Des maux et des chiffres. L’évaluation des incapacités en médecine légale du vivant

A large part of forensic medicine in France consists in examining victims of assault in dedicated hospital departments called “unités médico-judiciaires” (UMJ) (medical-judiciary units). This article explores the assessment of injuries carried out by forensic pathologists upon the request of the prosecutor. This evaluation serves as a basis for the production of certificates, as well as for the calculation of the number of days of total incapacity to work (TIW). This article examines this calculation, which is highly variable, and analyzes the social determinants of forensic judgment on two distinct levels. It first shows that each UMJ strives to resolve the heterogeneity of opinions on TIW by implementing its own corrective measures. UMJs therefore problematize forensic medicine as a “report medicine,” grounded in harmonized practices. This article then analyzes how TIW is dealt with in medical consultations, and shows that forensic pathologists engage with a “medicine of violence.” In their medical practice, they come up against many diverse situations that require expertise, assemble and combine different frameworks at the intersection of the medical and the judicial, while assessing the victims’ particular bodies and words

Health, Medicine and Society · Healthcare Systems and Practices · Migration, Identity, and Health · Philosophy

• Violence conjugale : de la catégorisation institutionnelle à la qualification pénale

  Marine Delaunay•Sociétés contemporaines•2026

  Add to list

• De la discrétion dans la sélection des crimes. Approche sociologique des déterminants de la correctionnalisation

  Rémi Rouméas•Déviance et Société•2022

  Add to list