Access•Stephen Halliwell•The Cambridge history of literary…•1990

  • Introduction and Notes

    John Muir•Greek Eyes on Europe•2022

  • Aristotle's Poetics

    Gerald F Else•Aristotle's Poetics•1957

  • Morphology of the Folktale

    Vladimir Propp, Laurence Scott et al.•Morphology of the Folktale•1968

  • The Fictions of Language and the Languages of Fiction

    Monika Fludernik•Fictions of Language and the…•2003

  • The Poetics of Incomprehensibility

    Stephen Orgel•Shakespeare Quarterly•1991

  • The Classical Hollywood Cinema

    David Bordwell•The Classical Hollywood Cinema•2003

  • Narrative and normative pattern

    Open Access•Tamar Yacobi•Journal of Literary Studies•1987

  • Aesthetic conception of Russian Formalism

    Open Access•Valerij Gretchko•Sign Systems Studies•2003

  • Narrative Theory and the Cognitive Sciences

    Daniela Herman•Narrative Inquiry•2001

  • The Ontology of the Literary Sign

    Donald G Marshall•boundary 2•1976

  • Dostoevsky and Gogol

    Edgar H Lehrman, Priscilla Meyer et al.•The Slavic and East European…•1980

  • Narrative and Anti-Narrative Structures in Lev Tolstoj's Early Works

    Andrew Wachtel, Eric de Haard•The Slavic and East European…•1991

  • Formalist Theory Revisited

    Mary A Nicholas•The Slavic and East European…•1992

  • Eisenstein's 'Ivan the Terrible

    Herbert Eagle, Kristin Thompson•The Slavic and East European…•1983

  • The Problem of Verse Language

    Barry P Scherr, Yuri Tynianov et al.•The Slavic and East European…•1982

  • The Classical Hollywood Cinema’

    Barry King•Screen•1986

  • A Sentimental Journey. Memoirs, 1917-1922

    George Gibian, Viktor Shklovsky et al.•The Russian Review•1970

  • Anti-Mimesis

    Cesare Casarino, Tom Cohen•American Literature•1995

  • Implied Author, Motivation and Theme and their Problematic Status

    Open Access•Nilli Diengott•Orbis Litterarum•1993

  • The Plot Thickens—or Not

    Open Access•Louise Sundararajan•Journal of Humanistic Psychology•2007

  • Zoo, or Letters Not about Love

    Maurice Friedberg, Viktor Shklovsky et al.•The Slavic and East European…•1972

  • Ordering the Unordered

    Meir Sternberg•Yale French Studies•1981

  • Narrative Humor (II)

    Jeroen Vandaele•Poetics Today•2012

  • Narrative Structure and Fictional Mediation

    Tamar Yacobi•Poetics Today•1987

  • Narrativity

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2010

  • Reply to Victor Erlich

    Open Access•Richard Sheldon•Slavic Review•1976

  • Fact, Fiction, and Form

    Ralph W Rader, James Phelan et al.•Poetics Today•2013

  • On Poetry and Trans-Sense Language

    Viktor Shklovsky, Gerald Janecek et al.•October•1985

  • Simile and Figurative Language

    Louise Bethlehem, Louise Shabat Bethlehem•Poetics Today•1996

  • Universals of Narrative and Their Cognitivist Fortunes (II)

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2003

  • An Introduction to the Structural Analysis of Narrative

    Roland Barthes, Lionel Duisit•New Literary History•1975

  • Literature and Cinematography

    Eyal Segal•Poetics Today•2011

  • Telling in Time (II)

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•1992

  • Telling in Time (I)

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•1990

  • Intratextuality, Extratextuality, Intertextuality

    Dan Shen, Dejin Xu•Poetics Today•2007

  • Mimesis and Motivation

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2012

  • Universals of Narrative and Their Cognitivist Fortunes (I)

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2003

  • Interart Narrative

    Tamar Yacobi•Poetics Today•2000

  • Omniscience in Narrative Construction

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2007

  • Claims of Stable Identity and (Un)reliability in Dissonant Narration

    Paul Mccormick•Poetics Today•2009

  • Proteus in Quotation-Land

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•1982

  • A Theory of Narrative

    Franz Stanzel, Franz K Stanzel et al.•Poetics Today•1985

  • Factives and Perspectives

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2001

  • Frames, Preferences, and the Reading of Third-Person Narratives

    Manfred Jahn•Poetics Today•1997

  • Fictional Reliability as a Communicative Problem

    Tamar Yacobi•Poetics Today•1981

  • Reading Intended Meaning Where None Is Intended

    H Porter Abbott•Poetics Today•2011

  • On Being Fair to Viktor Shklovsky or the Act of Hedged Surrender

    Open Access•Victor Erlich•Slavic Review•1976

  • Boris Eikhenbaum in Opoiaz

    Open Access•Carol Any•Slavic Review•1990

  • Reference, Coreference, Referring, and the Dual Structure of Literary Narrative

    Uri Margolin•Poetics Today•1991

  • Telling in Time (III)

    Meir Sternberg•Poetics Today•2006

  • Farce and the Poetics of the 'Vraisemblable

    Menachem Brinker•Critical Inquiry•1983

  • Order and Disorder in Film and Fiction

    Alain Robbe-Grillet, Bruce Morrissette•Critical Inquiry•1977

Unique citing works20
Citations per year0,77
Citation span2000 - 2026 (27)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 4

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae