Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Where do I belong

Narrating collective identity and translocational positionality

Bibliographic Data

ID5772490
AuthorsFloya Anthias (Oxford Brookes University, corresponding author)
Year2002
Volume2
Issue4
Pages491-514
Publication date2002-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEthnicities (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1468-7968 • E-ISSN: 1741-2706
PublisherSAGE Publishing (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/14687968020020040301
OpenAlexW2136419795
LanguageEN
Citations received238
References cited33

This article argues that the concept of `identity' is of limited heuristic value and proposes that it may instead be more useful to deploy the notion of narratives of location and positionality for addressing the range of issues normally thought to be about collective identity. Location and positionality (and translocational positionality) are more useful concepts for investigating processes and outcomes of collective identification - that is, the claims and attributions that individuals make about their position in the social order of things, their views of where and to what they belong (and to what they do not belong) as well as an understanding of the broader social relations that constitute and are constituted in this process. This enables a complete abandonment of the residual elements of essentialization retained even within the idea of fragmented and multiple identities so favoured by critics of unitary notions of identity. The article will draw on research into the ways in which experiences of `race' and ethnicity were articulated in the narrations produced by British-born youngsters of Greek Cypriot background

Abandonment (legal · Aesthetics · Collective identity · Epistemology · Ethnic group · Identification · Narrative · Political science · Politics · Social group · Social identity theory · Social science · Sociology · Unitary state · Value (mathematics · Anthropology · Contemporary and Historical Greek Studies · Cyprus History, Politics, Society · Gender Studies · Law · Migration, Refugees, and Integration · Psychology · Social Psychology

  • Navigating Marginalization through Religion

    Open Access•Kwanchit Sasiwongsaroj, Vithaya Chaidee•Journal of Ethnic and Cultural…•2026

  • Feeling foreign

    Open Access•Ayşe Aldemir•Identities•2026

  • Reverse or Reflexive Transnationalism? Second-Generation Turkish-Germans’ Engagements With “Here” and “There” After Return Migration

    Open Access•Russell King, Nilay Kılınç•International Migration Review•2026

  • Post-Apartheid South African immigrants in Australia

    C C Sonn, Gavin Ivey et al.•Qualitative Psychology•2017

  • Enfoque interseccional en las personas desplazadas por causas medioambientales

    Open Access•Patricia Bueso Izquierdo•Migraciones Publicación del…•2022

  • Horizontes de la intervención social con infancia migrante en Chile

    Open Access•Iskra Pávez, Iskra Pavez Soto et al.•RUMBOS TS Un Espacio Crítico para…•2020

  • Women on the Move

    Julia Tofantshuk, María Amor Barros del Río et al.•Women on the Move•2018

  • Emotion and Affect

    Open Access•Birgitt Röttger-Rössler•Cambridge Handbook of Psychological…•2025

  • Nationalizing Citizenship

    Open Access•Mojca Pajnik•Ethnic Minorities and Politics in…•2016

  • Belongings in a Globalising and Unequal World

    Floya Anthias•The Situated Politics of Belonging•2006

  • Strategic (De)racing

    Open Access•Sepideh Borzoo•Gender Work and Organization•2026

  • Intersections and Translocations

    Open Access•Floya Anthias•European Journal of Educational…•2011

  • Transnational Climate Anxiety

    Open Access•N Ali•Area•2026

  • To ‘go gender’ – A conceptual framework for analysing migration-related strategic gender practices

    Open Access•Susanne Stenbacka, G Forsberg•Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift -…•2020

  • Paper Lives of Chinese Migrants and the History of the Undocumented

    Open Access•Beth Lew-Williams•Modern American History•2021

  • A dialogical approach to navigating cultural heritage and self-identification

    Open Access•Anna Gruszczyńska‐thompson•Cogent Social Sciences•2025

  • Göçle Şeki̇llenen Kadinlik

    Open Access•Tamer Küçükyağcı•Avrasya Uluslararası Araştırmalar…•2025

  • Migrants' descendants in Italy

    Allievi, Stefano Allievi et al.•MONDI MIGRANTI•2025

  • Performative Anchoring Practices and the Making of Belonging in Diaspora

    Open Access•Andrea Pelliccia•Studies in Ethnicity and…•2026

  • Imagined places of the past

    Open Access•Michael J Lomas, Eunice Ayodeji et al.•Current Psychology•2024

  • From feeling different to becoming collective

    Open Access•Ainhoa Rodríguez-Zafra, Irene García-Molina•Current Psychology•2026

  • Children's exploration of the concepts of home and belonging

    Open Access•Fiona Maine, Benjamin Brummernhenrich et al.•International Journal of…•2021

  • Identity and Intersectionality in Public Administration

    Open Access•Danyao Li, Austin Mccrea•Administration & Society•2026

  • “Your English Sounds Almost British”

    Open Access•Pramod K Sah•TESOL Quarterly•2026

  • Displaced academics’ mobility and translocational positionalities

    Open Access•Ahmad Akkad•Higher Education•2026

  • Narratives of Belonging in the Digital Diaspora

    Open Access•Theresa Heyd•Open Linguistics•2016

  • “Public” perceptions of gamete donation

    Open Access•N Hudson, Lorraine Culley et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2009

  • Displaced belonging

    Open Access•Shirin Assa•Irish Journal of Sociology•2024

  • Power dynamics of post-genocide street renaming in urban Rwanda - the territorial demarcation between the past and the present

    Open Access•Jean de Dieu Amini Ngabonziza, Tove Rosendal•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2025

  • Ohne Geld kannst du draußen nicht überleben“

    Open Access•Tina Spies•Erziehungswissenschaftliche…•2015

  • Texas Czech Ethnic Identity

    Lida Dutkova-Cope•The Slavic and East European…•2003

  • From Diaspora with Dreams, Dreaming about Diaspora

    Erik Olsson•Diaspora A Journal of Transnational…•2014

  • Identity vs. sense of belonging

    Open Access•Олена Злобіна•Ukrainian society•2024

  • “When we one day have a job and pay taxes, we will be appreciated and respected”

    Open Access•Live Stretmo, Mostafa Hosseini•Identities•2026

  • The Inaccessible Ithaca

    Open Access•Kalie Kerpaci, Martin Kuka•Population Space and Place•2026

  • ‘You are Danish, or you are not’

    Open Access•Klarissa Lueg•The Sociological Review•2026

  • A contradiction in terms? migrant activists in the Sweden Democrats party

    D Mulinari, Anders Neergaard•Identities•2019

  • Religion and Interconnection With Zimbabwe

    Open Access•Collis Garikai Machoko•Journal of Black Studies•2013

  • Making space for ambiguity

    C N Laoire•Identities•2016

  • The value of culturedness

    Open Access•Lejla Voloder, P Andits•The Australian Journal of…•2016

  • From being othered to promoting the value of otherness

    Open Access•Annavittoria Sarli•Identities•2024

  • Migrant women, place and identity in contemporary women’s writing

    Sharon Krummel•Identities•2015

  • Identifications, communities and connections

    A Dhoest•Identities•2016

  • Routes to Roots

    Open Access•Russell King, Nilay Kılınç•Nordic Journal of Migration…•2014

  • Language and Negotiation of Identities Among Young Kurds in Finland

    Open Access•Mari Toivanen•Nordic Journal of Migration…•2013

  • Temporal and Generational Impact on Identity, Home(Land) and Politics of Belonging Among the Kurdish Diaspora

    Open Access•Minoo Alinia, Barzoo Eliassi•Nordic Journal of Migration…•2014

  • The Visual Lexica of (National) Belonging and Nonbelonging in the Accounts of Young Kurds in Finland

    Open Access•Mari Toivanen•Nordic Journal of Migration…•2014

  • I was born here

    Open Access•Charlotte Hyltén-Cavallius, Lotta Fernstål•Ethnologia Europaea•2021

  • Situated agency in precarious labor

    Open Access•Julia Barbar, Rabia Naguib•Gender in Management An…•2026

  • ‘As a woman…’; ‘As a Muslim…’

    Open Access•Lee Jarvis, Michael Lister•Critical Social Policy•2017

  • Mujer Migrante, Mestiza, No-Heterosexual, Colonizada Y Élite

    Open Access•Danae Gallo González•Revista Iberoamericana•2026

  • Gendered dimensions of return migration

    Open Access•Augusto Gamuzza, Camilo Tamayo Gomez et al.•International Review of Sociology•2026

  • Survival now versus survival later

    Orlando O Harris•Culture Health & Sexuality•2019

  • Unpacking Young Migrants’ Collective Identities

    Open Access•E Katartzi•Children & Society•2017

  • A Model of Spaces and Access in the Construction of Asian and Asian American Identities

    Open Access•Chadrhyn A A Pedraza•Genealogy•2025

  • Navigating Belonging While Experiencing Discrimination

    Open Access•Amanda Miriam Tallis•Genealogy•2025

  • Introduction to “Identity in Flux

    Open Access•Nikos Gogonas, Christina Maligkoudi•Genealogy•2026

  • Citizens here and there against the crisis

    Open Access•M Artero•Frontiers in Sociology•2025

  • This is My Home’

    Open Access•Marta Bivand Erdal•Comparative Migration Studies•2014

  • Introduction

    Marianela Barrios Aquino, Nicola Chanamuto et al.•Emotions History Culture Society•2022

  • Insights into the Use of Social Comparison in Migrants’ Transnational Social Positioning Strategies

    Open Access•I Stock•Social Inclusion•2021

  • Victims of Trafficking”

    Open Access•Amy M Russell•Societies•2014

  • Exploring Migrant Employees’ ‘Rights-Talk’ in the British Hospitality Sector

    Open Access•Samentha Goethal•Business and Human Rights Journal•2019

  • Deep situationality

    Tatiana Matejskova•Migration Studies•2013

  • Privileged, ambivalent, or contested? How cultural repertoires facilitate different forms of belonging among immigrants in Czechia

    Open Access•Radka Klvaňová, Ivana Rapoš Božič•Migration Studies•2026

  • Time horizons in young people ́s career narratives – strategies, temporal orientations and imagined parallel futures negotiated in local settings

    Open Access•Catarina Lundqvist•Education Inquiry•2019

  • Locating Iranian Diasporas in Fifty Years of Academic Discourse

    Open Access•Z Karimi, Mahmoud Ghazi Tabatabaei•Middle East Critique•2023

  • Feminist futures in gender-in-leadership research

    Open Access•Jenny K Rodríguez, Edeltraud Guenther et al.•Gender in Management An…•2022

  • Belonging in an aquapelago

    Open Access•Erika Anne Hayfield, Helene Pristed Nielsen•Island Studies Journal•2022

  • Considérations théoricométhodologiques autour de la mixité

    Open Access•Dan Rodríguez-García•Enfances Familles Générations•2013

  • Revealing Hidden Proficiencies

    Open Access•Rita Fennelly‐Atkinson, Deblina Pakhira•TechTrends•2024

  • The co-production of difference? Exploring urban youths’ negotiations of identity in meeting with difficult heritage of human classification

    Kaja Hannedatter Sontum•Museums & Social Issues•2018

  • Rhythmic Island

    Open Access•Russell King, A Lulle•Population Space and Place•2015

  • Migration, precariousness, and the linked lives of newcomers in Hong Kong

    Open Access•Adrian J Bailey, Rainbow Wing Yan Ng et al.•Population Space and Place•2020

  • From the Marginal Immigrant to the Mobile Citizen

    Open Access•Marcu•Population Space and Place•2014

  • Gendered translocal connectedness

    Open Access•Luise Porst, P Sakdapolrak•Population Space and Place•2020

  • Anchoring, feelings of belonging, and the complex identities of migrant teenagers in Slovenia

    Open Access•Mateja Sedmak, Zorana Medarić•Studies in Ethnicity and…•2022

  • Disentangling the transnational belongingness of children in and beyond a Danish school

    Open Access•Søren Sindberg Jensen•Studies in Ethnicity and…•2022

  • Platoon’ Friendship of the Soviet Academic Diaspora

    Open Access•Irina Isaakyan•Studies in Ethnicity and…•2010

  • In/visibility strategies and enacted diversity

    Rosa Mas Giralt•Children s Geographies•2011

  • I might know when I'm an adult’

    Cara D Linzmayer, Elizabeth Halpenny•Children s Geographies•2013

  • Young Muslims’ religious identities in relation to places beyond the UK

    Open Access•Laura Kapinga, Bettina Van Hoven et al.•Children s Geographies•2022

  • Unravelling intersectional identities

    Alia Razia Malik, Zohra Fatima•Feminist Media Studies•2025

  • Mapping geographies of home in the Tunisian diaspora

    Open Access•Monia Channoufi•National Identities•2025

  • Toward multi-dimensional and developmental notion of researcher positionality

    Open Access•Hangyan Lu, Warren A Hodge•Qualitative Research Journal•2019

  • Eurocentric ethics and Pakhtunwali in Northwest Pakistan

    Open Access•Sanaullah, Sanaullah Sanaullah•Qualitative Research Journal•2025

  • Unsettling Australian settler supremacy

    David Hollinsworth•Race Ethnicity and Education•2014

  • The Struggle for Survival of Syrian Immigrant Single Mothers

    Open Access•Ayşe Nur Katmer, Metin Gani Tapan et al.•Child & Family Social Work•2025

  • Language, culture and border lives

    Nancy Nelson Spivey, Nancy Nelson et al.•Culture and Education•2014

  • Unpacking Young People’s National Identities

    Open Access•E Katartzi•Young•2017

  • Negotiating social belonging

    Open Access•Nali Moftizadeh, Hanna Zagefka et al.•Journal of Community & Applied…•2022

  • Spaces of the local, spaces of the nation

    Open Access•Christy Kulz•European Urban and Regional Studies•2022

  • The impact of (counter-)terrorism on public (in)security in Nigeria

    Open Access•Akinyemi Oyawale•Security Dialogue•2022

  • Where Do I Belong? Narratives of Rodina among Russian-speaking Youth in Kazakhstan

    Alina Jašina-Schäfer•Europe Asia Studies•2018

  • Everyday politics of belonging

    Open Access•Tina Mathisen•Gender Place & Culture•2025

  • Translocational Irish identities in Edna O’Brien’s memoir Country Girl (2012)

    María Amor Barros-Del Río•Gender Place & Culture•2016

  • Tacit differences, ethnicity and neoliberalism

    Agata Lisiak, Magdalena Nowicka•Gender Place & Culture•2017

  • Performing ‘Oriental’ masculinities

    Tamsin Barber•Gender Place & Culture•2014

  • Domestic work, learning and literacy practices across transnational space

    Amy North•International Studies in…•2018

  • Now My Life in Syria Is Finished’

    Andreas Schmoller•Islam and Christian–Muslim…•2016

  • Group psychology and the analysis of the ego.

    Sigmund Freud, James Strachey•1922

  • Citizenship and Migration

    Stephen Castles, Alastair Davidson•Citizenship and Migration•2000

  • Course in General Linguistics

    Ferdinand De Saussure, Laura Key et al.•Course in General Linguistics•2017

  • The Interpretation of Cultures

    Clifford Geertz•The Interpretation of Cultures•1973

  • Studies in ethnomethodology

    Harold Garfinkel•Studies in ethnomethodology•1984

  • Citizenship and Migration

    Stephen Castles, Alastair Davidson•Citizenship and Migration•2020

  • Narrative Identity

    Paul Ricoeur•Philosophy Today•1991

  • The Politics of Presence

    A Phillips•The politics of presence•1998

  • ‘Bodies that Matter’

    Judith Butler, Janet Price et al.•Feminist Theory and the Body•1999

  • Global diasporas

    Robin Cohen•Global diasporas•1997

  • Debating Cultural Hybridity

    P Werbner, T Modood•Debating Cultural Hybridity•2015

  • The Logic of Practice

    Pierre Bourdieu•The Logic of Practice•1990

  • Social Identity

    Richard Jenkins•SOCIAL IDENTITY•1996

  • Dissemination

    Jacques Derrida, Barbara Johnson•Dissemination•1981

  • Archaeology of Knowledge

    Michel Foucault•Archaeology of Knowledge•2013

  • The archaeology of knowledge

    Open Access•Neil Warren•Social Science & Medicine (1967•1973

  • Nationalism as group solidarity

    Michael Hechter•Ethnic and Racial Studies•1987

  • Rethinking Social Divisions

    Open Access•Floya Anthias•The Sociological Review•1998

  • The Narrative Self in Autobiographical Accounts of Illness

    Open Access•Michael P Kelly, Hilary Dickinson•The Sociological Review•1997

  • Course in General Linguistics

    Ferdinand De Saussure, Charles Bally et al.•Journal of American Folklore•1960

  • On Auto/Biography in Sociology

    Open Access•Liz Stanley•Sociology•1993

  • Connecting 'Race' and Ethnic Phenomena

    Open Access•Floya Anthias•Sociology•1992

  • Is multiculturalism the solution

    M Wieviorka•Ethnic and Racial Studies•1998

  • New hybridities, old concepts

    Floya Anthias•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2001

  • Beyond 'identity

    Open Access•Rogers Brubaker, Frederick Cooper et al.•Theory and Society•2000

  • Evaluating 'Diaspora

    Open Access•Floya Anthias•Sociology•1998

  • The narrative constitution of identity

    Open Access•Margaret R Somers•Theory and Society•1994

Unique citing works238
Citations per year10,35
Citation span2003 - 2026 (24)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 232

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae