Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Biotechnology and the American Media

The Policy Process and the Elite Press, 1970 to 1999

Bibliographic Data

ID6219166
AuthorsMatthew C Nisbet (0000-0002-6765-1364, corresponding author), Bruce V Lewenstein (0000-0002-1272-372X, Cornell University)
Year2002
Volume23
Issue4
Pages359-391
Publication date2002-06-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueScience Communication (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1075-5470 • E-ISSN: 1552-8545
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/107554700202300401
OpenAlexW2109921914
LanguageEN
Citations received152
References cited33

The authors present a quantitative content analysis of biotechnology-related coverage appearing in the New York Times and Newsweekbetween 1970 and 1999, examining patterns of media attention and evaluating the source impact of various political and social actors on the themes, frames, and tone of coverage. Although media attention to biotechnology steadily increased across the 1980s and most of the 1990s, it has been highly episodic, peaking and plummeting in response to major scientific announcements. Even in its peak years of coverage, biotechnology still rests rather modestly on the overall media agenda compared with other issues related to science, technology, or popular culture. The character of biotechnology-related coverage has been overwhelmingly positive, with heavy emphasis on the frames of scientific progress and economic prospect. A departure from this trend only occurs in correspondence to the late 1990s debate over cloning, as a greater media emphasis on ethics and controversy emerges

Biology · Media coverage · Media studies · Political science · Politics · Sociology · Climate Change Communication and Perception · Law · Media Studies and Communication · Science Education and Perceptions · Biotechnology

  • Worldviews and public attitudes toward gene-edited foods in Japan

    Open Access•Tomiko Yamaguchi, Ildeung et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2026

  • Framing of science issues in opinion-leading news

    Thomas Listerman•Public Understanding of Science•2010

  • Copper toxicity across salinities from freshwater to seawater in the euryhaline fish Fundulus heteroclitus

    Open Access•Jonathan Blanchard, Martin Grosell•Aquatic Toxicology•2006

  • From Press Release to News

    Seow Ting Lee, Iccha Basnyat•Health Communication•2013

  • News Narratives about Nano S&T in Major U.S. and Non-U.S. Newspapers

    Open Access•Lowndes F Stephens•Science Communication•2005

  • Gene Drives in the U.K., U.S., and Australian Press (2015–2019)

    Open Access•Aleksandra Stelmach, Brigitte Nerlich et al.•Science Communication•2022

  • How does the French press handle a controversial biotechnology? A psychosocial study of media coverage of human genome editing

    Open Access•Thibaud Marmorat, Solveig Lelaurain et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2025

  • Hyped biomedical science or uncritical reporting? Press coverage of genomics (1992–2001) in Québec

    Open Access•E Racine, Isabelle Gareau et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2006

  • Broadening Exposure to Climate Change News? How Framing and Political Orientation Interact to Influence Selective Exposure

    Open Access•Lauren Feldman, P Sol Hart•Journal of Communication•2018

  • Testing Fear of Isolation as a Causal Mechanism

    Sung‐Hoon Kim, S-H Kim•International Journal of Public…•2012

  • Government frames and their influence on news framing

    Open Access•Frida V Rodelo, Carlos Muñiz Muriel•Global Media and Communication•2018

  • Where exactly between utopia and dystopia? A framing analysis of AI and automation in US newspapers

    Open Access•Hannes Cools, B Van Gorp et al.•Journalism•2022

  • A comparison of the visual and story frames Al Jazeera English and CNN employed during the 2011 Egyptian revolution

    Open Access•Michel M Haigh, Michael Bruce•International Communication Gazette•2017

  • Talking about bio-fuel in the news

    Sei-Hill Kim, John C Besley et al.•Journalism Studies•2013

  • The Debate Surrounding Gm Crops in South America and Its Coverage in the Newspapers Clarín and Folha De S. Paulo From 2016 – 2018

    Open Access•María Luisa Azpíroz•Brazilian Journalism Research•2020

  • “This Emerging Technology is Revolutionary!”

    Open Access•Ming Wang, Ding Xu•Online Media and Global…•2026

  • Voices and media frames in the public debate on artificial intelligence

    Open Access•Florin Zai, Tobias Rohrbach et al.•Frontiers in Communication•2025

  • How Did the Media Frame Cop29

    Open Access•Özge Cengiz•The Turkish Online Journal of…•2025

  • Who drives news coverage of trans issues? Intermedia agenda setting dynamics in Spanish digital press

    Open Access•Rubén Araujo•Journalism•2024

  • Newspaper coverage of artificial intelligence

    Open Access•Shaojing Sun, Yujia Zhai et al.•Telematics and Informatics•2020

  • Framing international news in China

    Open Access•Xianwen Kuang, Hui Wang•Global Media and China•2020

  • The Narrative Cycle of Climate Change in the Greek Newspapers, 2001–2008

    Georgios Gkiouzepas, Γεώργιος Γκιουζέπας et al.•Environmental Communication•2018

  • Chemical Controversy

    Paul R Brewer, David Wise et al.•Environmental Communication•2014

  • Of Society, Nature, and Health

    Kathleen M Rose, Dominique Brossard et al.•Environmental Communication•2020

  • Promising Directions for Environmental Communication Research

    Anders Hansen•Environmental Communication•2015

  • A Missed Opportunity

    Nicole Lee, Nicole M Lee et al.•Environmental Communication•2018

  • On Neo-luddites led by Ayatollahs

    Pieter Maeseele•Environmental Communication•2010

  • Competing Crises? Media Coverage and Framing of Climate Change During the Covid-19 Pandemic

    Mark C J Stoddart, Hector Ramos et al.•Environmental Communication•2023

  • Bridging Science and Journalism

    Open Access•Julia A Lynch, John Lynch et al.•Science Communication•2014

  • Looking Over the Shoulders of Researchers

    Open Access•Kristian Hvidtfelt Nielsen, Charlotte Autzen•Science Communication•2011

  • Value Predispositions, Mass Media, and Attitudes Toward Nanotechnology

    Open Access•Shirley S Ho, Dietram A Scheufele et al.•Science Communication•2010

  • Examining Muslims’ Opinions Toward Cultured Meat in Singapore

    Open Access•Shirley S Ho, Stanley A Wijaya et al.•Science Communication•2024

  • Science and National Pride

    Open Access•Szczepan Lemańczyk•Science Communication•2014

  • Interpersonal Discussion Following Citizen Engagement About Nanotechnology

    Open Access•John C Besley, Victoria Kramer et al.•Science Communication•2008

  • Quantitative Frame Analysis of How the Gene Concept Is Presented in Tabloid and Elite Newspapers

    Open Access•Rebecca Bruu Carver, Einar Andreas Rødland et al.•Science Communication•2012

  • Introductory Note

    Open Access•Susanna Hornig Priest•Science Communication•2002

  • To Eat or Not to Eat

    Open Access•Ivanka Pjesivac, Marlit Hayslett et al.•Science Communication•2020

  • In the Face of Critique

    Open Access•Elyse Amend, David M Secko et al.•Science Communication•2011

  • Dr. Soundbite”

    Open Access•Marjorie Kruvand•Science Communication•2012

  • Content Analysis of New York Times Coverage of Space Issues for the Year 2000

    Open Access•Fiona Clark, Deborah L Illman et al.•Science Communication•2003

  • Framing Justice

    Open Access•John C Besley, Katherine A Mccomas•Communication Theory•2005

  • The Therapeutic Promise of Pluripotency and its Political use in the Italian Stem Cell Debate

    Lorenzo Beltrame•Science as Culture•2014

  • Changing Social Representations and Agenda Interactions of Gene Editing After Crises

    Open Access•Anfan Chen, Xing Zhang•Social Science Computer Review•2021

  • YouTube Comments on Gene-Edited Babies

    Open Access•Jiaojiao Ji, Hongchao Hu et al.•Social Science Computer Review•2022

  • Skepticism About Media Effects Concerning the Environment

    John C Besley, Jarrod Shanahan•Society & Natural Resources•2004

  • Public attitudes toward biofuels

    Open Access•Michael A Cacciatore, Micheal A Cacciatore et al.•Politics and the Life Sciences•2012

  • The plurality and shifting of framing genetical modification risks on Chinese social media

    Xiaoxiao Cheng•Health Risk & Society•2025

  • Public engagement by researchers of different disciplines in Singapore

    Open Access•Shirley S Ho, Jiemin Looi et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2019

  • Let’s (not) talk about synthetic biology

    Open Access•Anja Bauer, Alexander Bogner•Public Understanding of Science•2020

  • Green metacycles of attention

    Open Access•Monika Djerf-Pierre•Public Understanding of Science•2013

  • The media and public opinion on genetics and biotechnology

    Open Access•Toby A Ten Eyck•Public Understanding of Science•2005

  • Mobile knowledge and the media

    Open Access•Stephen Bocking•Public Understanding of Science•2012

  • The social embedding of biomedicine

    Open Access•P Weingart, Christian Salzmann et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2008

  • Taking stock

    Open Access•Mike S Schäfer•Public Understanding of Science•2012

  • Reassessing the concept of a medialization of science

    Open Access•Simone Rödder•Public Understanding of Science•2009

  • Making a small country count

    Open Access•Rikke Schmidt Kjærgaard•Public Understanding of Science•2010

  • Understanding citizen perceptions of science controversy

    Open Access•Matthew C Nisbet, Kirby Goidel et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2007

  • Different ways of problematising biotechnology – and what it means for technology governance

    Open Access•Alexander Bogner, Helge Torgersen•Public Understanding of Science•2015

  • Embryonic stem cell

    Open Access•Claudia Jurberg, Marina Verjovsky et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2009

  • European journalists and the sea

    Open Access•Bruno Pinto, 刘坚 刘坚 et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2023

  • Implicit media frames

    Open Access•Iina Hellsten, James Dawson et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2010

  • Understanding public support for stem cell research

    Open Access•Hui Liu, Liu Hui et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2009

  • First-in-human gene therapy clinical trials in the media

    Open Access•Rachele E Willard, Marilyn S Baffoe-Bonnie et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2026

  • Sociotechnical imaginaries of gene editing in food and agriculture

    Open Access•Ashmita Das, Diana Cordoba et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2025

  • Cloning sensations

    Open Access•M Horst•Public Understanding of Science•2005

  • Coping with uncertainty

    Open Access•Regula Valérie Burri•Public Understanding of Science•2009

  • Italian news coverage of radiation in the early decades of the twentieth century

    Open Access•Andrea Candela, Federico Pasquaré Mariotto•Public Understanding of Science•2016

  • Playing God? Media coverage of CRISPR in the United States

    Open Access•Patricia Stapleton, Alessandra Torres Yabar•Public Understanding of Science•2023

  • Opening the black box

    Open Access•Alan Petersen, Alison Anderson et al.•Public Understanding of Science•2009

  • Artists or art thieves? media use, media messages, and public opinion about artificial intelligence image generators

    Open Access•Paul R Brewer, Liam Cuddy et al.•AI & Society•2025

  • International News Coverage of Human Trafficking Arrests and Prosecutions

    Erin Denton•Women & Criminal Justice•2010

  • CRISPR Images

    Open Access•Wyatt Dawson, Ashley Paintsil et al.•Bulletin of Science Technology &…•2022

  • Media framing the reception of unmanned aerial vehicles in the United States of America

    Open Access•Patricia K Freeman, Robert S Freeland•Technology in Society•2015

  • Gatekeeper, Diskursproduzenten und Agenda-Setter — Akteursrollen von Massenmedien in Innovationsprozessen

    Annie Waldherr•Massenmedien Als Politische Akteure•2008

  • Securing our genetic health

    Open Access•Alan Petersen•Sociology of Health & Illness•2005

  • Fantastisk eller farefullt? Norske avisers dekning av assistert befruktning fra 1978 til 2007

    Hanne Hestvik Kleiven•Sosiologisk tidsskrift•2009

  • Elements of public trust in the American food system

    John T Lang•Food Policy•2013

  • Politicizing science

    Open Access•Michael B Brown, Mark B Brown•Social Studies of Science•2014

  • Mapping the intermedia agenda setting (IAS) literature

    Open Access•Yan Su, Xizhu Xiao•The Agenda Setting Journal•2021

  • On Media and Science in Late Modern Societies

    Pieter Maeseele•Annals of the International…•2013

  • Are attitudes toward labeling nano products linked to attitudes toward GMO? Exploring a potential ‘spillover’ effect for attitudes toward controversial technologies

    Open Access•Heather Akin, Sara K Yeo et al.•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2018

  • Comparative analysis of media coverage concerning the social implications on three life sciences in Japan during 1991–2020

    Open Access•Kohei Takeda, M Komata et al.•Frontiers in Sociology•2025

  • Media and evidence-informed policy development

    Carla Meurk, Harvey Whiteford et al.•Contemporary Social Science•2015

  • The Construction of News

    Open Access•Toby Bolsen•The International Journal of…•2010

  • Restricted Voices in the New Zealand GM Debate

    Douglas Ashwell•East Asian Science Technology and…•2011

  • Attention to Stem Cell Research in Japanese Mass Media

    Ryuma Shineha•East Asian Science Technology and…•2016

  • Textual Representation and Intertextuality of Graphene in Swedish Newspapers

    Open Access•Max Boholm•NanoEthics•2020

  • Public Involvement and Narrative Fallacies of Nanotechnologies

    Open Access•Erik Thorstensen•NanoEthics•2014

  • Between National Pride and the Scientific Success of “Others”

    Open Access•Szczepan Lemańczyk•NanoEthics•2012

  • Propaganda persuasion, critical learning, and social recreation

    Open Access•Weiying Shi, Fei Shen et al.•Chinese Journal of Communication•2026

  • Grasping scientific news

    Elyse Amend, Gabriela Capurro et al.•Journalism Practice•2014

  • Four Models of Science Journalism

    David Secko, Elyse Amend et al.•Journalism Practice•2012

  • Balancing Product Reviews, Traffic Targets, and Industry Criticism

    J Scott Brennen, Philip N Howard et al.•Journalism Practice•2020

  • Communication, media and environment

    Open Access•Anders Hansen•International Communication Gazette•2011

  • On news media and democratic debate

    Open Access•Pieter Maeseele•International Communication Gazette•2011

  • Tinkering with nature

    Open Access•Anders Hansen•Comunicação e Sociedade•2004

  • Turning Sexual Science Into News

    Kimberly R McBride, Stephanie A Sanders et al.•The Journal of Sex Research•2007

  • Do Citizens Want to Have Their Say? Media, Agricultural Biotechnology, and Authoritarian Views of Democratic Processes in Science

    Dominique Brossard, Jarrod Shanahan•Mass Communication & Society•2003

  • Framing Wind Energy

    Keith Joseph Zukas•Mass Communication & Society•2016

  • Legislation by Agenda-Setting

    Simon Ki•Mass Communication & Society•2013

  • Genetic alchemy

    Sheldon Krimsky•Genetic alchemy•1982

  • Risk Society

    Ulrich Beck•Risk Society•2013

  • Reporters and officials

    Leon V Sigal•Reporters and officials•1974

  • Science and the media

    Open Access•P Weingart•Research Policy•1998

  • Worlds Apart? The Reception of Genetically Modified Foods in Europe and the U.S.

    Open Access•George Gaskell, Martin W Bauer et al.•Science•1999

  • Making news

    Gaye Tuchman•Making news•1978

  • Agendas, alternatives, and public policies

    John W Kingdon•Agendas, alternatives, and public…•1995

  • Whole World Is Watching

    Todd Gitlin•Whole World Is Watching•2005

  • Civilization and madness

    Open Access•Sheila Jasanoff•Public Understanding of Science•1997

  • A Grain of Truth

    Susanna Hornig Priest•Public Understanding of Science•2002

  • Biomedical Innovation and the Press

    Open Access•Nancy Pfund, Laura Hofstadter•Journal of Communication•1981

  • Environmental Risks and the Media

    Stuart Allan, Bárbara Adam et al.•Environmental Risks and the Media•2000

  • Frame Reflection

    Peter B Meyer•Journal of Economic Issues•1995

  • Framing as a Theory of Media Effects

    Open Access•Dietram A Scheufele•Journal of Communication•1999

  • Twenty-Five Years of the Spiral of Silence

    Dietram A Scheufle, Patricia Moy•International Journal of Public…•2000

  • Political Communication Research

    Akira Ichikawa•Canadian Journal of Communication•1986

  • Impact

    Open Access•William L Rivers•Government Information Quarterly•1988

  • Genetic Alchemy

    Michael G Morgan, Sheldon Krimsky•Journal of Policy Analysis and…•1983

  • The Social Construction of a Scientific Controversy

    Open Access•Michael Altimore•Science Technology & Human Values•1982

  • The interaction of journalists and scientific experts

    Open Access•Hans P Peters•Media Culture & Society•1995

  • The Whole World is Watching

    Open Access•Andrew K Semmel•Political Science Quarterly•1983

  • Impact

    Open Access•Doris A Graber, Doris Α Graber•Political Science Quarterly•1987

  • Risk society

    Ulrich Beck•Risikogesellschaft•1992

  • The Politics of Agenda-Building

    Roger W Cobb, Charles D Elder•The Journal of Politics•1971

  • Popularizing Biotechnology

    Open Access•L Christopher Plein•Science Technology & Human Values•1991

  • Framing Processes and Social Movements

    Robert D Benford, David A Snow•Annual Review of Sociology•2000

  • Media Discourse and Public Opinion on Nuclear Power

    William A Gamson, Andre Modigliani•American Journal of Sociology•1989

Unique citing works152
Citations per year6,33
Citation span2002 - 2026 (25)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 150

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae