Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Strategies for Comparative Urbanism

Post-socialism as a De-territorialized Concept

Bibliographic Data

ID4937590
AuthorsTauri Tuvikene (0000-0003-4617-3284, Centre for Landscape and Culture, Tallinn University Narva mnt 25 10120 Tallinn Estonia, corresponding author)
Year2016
Volume40
Issue1
Pages132-146
Publication date2016-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueInternational Journal of Urban and Regional Research (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0309-1317 • E-ISSN: 1468-2427
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/1468-2427.12333
OpenAlexW2338905226
LanguageEN
Citations received98
References cited67

The aim of this article is to critically assess the study of post-socialist cities with respect to comparative urbanism. Even though comparative urbanism has challenged the division of the world into largely incommensurable regional containers, where some regions are sources of theory while others remain in the periphery of thinking, post-socialist cities have remained doubly excluded: neither centre nor periphery, neither mainstream nor part of the critique. This article introduces three ways in which post-socialism has and could be perceived: as a container, as a condition and as a de-territorialized concept. It is argued here that seeing post-socialism as a de-territorialized concept that would apply to particular aspects of cities and societies rather than territorialized units in general would allow cities regularly seen as post-socialist to be incorporated into global urban theorizing, while distinctive local histories and experiences still remain analytically present. The article cautions researchers against area-based imaginations of urban theorization, instead arguing in favour of an approach that sees cities first and foremost as ordinary while some aspects could be claimed to be post-socialist. Tallinn is used here as a site from which to draw examples for this mainly literature-based conceptual analysis

Mainstream · Global Urban Networks and Dynamics · Urban Planning and Governance · Urbanization and City Planning

  • Den Osten im Blick

    Open Access•Matthias Bernt, Andrej Holm•sub\urban zeitschrift für…•2020

  • From Systemic Underdevelopment to Basic Urban Maintenance

    Open Access•Smirnova, Ekaterina Adrianova•Changing Societies and…•2022

  • Transforming Public Spaces in Post-Socialist China’s Danwei Neighbourhoods

    Open Access•Tao Shi, Fangjie Guo•Urban Planning•2024

  • From a Small Village to an Exclusive Gated Community

    Open Access•Adrienne Csizmady, Márton Bagyura et al.•Urban Planning•2022

  • Structural Transformations and Everyday Spatial Consequences in Austerity Ireland

    Open Access•Sander Van Lanen•Urban Planning•2023

  • Captured by Political Power

    Open Access•Gergely Olt, Adrienne Csizmady et al.•Urban Planning•2024

  • Totalitarian Flower Pavilion

    Open Access•Łukasz Drozda•Urban Planning•2024

  • Decentralization in Ukraine

    Open Access•Sophia Ilyniak•Urban Planning•2024

  • Neighbourhood (dis)satisfaction in a former closed Soviet city

    Open Access•Oleksii Havryliuk•Bulletin of Geography.…•2022

  • In Search of the Global East

    Open Access•Marguerite Müller, Martin Müller et al.•Sotsiologicheskoe Obozrenie /…•2020

  • Máshonnan tekinteni a posztszocialista városokra? Beszámoló a Cities After Transition hálózat 2017-es konferenciájáról

    Open Access•Márton Berki•Tér és Társadalom•2018

  • A liminalitás terei és idői az európai posztszovjet térben az orosz és szovjet expanziós törekvések tükrében

    Open Access•Margit Kőszegi, Márton Berki et al.•Tér és Társadalom•2018

  • A moldáv identitás rétegei

    Open Access•Tamás Illés, Zsolt Bottlik•Tér és Társadalom•2018

  • In Search of the Global East

    Open Access•Marguerite Müller•Geopolitics•2020

  • Revising Postsocialism

    Open Access•Francisco Martinez•Culture Unbound Journal of…•2021

  • Is there a ‘post-socialist hipster’? Exploring hipsterfication in Prague

    Open Access•Adela Stettler, Greta Kukeli•Social & Cultural Geography•2026

  • Postsocialism in International Relations

    Open Access•Claudia Aradau•Review of International Studies•2024

  • Urban marginality, Racialisation, Interdependence

    Daria Krivonos•Housing Studies•2025

  • Waste and postsocialism in Estonia

    Open Access•Francisco Martinez, Kaia Beilmann•Environment and Planning C…•2020

  • Introduction

    Abel Polese, Lela Rekhviashvili•Caucasus Survey•2017

  • Fighting for Space Within the Cis‐ and Heteronormative Public Sphere

    Open Access•Alexandra Sipos, Márton Bagyura•Social Inclusion•2024

  • From genplan to master plan

    Sofia Borushkina, Антон Городничев•Territory Politics Governance•2023

  • W poszukiwaniu Globalnego Wschodu

    Open Access•Marguerite Müller, Anna Piekarska•Praktyka Teoretyczna•2020

  • Keeping you post-ed

    Open Access•Myriam Houssay‐holzschuch•Dialogues in Human Geography•2021

  • Of waters and bridges

    Open Access•Myriam Houssay‐holzschuch•Dialogues in Human Geography•2021

  • The East is a Delicate Matter

    Open Access•Marguerite Müller, Martin Müller et al.•Sotsiologicheskoe Obozrenie /…•2021

  • Housing stratification in Romania

    Open Access•Adriana Mihaela Soaita, C Dewilde•Journal of Housing and the Built…•2020

  • Locked-in post-socialism

    Open Access•Stefan Bouzarovski, Luděk Sýkora et al.•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2016

  • A part of the world or apart from the world? The postsocialist Global East in the geopolitics of knowledge

    Elena Trubina, David Gogishvili et al.•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2020

  • Goodbye, post-socialism? Stranger things beyond the Global East

    L Chelcea•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2023

  • Questioning post-socialism in urban studies? Don’t shoot ourselves in the foot

    Open Access•Luděk Sýkora•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2025

  • Competing for space in Tbilisi

    David Gogishvili•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2021

  • Introduction

    Slavomíra Ferenčuhová, Michael Gentile•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2016

  • Conceptual forum

    Sonia Hirt, Slavomíra Ferenčuhová et al.•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2016

  • Unheeded knowledge? Thirty years of research on large housing estates in European post-socialist cities

    Jana Kočková, Slavomíra Ferenčuhová•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2025

  • Not so global climate change? Representations of post-socialist cities in the academic writings on climate change and urban areas

    Slavomíra Ferenčuhová•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2020

  • Limited post-socialism, meaningful analysis

    Tauri Tuvikene•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2025

  • Introduction

    Matthias Bernt•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2025

  • Londongrad, a post-socialist city

    Nadir Kinossian•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2025

  • Periphery, uncertainty, and legacy

    Open Access•Maria Podkorytova, Artem Konuykhov et al.•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2023

  • How post-socialist is gentrification? Observations in East Berlin and Saint Petersburg

    Matthias Bernt•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2016

  • From anti-socialist urbanism to fostering paths for insurgent global urban futures

    Ana Vilenica•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2025

  • The ambiguous politics of improvisation

    Jill Pope•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2020

  • Starting from anywhere, making connections

    Jennifer Robinson•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2016

  • Moving post-socialist publics

    Wladimir Sgibnev, Tauri Tuvikene•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2024

  • Post-socialism

    Erika Nagy•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2025

  • Poliitilised ökoloogiad ja antropotseen urbaansuse pingeväljade maastikes

    Open Access•Tarmo Pikner•Mäetagused•2022

  • A Critical-Realist View of Housing Quality within the Post-Communist EU States

    Open Access•Adriana Mihaela Soaita, C Dewilde•Housing Theory and Society•2017

  • Urban Narratives on the Changing Nature of Social Capital in Post-Communist Romania

    Adriana Mihaela Soaita, Barend Wind•Europe Asia Studies•2020

  • Decolonial approaches to urban transport geographies

    Open Access•Astrid Wood, Wojciech Kębłowski et al.•Journal of Transport Geography•2020

  • Urban Transformation and Experiences of ‘Becoming Marginal’ in Russia

    Open Access•Kirsti Stuvøy•International Journal of Politics…•2023

  • On infrastructure repair and gender politics

    Lily Song, Helen Sooväli-Sepping et al.•Journal of Urban Affairs•2021

  • Exploring agency of change in small industrial towns through urban renewal initiatives

    Maria Gunko, Nadir Kinossian et al.•Geografiska Annaler Series B…•2021

  • Eastern Europe and the geography of knowledge production

    Open Access•Petr Jehlička•Progress in Human Geography•2021

  • Diluted Post ‐ Socialism

    Open Access•Łukasz Drozda•International Journal of Urban…•2024

  • Rethinking the post-socialist city

    Open Access•Nadir Kinossian•Urban Geography•2022

  • Gentrification in Chinese cities? Speaking to the context-versus-concept debate in regional terms

    Yanpeng Jiang, Paul Waley et al.•Urban Geography•2025

  • Wishing the wall back

    Jürgen Von Mahs•Urban Geography•2021

  • Tracing urbanism

    Astrid Wood•Urban Geography•2019

  • Ethnographies of urban change

    Slavomíra Ferenčuhová, Petr Vašát•Urban Geography•2021

  • From modernism to kitsch

    Max Holleran, Fabio Mattioli•Urban Geography•2020

  • Between appropriation and occupation

    Alex Vasudevan, Alexander Vasudevan•Urban Geography•2019

  • Urban space as a commons in print media discourse in Poland after 1989

    Open Access•Maja Grabkowska•Cities•2018

  • Rethinking resilience

    Petr Jehlička, Petr Daněk et al.•Canadian Journal of Development…•2019

  • Marks on the city

    Vaike Haas•Journal of Baltic Studies•2019

  • Reclaiming Socialist Space, Caricaturing Socialism? Urban Interventions and the Cleansing of Political Content in State‐Socialist Public Housing After 2008

    Open Access•Maroš Krivý•Antipode•2022

  • Worlding and provincialising smart cities

    Open Access•Byron Miller, Kelly Ward et al.•Urban Studies•2021

  • Suburbanisation in East Germany

    Open Access•Matthias Bernt, Anne Volkmann•Urban Studies•2024

  • Socialist worldmaking

    Open Access•Łukasz Stanek•Urban Studies•2022

  • Transcending path dependencies

    Open Access•Jakub Galuszka•Urban Studies•2022

  • Framing digital future

    Open Access•Arto Lanamäki, Tauri Tuvikene•Geoforum•2021

  • Governing through stolichnaya praktika

    Open Access•Daniela Zupan, Даниэла Зупан et al.•Geoforum•2021

  • Post-Apocalyptic Wasteland” or “Digital Ecosystem”? Postsocialist Ecological Imaginaries in Tallinn, Estonia

    Open Access•Maroš Krivý•Geoforum•2021

  • Practising comparative urbanism

    Open Access•Frances Brill•Area•2022

  • Post‐socialist infrastructuring

    Open Access•Tauri Tuvikene, Wladimir Sgibnev et al.•Area•2020

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Naum Trajanovski, Milena Błahuta et al.•Journal of Nationalism Memory &…•2023

  • From a Buffer Zone to a Frontline Region? Unmapping Eastern Europe in a Multi-Order World

    Open Access•Emilian Kavalski•Geopolitics•2025

  • Zombie socialism and the rise of neoliberalism in post-socialist Central and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•L Chelcea, Oana Druta•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2016

  • The importance of recognizing difference

    Open Access•Petr Jehlička, Kerstin Jacobsson•Political Geography•2021

  • Narva as Method

    Open Access•Francisco Martinez•Anthropological Journal of…•2020

  • From neighborhood detail to urban theory

    Slavomíra Ferenčuhová•Urban Geography•2025

  • The new urban backlash

    Open Access•Łukasz Drozda•Mobilities•2025

  • The end of postsocialism (as we knew it)

    Open Access•Ottavia Cima, Lucie Sovová•Progress in Human Geography•2022

  • Goodbye, Postsocialism

    Open Access•Marguerite Müller•Europe Asia Studies•2019

  • Remains of the Soviet Past in Estonia

    Francisco Martinez, Alena Ledeneva et al.•Remains of the Soviet Past in…•2018

  • Explicit Definitions and Implicit Assumptions about Post-Socialist Cities in Academic Writings

    Open Access•Slavomíra Ferenčuhová•Geography Compass•2016

  • Post-socialist (auto)mobilities

    Open Access•Tauri Tuvikene•Geography Compass•2018

  • Rendering the Actually Existing Sharing Economy Visible

    Open Access•Petr Jehlička, Petr Daněk•Sociologia Ruralis•2017

  • From liberation to freedom

    Open Access•Jason Mccombs•Environment and Planning D…•2024

  • Improvising urban spaces, inhabiting the in-between

    Open Access•Marguerite Müller, Elena Trubina•Environment and Planning D…•2020

  • Area studies and geography

    Open Access•James Derrick Sidaway, Elaine Lynn-Ee Ho et al.•Environment and Planning D…•2016

  • Three Metals and the 'Post-Socialist City

    Open Access•Michael Gentile•International Journal of Urban…•2018

  • Informalization of the State

    Open Access•Julie‐anne Boudreau•International Journal of Urban…•2019

  • Symbolic Displacement Revisited

    Open Access•Ingmar Pastak, Anneli Kährik•International Journal of Urban…•2021

  • Writing Across Contexts

    Open Access•H Hilbrandt, Susana Neves Alves et al.•International Journal of Urban…•2017

  • Religious Materialities, Aesthetics, and Protests in Urban Poland

    Natalia Zawiejska, Anna M Maćkowiak•Material Religion•2023

  • Territory, enclosure, and state territorial mode of production in the Russian imperial periphery

    Open Access•Smirnova•Geographica Helvetica•2019

  • The Fall of Marshall Konev

    Open Access•Petr Gibas, Karolína Pauknerová•Ethnologia Polona•2021

  • The Global 1989

    Open Access•George Lawson, Chris Armbruster et al.•Global 1989•2010

  • Cities After Socialism

    Open Access•Gregory Andrusz, Michael Harloe et al.•Cities after Socialism•1996

  • The Routledge Handbook on Cities of the Global South

    Susan Parnell, Sophie Oldfield•Routledge Handbook on Cities of…•2014

  • Iron Curtains

    Open Access•Sonia Hirt, Sonia A Hirt•Iron Curtains•2012

  • Ordinary Cities

    Jennifer Robinson, Jennifer G Robinson et al.•Ordinary Cities•2013

  • The Post-Socialist City

    Open Access•Kiril Stanilov•Post-Socialist City•2007

  • Learning the City

    Open Access•Colin Mcfarlane•Learning the City•2011

  • Rethinking Informality

    Colin Mcfarlane•Planning Theory & Practice•2012

  • Provincializing Europe

    Dipesh Chakrabarty•Provincializing Europe•2000

  • Cars for Comrades

    Lewis H Siegelbaum•Cars for Comrades•2011

  • Urban Theory Beyond the West

    T Edensor, Mark Jayne•Urban Theory Beyond the West•2012

  • Uncertain Transition

    M Burawoy, Elizabeth Dunn et al.•Uncertain Transition•2000

  • Domesticating Neo‐Liberalism

    Open Access•Alison Stenning, Adrian Smith et al.•Domesticating Neo-Liberalism•2010

  • What Was Socialism, and What Comes Next

    Katherine Verdery•What Was Socialism, and What…•1996

  • Socio-economic residential differentiation in post-socialist Tallinn

    Open Access•Sampo Ruoppila, Anneli Kährik•Journal of Housing and the Built…•2003

  • Re-viewing informality

    Tim Bunnell, Andrew Harris•International Development…•2012

  • Post-socialist hybrids

    Open Access•Katarzyna Marciniak•European Journal of Cultural…•2009

  • The urban now

    Open Access•Jennifer Robinson•European Journal of Cultural…•2013

  • Reorganizing Cross-Border Governance Capacity

    Open Access•Tarmo Pikner•European Urban and Regional Studies•2008

  • The spirit of post-socialism

    Open Access•John Pickles•European Urban and Regional Studies•2010

  • Metropolitan processes in post‐communist states

    Thomas Borén, Michael Gentile•Geografiska Annaler Series B…•2007

  • Suburbanization in countries in transition

    Kadri Leetmaa, Tiit Tammaru•Geografiska Annaler Series B…•2007

  • Characteristics of post-socialist urban transformation in East Central Europe

    Open Access•Ulrike Sailer-Fliege•GeoJournal•1999

  • Changes in the internal spatial structure of post-communist Prague

    Open Access•Luděk Sýkora•GeoJournal•1999

  • Europe's eastern expansion and the reinscription of otherness in East-Central Europe

    Open Access•Merje Kuus•Progress in Human Geography•2004

  • Introduction—Experiments in Comparative Urbanism

    Colin Mcfarlane, Jennifer Robinson•Urban Geography•2012

  • Landscapes of Postmodernity

    Sonia Hirt•Urban Geography•2008

  • Comparative Debates in Post-Socialist Urban Studies

    Karin Wiest•Urban Geography•2012

  • Soviet Prefabricated Panel Housing Estates

    Anneli Kährik, Tiit Tammaru•Housing Studies•2010

  • Whatever happened to the (post)socialist city

    Open Access•Sonia Hirt•Cities•2013

  • Heteropolitanization

    Open Access•Michael Gentile, Tiit Tammaru et al.•Cities•2012

  • New post-socialist urban landscapes

    Open Access•Zoltán Kovács•Cities•2014

  • Population Composition in New Suburban Settlements of the Tallinn Metropolitan Area

    Open Access•Anneli Kährik, Tiit Tammaru•Urban Studies•2008

  • The (Post-) Socialist Entrepreneurial City as a State Project

    Open Access•Fulong Wu•Urban Studies•2003

  • Socialist Summer-home Settlements in Post-socialist Suburbanisation

    Open Access•Kadri Leetmaa, Isolde Bradе et al.•Urban Studies•2012

  • Beyond the Third World City

    Open Access•Howard Dick, H W Dick et al.•Urban Studies•1998

  • Post-socialist Cities and Urban Studies

    Open Access•Harold Fisher Wilson•Urban Studies•2013

  • Multiple Transformations

    Open Access•Luděk Sýkora, Stefan Bouzarovski•Urban Studies•2012

  • From Priority‐led to Market‐led Suburbanisation in a Post‐communist Metropolis

    Open Access•Kadri Leetmaa, Tiit Tammaru et al.•Tijdschrift voor Economische en…•2009

  • Residential Segregation in a Medium‐Sized Post‐Soviet City

    Open Access•Michael Gentile•Tijdschrift voor Economische en…•2003

  • The political economy of place at the post‐socialist urban periphery

    Open Access•Oleg Golubchikov, Nicholas A Phelps•Transactions of the Institute of…•2011

  • Post‐socialism and the changing geographies of the everyday in Poland

    Open Access•Alison Stenning•Transactions of the Institute of…•2005

  • Urban Policy Mobilities and Global Circuits of Knowledge

    Erin Mccann, Eugene Mccann•Annals of the Association of…•2011

  • Out there and in here

    Open Access•Alison Stenning•Area•2005

  • Deconstructing Regions

    Open Access•Anssi Paasi•Environment and Planning A…•1991

  • Territory, authority, rights

    Saskia Sassen•Territory, authority, rights•2006

  • Chasing Warsaw

    Patrice M Dabrowski•The Polish Review•2018

  • Urban Informality

    Ananya Roy•Journal of the American Planning…•2005

  • The Birth of Biopolitics

    Open Access•Arnold I Davidson, Graham Burchell et al.•Birth of Biopolitics•2008

  • History, Geography and Difference in the Post-socialist World

    Open Access•Alison Stenning, Kathrin Hörschelmann•Antipode•2008

  • The 21st-Century Metropolis

    Ananya Roy•Regional Studies•2008

  • Mobilizing policy

    Open Access•J Peck, Nik Theodore•Geoforum•2010

  • Regions unbound

    Ash Amin•Geografiska Annaler Series B…•2004

  • Global and world cities

    Open Access•Jennifer Robinson•International Journal of Urban…•2002

  • The Expatriate Real Estate Complex

    Open Access•Andrew C G Cook, Andrew Cook•International Journal of Urban…•2010

  • Cities in a World of Cities

    Open Access•Jennifer Robinson•International Journal of Urban…•2011

  • The Comparative City

    Open Access•Colin Mcfarlane•International Journal of Urban…•2010

  • The Belgrade Wall

    Open Access•Sonia Hirt, Mina Petrović•International Journal of Urban…•2011

  • Gated Communities for Security or Prestige? A Public Choice Approach and the Case of Budapest

    Open Access•Zoltán Cséfalvay•International Journal of Urban…•2011

Unique citing works98
Citations per year9,8
Citation span2016 - 2026 (11)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 98

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae