Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Regulatory Competition and Environmental Enforcement

Is There a Race to the Bottom

Bibliographic Data

ID6231867
AuthorsDavid M Konisky (0000-0002-1146-3938, University of Missouri, corresponding author)
Year2007
Volume51
Issue4
Pages853-872
Publication date2007-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Journal of Political Science (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0092-5853 • E-ISSN: 1540-5907
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/j.1540-5907.2007.00285.x
OpenAlexW2092050244
LanguageEN
Citations received138
References cited46

This article examines several of the key hypotheses suggested by the race to the bottom theory in environmental regulation. The research studies annual state‐level enforcement of federal air, water, and hazardous waste pollution control regulation, covering the period from 1985 to 2000. Specifically, the study estimates a series of strategic interaction models to examine whether a state's environmental regulatory behavior is influenced by the regulatory behavior of the states with which it competes for economic investment. While there is clear evidence of strategic interaction in state environmental regulatory behavior, states do not respond in the asymmetric manner suggested by the race to the bottom theory

Business · Competition (biology · Economics · Enforcement · Environmental justice · Environmental regulation · Hazardous waste · Incentive · Investment (military · Microeconomics · Political science · Public economics · Race (biology · Race to the bottom · Race to the Top · Sociology · State (computer science · Strategic interaction · Waste management · Ecology · Economic and Environmental Valuation · Engineering · Law · Legal and Constitutional Studies · Regulation and Compliance Studies

  • Political career incentives and the environmental costs

    Open Access•JingXuan Xu, Hao Xu et al.•Journal of Development Economics•2026

  • Race-to-the-bottom dynamics in industrial land pricing

    Open Access•Ran Tao, Jialin Yu et al.•Journal of Development Economics•2027

  • Has the Clean Air Interstate Rule Fulfilled Its Mission? An Assessment of Federal Rule-Making in Preventing Regional Spillover Pollution

    Open Access•Douglas Glasgow, Derek Glasgow et al.•Review of Policy Research•2017

  • The states of public opinion on the environment

    Loretta Fowler, Luke Fowler•Environmental Politics•2016

  • Understanding Regulation

    Richard Baldwin, Robert Baldwin et al.•Understanding regulation•2011

  • Green technology innovation and financial development

    Open Access•Chengchao Lv, Changhua Shao et al.•Energy Economics•2021

  • Does central supervision enhance local environmental enforcement? Quasi-experimental evidence from China

    Open Access•Bing Zhang, Xiaolan Chen et al.•Journal of Public Economics•2018

  • Strategic interaction of environmental regulation and green productivity growth in China

    Open Access•Xin Peng•The Science of The Total…•2020

  • Land-use policies and corporate investments in agriculture in the Gran Chaco and Chiquitano

    Open Access•Yann Le Polain De Waroux, Rhianna Garrett et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2016

  • Multiple mechanisms of policy diffusion in China

    Youlang Zhang, Xufeng Zhu•Public Management Review•2019

  • Governing Complexity

    Open Access•Dustin Garrick, William Blomquist et al.•Governing Complexity•2019

  • An Introduction to Polycentricity and Governance

    Open Access•Mark Stephan, Graham R Marshall et al.•Governing Complexity•2019

  • Seeing Polycentrically

    Open Access•William Blomquist, William A Blomquist et al.•Governing Complexity•2019

  • Environmental Regulation at the Crossroads

    Open Access•Li Yuan•Business Strategy and the…•2026

  • The impact of geographic, mobility and social media ties on massive-scale regional public emotional interaction

    Open Access•Jia Xu, Liangdong Lu et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2025

  • Driving Green Innovation Through Environmental Collaboration

    Open Access•Tingting Xu, Shuying Li et al.•SAGE Open•2026

  • The Environmental Race to the Bottom, Revisited

    Open Access•David M Konisky, Nathan D Woods•Regulation & Governance•2026

  • Pollution risk transfer in cross-border tourism

    Xin Long Xu, Ying Zi Lin et al.•Current Issues in Tourism•2023

  • Remove or redistribute

    Open Access•Rong Ma, Xiaojun Shi•Environment and Development…•2023

  • The spatial spillover effect of urban sprawl and fiscal decentralization on air pollution

    Open Access•Xiaodong Yang, Jianlong Wang et al.•Empirical Economics•2022

  • Average and heterogeneous effects of political party on state education finance and outcomes

    Open Access•Mark Chin, Mark J Chin et al.•Economics of Education Review•2025

  • Boundary effects of water pollution under differentiated environmental decentralization modes

    Open Access•Dunhu Chang, Zeyang Zhang et al.•Environmental Impact Assessment…•2026

  • How do technological innovation and fiscal decentralization affect the environment? A story of the fourth industrial revolution and sustainable growth

    Open Access•Ya Cheng, U Awan et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2021

  • The Industrial Organization of Regulatory Capture

    Open Access•Nathan D Woods, Kenneth Aba et al.•Social Science Quarterly•2026

  • Amend

    Open Access•Nathan Sanders, Nathan Edward Sanders•Media and Communication•2019

  • Peer effects in local government decision-making

    Open Access•Jiajun Xu, Jinchao Wang et al.•Sustainable Cities and Society•2022

  • Minimum Wage Competition between Local Governments in China

    Yanan Li, Ravi Kanbur et al.•The Journal of Development Studies•2019

  • Qualitative Freiheit

    Open Access•Claus Dierksmeier•Qualitative Freiheit•2016

  • Policy devolution and cooperation dilemmas

    Open Access•Robert J Carroll, David M Konisky et al.•Journal of Theoretical Politics•2026

  • Evaluating the environmental and economic implications of curbing transboundary pollution

    Open Access•Zeyang Zhang, Yuanyi Xu et al.•Journal of Development Economics•2026

  • AI and Global Governance

    Open Access•Michael Veale, Kira Matus et al.•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2023

  • Environmental Regulation Competition and Carbon Emissions

    Open Access•Lizhi Cui, Ding Yining et al.•International Journal of…•2022

  • Research on the Spatial Correlation of China’s Haze Pollution and the Government’s Cooperative Governance Competitive Strategy

    Open Access•Shijin Wang, Guirong Ji et al.•International Journal of…•2022

  • The Price of Becoming a City

    Open Access•Zhihong Zeng, Chen You•International Journal of…•2022

  • Interplay of Environmental Regulation and Local Protectionism in China

    Open Access•Guanghui Tian, Jianming Miao et al.•International Journal of…•2022

  • Whether Green Finance Can Effectively Moderate the Green Technology Innovation Effect of Heterogeneous Environmental Regulation

    Open Access•Yong Fang, Zhenquan Shao•International Journal of…•2022

  • How Does Environmental Regulation Affect the Green Growth of China’s Citrus Industry? The Mediating Role of Technological Innovation

    Open Access•Hepei Zhang, Zhong Zhang-bao et al.•International Journal of…•2022

  • The Impact of Foreign Direct Investment on Environmental Pollution in China

    Open Access•Wang Shi, Hua Wang et al.•International Journal of…•2020

  • Local Government Competition, Environmental Regulation Intensity and Regional Innovation Performance

    Open Access•Jinqian Deng, Na Zhang et al.•International Journal of…•2019

  • Environmental Regulation, Tenure Length of Officials, and Green Innovation of Enterprises

    Open Access•Fan Wang, Wang Fan et al.•International Journal of…•2020

  • Strategic interactions of Chinese cities in improving total factor energy efficiency

    Open Access•Lixingzi Yang, Li-xingzi Yang et al.•Environment Development and…•2024

  • The nonlinear influence of innovation efficiency on carbon and haze co-control

    Open Access•Sai Yuan, Xiongfeng Pan et al.•Environment Development and…•2023

  • How does environmental regulation affect industrial green productivity of China's cities

    Open Access•Zhen Chen, Ce Jia•Environment Development and…•2023

  • Analyzing the impact of local government competition on green total factor productivity from the factor market distortion perspective

    Open Access•Juan Tang, Fangming Qin•Environment Development and…•2022

  • A study of the spatial spillover effects and mechanisms of the digital economy on tourism carbon neutrality ability

    Open Access•Jianlei Han, Wenqian Zheng et al.•Environment Development and…•2025

  • Reform of government level and local environmental pollution

    Open Access•Jingyuan Yu, Shuai Chen et al.•Environment Development and…•2023

  • Local environmental legislation and employment growth

    Open Access•Lei Wen, Hongbing Li et al.•Environment Development and…•2023

  • Local-neighborhood effects of different environmental regulations on green innovation

    Open Access•Wugan Cai, Peiyun Ye•Environment Development and…•2022

  • Pressures and responses to stationary waste gas emissions

    Open Access•Qingzi Huang, Dongdong Li•Environment Development and…•2023

  • Enterprise environmental performance under China's framework for Central Environmental Protection Inspection

    Open Access•Xiang Li, Hailin Lan et al.•Journal of International…•2025

  • Does central ecological transfer payment enhance local environmental performance? Quasi-experimental evidence from China

    Open Access•Yuhong Cheng, Ben Ma et al.•Ecological Economics•2023

  • Anti-corruption and corporate pollution mitigation

    Open Access•Zhifang Zhou, Shangjie Han et al.•Ecological Economics•2023

  • Regional variation in environmental inequality

    Open Access•Klara Zwickl, Mildred Ash et al.•Ecological Economics•2014

  • Environmental decentralization and political centralization

    Open Access•Per G Fredriksson, Jim R Wollscheid•Ecological Economics•2014

  • Localizing the energy transition

    Open Access•Oksan Bayulgen•Energy Research & Social Science•2020

  • Decarbonizing Bitcoin

    Open Access•Jon Truby•Energy Research & Social Science•2018

  • Influences on Adoption of Greenhouse Gas Reduction Targets among US States, 1998-2008

    Open Access•Tabitha M Cale, Margaret A Reams•Open Journal of Political Science•2013

  • Non-linear effects of environmental regulation and innovation – Spatial interaction evidence from the Yangtze River Delta in China

    Open Access•Qian Zhou, Yanan Song et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2020

  • Can constitutions bring about revolutions? How to enhance decarbonization success

    Open Access•Alessandra Cepparulo, Giuseppe Eusepi et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2018

  • Public policy in multi-level systems

    Open Access•Hanna Kleider, Simon Toubeau•Regional & Federal Studies•2022

  • Economic Competition, Policy Interdependence, and Labour Rights

    Zhiyuan Wang•New Political Economy•2017

  • The impact of political party control and economic forces on redistributive state wage policies since 1968

    Open Access•Christopher Dennis, Thomas J Hayes et al.•Party Politics•2024

  • Choosing a Lesser Evil

    Open Access•Zhiyuan Wang•Political Research Quarterly•2020

  • Can public surveillance promote corporate environmental innovation? The mediating role of environmental law enforcement

    Open Access•Zhongju Liao, Chen Weng et al.•Sustainable Development•2020

  • Environmental governance, local government competition and industrial green transformation

    Open Access•Luxin Yang, Yucheng Liu et al.•Sustainable Development•2022

  • Does fiscal decentralization and eco‐innovation promote sustainable environment? A case study of selected fiscally decentralized countries

    Open Access•Xiangfeng Ji, Muhammad Umar et al.•Sustainable Development•2020

  • Local government competition, environmental regulation, and green development in China

    Open Access•Yang Liu, Liu Yang et al.•Sustainable Development•2023

  • Composite fiscal decentralisation and green innovation

    Open Access•Yunpeng Sun, Asif Razzaq•Sustainable Development•2022

  • Achieving regional sustainability and carbon neutrality target in Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa economies

    Open Access•Maxwell Chukwudi Udeagha, Edwin Muchapondwa•Sustainable Development•2023

  • A study on the evolution of competition pattern of inland container ports along the Yangtze River in China

    Open Access•Jia Shi, Yuquan Jiao et al.•Journal of Transport Geography•2023

  • Charity Watchdogs and the Limits of Information-Based Regulation

    Open Access•Rebecca Szper, Aseem Prakash•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2010

  • Explaining state investment in drinking water infrastructure for disadvantaged communities, 1997-2016

    Open Access•Xi Chen, Jonathan M Fisk et al.•Utilities Policy•2026

  • Leader to Laggard

    Open Access•David Brian Robertson, David Robertson•Studies in American Political…•2020

  • Minor Party Major Change

    Open Access•Cassidy Reller•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2025

  • Should Countries Engage in a Race to the Bottom? The Effect of Social Spending on FDI

    Open Access•R Douglas Hecock, Eric M Jepsen•World Development•2012

  • Are foreign firms good for the environment? FDI and protected areas

    Open Access•Ana Carolina Garriga, Muzhou Zhang•International Interactions•2025

  • How Political Turbulence Changes Disincentives of Environmental Protection

    Open Access•Juncheng Feng, Kezhong Zhang et al.•Social Indicators Research•2015

  • Can centralization of environmental regulations reduce firm emissions? Evidence from county‐prefecture centralization reforms in China

    Open Access•Xun Cao, Mingqin Wu•Journal of Policy Analysis and…•2025

  • Inequities in enforcement? Environmental justice and government performance

    Open Access•David M Konisky•Journal of Policy Analysis and…•2008

  • China’s local governments breaking the land use planning quota

    Open Access•Jian Wang, Qun Wu et al.•Land Use Policy•2020

  • Joint prevention and control mechanism for air pollution regulations in China

    Open Access•Zhaopeng Chu, Chen Bian et al.•Environmental Impact Assessment…•2021

  • Chain of command vs. Who’s in command

    Open Access•Christopher Reenock, David M Konisky et al.•Policy Studies Journal•2022

  • U.S. Environmental Policy Implementation on Tribal Lands

    Open Access•Manuel P Teodoro, Mellie Haider et al.•Policy Studies Journal•2018

  • Does Local Government Competition Reduce Environmental Governance Performance? The Role of Public Value Conflict and Media Sentiment

    Open Access•Bin Guan•Administration & Society•2023

  • Political cycles’ impact on Chinese local governments’ environmental expenditures

    Open Access•Zengbao Hu, Stuart McDonald et al.•Public Choice•2026

  • Environmental Justice and Patterns of State Inspections

    Open Access•Francesca Spina•Social Science Quarterly•2015

  • How Do State‐Level Environmental Policies Impact the Voting Behavior of National Legislators

    Open Access•Thomas L Brunell, Brett Cease•Social Science Quarterly•2019

  • Innovation in Financing Energy‐Efficient and Renewable Energy Upgrades

    Open Access•Ruth Winecoff, Mariaelisa Graff et al.•Social Science Quarterly•2020

  • Innovation and Interdependence

    Open Access•Cleo O’Brien-Udry, Tyler Pratt•International Studies Quarterly•2025

  • Party polarization, disappearing regions, and nationalized environmental politics

    Loretta Fowler, Cathy Hunt et al.•Environmental Politics•2026

  • Foreignness as an Asset

    Patrick Bayer•The Journal of Politics•2023

  • Shifting Winds

    Open Access•Joshua G Wiener, Tomas M Koontz•Policy Studies Journal•2010

  • Race to the Bottom’ or ‘Race to Brussels’? Environmental Competition in Europe

    Open Access•Katharina Holzinger, Thomas Sommerer•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2011

  • From Backwaters to Major Policymakers

    Open Access•Jacob M Grumbach•Perspectives on Politics•2018

  • Assessing U.S. State Susceptibility to Environmental Regulatory Competition

    Open Access•David M Konisky•State Politics & Policy Quarterly•2009

  • Governor Partisanship Explains the Adoption of Statewide Mask Mandates in Response to Covid-19

    Open Access•Christopher Adolph, Kenya Amano et al.•State Politics & Policy Quarterly•2021

  • The effectiveness‐equity tradeoff when resources decline

    Open Access•Sanghee Park, Jiaqi Liang•Public Administration Review•2024

  • Renewable Energy Politics

    Open Access•Hongtao Yi, Richard Feiock•Policy Studies Journal•2014

  • Who gets what and why? A configurational analysis of China’s environmental regulatory enforcement

    Open Access•Wenya Zhang•Journal of Chinese Governance•2025

  • Bringing in horizontal strategic interactions

    Open Access•Ziteng Fan, Yijia Jing et al.•Government Information Quarterly•2025

  • Regression Analysis of Count Data

    A Colin Cameron, Pravin K Trivedi•Regression Analysis of Count Data•1998

  • Spatial Econometrics

    Open Access•Luc Anselin•Spatial Econometrics•1988

  • Problems with Instrumental Variables Estimation When the Correlation Between the Instruments and the Endogeneous Explanatory Variable is Weak

    John Bound, David A Jaeger et al.•Journal of the American…•1995

  • Strategic Interaction Among Governments

    Open Access•Jan K Brueckner•International Regional Science…•2003

  • Problems with Instrumental Variables Estimation when the Correlation between the Instruments and the Endogenous Explanatory Variable is Weak

    John Bound, David A Jaeger et al.•Journal of the American…•1995

  • A Generalized Spatial Two-Stage Least Squares Procedure for Estimating a Spatial Autoregressive Model with Autoregressive Disturbances

    Open Access•Harry H Kelejian, Ingmar R Prucha•The Journal of Real Estate…•1998

  • Do Local Governments Engage in Strategic Property—Tax Competition?

    Jan K Brueckner, Luz Amparo Saavedra•National Tax Journal•2001

  • Budget spillovers and fiscal policy interdependence

    Open Access•Anne Case, Anne C Case et al.•Journal of Public Economics•1993

  • Economic competition among jurisdictions

    Open Access•Wallace E Oates, Robert M Schwab•Journal of Public Economics•1988

  • Instrumental Variables Regression with Weak Instruments

    Douglas O Staiger, Douglas Staiger et al.•Econometrica•1997

  • Trading Up

    David Vogel•Trading Up•2009

  • Estimation and inference in econometrics

    Russell Davidson•Estimation and inference in…•1993

  • Pollution Abatement Costs and Foreign Direct Investment Inflows to U.S. States

    Wolfgang Keller, Arik Levinson•The Review of Economics and…•2002

  • Voting Preferences and the Environment in the American Electorate

    Deborah Lynn Guber•Society & Natural Resources•2001

  • Voting Preferences and the Environment in the American Electorate

    Deborah Lynn Guber•Society & Natural Resources•2001

  • Do States Play Welfare Games

    Open Access•David Figlio, David N Figlio et al.•Journal of Urban Economics•1999

  • A Model of Welfare Competition with Evidence from AFDC

    Open Access•Luz Amparo Saavedra•Journal of Urban Economics•2000

  • Strategic Interaction and the Determination of Environmental Policy across U.S. States

    Open Access•Per G Fredriksson, Daniel L Millimet•Journal of Urban Economics•2002

  • Are Naturalized Voters Driving the California Latino Electorate? Measuring the Effect of Irca Citizens on Latino Voting

    Open Access•Matt A Barreto, Ricardo Ramírez et al.•Social Science Quarterly•2005

  • Interstate Competition and Environmental Regulation

    Open Access•Nathan D Woods, Neal D Woods•Social Science Quarterly•2006

  • Effects of Air Quality Regulations on Polluting Industries

    Randy A Becker, Randy Becker et al.•Journal of Political Economy•2000

  • The Impacts of Environmental Regulations on Industrial Activity

    Madison Greenstone, Michael Greenstone•Journal of Political Economy•2002

  • Federalism and Policy Responsiveness

    B Dan Wood•The Journal of Politics•1991

  • The Political Economy of Gubernatorial Smokestack Chasing

    Open Access•Robert C Turner•State Politics & Policy Quarterly•2003

  • Clean Air Federalism

    Open Access•Matthew Potoski•Public Administration Review•2001

  • State Enforcement of the Federal Hazardous Waste Program

    Charles Davis, Charles L Davis et al.•Polity•1999

  • Life Is Not Fair

    Susan B Hansen•Political Research Quarterly•1999

  • Environmental Policy and Party Divergence in Congress

    Charles R Shipan, William R Lowry•Political Research Quarterly•2001

  • Determinants of State Economic Perceptions

    Open Access•Richard G Niemi, John Bremer et al.•Political Behavior•1999

  • Dimensions of State Environmental Policies

    Open Access•Matthew Potoski, Nathan D Woods•Policy Studies Journal•2002

  • Measuring Citizen and Government Ideology in the American States, 1960-93

    William D Berry, Evan J Ringquist et al.•American Journal of Political…•1998

  • Racing to the Bottom? Trade, Environmental Governance, and ISO 14001

    Open Access•Aseem Prakash, Matthew Potoski•American Journal of Political…•2006

  • Economic Geography and Economic Voting

    Open Access•Michael Ebeid, Judith Rodden et al.•British Journal of Political…•2006

  • Economic and Referendum Voting

    Open Access•Lonna Rae Atkeson, Randall W Partin•American Political Science Review•1995

  • Remodeling the Competition for Capital

    Open Access•Scott J Basinger, Scott Basinger et al.•American Political Science Review•2004

  • Fiscal Policy Outcomes and Electoral Accountability in American States

    Open Access•Robert C Lowry, James E Alt et al.•American Political Science Review•1998

Unique citing works138
Citations per year7,26
Citation span2007 - 2027 (21)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 134

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae