Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Constraints on Cabinet Formation in Parliamentary Democracies

Bibliographic Data

ID6231799
AuthorsKaare W Strøm, Kaare Strom, Ian Budge (University of Essex), Michael Laver (0000-0001-7515-9831, University of Essex), Michael J Laver
Year1994
Volume38
Issue2
Pages303
Publication date1994-05-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Journal of Political Science (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0092-5853 • E-ISSN: 1540-5907
PublisherJSTOR (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.2307/2111406
OpenAlexW2085753961
LanguageEN
Citations received146
References cited23

Coalition theory typically treats political parties involved in government formation in parliamentary democracies as if they were unconstrained players in an institution-free world. Yet actual coalition options are often severely constrained by institutional arrangements and prior commitments. We develop a systematic account of different constraints on government formation and examine their frequency across 10 parliamentary democracies. Hypothetical and empirical examples demonstrate how a small number of constraints can dramatically reduce the range of coalition options and redistribute bargaining power among political parties. More adequate coalition theories need to recognize the effects of such constraints and to build on the theoretical lessons of the neoinstitutionalist approach to legislative behavior

Cabinet (room · Coalition government · Democracy · Economics · Government (linguistics · Institution · Legislature · Multi-party system · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Power (physics · Public economics · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Engineering · Law · Political Influence and Corporate Strategies · Public Administration · Social Policy and Reform Studies

  • The Party System

    Charles Little, Conor Little et al.•Oxford Handbook of Irish Politics•2021

  • Cabinets, Ministers, and Gender

    Claire Annesley, Karen Beckwith et al.•Cabinets, Ministers, and Gender•2019

  • La opinión pública catalana frente a la coalición parlamentaria entre PSOE y CiU en la V Legislatura de las Cortes Generales (1993-1996)

    Open Access•Jordi Calvet Crespo, Jordi Calvet I Crespo•Revista Española de Investigaciones…•1999

  • Gamson–Shapley Laws

    Open Access•Nataliya Demyanenko, Pierfrancesco La Mura•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2023

  • Elite affective polarization and government formation

    Open Access•Hanna Bäck, Royce Carroll et al.•European Journal of Political…•2026

  • Communication theoretical implications of the Ray Rice controversy

    Open Access•Payal Cascio, Lincoln Geraghty•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2016

  • Coalition Politics in Central Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Torbjörn Bergman, Gabriella Ilonszki et al.•Coalition Politics in Central…•2023

  • Coalition Preferences and Party Systems

    Open Access•Charles Little•Government and Opposition•2026

  • Frauen in politischen Spitzenämtern. Die Ernennung von weiblichen Ministern in die Landeskabinette der deutschen Bundesländer

    Open Access•Daniel Höhmann•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2017

  • Party system factors and the formation of minority governments in Central and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Dorothea Keudel-Kaiser•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2016

  • Ethnic diversity in central government cabinets

    William O’brochta•Politics Groups and Identities•2020

  • The Ins and Outs of Conceptualizing Inclusion

    Open Access•Cullen S Hendrix, Cullen Hendrix•Journal of Global Security Studies•2019

  • Electoral rules, voter mobilization and the Islamist landslide in the Saudi municipal elections of 2005

    Hendrik Kraetzschmar, Hendrik Jan Kraetzschmar•Contemporary Arab Affairs•2010

  • New Parties, Fractionalization, and the Increasing Duration of Government Formation Processes in the EU Member States

    Open Access•Marco Morini, Marco Cilento•Politics & Policy•2020

  • Party Size, Ideology, and Executive‐Level Representation in Advanced Parliamentary Democracies

    Open Access•Carolyn Forestiere•Politics & Policy•2009

  • From toleration to recognition

    Open Access•Mathias Holst Nicolaisen•Comparative European Politics•2023

  • Why are multi-party minority governments viable in India? Theory and comparison

    Eswaran Sridharan•Commonwealth and Comparative…•2012

  • Alternation, Inclusion and the European Union

    Open Access•Andrea Kaiser•European Union Politics•2002

  • Regional Nationalist Parties and Constitutional Change in Parliamentary Democracies

    Simon Toubeau•Regional & Federal Studies•2011

  • A Sheep in Wolf's Clothing or a Gift from Heaven? Left–Left Coalitions in Comparative Perspective

    Dan Hough, Tània Verge Mestre•Regional & Federal Studies•2009

  • Government Formation and Policy Formulation in the German States

    Thomas Däubler, Marc Debus•Regional & Federal Studies•2009

  • Explaining Government Formation in Multi-level Settings

    Irina Ştefuriuc•Regional & Federal Studies•2009

  • Incumbency advantages, Prime Minister replacements and government formation

    Open Access•Hanna Bäck, Marc Debus et al.•Party Politics•2025

  • Natural because it had become just that.’ Path dependence in pre-electoral pacts and government formation

    Tim Bale, Jonathan Boston et al.•Australian Journal of Political…•2005

  • Speaking European

    Andrew Konitzer•Europe Asia Studies•2011

  • The Duration of Caretaker Periods and the Formation of Parliamentary Governments

    Open Access•Francesco Bromo•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2025

  • Experimenting with coalition government

    Jonathan Boston, Stephen Levine et al.•The Journal of Commonwealth &…•1997

  • Gamson's Law in the City Hall

    Open Access•Marius Perrin•Scandinavian Political Studies•2026

  • Pre-electoral commitments and government formation

    Open Access•Marc Debus•Public Choice•2009

  • When Does Electoral Cooperation End? How Relative Changes in Popular Support Undermine Election Alliances in India

    Open Access•Dyutiman Saunik, Adam Ziegfeld•Studies in Comparative…•2025

  • Regional Government Formation in Varying Multilevel Contexts

    Hanna Bäck, Marc Debus et al.•Regional Studies•2012

  • Overcoming the fear of commitment

    Open Access•Elin Haugsgjerd Allern, Nicholas Aylott•Acta Politica•2009

  • The drivers of resemblance in presidential regimes

    Open Access•Lucas Couto•European Political Science Review•2025

  • Coalition Formation and the Regime Divide in New Democracies

    Anna Grzymala-Busse•Comparative Politics•2001

  • Understanding Pre-electoral Coalitions in Central and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Raimondas Ibenskas•British Journal of Political…•2016

  • Investiture rules and formation of minority governments in European parliamentary democracies

    Open Access•José Antônio Cheibub, Shane Martins et al.•Party Politics•2021

  • Communist Successor Parties And Coalition Formation In Eastern Europe

    Open Access•James N Druckman, Andrew Roberts•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2007

  • How Do They Get In? Radical Parties and Government Participation in European Democracies

    Open Access•Andreas Fagerholm•Government and Opposition•2021

  • The influence of presidential heads of state on government formation in European democracies

    Open Access•HIN‐GOO KANG, SHIN‐GOO KANG•European Journal of Political…•2009

  • Does winning pay? Electoral success and government formation in 15 West European countries

    Open Access•Mikko Mattila, Tapio Raunio•European Journal of Political…•2004

  • Uncovering the micro-foundations of turnout and electoral systems

    Open Access•Tse-Hsin Chen•Electoral Studies•2011

  • La opinión pública catalana frente a la coalición parlamentaria entre PSOE y CiU en la V Legislatura de las Cortes Generales (1993-1996)

    Open Access•Jordi Calvet Crespo, Jordi Calvet I Crespo•Revista Española de Investigaciones…•2024

  • Gendering Coalitional Presidentialism in Brazil

    Open Access•Malu A C Gatto, Pinto Dos Santos et al.•Journal of Politics in Latin…•2022

  • Unusual Bedfellows? PRI-PVEM Electoral Alliances in Mexican Legislative Elections

    Open Access•Jae‐jae Spoon, Amalia Pulido Gómez•Journal of Politics in Latin…•2017

  • Offices and policies - Why do oppositional parties form pre-electoral coalitions in competitive authoritarian regimes

    Open Access•Michael Wahman•Electoral Studies•2011

  • Theorie und Empirie der Vergleichenden Koalitionsforschung

    Open Access•Thomas Bräuninger, Marc Debus•Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft•2024

  • Koalitionsbildung in deutschen Großstädten

    Martin Gro•Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft•2014

  • Pieces of the puzzle? Coalition formation and tangential preferences

    Open Access•Paul Dumont, Albert Falcó-Gimeno et al.•West European Politics•2024

  • Assembly dissolution powers and incumbency advantages in coalition formation

    Petra Schleiter, Cristina Bucur•West European Politics•2024

  • Do Voters’ Coalition Preferences Affect Government Formation

    Marc Debus, Jochen Müller et al.•West European Politics•2013

  • Events’ and ‘causes’ in cabinet termination and survival

    Giuseppe Ieraci•West European Politics•1996

  • Parliaments and government termination

    Reuven Y Hazan, Bjørn Erik Rasch•West European Politics•2022

  • Parliamentary government in different shapes

    Guy‐erik Isaksson•West European Politics•2001

  • The formalisation of minority governments

    Open Access•Maria Thürk, Svenja Krau•West European Politics•2024

  • Institutions and coalition formation

    Sven-Oliver Proksch, Jonathan B Slapin et al.•West European Politics•2006

  • Combining large-nand small-nstrategies

    Hanna Bäck, Paul Dumont et al.•West European Politics•2007

  • Why Do Parties Merge? Electoral Volatility and Long-Term Coalitions

    Giovanna M Invernizzi•The Journal of Politics•2024

  • Exploiting the Cracks

    Marc Van De Wardt, Catherine E De Vries et al.•The Journal of Politics•2014

  • All the President’s Men? The Appointment of Female Cabinet Ministers Worldwide

    Mona Lena Krook, Diana Z O’brien•The Journal of Politics•2012

  • A Step in the Wrong Direction

    Leonard W Martins, Lanny W Martins et al.•The Journal of Politics•2014

  • Let’s Just Agree to Disagree

    Shaun Bowler, Thomas Bräuninger et al.•The Journal of Politics•2016

  • Like Leaves in the Wind? Economic Conditions and Government Survival in Italy (1946–2015)

    Luca Pinto•South European Society & Politics•2018

  • Small and Divided Parties in Multi-Level Settings

    Irina Ştefuriuc, Tània Verge Mestre et al.•South European Society & Politics•2008

  • Foreign Policy Objectives

    Open Access•Dag Arne Christensen•Scandinavian Political Studies•1998

  • Presidencialismo y coaliciones de gobierno en América Latina

    Open Access•Adrián Albala•Revista de ciencia política•2016

  • Reforming An Electoral System – An Experiment That Failed

    Aurelian Giugăl, Ron Johnston et al.•Representation•2020

  • Assessing Patterns of Executive Representation in Parliamentary Systems

    Carolyn Forestiere•Representation•2007

  • Legislative Power and Women's Representation

    Open Access•Leslie Schwindt-Bayer, Leslie A Schwindt‐bayer et al.•Politics & Gender•2014

  • When do coalitions form under presidentialism, and why does it matter? A configurational analysis from Latin America

    Open Access•Adrián Albala•Politics•2021

  • Presidents and Cabinet Payoffs in Coalition Governments

    Open Access•Cristina Bucur•Political Studies Review•2020

  • Dynamic Approaches to Studying Parliamentary Coalitions

    Open Access•James N Druckman•Political Research Quarterly•2008

  • Debating the Populist Pariah

    Open Access•Esther Mary L Calvo, Hanna Bäck et al.•Political Research Quarterly•2024

  • Presidential Partisanship in Government Formation

    Open Access•Cristina Bucur, José Antônio Cheibub•Political Research Quarterly•2017

  • Manifestos, salience and junior ministerial appointments

    Open Access•Zachary David Greene, Christian B Jensen et al.•Party Politics•2016

  • Empty Nets

    Open Access•Christopher S Allen•Party Politics•2009

  • Drawing from the bargaining pool

    Open Access•Julia Fleischer, Markus Seyfried•Party Politics•2015

  • Government formation under the shadow of a core party

    Open Access•Luigi Curini, Luca Pinto•Party Politics•2013

  • Coalition formation at the local level

    Open Access•Marc Debus, Martin Gro•Party Politics•2016

  • Office and Policy Payoffs in Coalition Governments

    Open Access•Marc Debus•Party Politics•2008

  • Representation at the margins

    Open Access•Marc André Bodet•Party Politics•2013

  • Is the Grass Really Greener

    Open Access•Tim Bale, Christine Dann•Party Politics•2002

  • Context and Coalition-Bargaining

    Open Access•James N Druckman, Andrew Roberts•Party Politics•2005

  • Not my government!’ The role of norms and populist attitudes on voter preferences for government formation after the election

    Open Access•Carolina Plescia, Jakob-Moritz Eberl•Party Politics•2021

  • Pre-electoral coalitions and voter turnout

    Open Access•Erik R Tillman•Party Politics•2015

  • Intra-Party Politics and Coalition Formation

    Open Access•Hanna Bäck•Party Politics•2008

  • Do electoral coalitions facilitate democratic consolidation in Africa

    Open Access•Donald Resnick, Danielle Resnick•Party Politics•2013

  • The radical left in coalition government

    Open Access•Richard Dunphy, Tim Bale•Party Politics•2011

  • Inter-factional conflicts and government formation

    Open Access•Andrea Ceron•Party Politics•2016

  • Explaining Cooperation over Casework between Members of National and Regional Parliaments

    Audrey André, Jonathan Bradbury et al.•Parliamentary Affairs•2015

  • You’ll never rule alone

    Michael Škvrňák•Local Government Studies•2021

  • Choosing Coalition Partners in Belgian Local Government

    Ellen Olislagers, Kristof Steyvers•Local Government Studies•2015

  • Talking Like Opposition Parties? Electoral Proximity and Language Styles Employed by Coalition Partners in a Mixed Member Majoritarian System

    Open Access•Hideo Ishima•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2024

  • Gaining Legislative Control Through Strategic District Nomination

    Open Access•Olga Shvetsova•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2002

  • Small in Size but Powerful in Parliament? The Legislative Performance of Minority Governments

    Open Access•Maria Thürk•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2022

  • Influence without Confidence

    Open Access•James N Druckman, Leonard W Martins et al.•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2005

  • Presidential Support in the Russian State Duma

    Open Access•Thomas F Remington•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2006

  • A model of electoral alliances in highly fragmented party systems

    Open Access•Marcelo De C Griebeler, Roberta Carnelos Resende•Journal of Theoretical Politics•2021

  • Conservative ministers in the Coalition government of 2010–15

    Tim Heppell, Timothy Heppell et al.•Journal of Legislative Studies•2016

  • Electoral incentives, policy compromise, and coalition durability

    Open Access•Adam P Liff, Ko Maeda•Japanese Journal of Political…•2019

  • Faraway, so close

    Open Access•Daniela Giannetti, Andrea Pedrazzani et al.•Italian Political Science…•2022

  • Ulysses and the Sirens

    Jon Elster•Ulysses and the Sirens•1979

  • The theory of political coalitions.

    William H Riker•The theory of political coalitions.•1962

  • An agenda for the study of institutions

    Open Access•Elinor Ostrom, Элинор Остром•Public Choice•1986

  • Parties and Democracy

    Open Access•Reuven Y Kazan•Political Science Quarterly•1991

  • Government Coalitions in Western Europe

    Open Access•Michael Taylor, Michael Laver•European Journal of Political…•1973

  • Ethnic conflict and elite bargaining

    Maureen Covell•West European Politics•1981

  • Government Formation in Multiparty Systems

    Open Access•Henrik Hermeren•Scandinavian Political Studies•1976

  • Office Seeking and Policy Pursuit in Coalition Theory

    Open Access•Ian Budge, Michael Laver•Legislative Studies Quarterly•1986

  • Studying Institutions

    Open Access•Kenneth A Shepsle•Journal of Theoretical Politics•1989

  • Party Competition and Party System Change

    Open Access•Michael Laver•Journal of Theoretical Politics•1989

  • Bureaucratic tradition, semi‐presidential rule and parliamentary government

    Open Access•Jaakko Nousiainen•European Journal of Political…•1988

  • Political competitition and multiparty coalition governments

    Open Access•Norman Schofield•European Journal of Political…•1993

  • Formation rules and minority governments

    Open Access•Torbjörn Bergman•European Journal of Political…•1993

  • A Behavioral Theory of Competitive Political Parties

    Kaare W Strøm, Kaare Strom•American Journal of Political…•1990

  • The Finnish general election of 1987

    Open Access•Sten Berglund•Electoral Studies•1987

  • Stable Governments and the Allocation of Policy Portfolios

    Open Access•David Austen-Smith, David Austen‐smith et al.•American Political Science Review•1990

  • Coalitions and Cabinet Government

    Open Access•Michael Laver, Kenneth A Shepsle•American Political Science Review•1990

  • Bargaining in Legislatures

    Open Access•David P Baron, John Ferejohn et al.•American Political Science Review•1989

  • Government Formation and Endogenous Parties

    Open Access•David P Baron•American Political Science Review•1993

  • Elections, Coalitions, and Legislative Outcomes

    Open Access•David Austen-Smith, David Austen‐smith et al.•American Political Science Review•1988

  • Restrictive Legislative Procedures in France and the United States

    Open Access•John D Huber•American Political Science Review•1992

  • A Spatial Bargaining Theory of Government Formation in Parliamentary Systems

    Open Access•David P Baron•American Political Science Review•1991

Unique citing works146
Citations per year4,42
Citation span1993 - 2026 (34)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 146

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae