Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Democratization During the Third Wave

Bibliographic Data

ID6232841
AuthorsStephan Haggard (0000-0003-1571-2580, Graduate School of Global Policy and Strategy, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, California 92093, corresponding author), Robert R Kaufman (0000-0001-8542-0415, Rutgers, the State University of New Jersey)
Year2016
Volume19
Issue1
Pages125-144
Publication date2016-05-11
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueAnnual Review of Political Science (BOOK_SERIES)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1094-2939 • E-ISSN: 1545-1577
PublisherAnnual Reviews (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1146/annurev-polisci-042114-015137
OpenAlexW2213511588
LanguageEN
Citations received47
References cited153

The initial optimism that greeted the onset of the “Third Wave” of democratization has cooled with the instability of many new democracies and the proliferation of stable competitive authoritarian regimes. These disappointments have produced a return to structural theories emphasizing the constraints posed by underdevelopment, resource endowments, inequality, and ethno-religious cleavages. We argue, however, for a sharper focus on the political mechanisms that link such factors to the emergence of democracy, including the extent of institutionalization in new democracies and the still understudied role of civil society and the capacity for collective action. The international dimensions of democratization also require closer analysis. We also underline a methodological point: The quest for an overarching theory of democracy and democratization may be misguided. Generalizations supported by cross-national statistical work yield numerous anomalies and indicate the need for approaches that emphasize combinations of causal factors, alternative pathways, and equifinality

Authoritarianism · Civil society · Collective action · Democracy · Democratization · Development economics · Economic growth · Economic system · Economics · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Positive economics · Sociology · Underdevelopment · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Law · Political Conflict and Governance · Religion and Society Interactions

  • The Origins of Secular Institutions

    H Zeynep Bulutgil•Origins of Secular Institutions•2022

  • The Street and the Ballot Box

    Open Access•Lynette H Ong•Street and the Ballot Box•2022

  • Decolonizing Public Administration in Latin America

    Open Access•Nicolas Didier•Public Administration and…•2025

  • Dealing with Migration at an Institutional Level

    Didem Doğanyılmaz Duman, Gökhan Duman et al.•New Global Studies•2024

  • From Dissent to Democracy

    Jonathan Pinckney, Jonathan C Pinckney•From Dissent to Democracy•2020

  • Reflections on Haitian Democracy

    Open Access•Yasmine Shamsie•Latin American Research Review•2019

  • Challenging the State

    Open Access•Liz Alden Wily•Human Ecology•2021

  • Pathways to hybridity

    Open Access•Антоанета Димитрова, Natasha Wunsch•European Politics and Society•2026

  • From killing many to targeting few

    Open Access•S C Li, Shaka Y J Li•Japanese Journal of Political…•2026

  • What are emerging markets? Unpacking emergence

    John Manuel Luiz•Critical Perspectives on…•2026

  • Activists Against Autocrats

    Open Access•Jonathan Pinckney, John Chin•Frontiers in Political Science•2021

  • Democracy with adjectives? Economic development and democracy in the Middle East

    Open Access•Salih Yasun•Frontiers in Political Science•2024

  • Facts and Norms in Democratization

    Open Access•Roberto Farneti•Democratic Theory•2017

  • Local politics for democratic quality and depth

    Open Access•O Fiona Yap•Asia & the Pacific Policy Studies•2021

  • Why Is the Political Regime of North Korea Tough? Comparison with the Market Economization of China, Vietnam, and Cuba

    Open Access•Satoru Miyamoto•East Asia•2022

  • The “Arab Exceptionalism” Re-examined from the Legal Perspective of Human Rights

    Antonio-Martín Porras-Gómez•Contemporary Arab Affairs•2020

  • Urbanization, education, and religion

    Open Access•Tony Huiquan Zhang, Anli Jiang•Sociology Compass•2023

  • Are the Poor the Weak Link? Democratic Support and Income Levels in Post-Crisis South Korea

    Open Access•Byunghwan Son•Journal of East Asian Studies•2016

  • Fear and Loathing or Strategic Priming? Unveiling the Audience in Duterte's Crime Rhetoric

    Open Access•Rogelio Alicor L Panao, Ronald A Pernia•Journal of East Asian Studies•2022

  • We don’t know who to trust’

    Open Access•Michael Braun, Michael J Braun•Globalizations•2026

  • Party system polarization in developing democracies

    Open Access•Hatice Mete, Aida Just•Turkish Studies•2021

  • Rethinking Europe’s external relations in an age of global turmoil

    Open Access•Robert Falkner•International Politics•2017

  • Russia's energy diplomacy with China

    Bo Xu, William M Reisinger•The Pacific Review•2018

  • Democratization as an impetus for peace talks in civil wars

    Open Access•Barış Arı•Conflict Management and Peace…•2022

  • Measuring Political Institutions in the Long Run

    Open Access•Nuno Garoupa, Rok Spruk•Social Indicators Research•2024

  • Can institutional quality reduce geopolitical risk? Evidence from G20 countries

    Open Access•Rizwan Akhtar Jamsheed, Cao Mingxing•International Political Science…•2025

  • Random walks into democracy and back

    Open Access•Thomas Apolte•European Journal of Political…•2025

  • The quality of state governance as a source of international differences in total factor productivity

    Open Access•Akash Issar, Jamus Jerome Lim et al.•Public Choice•2026

  • From Aid to Empowerment

    Open Access•Marike Blanken, Felix Wiebrecht et al.•The Journal of Development Studies•2025

  • The Psychology of Repression and Polarization

    Open Access•Elizabeth R Nugent•World Politics•2020

  • Unpopular Protest

    Neil Ketchley, Thoraya El-Rayyes•The Journal of Politics•2021

  • The Deconsolidation of Democracy

    Open Access•Jack Corbett•Political Studies Review•2020

  • Political Knowledge in the Context of Changing Institutions

    Open Access•Sofia Vidotto, Rebecca Weitz-Shapiro et al.•Political Research Quarterly•2025

  • Creating Democratic Citizens

    Open Access•N Huhe, Min Tang et al.•Political Research Quarterly•2018

  • Comparing America

    Open Access•Didi Kuo•Perspectives on Politics•2019

  • Does taxation lose its role in contemporary democratisation? State revenue production revisited in the third wave of democratisation

    Open Access•Junko Kato, Seiki Tanaka•European Journal of Political…•2019

  • Weak party system institutionalization and autocratization

    Bedirhan Erdem Mutlu, Salih Yasun•Democratization•2025

  • Sources of Authoritarian Resilience

    Dmitrii Kofanov•Comparative Politics•2024

  • Conceptualizing and Measuring Autocratization Episodes

    Open Access•Lars Pelke, Aurel Croissant•Swiss Political Science Review•2021

  • Is Political Science (Still) Ignoring Religion? An Analysis of Journal Publications, 2011–2020

    Open Access•Steven Kettell•PS Political Science & Politics•2024

  • Democratization in the Global South

    Open Access•Kristian Stokke•Geography Compass•2018

  • Domestic elites and external actors in post-conflict democratisation

    Sonja Grimm, Brigitte Weiffen•Conflict Security and Development•2018

  • Conquering and coercing

    Open Access•Nam Kyu Kim, Alex M Kroeger•Journal of Peace Research•2019

  • Inequality and Political Representation in the Philippines and Singapore

    Gary Rodan, Garry Rodan•Journal of Contemporary Asia•2021

  • Punishment and Politicization in the International Human Rights Regime

    Open Access•Rochelle Terman, J Byun•American Political Science Review•2022

  • The Institutionalisation of Power Revisited

    Open Access•Denis M Tull, Claudia Simons•Africa Spectrum•2017

  • Inequality and the eroding base of liberal democracy

    Open Access•Sang Kyung Lee•Social Science Research•2024

  • Political Order in Changing Societies

    Samuel P Huntington•Political Order in Changing…•1969

  • Forging democracy from below

    Elisabeth Jean Wood•Forging democracy from below•2000

  • Capitalist development and democracy

    Dietrich Rueschemeyer•Capitalist development and…

  • Conflict and peacemaking in multiethnic societies

    Joseph V Montville•Conflict and peacemaking in…•1990

  • The Oil Curse

    Michael L Ro, Michael L Ross•Oil Curse•2012

  • Judicial Review in New Democracies

    Open Access•T Ginsburg•Judicial Review in New Democracies•2003

  • Presidents and Assemblies

    Open Access•Matthew Soberg Shugart, John Michael Carey•Presidents and Assemblies•1992

  • Crude Democracy

    Open Access•Thad Dunning•Crude Democracy•2008

  • Paths toward Democracy

    Open Access•Ruth Berins Collier•Paths Toward Democracy•1999

  • Democracies and Dictatorships in Latin America

    Open Access•Scott Mainwaring, Aníbal Pérez-Liñán•Democracies and Dictatorships in…•2014

  • Multiethnic Coalitions in Africa

    Leonardo R Arriola•Multi-Ethnic Coalitions in Africa•2012

  • Voting for Autocracy

    Open Access•Beatriz Magaloni•Voting for Autocracy•2006

  • Curbing Clientelism in Argentina

    Open Access•Rebecca Weitz-Shapiro, Rebecca Weitz‐shapiro•Curbing Clientelism in Argentina•2014

  • The Self-Restraining State

    Paul Collier, Pilar Domingo et al.•The Self-Restraining State•1999

  • The Politics of Authoritarian Rule

    Open Access•Milan W Svolik•Politics of Authoritarian Rule•2012

  • An Introduction to the Bootstrap

    Bradley Efron, Robert Tibshirani et al.•Introduction to the Bootstrap•1994

  • The Failure of Presidential Democracy

    Juan J Linz, Arturo Valenzuela et al.•The Failure of Presidential…•1994

  • Ordinary People in Extraordinary Times

    Nancy Bermeo, Nancy G Bermeo•Ordinary People in Extraordinary…•2003

  • Conclusion

    Open Access•Scott Mainwaring, Matthew Soberg Shugart•Presidentialism and Democracy in…•1997

  • Fractionalization

    Open Access•Alberto Alesina, Arnaud Devleeschauwer et al.•Journal of Economic Growth•2003

  • Political man

    Seymour Martin Lipset•Political man•1983

  • Democracy and the Market

    Open Access•Adam Przeworski•Democracy and the Market•1991

  • The Global Diffusion of Markets and Democracy

    Open Access•Beth A Simmons, Frank Dobbin et al.•Global Diffusion of Markets and…•2008

  • Democracy and Development

    Open Access•Adam Przeworski, Michael E Alvarez et al.•Democracy and Development•2000

  • Presidentialism, Parliamentarism, and Democracy

    Open Access•José Antônio Cheibub•Presidentialism, Parliamentarism,…•2006

  • Electoral Authoritarianism

    Andreas Schedler•The Sage Handbook of Comparative…•2009

  • Social Media and the Decision to Participate in Political Protest

    Open Access•Zeynep Tufekci, Christopher P Wilson et al.•Journal of Communication•2012

  • Capitalist Development and Democracy

    Iván Llamazares Valduvieco•Sociological Worlds•2013

  • Democratic Jihad ? Military Intervention And Democracy

    Nils Petter Gleditsch, Lene Siljeholm Christiansen et al.•2007

  • The Fate of Young Democracies

    Open Access•Ethan B Kapstein, Nathan Converse•Fate of Young Democracies•2008

  • Democracy

    L Diamond, Larry Jay Diamond et al.•Democracy: a reader•2009

  • Why civil resistance works

    Maria J Stephan, Erica Chenoweth•Choice Reviews Online•2012

  • Democracy, Dictatorship, and Term Limits

    Annette Baturo, Alexander Baturo•Democracy, Dictatorship, and Term…•2014

  • Rebellious Civil Society

    Grzegorz Ekiert, Jan Kubik•Rebellious Civil Society•1999

  • Driving Democracy

    Open Access•P Norris•Driving Democracy•2008

  • Determinants of Democratization

    Open Access•Jan Teorell•Determinants of Democratization•2010

  • The Political Economy of Democratic Transitions

    Stephan Haggard, Robert R Kaufman•Political Economy of Democratic…•1996

  • Inequality, Grievances, and Civil War

    Open Access•Lars-Erik Cederman, Kristian Skrede Gleditsch et al.•Inequality, Grievances, and Civil…•2013

  • Political Institutions under Dictatorship

    Open Access•Jill Gandhi, Jennifer Gandhi•Political Institutions under…•2008

  • Brokers, Voters, and Clientelism

    Open Access•C Stoke, Susan C Stokes et al.•Brokers Voters And Clientelism…•2013

  • Electing to Fight

    Edward D Mansfield, Jack Snyder•Electing to fight•2005

  • Inequality and Democratization

    Open Access•Ben W Ansell, David Samuels et al.•Inequality and Democratization•2014

  • Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation

    Juan J Linz, Juan Linz et al.•Problems of democratic transition…•1996

  • Competitive Authoritarianism

    Open Access•Steven Levitsky, Lucan A Way•Competitive Authoritarianism…•2001

  • Democracy in Africa

    Open Access•Nic Cheeseman, Nicholas Cheeseman•Democracy in Africa•2015

  • Democracy in Divided Societies

    Open Access•Benjamin Reilly•Democracy in Divided Societies•2001

  • Democracy and Redistribution

    Carles Boix•Choice Reviews Online•2005

  • Liberal Pessimism

    Open Access•Stephan Haggard•Asia & the Pacific Policy Studies•2013

  • Promoting Democracy after Conflict

    Open Access•Marina Ottaway•International Studies Perspectives•2003

  • How Autocracies Fall

    Andrea Kendall-Taylor, Andrea Kendall--Taylor et al.•The Washington Quarterly•2014

  • Democratization and the Danger of War

    Reinhard Wolf, Erich Weede et al.•International Security•1996

  • Containing Fear

    David A Lake, Donald Rothchild•International Security•1996

  • Democratization and the Danger of War

    Edward D Mansfield, Jack Snyder•International Security•1995

  • The Legacies of Liberalism

    Henry Veltmeyer, James Mahoney•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•2003

  • The Future of Freedom-Illiberal democracy at home and abroad

    Open Access•G V Gupta•Social Change•2004

  • Democracy and dictatorship revisited

    Open Access•José Antônio Cheibub, Jill Gandhi et al.•Public Choice•2010

  • Sparks and prairie fires

    Open Access•Timur Kuran•Public Choice•1989

  • Classifying Political Regimes in Latin

    Open Access•Scott Mainwaring, Daniel M Brinks et al.•Studies in Comparative…•2001

  • Classifying political regimes

    Open Access•Mike Alvarez, José Antônio Cheibub et al.•Studies in Comparative…•1996

  • Economic Inequality, Relative Power, and Religiosity

    Open Access•Frederick Solt, Philip Habel et al.•Social Science Quarterly•2011

  • Radicals, Reformers, and Reactionaries

    Kenneth Maxwell, Youssef Cohen•Foreign Affairs•1995

  • Diversity, Conflict and Democracy

    M Steven Fish, Matthew Kroenig•Democratization•2006

  • Variation in Institutional Strength

    Steven Levitsky, María Victoria Murillo•Annual Review of Political Science•2009

  • The Elite Variable in Democratic Transitions and Breakdowns

    John Higley, Michael Burton et al.•American Sociological Review•1989

  • Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy

    Barrington Moore, Jr Barrington Moore•Social Origins of Dictatorship…•1974

  • Dictators and Democrats

    Stephan Haggard, Robert R Kaufman•Dictators and Democrats•2016

  • Ethnic groups in conflict

    Donald L Horowitz•Ethnic groups in conflict•2000

  • The Dynamics of Informational Cascades

    Open Access•Susanne Lohmann•World Politics•1994

  • Inequality and Democracy

    Open Access•Christian Houle•World Politics•2009

  • How International Organizations Support Democratization

    Open Access•Paul Poast, Johannes Urpelainen•World Politics•2015

  • Contentious Politics in New Democracies

    Open Access•Grzegorz Ekiert, Jan Kubik•World Politics•1998

  • Poverty, the Coup Trap, and the Seizure of Executive Power

    Open Access•John B Londregan, John Londregan et al.•World Politics•1990

  • Rethinking Recent Democratization

    Open Access•Valerie Bunce•World Politics•2003

  • Endogenous Democratization

    Open Access•Carles Boix, C Stoke et al.•World Politics•2003

  • The Contradiction of Modernization

    Ryan Kennedy•The Journal of Politics•2010

  • Two Modes of Democratic Breakdown

    Ko Maeda•The Journal of Politics•2010

  • The Effect of Elections on Postconflict Peace and Reconstruction

    Thomas Edward Flores, Irfan Nooruddin•The Journal of Politics•2012

  • Explaining Democratic Survival Globally (1946–2002)

    Ming Sing•The Journal of Politics•2010

  • Correlation Versus Interchangeability

    Open Access•Gretchen Casper, Claudiu D Tufis et al.•Political Analysis•2003

  • The End of the Transition Paradigm

    Open Access•Thomas Carothers•Journal of democracy•2002

  • Elections Without Democracy

    Open Access•L Diamond•Journal of democracy•2002

  • What Makes Democracies Endure

    Open Access•José Antônio Cheibub, Adam Przeworski et al.•Journal of democracy•1996

  • Pathways from Authoritarianism

    Open Access•Axel Hadenius, Jan Teorell•Journal of democracy•2007

  • Elections Without Democracy

    Open Access•Andreas Schedler•Journal of democracy•2002

  • The Case for Presidential Term Limits

    Open Access•Gideon Maltz•Journal of democracy•2007

  • The Decline of the African Military Coup

    Open Access•John F Clark•Journal of democracy•2007

  • Redemocratization in Chile

    Open Access•Manuel Antonio Garretón Merino•Journal of democracy•1995

  • Poverty, Inequality, and Democracy

    Open Access•Ethan B Kapstein, Nathan Converse•Journal of democracy•2008

  • African Elections as Vehicles for Change

    Open Access•Nic Cheeseman•Journal of democracy•2010

  • The Quality of Democracy

    Open Access•Dietrich Rueschemeyer•Journal of democracy•2004

  • Exchange

    Open Access•Edward D Mansfield, Jack Snyder•Journal of democracy•2007

  • How Democracies Emerge

    Open Access•Thomas Carothers•Journal of democracy•2007

  • Constitutional Design for Divided Societies

    Open Access•Arend Lijphart•Journal of democracy•2004

  • The Institutionalization of Political Power in Africa

    Open Access•Daniel N Posner, Donald Posner et al.•Journal of democracy•2007

  • Stronger Legislatures, Stronger Democracies

    Open Access•M Steven Fish•Journal of democracy•2006

  • Time to Kill

    Open Access•Dawn Brancati, Jack L Snyder et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2013

  • The Rule of Law in Post-Conflict Settings

    Open Access•Stephan Haggard, Lydia Brashear Tiede et al.•International Studies Quarterly•2014

  • From Shocks to Waves

    Open Access•Seva Gunitsky•International Organization•2014

  • Diffusion and the International Context of Democratization

    Kristian Skrede Gleditsch, Michael D Ward•International Organization•2006

  • Democratization and International Organizations

    Edward D Mansfield, Jon C Pevehouse et al.•International Organization•2006

Unique citing works47
Citations per year4,7
Citation span2016 - 2026 (11)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 47

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae