Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

War, Rivalry, and State Building in Latin America

Bibliographic Data

ID6230150
AuthorsCameron G Thies (0000-0002-9932-1394, Louisiana State University, corresponding author)
Year2005
Volume49
Issue3
Pages451
Publication date2005-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Journal of Political Science (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0092-5853 • E-ISSN: 1540-5907
PublisherJSTOR (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.2307/3647725
OpenAlexW4241374462
LanguageEN
Citations received161
References cited57

Scholars of Latin America have recently begun to apply the bellicist approach to state building to the region, the central claim of which is that wars are a great stimulus to centralizing state power and building institutional capacity. This article argues that current applications of these models of state building are too narrowly specified to be of much use in Latin America or elsewhere in the developing world. Replacing the focus on interstate war with the more general phenomenon of interstate rivalry, alongside the consideration of intrastate rivals, allows us to account for the impact of both external and internal forces on the development of the state. I demonstrate the utility of this approach through several cross‐sectional time‐series analyses that provide evidence that external and internal rivals affect the Latin American state in a manner consistent with the general nature of bellicist theory

Development economics · Economic history · Economics · Latin Americans · Macroeconomics · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Rivalry · Sociology · State (computer science · State-building · Stimulus (psychology · Computer Science · History · International Development and Aid · International Relations and Foreign Policy · International Relations in Latin America · Law · Political Conflict and Governance · Psychology

  • Taxation and State-Building in Developing Countries

    Odd‐Helge Fjeldstad, Deborah Brautigam et al.•Taxation and State-Building in…•2009

  • Strongmen and warmaking

    Open Access•Ayşe Zarakol•Thesis Eleven•2026

  • How Border Disputes Influence Disaster Response

    Open Access•Adam Lappe, Stephen Mark Mitchell et al.•International Studies Quarterly•2026

  • Political Factors in the Growth of Social Assistance

    Armando Barrientos, Sony Pellissery•Politics of Inclusive Development•2014

  • The Gendered Politics of Securing Inclusive Development

    Sohela Nazneen, Simeen Mahmud•Politics of Inclusive Development•2014

  • Governing Natural Resources for Inclusive Development

    Anthony J Bebbington, Anthony Bebbington•Politics of Inclusive Development•2014

  • Continual Contestations at the China-Myanmar Border

    Enze Han•Asymmetrical Neighbors•2019

  • The Political Determinants of Economic Growth

    Kunal Sen•Politics of Inclusive Development•2014

  • Communist Revolutions at the Borderland

    Enze Han•Asymmetrical Neighbors•2019

  • Exploring the Politics of Inclusive Development

    Open Access•Sam Hickey, Kunal Sen et al.•Politics of Inclusive Development•2014

  • Ethnicity, State Capacity, and Development

    Prerna Singh, M Vom Hau•Politics of Inclusive Development•2014

  • Comparative Nation Building across the Borderland Area

    Enze Han•Asymmetrical Neighbors•2019

  • The Politics—and Process—of Rule of Law Systems in Developmental States

    Open Access•Deval Desai, Michael Woolcock•Politics of Inclusive Development•2014

  • Spillover of the Chinese Civil War and Militarization of the Borderland

    Enze Han•Asymmetrical Neighbors•2019

  • The Neighborhood Effect of State and Nation Building

    Enze Han•Asymmetrical Neighbors•2019

  • China in Africa

    Giles Mohan•Politics of Inclusive Development•2014

  • Conclusion

    Enze Han•Asymmetrical Neighbors•2019

  • The Historical Pattern of State Formation in Upland Southeast Asia

    Enze Han•Asymmetrical Neighbors•2019

  • Taxation and State Capacity

    James E Mahon•Oxford Handbook of Governance and…•2023

  • The Politics of What Works for the Poor in Public Expenditure and Taxation

    Paul Mosley•Politics of Inclusive Development•2014

  • Notes on Transliterations and References

    Enze Han•Asymmetrical Neighbors•2019

  • The Politics of Aid Revisited

    Arjan De Haan, Ward Warmerdam•Politics of Inclusive Development•2014

  • Dynamics of Transboundary Economic Flows

    Enze Han•Asymmetrical Neighbors•2019

  • The Politics of What Works in Service Delivery

    Claire Mcloughlin•Politics of Inclusive Development•2014

  • The Institutions Curse

    Open Access•Victor Menaldo•Institutions Curse•2016

  • How States Die

    Douglas Lemke•How States Die•2025

  • Autocracy and Redistribution

    Open Access•Michael Albertus•Autocracy and Redistribution•2015

  • State Capacity and Economic Development

    Daron Acemoglu, Camilo García-Jimeno et al.•American Economic Review•2015

  • El poder infraestructural en Uruguay durante la Primera Globalización

    Open Access•Camilo Martínez•América Latina en la Historia…•2026

  • India–China and Their War-making Capacities

    Open Access•Christopher K Colley, Prashant Hosur Suhas•Journal of Asian Security and…•2021

  • On Tax Efforts and Colonial Heritage in Africa

    Thandika Mkandawire•The Journal of Development Studies•2010

  • From Peril to Partnership

    Paul Angelo, Paul J Angelo•From Peril to Partnership•2023

  • Mobilization and Conflict in Multiethnic States

    Manuel Vogt•Mobilization and Conflict in…•2019

  • A False Start on the Road to Mercosur

    Open Access•Christopher Darnton•Latin American Research Review•2012

  • Elimination/Deracination

    Open Access•Jorge E Cuéllar•American Indian Culture and…•2018

  • The Legacy of Civil War Dynamics

    Open Access•Luz Marina Arias, Luis De La Calle•Latin American Research Review•2021

  • Civil wars as critical junctures

    Open Access•Kai M Thaler•Review of International Studies•2024

  • The impacts of armed conflict on human development

    Open Access•Paola Vesco, Ghassan Baliki et al.•World Development•2025

  • Is Africa Different? Historical Conflict and State Development

    Mark Dincecco, James Fenske et al.•Economic History of Developing…•2019

  • Internal Conflicts and Shadow Economies

    Open Access•Dursun Peksen, Bryan R Early et al.•Journal of Global Security Studies•2019

  • The Human Cost of the Weapons Trade

    Open Access•Carla Martinez Machain, Jeffrey Pickering•Journal of Global Security Studies•2019

  • Interstate Rivalries and Expansions in Military Capacity

    Open Access•Prashant Hosur Suhas, Shelli Israelsen•International Area Studies Review•2021

  • Geographical and temporal patterns of interstate security competition

    Open Access•Jo Jakobsen, Thomas Halvorsen•International Area Studies Review•2019

  • Peacemaking as Statebuilding

    Open Access•Madhav Joshi, Roger Mac Ginty•Journal of Intervention and…•2025

  • Regime Type and Interstate War Finance

    Jeff Carter, Glenn Palmer•Foreign Policy Analysis•2016

  • Role Theory and Foreign Policy Analysis in Latin America

    Open Access•Cameron G Thies•Foreign Policy Analysis•2014

  • External Threats, Internal Challenges, and State Building in East Asia

    Open Access•Enze Han, Cameron G Thies•Journal of East Asian Studies•2019

  • Neorealism in Search of New Territory

    Open Access•Cameron G Thies•International Studies Review•2008

  • Tilly Tally

    Open Access•Brian D Taylor, Roxana Botea•International Studies Review•2008

  • Les origines institutionnelles et l'économie politique comparative du développement tardif

    David Waldner, Elyssa Dunfee•Revue internationale de politique…•2011

  • Process and Effect in Tilly’s Analytical Toolbox

    Jose Angel Gutierrez•Civil Wars•2023

  • Financing welfare regimes

    Open Access•Ian Gough, Miriam Abu Sharkh•International Journal of Social…•2011

  • State Power and Its Implications for Civil War Colombia

    Alex McDougall•Studies in Conflict and Terrorism•2009

  • The Concept and Evolution of the Developmental State

    Esteban Pérez Caldentey•International Journal of…•2008

  • Democracies, Territory, and Negotiated Compromises

    Open Access•Steven V Miller, Douglas M Gibler•Conflict Management and Peace…•2011

  • Borders, Rivalry, Democracy, and Conflict in the European Region, 1816-1994

    Open Access•Karen Rasler, William R Thompson•Conflict Management and Peace…•2011

  • Foreign military intervention and post-colonial state-building

    Open Access•Jeffrey Pickering, Emizet F Kisangani•Conflict Management and Peace…•2013

  • A political economy of human rights

    Open Access•Jacqueline H R Demeritt, Joseph K Young•Conflict Management and Peace…•2013

  • Issue Rivalries

    Open Access•Stephen Mark Mitchell, Sara Mclaughlin Mitchell et al.•Conflict Management and Peace…•2011

  • Building a tax state in the 21st century

    Open Access•Julian Limberg•World Development•2022

  • Building support for taxation in developing countries

    Open Access•Gustavo Flores-Macías, Gustavo A Flores-Macías•World Development•2018

  • The Strategic Development of Border Areas

    Michael E Aleprete, Aaron M Hoffman•International Interactions•2012

  • The colonial roots of structural coup-proofing

    Marius Mehrl, Ioannis Choulis•International Interactions•2021

  • Balances Without Great Powers

    William B Moul•International Interactions•2012

  • The Construction of a Latin American Interstate Culture of Rivalry

    Cameron G Thies•International Interactions•2008

  • The Invisible Impact of Conflict

    Dain Yoo, Da Sul Kim•International Interactions•2024

  • Resource Curse in Reverse

    Stephen Mark Mitchell, Cameron G Thies•International Interactions•2012

  • Intra-national IR in Africa

    Open Access•Douglas Lemke•Review of International Studies•2011

  • Do institutions matter? Taxation and state formation in Pakistan

    Fahd Ali•Canadian Journal of Development…•2025

  • Medieval Roots of the Modern State

    Open Access•Jørgen Møller•Social Science History•2018

  • Behind the trigger

    Saul M Rodriguez•Third World Quarterly•2024

  • War and state formation in Lebanon

    Andrew Delatolla•Third World Quarterly•2016

  • Civil War, Institutional Change, and the Criminalization of the State

    Open Access•R A Schwartz•Studies in Comparative…•2020

  • Pathways to State Capacity

    Open Access•Sebastián Mazzuca, Adam Sheingate•Studies in Comparative…•2026

  • Bounded Rule and Regional Stability in Fragile States

    Michael F Harsch, Kevin K Troy•The Journal of Politics•2023

  • Warfare, Fiscal Gridlock, and State Formation During Europe’s Military Revolution

    Gary W Cox, Mark Dincecco et al.•The Journal of Politics•2024

  • Political Competition and State Capacity

    Open Access•Leopoldo Fergusson, Horacio Larreguy et al.•The Economic Journal•2022

  • From Pluribus to Unum ? The Civil War and Imagined Sovereignty in Nineteenth-Century America

    Open Access•Marshall M Lee, Nan Zhang et al.•American Political Science Review•2023

  • Democratization, elections and the ‘de facto state dilemma’

    Open Access•Benjamin Macqueen•Cooperation and Conflict•2015

  • Asymmetrical Neighbors

    Enze Han•Asymmetrical Neighbors•2019

  • War Did Make States

    Open Access•Lars-Erik Cederman, Paola Galano Toro et al.•International Organization•2023

  • Violent Conflict and Political Development Over the Long Run

    Mark Dincecco, Yuhua Wang•Annual Review of Political Science•2018

  • Tilly Goes to Church

    Open Access•Anna Grzymala-Busse•American Political Science Review•2024

  • Different Paths to the Modern State in Europe

    Open Access•K KIVANÇ KARAMAN, K Kıvanç Karaman et al.•American Political Science Review•2013

  • Latin American Corruption in Geographic Perspective

    Barney Warf, Samuel Alexander Stewart•Journal of Latin American geography•2016

  • The Politics of Inclusive Development

    Samuel Hickey, Sam Hickey et al.•Politics of Inclusive Development•2014

  • State Capacity Redux

    Elissa Berwick, Fotini Christia•Annual Review of Political Science•2018

  • Bureaucracy and Service Delivery

    Thomas B Pepinsky, Jan Pierskalla et al.•Annual Review of Political Science•2017

  • National Design and State Building in Sub-Saharan Africa

    Open Access•Cameron G Thies•World Politics•2009

  • Banking crises and the modern tax state

    Open Access•Julian Limberg•Socio-Economic Review•2022

  • Paying for War and Building States

    Open Access•Ryan Saylor, Nicholas C Wheeler•World Politics•2017

  • The Political Economy of State Building in Sub-Saharan Africa

    Cameron G Thies•The Journal of Politics•2007

  • Games Rivals Play

    Michael G Findley, James A Piazza et al.•The Journal of Politics•2012

  • The Coevolution of Networks of Interstate Support, Interstate Threat, and Civil War

    Kyle Beardsley•The Journal of Politics•2024

  • Advancing the Study of Stateness in Central America

    Open Access•Jorge Vargas Cullell•Revista de ciencia política•2012

  • Territorial Politics and Institutional Change

    Jörg Broschek, Bettina Petersohn et al.•Publius The Journal of Federalism•2018

  • Perceptions of governance

    Sasha Klyachkina•Post-Soviet Affairs•2021

  • The Spatial Dimensions of State Fiscal Capacity The Mechanisms of International Influence on Domestic Extractive Efforts

    Open Access•Cameron G Thies, Olga Chyzh et al.•Political Science Research and…•2016

  • War, Rivalry, and State Building in the Middle East

    Open Access•Lingyu Lu, Cameron G Thies•Political Research Quarterly•2013

  • External Territorial Threats and Military Regimes

    Open Access•Nam Kyu Kim•Political Research Quarterly•2019

  • What price vigilance?

    Bruce M Russett•What price vigilance?•1970

  • Structure and change in economic history

    Douglass Cecil North•Structure and change in economic…•1981

  • The Formation of national States in Western Europe

    Charles Tilly•The Formation of national States…•1975

  • Political Survival

    Barry Ames•Political Survival•1987

  • Progress, Poverty and Exclusion

    Rosemary Thorp•1998

  • State Building and Late Development

    David Waldner•State Building and Late Development•1999

  • Coercion, capital, and European states, AD 990-1992

    Charles Tilly•Coercion, capital, and European…•1992

  • States and Power in Africa: Comparative Lessons in Authority and Control

    Jeffrey Herbst•States and Power in Africa•2015

  • Shaping the Political Arena

    Ruth Berins Collier, Donald Collier et al.•Shaping the Political Arena•2015

  • Birth of the Leviathan

    Open Access•Thomas Ertman•Birth of the Leviathan•1997

  • Big, Slow-Moving, and … Invisible

    Open Access•Paul Pierson•Comparative Historical Analysis…•2003

  • The Other Mirror

    Open Access•Miguel Angel Centeno, Fernando Lopez-Alves•Other Mirror•2001

  • Forced synthesis of trace amounts of juvenile hormone II from propionate by corpora allata of a juvenile hormone III-producing insect

    Open Access•Ira Katznelson, R Feyereisen et al.•Experientia•1988

  • War and Peace in International Rivalry

    Paul F Diehl, Gary Goertz et al.•War and Peace in International…•2000

  • The State and Fiscal Sociology

    John L Campbell•Annual Review of Sociology•1993

  • The War Ledger

    A F K Organski, Jacek Kugler•War Ledger•1980

  • Territorial nationalism in spatial rivalries

    Cameron G Thies•International Interactions•2001

  • Democracy, regime change, and rivalry termination

    D Scott Bennett•International Interactions•1997

  • Modernity and the process of state formation

    Andrew Kirby, Michael D Ward•International Interactions•1991

  • Responding to State Failure in Africa

    Jeffrey Herbst•International Security•1996

  • War and the State in Africa

    Jeffrey Herbst•International Security•1990

  • Responding to State Failure in Africa

    Jeffrey Herbst•International Security•1997

  • On the peaceful disposition of military dictatorships

    Stanislav Andreski•Journal of Strategic Studies•1980

  • Progress, Poverty, and Exclusion

    Richard N Cooper, Rosemary Thorp•Foreign Affairs•1999

  • The Path to European Integration

    Open Access•Paul Pierson•Comparative Political Studies•1996

  • Political Regimes and the Extractive Capacity of Governments

    Open Access•José Antônio Cheibub•World Politics•1998

  • Measuring Rivalry Termination, 1816-1992

    Open Access•D Scott Bennett•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1997

  • Principal Rivalries

    Open Access•William R Thompson•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1995

  • It Takes Two to Tango

    Open Access•Paul R Hensel, Paul F Diehl•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1994

  • Identifying Rivals and Rivalries in World Politics

    William R Thompson•International Studies Quarterly•2001

  • Security, Bargaining, and the End of Interstate Rivalry

    D Scott Bennett•International Studies Quarterly•1996

  • State Building, Interstate and Intrastate Rivalry

    Open Access•Cameron G Thies•International Studies Quarterly•2004

  • The Absence of Middle Eastern Great Powers

    Open Access•I S Lustick•International Organization•1997

  • War and strong states, peace and weak states

    Open Access•Michael C Desch•International Organization•1996

  • War and Economic Development

    Richard Stubbs•Comparative Politics•1999

  • A Historical Institutionalist Approach to the Uruguay Round Agricultural Negotiations

    Open Access•Cameron G Thies•Comparative Political Studies•2001

  • War and the Three Faces of Power

    Open Access•Keith Jaggers•Comparative Political Studies•1992

  • The Initiation and Termination of Enduring Rivalries

    Gary Goertz, Paul F Diehl•American Journal of Political…•1995

  • Integrating and Testing Models of Rivalry Duration

    D Scott Bennett•American Journal of Political…•1998

  • What To Do (and Not to Do) with Time-Series Cross-Section Data

    Open Access•Niels Beck, Nathaniel Beck et al.•American Political Science Review•1995

  • The Paradoxical Nature of State Making

    Open Access•Youssef Cohen, Bonny R Brown et al.•American Political Science Review•1981

  • War Making and State Making

    Open Access•Karen Rasler, Karen A Rasler et al.•American Political Science Review•1985

  • Violent Peace

    Open Access•Manuela Aguilar, David R Mares et al.•Latin American Politics and Society•2002

  • Blood and Debt

    Miguel Angel Centeno•Blood and Debt•2015

  • The Predatory Theory of Rule

    Open Access•Margaret Levi•Latin American Politics and Society•1981

  • Blood and Debt

    Miguel Angel Centeno•American Journal of Sociology•1997

Unique citing works150
Citations per year8,05
Citation span2006 - 2026 (21)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 158

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae