Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Protecting Popular Self-Government from the People? New Normative Perspectives on Militant Democracy

Bibliographic Data

ID6232824
AuthorsJan-Werner Müller (0000-0002-4627-2509, Princeton University), Jan‐werner Müller (Princeton University, corresponding author)
Year2016
Volume19
Issue1
Pages249-265
Publication date2016-05-11
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueAnnual Review of Political Science (BOOK_SERIES)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1094-2939 • E-ISSN: 1545-1577
PublisherAnnual Reviews (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1146/annurev-polisci-043014-124054
OpenAlexW2299125396
LanguageEN
Citations received52
References cited32

This article assesses recent normative theorizing on militant democracy—the idea that, to protect themselves, democracies might under some circumstances have to restrict the rights of those set on undermining or outright destroying democracy. Particular attention is paid to new justifications of militant democracy that seek to avoid the danger of militant democracy itself damaging democracy, as well as to the question of who the agent deciding on implementing militant democracy ought to be. Three new challenges for thinking about militant democracy are identified: certain forms of religious belief and practice, new varieties of authoritarianism that include elections and some limited freedoms, and the question of whether international and supranational institutions can play a role in protecting democracies

Authoritarianism · Democracy · Law and economics · Militant · Normative · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Representative democracy · Sociology · Law · Political Philosophy and Ethics · Political Theology and Sovereignty · Religion and Society Interactions

  • Affirming democracy

    Open Access•Maxime Lepoutre•Political Studies•2026

  • The Spirit of Democracy

    Sofia Näsström•Spirit of Democracy•2021

  • Populism and the Question of How to Respond to It

    Cristóbal Rovira Kaltwasser•The Oxford Handbook of Populism•2017

  • Die Idee der Freiheit und ihre Semantiken

    Open Access•Nicole J Saam, Heiner Bielefeldt•Die Idee der Freiheit und Ihre…•2023

  • Democracy in Hard Places

    Open Access•Scott Mainwaring, Tarek Masoud•Democracy in Hard Places•2022

  • Rethinking democratic subversion

    Andreas Schedler•The Routledge Handbook of…•2024

  • Militant Consociational Democracy

    Open Access•Matthijs Bogaards•Compromises in Democracy•2020

  • Pruning of the People

    Open Access•Emily Salamanca•Philosophies•2023

  • Varianten von othering

    Open Access•Thomas Krumm•ZPTh – Zeitschrift für Politische…•2024

  • Dog-whistle politics in far-right discourse

    Open Access•Armin Langer, Florian Hartleb et al.•European Journal of Political…•2026

  • “Am I My Fellow Citizens’ Keeper?” Distrust, Democratic Backsliding, and Conspiracy Theories

    Open Access•Adelin-Costin Dumitru•Constellations•2026

  • Democracy despite Itself

    Benjamin A Schupmann•Democracy despite Itself•2024

  • Should critical public intellectuals defend liberal democratic institutions

    Open Access•Patrick Nitzschner•European Political Science•2026

  • Democratic Frontsliding in the European Union

    Open Access•Christophe Hillion, Tommaso Pavone et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2025

  • Governments limiting fundamental rights

    Open Access•Nicole Bolleyer, Paula Guzzo Falci•International Journal of…•2026

  • Setting limits to tolerance

    Open Access•Eva‐maria Trüdinger, C Ziller•Frontiers in Political Science•2023

  • Anti-immigrant backlash

    Open Access•Zsolt Kapelner•Comparative Migration Studies•2024

  • Transnational militant democracy

    Open Access•Ulrich Wagrandl•Global Constitutionalism•2018

  • European political parties’ complicity in democratic backsliding

    Open Access•Fabio Wolkenstein•Global Constitutionalism•2021

  • Democratic self-defence by constitutional integration

    Open Access•Jakub Dienstbier•International Journal of Law in…•2026

  • Democratic self-defense

    Open Access•Sofia Näsström•Distinktion Journal of Social…•2021

  • European Union defensive democracy’s responses to disinformation

    Krisztina Juhász•Journal of Contemporary European…•2024

  • How not to respond to populism

    Open Access•Anthoula Malkopoulou, Benjamin Moffitt•Comparative European Politics•2023

  • Political parties and dissensus over liberal democracy in the European Parliament

    Open Access•Ramona Coman, Nathan Brack et al.•Comparative European Politics•2026

  • Tolerant and intolerant responses to populist parties

    Open Access•Angela K Bourne, Angela Bourne et al.•Comparative European Politics•2023

  • What militant democrats and technocrats share

    Open Access•Anthoula Malkopoulou•Critical Review of International…•2020

  • The elitist defence of democracy against populists using education and money

    Tore Vincents Olsen•Critical Review of International…•2022

  • Why and How Should the European Union Defend its Values

    Open Access•Tore Vincents Olsen•Res Publica. Revista de Historia…•2022

  • The normative threat of subtle subversion

    Maria Mälksoo•Cambridge Review of International…•2019

  • Battle, competition, and game

    Open Access•Timo Pankakoski•Philosophy & Social Criticism•2025

  • The “populist” foundation of liberal democracy

    Open Access•Lasse Thomassen•Philosophy & Social Criticism•2022

  • Militant constitutionalism

    Open Access•Jerg Gutmann, Stefan Voigt•Public Choice•2023

  • The Asymmetrical Political Ethics of the European Parliament

    Open Access•Attila Mráz•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2025

  • Countering Illiberalism in Liberal Democracies

    Open Access•Giovanni Capoccia•Comparative Political Studies•2026

  • Saving Popular Sovereignty From a Slow Death in the European Union

    Open Access•Jan Pieter Beetz•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2024

  • Defending the European political order

    Open Access•Ludvig Norman•European Journal of Social Theory•2017

  • Societal Responses to Right-Wing Extremism

    Antonis A Ellinas, Iasonas Lamprianou•South European Society & Politics•2021

  • To Democratize or to Protect? How the Response to Anti‐System Parties Reshapes the EU's Transnational Party System

    Open Access•Ludvig Norman•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2021

  • Varieties of dissensus over liberal democracy in the EU. National and transnational actors

    Nathan Brack, Ramona Coman et al.•European Politics and Society•2025

  • Public broadcasting and democracy’s defense

    Open Access•Josef Hien, Ludvig Norman•Democratization•2023

  • Defending democracy

    Open Access•Rune Møller Stahl, Benjamin Ask Popp-Madsen et al.•Constellations•2022

  • Anti-utopian blueprints

    Open Access•Sebastiaan Bierema•Distinktion Journal of Social…•2024

  • Three Models of Democratic Self-Defence

    Open Access•Anthoula Malkopoulou, Ludvig Norman•Political Studies•2018

  • From Stormont to Strasbourg – militant democracy in consociations

    András Gál•Democratization•2025

  • Militant democracy and the pre-emptive constitution

    Zachary Elkins•Democratization•2022

  • Opposition to populist backsliding

    K Weyland•Democratization•2025

  • Disrupting the autocratization sequence

    Open Access•Anna Lührmann•Democratization•2021

  • Allotted chambers as defenders of democracy

    Open Access•Peter Stone, Anthoula Malkopoulou•Constellations•2022

  • Democratic self‐defense and public sphere institutions

    Open Access•Ludvig Norman, Ludvig Beckman•Constellations•2024

  • Asymmetric Mass Mobilization and the Vincibility of Democracy in Hungary

    Open Access•Laura Jakli, Béla Greskovits et al.•Comparative Political Studies•2025

  • Toward A (Not The) Political Philosophy Of Populism

    Open Access•Gal Gerson•Canadian Journal of Political…•2024

  • Movement versus Party

    Open Access•Antonis A Ellinas, Iasonas Lamprianou•American Political Science Review•2024

  • Should the EU Protect Democracy and the Rule of Law inside Member States?

    Open Access•Jan‐werner Müller•European Law Journal•2015

  • Democracy and the Market

    Open Access•Adam Przeworski•Democracy and the Market•1991

  • Militant Democracy

    Jan-Werner Müller, Jan‐werner Müller et al.•The Oxford handbook of…•2012

  • Procedural Fairness in a Militant Democracy

    Open Access•Thilo Rensmann•German Law Journal•2003

  • A Theory of Justice

    John Rawls•Theory of Justice•1971

  • A Right to Do Wrong

    Jeremy Waldron•Ethics•1981

  • When the State Speaks, What Should It Say?

    Open Access•Corey Brettschneider•When the State Speaks, What…•2012

  • A Theory of Militant Democracy

    Alexander S Kirshner, Alexander Kirshner•A theory of militant democracy•2014

  • Militant Democracy

    Svetlana Tyulkina•Militant democracy•2015

  • Competitive Authoritarianism

    Open Access•Steven Levitsky, Lucan A Way•Competitive Authoritarianism…•2001

  • Are Bans on Political Parties Bound to Turn Out Badly? A Comparative Investigation of Three ‘Intolerant’ Democracies

    Open Access•Tim Bale•Comparative European Politics•2007

  • The Rights of Unreasonable Citizens

    Open Access•Jonathan Quong•Journal of Political Philosophy•2004

  • From Communist to Muslim

    Samuel Moyn•South Atlantic Quarterly•2014

  • The age of ideologies

    Joseph Frankel•International Affairs•1985

  • The Emerging Right to Democratic Governance

    Open Access•Thomas M Franck•American Journal of International…•1992

  • Exile, Ostracism, and Democracy

    Sara Forsdyke•Exile, Ostracism, and Democracy•2009

  • Guarding the Perimeter

    Open Access•Patrick Macklem•Constellations•2012

  • Democracy and political theory

    Claude Lefort•Essais sur le politique•1988

  • Liberal rights

    Jeremy Waldron•Liberal rights•1993

  • Defending Democracy

    Open Access•Stefan Rummen, Stefan Rummens et al.•Political Studies•2010

  • International Organizations & Democracy

    Open Access•Morton H Halperin, Kristen Lomasney•Journal of democracy•1993

  • The Representative Claim

    Michael Saward•2010

  • Religion and Freedom of Speech

    Open Access•Robert C Post, Robert Post•Constellations•2007

  • Banning the Former Ruling Party

    Open Access•Peter Niesen•Constellations•2012

  • Democratic Authoritarianism

    Dawn Brancati•Annual Review of Political Science•2014

  • Militant Democracy

    Giovanni Capoccia•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2013

  • How the French State Justifies Controlling Muslim Bodies

    John R Bowen•Social research•2011

  • Militant Democracy and Fundamental Rights, II

    Open Access•Karl Loewenstein•American Political Science Review•1937

  • Militant Democracy and Fundamental Rights, I

    Open Access•Karl Loewenstein•American Political Science Review•1937

Unique citing works52
Citations per year5,78
Citation span2017 - 2026 (10)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 51

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae